# Planck (spacecraft)

(Redirected from Planck Surveyor)
Planck
Artist's impression of the Planck spacecraft
Names COBRAS/SAMBA
Mission type Space telescope
Operator ESA
COSPAR ID 2009-026B
SATCAT № 34938
Website http://www.esa.int/planck
Mission duration Planned: >15 months
Final: 4 years, 5 months, 8 days
Spacecraft properties
Manufacturer Thales Alenia Space
Launch mass 1,950 kg (4,300 lb)[1]
Payload mass 205 kg (452 lb)
Dimensions Body: 4.20 m × 4.22 m (13.8 ft × 13.8 ft)
Start of mission
Launch date 14 May 2009, 13:12:02 UTC
Rocket Ariane 5 ECA
Launch site Guiana Space Centre,
French Guiana
Contractor Arianespace
Entered service 3 July 2009
End of mission
Disposal Decommissioned
Deactivated 23 October 2013, 12:10:27 UTC
Orbital parameters
Reference system L2 point
(1,500,000 km / 930,000 mi)
Regime Lissajous
Main telescope
Type Gregorian
Diameter 1.9 m × 1.5 m (6.2 ft × 4.9 ft)
Wavelengths 27 GHz to 1 THz

ESA astrophysics insignia for the Planck mission

 Horizon 2000 ← Herschel

Planck was a space observatory operated by the European Space Agency (ESA) from 2009 to 2013, which mapped the anisotropies of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) at microwave and infra-red frequencies, with high sensitivity and small angular resolution. The mission substantially improved upon observations made by the NASA Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP). Planck provided a major source of information relevant to several cosmological and astrophysical issues, such as testing theories of the early Universe and the origin of cosmic structure; as of 2013 it has provided the most accurate measurements of several key cosmological parameters, including the average density of ordinary matter and dark matter in the Universe.

The project was started around 1996 and was initially called COBRAS/SAMBA: the Cosmic Background Radiation Anisotropy Satellite/Satellite for Measurement of Background Anisotropies. It was later renamed in honour of the German physicist Max Planck (1858–1947), who derived the formula for black-body radiation.

Built at the Cannes Mandelieu Space Center by Thales Alenia Space, and created as a medium-sized mission for ESA's Horizon 2000 long-term scientific programme, Planck was launched in May 2009,[2] reaching the Earth/Sun L2 point by July, and by February 2010 had successfully started a second all-sky survey. On 21 March 2013, the mission's first all-sky map of the cosmic microwave background was released, with an expanded release including polarization data in February 2015; final data analysis will continue into 2016.

At the end of its mission Planck was put into a heliocentric orbit and passivated to prevent it from endangering any future missions. The final deactivation command was sent to Planck in October 2013.

## Objectives

The mission had a wide variety of scientific aims, including:[3]

Planck has a higher resolution and sensitivity than WMAP, allowing it to probe the power spectrum of the CMB to much smaller scales (×3). It also observes in 9 frequency bands rather than WMAP's 5, with the goal of improving the astrophysical foreground models.

It is expected that most Planck measurements will be limited by how well foregrounds can be subtracted, rather than by the detector performance or length of the mission, a particularly important factor for the polarization measurements. The dominant foreground radiation depends on frequency, but could include synchrotron radiation from the Milky Way at low frequencies, and dust at high frequencies.

## Instruments

The 4 K reference load qualification model
LFI 44 GHz horn and front-end chassis
LFI focal plane model

The spacecraft carries two instruments: the Low Frequency Instrument (LFI) and the High Frequency Instrument (HFI).[3] Both instruments can detect both the total intensity and polarization of photons, and together cover a frequency range of nearly 830 GHz (from 30 to 857 GHz). The cosmic microwave background spectrum peaks at a frequency of 160.2 GHz.

