LaBarbera has been heavily criticised for spreading hate speech and misinformation about homosexuality, with AFTAH being designated as a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) for spreading "hateful propaganda".
LaBarbera was a reporter for The Washington Times until 1990 and covered stories such as Communism in Central America, then became a freelance reporter in Nicaragua. He then worked for Accuracy in Media and became a contributing editor at Human Events magazine.
In early August 1994, LaBarbera and another activist, Bill Horn, were invited to Shreveport, Louisiana, by pastor Billy McCormack (vice president of the Christian Coalition of America) to make a presentation on the homosexual rights agenda. Horn produced the video The Gay Agenda, and LaBarbera edited the newsletter, the Lambda Report. After LaBarbera and Horn left Shreveport, McCormack's University Baptist Church burned to the ground. Arson was suspected but authorities determined that the structure was destroyed by lightning.
LaBarbera served as a senior policy analyst for the Culture and Family Institute, a conservative Christian group opposed to LGBT rights. LaBarbera said that the end result of Lawrence v. Texas was "like the Roe v. Wade of the homosexual issue."
Americans for Truth about Homosexuality
LaBarbera is founder and president of Americans for Truth about Homosexuality (AFTAH), which describes itself as "dedicated to exposing the homosexual activist agenda". It was a 501(c)3 United States tax-exempt organization until stripped of that designation following years of failing to file the appropriate paperwork. It is classified as an anti-gay hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC). Upon learning of the designation in December 2010, LaBarbera considered it a point of pride and stated "If you are not on the SPLC hate list, you are not doing enough." LaBarbera has stated that SPLC determinations that AFTAH makes false and derogatory claims about homosexuals is inaccurate. Yet LaBarbera has at the same time claimed that the majority of children who are sexually abused are male as are their abusers, painting homosexual males as pedophiles and a danger to society.
In April 2013, he said that high incidents of gay-on-gay violence and higher rates of STIs among homosexuals were "reassuring" to his mission as it demonstrated that God saw homosexuality as an "abomination".
He has also been referred to as, "Porno Pete," by members of the LBGT community (including Dan Savage) for his alleged habit of showing up at numerous Pride events and taking pictures of the parade antics.
2014 visit to Saskatchewan
In April 2014, LaBarbera's planned appearance in Weyburn, Saskatchewan, Canada at a Saskatchewan Pro-Life Association convention was met with controversy from residents. A group known as Intolerance Free Weyburn started a petition urging organizers to reconsider LaBarbera's involvement, and planned a protest at the event itself, citing AFTAH's history of anti-gay rhetoric, and for being designated as a hate group by SPLC. Despite receiving similar criticism in 2013 for inviting a speaker from Courage International to the convention, the decision was defended by the organization's president Marcy Mallette, who stated that "his website is for truth, and that's not hateful at all", but also went on to say that she "welcome[d] dialogue", given that "there's nothing worse than just being silent about everything." LaBarbera himself confirmed that he would still appear at the event, characterized the protest as a "homo-Marxist attempt to shut down my speech", and indicated that he was also looking forward to meet Bill Whatcott, a fellow anti-gay and pro-life supporter that he dubbed "the most fearless truth-teller" he had ever met, at the event as well. Debra Button, mayor of Weyburn, announced that she and her city council would consider pulling the CDN$1,000 in funding it had provided for the event in response to the controversy.
On April 10, 2014—two days before the conference, LaBarbera was denied entry into Canada by customs officials at Regina International Airport, arguing that his appearance at the event could violate Canadian laws on hate speech and "wilful incitement of hatred". He was detained for questioning by officials regarding his stance on homosexuality, his organization's ideologies, his purposes for attending the event, and his luggage and electronic devices were also inspected by officials. LaBarbera personally blamed the campaign of Intolerance Free Weyburn for the detention. He was released following an appeal with the Canadian Border Services Agency the following morning. The following Monday, LaBarbera and Bill Whatcott visited the University of Regina, where they displayed anti-abortion posters and distributed pamphlets on the "evils" of homosexuality. They were both arrested after they refused to respond to requests by officials to leave the premises; Whatcott admitted that they had defied a formal denial of permission to set up a table at the university. They were both charged with mischief, and held in custody overnight. Both LaBarbera and Whatcott were released the following day, pending a trial on May 26. They also cancelled a planned appearance at the University of Saskatchewan, with LaBarbera choosing to head home to the United States.
- Dininny, Shannon (January 16, 2012). "Civil-rights history gets boost; Whitman College students to teach subject this week". The Seattle Times (Seattle, WA).
- Cruz, Hector (August 26, 2010). "Naperville anti-gay group slams Elisabeth Hasselbeck for recent pro-gay marriage remarks". Chicago Examiner (Chicago, IL).
Earlier this year, AFTAH was labeled as a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC) for spreading hateful propaganda, and claiming that homosexuality can be cured.
- "About Americans for Truth and Founder Peter LaBarbera". Americans for Truth. Retrieved April 1, 2011.
- "Religioius Right update". publiceye.org. Retrieved June 6, 2012.
- Robertson, Tatsha. "Gays, Lesbians Praise Decision Others Compare It to Roe V. Wade." Boston Globe. June 27, 2003. National/Foreign A28. Retrieved on February 16, 2011.
- Peter LaBarbera (Mar 3, 2010). "Peter LaBarbera for State Central Committeeman for the 13th Congressional District". Republicans for Family Values. Retrieved October 26, 2011.
- "About Americans for Truth and Founder Peter LaBarbera". Americans for Truth. Retrieved 2011-08-02.
- Harmon, Andrew. "IRS Revokes Antigay Group's Tax Exempt Status". The Advocate. Retrieved 2011-08-02.
- Schlatter, Evelyn. "18 Anti-Gay Groups and Their Propaganda". Southern Poverty Law Center. Retrieved 2011-08-02.
- Shapiro, Ari. "Gay Republicans Feel Heat from the Foley Scandal." National Public Radio. October 13, 2006. Retrieved on February 16, 2011.
- Birkey, Andy (6 December 2010). "Minnesota Family Council’s Anderson talks with ‘hate group’ founder". The Minnesota Independent. Retrieved 30 September 2012.
- "Peter LaBarbera Interview". Concerned Women of America. Retrieved 2012-11-28.
- Joseph Patrick McCormick, US radio host: ‘STIs and anti-gay violence prove that God thinks homosexuality is wrong’, Pink News, April 22, 2013
- Dan Savage,  "Raw Story", Jul 28
- "Anti-gay speaker from U.S. vows to speak in Saskatchewan". CBC News. Retrieved 4 April 2014.
- "Saskatchewan Pro-Life event draws fire". Leader Post. Retrieved 4 April 2014.
- "Controversial speaker allowed entry into Canada". Leader-Post (Regina). Retrieved 11 April 2014.
- "Controversial U.S. speaker Peter LaBarbera detained at Regina airport". CBC News. Retrieved 11 April 2014.
- "Controversial speaker denied entry to Canada". Leader Post (Regina). Retrieved 11 April 2014.
- "LaBarbera Denied Entry into Canada for Pro-Family Speech – Appeals Decision Today – Responds to Letter to Catholics from Regina Archbishop Daniel Bohan". Americans for Truth about Homosexuality. Retrieved 11 April 2014.
- "Anti-gay activist voluntarily leaves Canada". Saskatoon Star-Phoenix. Retrieved 16 April 2014.
- "U.S. anti-gay activist Peter LaBarbera arrested in Regina". CBC News. Retrieved 14 April 2014.
- "Anti-gay activist Peter LaBarbera heading home to U.S.". CBC News. Retrieved 16 April 2014.