Phantom ballplayer

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Brian Jeroloman spent a month with the 2011 Toronto Blue Jays without appearing in a game.

A phantom ballplayer is either a baseball player who is incorrectly listed in source materials as playing in a Major League Baseball (MLB) game, often the result of typographical or clerical errors, or a player who spent time on an MLB active roster without ever appearing in an MLB contest during his career. Most of the first form of phantom players date from the 19th or early 20th century, with at least one showing up as late as World War II.

A modern-day phantom ballplayer is generally caused by the player being removed from the active roster by a subsequent action (such as being optioned to a minor league team) or the team reaching the end of their season, and the player not having later opportunity to play in a major league game. Many of these phantom players were September call-ups in backup roles.

Phantoms who never were[edit]

Pete Compton of the St. Louis Browns, now credited with the plate appearance of "Lou Proctor"
  • Edward L. Thayer supposedly played one game for the 1876 New York Mutuals; he was listed in The Official Encyclopedia of Baseball as having been born in Mechanic Falls, Maine.[1]:333 The player was actually George Fair, who adopted a pseudonym that, coincidentally, resembled the name of then-12-year-old Ernest Lawrence Thayer, who would later go on to become a poet and write "Casey at the Bat." (Some 19th and early 20th century players sometimes played under assumed names in an attempt to circumvent contractual obligations with another club.)
  • An outfielder named Turbot (no first name given) was listed in The Official Encyclopedia of Baseball as playing one game for the 1902 St. Louis Cardinals.[1]:339 In the 1971 anthology This Great Game, writer and humorist Roy Blount Jr. included him on his "all-time fish team" (as turbot is also the name of a fish) and bemoaned that Turbot had been dropped from the encyclopedia; "I don't know what happened to him, but we need him in the outfield."[2]
  • Lou Proctor was listed as playing one game for the 1912 St. Louis Browns, drawing a walk in his only plate appearance. He appeared in The Official Encyclopedia of Baseball as a pinch hitter named "L. Proctor".[1]:284 Research in the 1980s, however, revealed that the appearance belonged to the Browns' Pete Compton. According to legend, Proctor was a Western Union operator who inserted his name into the box score as a prank. However, whether Proctor existed—even as a prankish telegraph operator—is unknown.
  • A catcher named Deniens (no first name given) was listed in The Official Encyclopedia of Baseball as having played one game for the 1914 Chicago Chi-Feds of the Federal League.[1]:125 Later research showed that the game was caught by the Chi-Feds regular second-string catcher Clem Clemens—historians reading a handwritten scorecard of the game had incorrectly deciphered "Clemens" as "Deniens".

Real players who never played[edit]

Research by the Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) has identified over 400 players who appeared on major league rosters, but did not appear in a major league game, since 1884.[3] A number of examples are presented here.


  • Pitcher Bill Stewart was on the roster of the 1919 Chicago White Sox,[4] but was sent to the minor leagues without playing for the team.[5] It is unclear whether he was on the team's active roster, as he had been injured the previous winter.[6] Stewart would go on to be an umpire in the National League and an ice hockey referee in the NHL.
  • First baseman Jeff Jones was briefly on the roster of the 1920 Philadelphia Athletics, but did not play. As with several other players of this era, it is not established if Jones was on the A's active roster during the season.
  • Outfielder Lou Almada made the major league roster of the 1927 New York Giants out of spring training, but was hurt as the season began, and did not reach the majors again. In 1933, his brother Mel Almada became the first Mexican to play in the majors.
  • Minor league pitching legend Jake Levy was reported in at least one contemporary account to have signed with the 1927 New York Giants in mid-September,[7] without getting into a game. Peter and Joachim Horvitz' The Big Book of Jewish Baseball list Levy's stint on the Giants bench as having occurred in 1932.[8] However, whether Levy spent any time at all on a Giants' active roster is a matter of dispute.
  • Al Olsen is an unusual example of a verifiable real-life person who did not play in the major leagues, but was included in official major league records for many years. Olsen, a career minor league pitcher, was credited as appearing in the first game of a doubleheader on May 16, 1943, as a pinch hitter (walking, and then stealing a base) for the Boston Red Sox against the Chicago White Sox. However, research by SABR in the 1980s showed that while Olsen had been with the 1943 Boston Red Sox during spring training, he was sent to San Diego of the Pacific Coast League before the 1943 season began.[9][10] Olsen pitched on May 15 for San Diego, and given wartime travel restrictions, could not have arrived in Chicago for the game the following day. Olsen himself said, "It wasn't me. I was a left-handed pitcher. I couldn't hit my hat. Besides, I never played a game in the major leagues."[11] The pinch hitting appearance probably, but not definitely, belongs to Leon Culberson; it also could have been Johnny Lazor, who wore uniform number 14, the same number Olsen wore in spring training. Official records now credit Culberson with the walk and stolen base[12]—though Culberson himself swears he did not play in what would have been his major league debut game (he was the starting center fielder in the second game of the doubleheader, thus his debut date is not in question).[13]