Planck's passive and active cooling systems allow its instruments to maintain a temperature of −273.05 °C (−459.49 °F), or 0.1 °C above absolute zero. From August 2009, Planck was the coldest known object in space, until its active coolant supply was exhausted in January 2012.[4]

NASA played a role in the development of the mission and contributes to the analysis of scientific data. Its Jet Propulsion Laboratory built components of the science instruments, including bolometers for the high-frequency instrument, a 20-kelvin cryocooler for both the low- and high-frequency instruments, and amplifier technology for the low-frequency instrument.[5]

### Low Frequency Instrument

Frequency
(GHz)
Bandwidth
(Δν/ν)
Resolution
(arcmin)
Sensitivity (total intensity)
ΔT/T, 14 month observation
(10−6)
Sensitivity (polarization)
ΔT/T, 14 month observation
(10−6)
30 0.2 33 2.0 2.8
44 0.2 24 2.7 3.9
70 0.2 14 4.7 6.7

The LFI has three frequency bands, covering the range of 30–70 GHz, covering the microwave to infra-red regions of the electromagnetic spectrum. The detectors use high-electron-mobility transistors.[3]

### High Frequency Instrument

The High Frequency Instrument qualification model.
Frequency
(GHz)
Bandwidth
(Δν/ν)
Resolution
(arcmin)
Sensitivity (total intensity)
ΔT/T, 14 month observation
(10−6)
Sensitivity (polarization)
ΔT/T, 14 month observation
(10−6)
100 0.33 10 2.5 4.0
143 0.33 7.1 2.2 4.2
217 0.33 5.5 4.8 9.8
353 0.33 5.0 14.7 29.8
545 0.33 5.0 147 N/A
857 0.33 5.0 6700 N/A

The HFI was sensitive between 100 and 857 GHz, using 48 bolometric detectors, manufactured by JPL/Caltech,[6] optically coupled to the telescope through cold optics, manufactured by Cardiff University's School of Physics and Astronomy,[7] consisting of a triple horn configuration and optical filters, a similar concept to that used in the Archeops balloon-borne experiment. These detection assemblies are divided into 6 frequency bands (centred at 100, 143, 217, 353, 545 and 857 GHz), each with a bandwidth of 33%. Of these six bands, only the lower four have the capability to measure the polarisation of incoming radiation; the two higher bands do not.[3]

On 13 January 2012, it was reported that the on-board supply of helium-3 used in Planck's dilution refrigerator had been exhausted, and that the HFI would become unusable within a few days.[8] By this date, Planck had completed five full scans of the CMB, exceeding its target of two. The LFI (cooled by helium-4) was expected to remain operational for another six to nine months.[8]

## Service Module

Some of the Herschel-Planck team, from left to right: Jean-Jacques Juillet, director of scientific programmes, Thales Alenia Space; Marc Sauvage, project scientist for Herschel PACS experiment, CEA; François Bouchet, Planck operations manager, IAP; and Jean-Michel Reix, Herschel & Planck operations manager, Thales Alenia Space. Taken during presentations of the first results for the missions, Cannes, October 2009.

A common service module (SVM) was designed and built by Thales Alenia Space in its Turin plant, for both the Herschel Space Observatory and Planck missions, combined into one single program.[3]

The overall cost is estimated to be €700 million for the Planck[9] and €1,100 million for the Herschel mission.[10] Both figures include their mission's spacecraft and payload, (shared) launch and mission expenses, and science operations.

Structurally, the Herschel and Planck SVMs are very similar. Both SVMs are octagonal in shape and each panel is dedicated to accommodate a designated set of warm units, while taking into account the dissipation requirements of the different warm units, of the instruments, as well as the spacecraft. On both spacecraft, a common design was used for the avionics, attitude control and measurement (ACMS), command and data management (CDMS), power, and tracking, telemetry and command (TT&C) subsystems. All units on the SVM are redundant.

### Power Subsystem

On each spacecraft, the power subsystem consists of a solar array, employing triple-junction solar cells, a battery and the power control unit (PCU). The PCU is designed to interface with the 30 sections of each solar array, to provide a regulated 28 volt bus, to distribute this power via protected outputs, and to handle the battery charging and discharging.

For Planck, the circular solar array is fixed on the bottom of the satellite, always facing the Sun as the satellite rotates on its vertical axis.

### Attitude and Orbit Control

This function is performed by the attitude control computer (ACC), which is the platform for the attitude control and measurement subsystem (ACMS). It was designed to fulfil the pointing and slewing requirements of the Herschel and Planck payloads.

The Planck satellite rotates at one revolution per minute, with an aim of an absolute pointing error less than 37 arc-minutes. As Planck is also a survey platform, there is the additional requirement for pointing reproducibility error less than 2.5 arc-minutes over 20 days.

The main line-of-sight sensor in both Herschel and Planck is the star tracker.

## Launch and orbit

The satellite was successfully launched, along with the Herschel Space Observatory, at 13:12:02 UTC on 14 May 2009 aboard an Ariane 5 ECA heavy launch vehicle from the Guiana Space Centre. The launch placed the craft into a very elliptical orbit (perigee: 270 km [170 mi], apogee: more than 1,120,000 km [700,000 mi]), bringing it near the L2 Lagrangian point of the Earth-Sun system, 1,500,000 kilometres (930,000 mi) from the Earth.

The manoeuvre to inject Planck into its final orbit around L2 was successfully completed on 3 July 2009, when it entered a Lissajous orbit with a 400,000 km (250,000 mi) radius around the L2 Lagrangian point.[11] The temperature of the High Frequency Instrument reached just a tenth of a degree above absolute zero (0.1 K) on 3 July 2009, placing both the Low Frequency and High Frequency Instruments within their cryogenic operational parameters, making Planck fully operational.[12]

## Decommissioning

In January 2012 the HFI exhausted its supply of liquid helium, causing the detector temperature to rise and rendering the HFI unusable. The LFI continued to be used until science operations ended on 3 October 2013. The spacecraft performed a manoeuvre on 9 October to move it away from Earth and its L2 point, placing it into a heliocentric orbit, while payload deactivation occurred on 19 October. Planck was commanded on 21 October to exhaust its remaining fuel supply; passivation activities were conducted later, including battery disconnection and the disabling of protection mechanisms.[13] The final deactivation command, which switched off the spacecraft's transmitter, was sent to Planck on 23 October 2013 at 12:10:27 UTC.[14]

## Results

Comparison of CMB results from COBE, WMAP and Planck

Planck started its First All-Sky Survey on 13 August 2009.[15] In September 2009, the European Space Agency announced the preliminary results from the Planck First Light Survey, which was performed to demonstrate the stability of the instruments and the ability to calibrate them over long periods. The results indicated that the data quality is excellent.[16]

On 15 January 2010 the mission was extended by 12 months, with observation continuing until at least the end of 2011. After the successful conclusion of the First Survey, the spacecraft started its Second All Sky Survey on 14 February 2010, with more than 95% of the sky observed already and 100% sky coverage being expected by mid-June 2010.[11]

Some planned pointing list data from 2009 have been released publicly, along with a video visualization of the surveyed sky.[15]

On 17 March 2010, the first Planck photos were published, showing dust concentration within 500 light years from the Sun.[17][18]

On 5 July 2010, the Planck mission delivered its first all-sky image.[19]

The first public scientific result of Planck is the Early-Release Compact-Source Catalogue, released during the January 2011 Planck conference in Paris.[20][21]

On 5 May 2014 a map of the galaxy's magnetic field created using Planck was published.[22]

### 2013 data release

On 21 March 2013, the European-led research team behind the Planck cosmology probe released the mission's all-sky map of the cosmic microwave background.[23][24] This map suggests the Universe is slightly older than thought: according to the map, subtle fluctuations in temperature were imprinted on the deep sky when the Universe was about 370,000 years old. The imprint reflects ripples that arose as early in the existence of the Universe as the first nonillionth (10−30) of a second. It is currently theorised that these ripples gave rise to the present vast cosmic web of galactic clusters and dark matter. According to the team, the Universe is 13.798±0.037 billion years old, and contains 4.82±0.05% ordinary matter, 25.8±0.4% dark matter and 69±1% dark energy.[25][26][27] The Hubble constant was also measured to be 67.80±0.77 (km/s)/Mpc.[23][25][28][29][30]