Bill Sharman, who was briefly on the roster of the 1951 Brooklyn Dodgers
  • Outfielder Bill Sharman spent time on the roster of the 1951 Brooklyn Dodgers when he was called up in mid-September;[14] he did not appear in a game. Sharman is often cited as the only player to be ejected from an MLB game without playing in one, when umpire Frank Dascoli cleared the entire Dodgers bench for arguing with a call at home plate on September 27, 1951.[15] However, Sharman was not ejected; those who had to leave the bench were still eligible to be brought into the game. Sharman is far more notable as a professional basketball player and coach than as a baseball player; he is one of only four individuals to be inducted into the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame as both a player and a coach.






  • Outfielder Luke Wilcox was briefly called up by the 2000 New York Yankees, July 13–16,[48][49] but did not appear in a game. He wore number 50 with the Yankees.
  • Catcher César King spent five days on the 2001 Kansas City Royals active roster, May 19–23,[50][51] without making an appearance.
  • Pitcher Jeff Urban was on the 2003 San Francisco Giants active roster on April 26–30 and again on August 1–2. He did not make an appearance during either stint.
  • Catcher David Parrish, son of Tiger great Lance Parrish, was called up by the 2004 New York Yankees for three days without making an appearance, after regular catcher Jorge Posada was hit in the face with a ball during a game. Parrish wore number 57 during his short stint as a Yankee.
  • Pitcher Cory Morris was on the active roster of the 2006 Baltimore Orioles on April 9–12, without making an appearance.
  • Catcher Tim Gradoville was on the 2006 Philadelphia Phillies active roster for 18 days in September without making an appearance
  • Pitcher Tim Lahey was on the active roster of the 2008 Philadelphia Phillies for the first six days of the season without making an appearance. Lahey spent his entire six-year minor league career pitching for the Minnesota Twins organization. However, in a five-month period from December 2007 to April 2008, he was selected by the Tampa Bay Rays in the Rule 5 draft, sold by the Rays to the Chicago Cubs, released by the Cubs, signed by the Phillies (where he was briefly on their active roster), and then returned to the Twins under conditions of the Rule 5 draft. Lahey managed to do all this without throwing a regular season pitch for anyone other than Minnesota farm teams.
  • Pitcher Luis Muñoz spent two games on the active roster of the 2008 Pittsburgh Pirates in July without making an appearance. His fate was probably sealed before he arrived, with Pirates general manager Neal Huntington saying of his call-up to the majors: "I would not anticipate Luis being here for an extended period of time. It was a step short of desperation."[52] Two days after his arrival, Munoz was removed from the Pirates roster and designated for assignment. He was eventually sent to the farm system of the Seattle Mariners.


denotes an active professional baseball player who could lose phantom status if he returns to the major leagues and appears in a game

Honorable mentions[edit] maintains lists of players who have appeared in only a single major league game; as of July 2018, there are nearly 1,000 batters and over 500 pitchers listed.[70] This section includes some examples, along with several other notables.