Cosmological parameters from 2013 Planck results[25][31]
Parameter Symbol Planck
Best fit
Planck
68% limits
Planck+lensing
Best fit
Planck+lensing
68% limits
Planck+WP
Best fit
Planck+WP
68% limits
Planck+WP
+HighL
Best fit
Planck+WP
+HighL
68% limits
Planck+lensing
+WP+highL
Best fit
Planck+lensing
+WP+highL
68% limits
Planck+WP
+highL+BAO
Best fit
Planck+WP
+highL+BAO
68% limits
Baryon density ${\displaystyle \Omega _{b}h^{2}}$ 0.022068 0.02207±0.00033 0.022242 0.02217±0.00033 0.022032 0.02205±0.00028 0.022069 0.02207±0.00027 0.022199 0.02218±0.00026 0.022161 0.02214±0.00024
Cold dark matter density ${\displaystyle \Omega _{c}h^{2}}$ 0.12029 0.1196±0.0031 0.11805 0.1186±0.0031 0.12038 0.1199±0.0027 0.12025 0.1198±0.0026 0.11847 0.1186±0.0022 0.11889 0.1187±0.0017
100x approximation to rs = DA (CosmoMC) ${\displaystyle 100\,\theta _{MC}}$ 1.04122 1.04132±0.00068 1.04150 1.04141±0.00067 1.04119 1.04131±0.00063 1.04130 1.04132±0.00063 1.04146 1.04144±0.00061 1.04148 1.04147±0.00056
Thomson scattering optical depth due to reionization ${\displaystyle \tau }$ 0.0925 0.097±0.038 0.0949 0.089±0.032 0.0925 0.089+0.012
−0.014
0.0927 0.091+0.013
−0.014
0.0943 0.090+0.013
−0.014
0.0952 0.092±0.013
Power spectrum of curvature perturbations ${\displaystyle \ln(10^{10}A_{s})}$ 3.098 3.103±0.072 3.098 3.085±0.057 3.0980 3.089+0.024
−0.027
3.0959 3.090±0.025 3.0947 3.087±0.024 3.0973 3.091±0.025
Scalar spectral index ${\displaystyle n_{s}}$ 0.9624 0.9616±0.0094 0.9675 0.9635±0.0094 0.9619 0.9603±0.0073 0.9582 0.9585±0.0070 0.9624 0.9614±0.0063 0.9611 0.9608±0.0054
Hubble's constant (km Mpc−1 s−1) ${\displaystyle H_{0}}$ 67.11 67.4±1.4 68.14 67.9±1.5 67.04 67.3±1.2 67.15 67.3±1.2 67.94 67.9±1.0 67.77 67.80±0.77
Dark energy density ${\displaystyle \Omega _{\Lambda }}$ 0.6825 0.686±0.020 0.6964 0.693±0.019 0.6817 0.685+0.018
−0.016
0.6830 0.685+0.017
−0.016
0.6939 0.693±0.013 0.6914 0.692±0.010
Density fluctuations at 8h−1 Mpc ${\displaystyle \sigma _{8}}$ 0.8344 0.834±0.027 0.8285 0.823±0.018 0.8347 0.829±0.012 0.8322 0.828±0.012 0.8271 0.8233±0.0097 0.8288 0.826±0.012
Redshift of reionization ${\displaystyle z_{re}}$ 11.35 11.4+4.0
−2.8
11.45 10.8+3.1
−2.5
11.37 11.1±1.1 11.38 11.1±1.1 11.42 11.1±1.1 11.52 11.3±1.1
Age of the Universe (Gy) ${\displaystyle t_{0}}$ 13.819 13.813±0.058 13.784 13.796±0.058 13.8242 13.817±0.048 13.8170 13.813±0.047 13.7914 13.794±0.044 13.7965 13.798±0.037
100× angular scale of sound horizon at last-scattering ${\displaystyle 100\,\theta _{*}}$ 1.04139 1.04148±0.00066 1.04164 1.04156±0.00066 1.04136 1.04147±0.00062 1.04146 1.04148±0.00062 1.04161 1.04159±0.00060 1.04163 1.04162±0.00056
Comoving size of the sound horizon at z = zdrag ${\displaystyle r_{drag}}$ 147.34 147.53±0.64 147.74 147.70±0.63 147.36 147.49±0.59 147.35 147.47±0.59 147.68 147.67±0.50 147.611 147.68±0.45

### 2015 data release

Results from an analysis of Planck's full mission were made public on 1 December 2014 at a conference in Ferrara, Italy.[32] A full set of papers detailing the mission results were released in February 2015.[33] Some of the results include:

• More agreement with previous WMAP results on parameters such as the density and distribution of matter in the Universe, as well as more exact results with less margin of error.
• Confirmation of the Universe having a 26% content of dark matter. These results also raise related questions about the positron excess over electrons detected by the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer, an experiment on the International Space Station. Previous research suggested that positrons could be created by the collision of dark matter particles, which could only occur if the probability of dark matter collisions is significantly higher now than in the early Universe. Planck data suggests that the probability of such collisions must remain constant over time to account for the structure of the Universe, negating the previous theory.
• Validation of the simplest models of inflation, thus giving the Lambda-CDM model stronger support.
• That there are likely only three types of neutrinos, with a proposed sterile neutrino flavour unlikely to exist.

Project scientists worked too with BICEP2 scientists to release joint research in 2015 answering whether a signal detected by BICEP2 was evidence of primordial gravitational waves, or was simple background noise from dust in the Milky Way galaxy.[32] Their results suggest the latter.[34]

Cosmological parameters from 2015 Planck results[33][35]
Parameter Symbol TT+lowP
68% limits
TT+lowP
+lensing
68% limits
TT+lowP
+lensing+ext
68% limits
TT,TE,EE+lowP
68% limits
TT,TE,EE+lowP
+lensing
68% limits
TT,TE,EE+lowP
+lensing+ext
68% limits
Baryon density ${\displaystyle \Omega _{b}h^{2}}$ 0.02222±0.00023 0.02226±0.00023 0.02227±0.00020 0.02225±0.00016 0.02226±0.00016 0.02230±0.00014
Cold dark matter density ${\displaystyle \Omega _{c}h^{2}}$ 0.1197±0.0022 0.1186±0.0020 0.1184±0.0012 0.1198±0.0015 0.1193±0.0014 0.1188±0.0010
100x approximation to rs / DA (CosmoMC) ${\displaystyle 100\,\theta _{MC}}$ 1.04085±0.00047 1.04103±0.00046 1.04106±0.00041 1.04077±0.00032 1.04087±0.00032 1.04093±0.00030
Thomson scattering optical depth due to reionization ${\displaystyle \tau }$ 0.078±0.019 0.066±0.016 0.067±0.013 0.079±0.017 0.063±0.014 0.066±0.012
Power spectrum of curvature perturbations ${\displaystyle \ln(10^{10}A_{s})}$ 3.089±0.036 3.062±0.029 3.064±0.024 3.094±0.034 3.059±0.025 3.064±0.023
Scalar spectral index ${\displaystyle n_{s}}$ 0.9655±0.0062 0.9677±0.0060 0.9681±0.0044 0.9645±0.0049 0.9653±0.0048 0.9667±0.0040
Hubble's constant (km Mpc−1 s−1) ${\displaystyle H_{0}}$ 67.31±0.96 67.81±0.92 67.90±0.55 67.27±0.66 67.51±0.64 67.74±0.46
Dark energy density ${\displaystyle \Omega _{\Lambda }}$ 0.685±0.013 0.692±0.012 0.6935±0.0072 0.6844±0.0091 0.6879±0.0087 0.6911±0.0062
Matter density ${\displaystyle \Omega _{m}}$ 0.315±0.013 0.308±0.012 0.3065±0.0072 0.3156±0.0091 0.3121±0.0087 0.3089±0.0062
Density fluctuations at 8h−1 Mpc ${\displaystyle \sigma _{8}}$ 0.829±0.014 0.8149±0.0093 0.8154±0.0090 0.831±0.013 0.8150±0.0087 0.8159±0.0086
Redshift of reionization ${\displaystyle z_{re}}$ 9.9+1.8
−1.6
8.8+1.7
−1.4
8.9+1.3
−1.2
10.0+1.7
−1.5
8.5+1.4
−1.2
8.8+1.2
−1.1
Age of the Universe (Gy) ${\displaystyle t_{0}}$ 13.813±0.038 13.799±0.038 13.796±0.029 13.813±0.026 13.807±0.026 13.799±0.021
Redshift at decoupling ${\displaystyle z_{*}}$ 1090.09±0.42 1089.94±0.42 1089.90±0.30 1090.06±0.30 1090.00±0.29 1089.90±0.23
Comoving size of the sound horizon at z = z* ${\displaystyle r_{*}}$ 144.61±0.49 144.89±0.44 144.93±0.30 144.57±0.32 144.71±0.31 144.81±0.24
100× angular scale of sound horizon at last-scattering ${\displaystyle 100\,\theta _{*}}$ 1.04105±0.00046 1.04122±0.00045 1.04126±0.00041 1.04096±0.00032 1.04106±0.00031 1.04112±0.00029
Redshift with baryon-drag optical depth = 1 ${\displaystyle z_{drag}}$ 1059.57±0.46 1059.57±0.47 1059.60±0.44 1059.65±0.31 1059.62±0.31 1059.68±0.29
Comoving size of the sound horizon at z = zdrag ${\displaystyle r_{drag}}$ 147.33±0.49 147.60±0.43 147.63±0.32 147.27±0.31 147.41±0.30 147.50±0.24
Legend