Moonlight Graham was featured in the 1989 film Field of Dreams
  • Outfielder Moonlight Graham played one inning on defense for the 1905 New York Giants on June 29, his only major league appearance, and did not have a plate appearance.[71] His story was featured in the 1989 fantasy movie Field of Dreams, with Frank Whaley playing Graham as a young ballplayer and Burt Lancaster playing Graham as an older adult.
  • The Sporting Life of February 24, 1906, reported that pitcher Jimmy Whalen sent in a contract to the New York Highlanders,[72] although it is unclear if Whalen made the team's active roster once the season was underway. Whalen never appeared in a major league game, although he won over 250 games in the minors.[73]
  • Tom Burr, a pitcher, played one inning in center field for the New York Yankees on April 21, 1914. He had no fielding chances and the game was won before he came to bat. In October 1918, Burr died in France while serving in World War I.
  • Shortstop Frank Verdi played one inning on defense for the 1953 New York Yankees on May 10, his only major league appearance, and did not have a plate appearance.[74]
  • Pitcher Larry Yount, older brother of Hall of Famer Robin Yount, suffered an injury while throwing warmup pitches after being summoned as a reliever during a September 15 game for the 1971 Houston Astros.[75] He did not face a batter and did not appear in any other MLB game. Under MLB rules, Larry Yount is credited with an appearance in that game—because he had been announced—despite not actually playing in the game.[76]
  • Infielder Gary Hargis made his lone MLB appearance as a pinch runner in an extra-innings game for the 1979 Pittsburgh Pirates on the next-to-last day of the season, September 29.[77][78]
  • Second baseman Bob Hegman played a single inning in the major leagues, as a defensive replacement for the 1985 Kansas City Royals on August 8.[77][79]
  • Pitcher Brian Mazone was to start a game for the 2006 Philadelphia Phillies on September 5,[80] but the game was rained out and the Phillies did not activate him to their roster. He spent the rest of his career, which ended in 2010, in the minors.[81] "That's a tough thing to shake", Mazone said. "I was getting called up by the Phillies in 2006 to make a start [replacing Randy Wolf], and the game got rained out and they sent me back down without activating me. Randy came up to me here and apologized. Not that he did anything wrong, he just felt bad."[82][permanent dead link]
  • Infielder Mark Kiger never appeared in an MLB regular season game, but he holds the distinction of being the only player whose major league career consists only of postseason games. Kiger was activated by the 2006 Oakland Athletics for the ALCS due to an injury to Mark Ellis. Kiger made two one-inning defensive appearances during the series, without having a plate appearance, and without ever playing in another MLB game.[83] The only players to have made their major league debuts in the postseason are Kiger and two others—Bug Holliday in the 1885 championship series, and Adalberto Mondesí in the 2015 World Series; both Holliday and Mondesí later played in regular season major league games.

Former phantom players who made MLB debut in subsequent seasons[edit]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ a b c d Turkin, Hy; Thompson, S. C. (1956). The Official Encyclopedia of Baseball. New York City: A. S. Barnes & Company. LCCN 56-5560.
  2. ^ Doris Townsend, ed. (1971). This Great Game. Prentice-Hall. p. 242. ISBN 0139190767.
  3. ^ Hickman, Bill (October 8, 2017). "Near Major Leaguers". SABR. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via Google Docs.
  4. ^ "Kid Gleason Promises Chicago Fans the Pennant". Oakland Tribune. April 17, 1919. p. 12. Retrieved June 3, 2018 – via
  5. ^ "Umpire Card for Bill Stewart". The Sporting News. Retrieved June 3, 2018 – via Retrosheet.
  6. ^ "Bill Stewart (umpire)". March 27, 2011. Retrieved June 3, 2018.
  7. ^ "May Fill Bill". The Indianapolis Star. Central Press. September 13, 1927. p. 12. Retrieved June 1, 2018 – via
  8. ^ Horvitz, Peter S.; Horvitz, Joachim (2001). The Big Book of Jewish Baseball: An Illustrated Encyclopedia & Anecdotal History. S.P.I. Books. ISBN 1561719730.
  9. ^ "Brown to Quit Baseball After Boston Failure". Harrisburg Telegraph. Harrisburg, Pennsylvania. AP. April 23, 1943. p. 18. Retrieved May 31, 2018 – via
  10. ^ "Al Olsen Minor League Statistics & History". Retrieved May 31, 2018.
  11. ^ Berkow, Ira (1990-01-31). "Sports of the Times; The Ghost Who Batted For Boston". The New York Times. Retrieved 2011-10-05.
  12. ^ "Chicago White Sox 4, Boston Red Sox 2 (1)". Retrosheet. May 16, 1943. Retrieved May 31, 2018.
  13. ^ "Boston Red Sox 4, Chicago White Sox 2 (2)". Retrosheet. May 16, 1943. Retrieved May 31, 2018.
  14. ^ "Brooklyn Recalls Bill Sharman, Lembo". Elmira Advertiser. Elmira, New York. AP. September 19, 1951. p. 8. Retrieved June 1, 2018 – via
  15. ^ "This Caused Rhubarb". Brooklyn Daily Eagle. September 28, 1951. p. 18. Retrieved June 1, 2018 – via
  16. ^ "Series Lineups". Arizona Daily Star. Tucson, Arizona. October 7, 1964. p. 37. Retrieved June 29, 2018 – via
  17. ^ "Frick Announces Series Eligibles". The Morning Call. Allentown, Pennsylvania. AP. September 25, 1964. p. 39. Retrieved July 6, 2018 – via
  18. ^ "Series Lineups". Arizona Daily Star. Tucson, Arizona. October 7, 1964. p. 37. Retrieved June 29, 2018 – via
  19. ^ "Ike Futch". Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  20. ^ "Sports (column)". El Paso Herald-Post. June 27, 1966. p. 17. Retrieved June 6, 2018 – via
  21. ^ "Twins Reactivate Kaat; Send Ogier To Farm System". Anderson Herald. Anderson, Indiana. UPI. May 2, 1968. p. 15. Retrieved June 1, 2018 – via
  22. ^ "Dukes, LA swap men". The Arizona Republic. UPI. May 12, 1974. p. D-2. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  23. ^ "Rick Rhoden Answers Call". Albuquerque Journal. Albuquerque, New Mexico. July 4, 1974. p. E-8. Retrieved March 16, 2017 – via
  24. ^ "Dukes Collect Some World Series Cash". Albuquerque Journal. Albuquerque, New Mexico. November 21, 1974. p. D-11. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  25. ^ "Ed Kurpiel". Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  26. ^ "Cards Recall Trio from Tulsa Team". The Southern Illinoisan. Carbondale, Illinois. September 12, 1974. p. 16. Retrieved June 6, 2018 – via
  27. ^ "Transactions". The Town Talk. Alexandria, Louisiana. April 26, 1977. p. B-3. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  28. ^ Gelfand, M. Howard (May 19, 1977). "Moves mean 'wasted year' for pitcher May". Minneapolis Tribune. p. 1D. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  29. ^ "Harry Saferight". Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  30. ^ "Pirates call up 8". The Morning Call. Allentown, Pennsylvania. September 1, 1979. p. 4. Retrieved June 6, 2018 – via
  31. ^ "Transactions". The Pantagraph. Bloomington, Illinois. July 3, 1987. p. B2. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  32. ^ "Sanderson back". Journal Gazette. Mattoon, Illinois. July 7, 1987. p. B-1. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  33. ^ "Merrifield assigned to instructional camp". Rocky Mount Telegram. Rocky Mount, North Carolina. September 12, 1987. p. 9. Retrieved June 1, 2018 – via
  34. ^ Dodd, Rustin (4 June 2016). "Royals' Whit Merrifield is taking his family along on big-league journey". Kansas City Star. Retrieved 2 September 2017.
  35. ^ Perrotto, John (1 September 2017). "Rumors and Rumblings – Merrifield fulfills father's dream". Fanrag. Retrieved 2 September 2017.
  36. ^ "Frequent flier". The Philadelphia Inquirer. July 12, 1988. p. 2-D. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  37. ^ "Transactions". Los Angeles Times. August 9, 1988. p. 34. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  38. ^ "Transactions". Los Angeles Times. August 11, 1988. p. 58. Retrieved June 14, 2018 – via
  39. ^ "Transactions". The Indianapolis Star. August 4, 1990. p. D-4. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via
  40. ^ "Transactions". The Indianapolis Star. August 6, 1990. p. B-4. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via
  41. ^ "Flashes". New York Daily News. May 2, 1992. p. 36. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via
  42. ^ "Transactions". Chicago Tribune. June 11, 1994. p. 3-7. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via
  43. ^ "Notes". Chicago Tribune. June 15, 1994. p. 4-7. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via
  44. ^ "Dark Side of the Moonlight". The Church of Baseball. June 21, 2010. Retrieved July 4, 2018.
  45. ^ Martinez, Michael (June 7, 1995). "Chimelis leaves Giants as a pariah". The Times. Shreveport, Louisiana. Knight Ridder. p. 3C. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via
  46. ^ "Transactions". Tampa Bay Times. September 3, 1996. p. 6C. Retrieved July 4, 2018 – via
  47. ^ Stephen, Eric (December 29, 2016). "Remembering the Dodgers who didn't play". SB Nation. Retrieved June 3, 2018.
  48. ^ Kimmerly, Geoff (July 15, 2000). "St. Johns native gets call up to Yankees". Lansing State Journal. Lansing, Michigan. p. C1. Retrieved June 29, 2018 – via
  49. ^ "Yankees recall Bellinger, send Wilcox to Columbus". The Post-Star. Glens Falls, New York. July 17, 2000. p. C5. Retrieved June 29, 2018 – via
  50. ^ "Game Notes". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. May 20, 2001. p. D9. Retrieved June 29, 2018 – via
  51. ^ "Transactions". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. May 24, 2001. p. D7. Retrieved June 29, 2018 – via
  52. ^ "Pirates promote Munoz; Cleveland claims Bulllington.", 2008-07-10. Retrieved 2013-01-07.
  53. ^ "Mariners Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions". June 2011. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  54. ^ "Mariners Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions". July 2011. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  55. ^ Bastian, Jordan (March 19, 2013). "Jeroloman out to shed 'phantom ballplayer' label".
  56. ^ "Athletics Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions". September 2011. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  57. ^ "Dodgers Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions". April 2012. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  58. ^ "Dodgers Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions". May 2012. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  59. ^ "White Sox Roster & Staff – Transactions". May 2014. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  60. ^ "Braves Roster & Staff – Transactions". September 2014. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  61. ^ "Yankees Roster & Staff – Transactions". July 2015. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  62. ^ "Angels Roster & Staff – Transactions". May 2016. Retrieved July 4, 2018.
  63. ^ "Angels Roster & Staff – Transactions". June 2016. Retrieved July 4, 2018.
  64. ^ "Braves Roster & Staff – Transactions". July 2016. Retrieved July 4, 2018.
  65. ^ Hummer, Steve (July 3, 2016). "Braves, Marlins get extra body for Sunday night game". The Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Retrieved July 4, 2018.
  66. ^ "Dodgers Roster & Staff – Transactions". August 2016. Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  67. ^ Hoch, Bryan (May 23, 2018). "Germany, Australia ... now Yanks for Bollinger: Wide-traveling left-hander joins club vs. Rangers at Globe Life Park". Retrieved May 23, 2018.
  68. ^ Franko, Kyle (May 29, 2018). "Ryan Bollinger still relishing unexpected call to Yankees". The Trentonian. Retrieved June 3, 2018.
  69. ^ Mark Polishuk (July 18, 2019). "Minor MLB Transactions: 7/18/19". MLB Trade Rumors. Retrieved July 18, 2019.
  70. ^ "Cup of Coffee Players". Retrieved July 24, 2018.
  71. ^ "Moonlight Graham Stats". Retrieved June 5, 2018.
  72. ^
  73. ^ "Jimmy Whalen Minor & Independent Leagues Statistics & History". Retrieved June 1, 2018.
  74. ^ "New York Yankees 7, Boston Red Sox 4". Retrosheet. May 10, 1953. Retrieved July 14, 2018.
  75. ^ "Astros' Rookie in 'Brief' Stint". Odessa American. Odessa, Texas. AP. September 16, 1971. p. 1-B. Retrieved May 31, 2018 – via
  76. ^ "Atlanta Braves 4, Houston Astros 2". Retrosheet. September 15, 1971. Retrieved May 31, 2018.
  77. ^ a b Walker, Ben (June 25, 2005). "Hollywood did not invent Moonlight Graham". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. AP.
  78. ^ "Chicago Cubs 7, Pittsburgh Pirates 6". Retrosheet. September 29, 1979. Retrieved June 6, 2018.
  79. ^ "Kansas City Royals 10, Detroit Tigers 3 (1)". Retrosheet. August 8, 1985. Retrieved July 24, 2018.
  80. ^ Miller, Stephen (September 6, 2006). "Rain washes out Mazone's shot". The Morning Call. Allentown, Pennsylvania. p. C1. Retrieved May 31, 2018 – via
  81. ^ "Brian Mazone Minor, Independent & Winter League Statistics & History". Retrieved May 31, 2018.
  82. ^
  83. ^ "Mark Kiger". Retrosheet. Retrieved July 6, 2018.
  84. ^ "Blue Jays recall Wagner, demote Walden". ESPN. April 9, 2014. Retrieved May 27, 2019.
  85. ^ Drellich, Evan (March 26, 2018). "Surprise! Poyner and Walden make Red Sox pitching staff". NBC Sports. Retrieved May 28, 2019.
  86. ^ "Mariners promote righty Harper, option Whalen". Retrieved May 28, 2019.

Further reading[edit]