## References

1. ^ "The Planck space observatory is integrated on Ariane 5 for Arianespace's upcoming launch". Arianespace. 24 April 2009. Retrieved 31 December 2013.
2. ^ "First Second of the Big Bang". How The Universe Works 3. 2014. Discovery Science.
3. "Planck: The Scientific Programme" (PDF). European Space Agency. 2005. ESA-SCI(2005)1. Retrieved 6 March 2009.
4. ^ "Coldest Known Object in Space Is Very Unnatural". Space.com. 7 July 2009. Retrieved 3 July 2013.
5. ^ "Planck: Mission Overview". NASA. Retrieved 26 September 2009.
6. ^ "The Planck High Frequency Instrument (HFI)". Jet Propulsion Laboratory. 21 March 2013. Retrieved 22 March 2013.
7. ^ "High Frequency Instrument (HFI)". Cardiff University. Retrieved 22 March 2013.
8. ^ a b Amos, Jonathan (13 January 2012). "Super-cool Planck mission begins to warm". BBC News. Retrieved 13 January 2012.
9. ^ "Planck: Fact Sheet" (PDF). European Space Agency. 20 January 2012. Archived from the original on 16 October 2012.
10. ^ "Herschel: Fact Sheet" (PDF). European Space Agency. 28 April 2010. Archived from the original on 13 October 2012.
11. ^ a b "Planck: Mission Status Summary". European Space Agency. 19 March 2013. Retrieved 22 March 2013.
12. ^ "Planck instruments reach their coldest temperature". European Space Agency. 3 July 2009. Retrieved 5 July 2009.
13. ^ "Planck on course for safe retirement". European Space Agency. 21 October 2013. Retrieved 23 October 2013.
14. ^ "Last command sent to ESA's Planck space telescope". European Space Agency. 23 October 2013. Retrieved 23 October 2013.
15. ^ a b "Simultaneous observations with Planck". European Space Agency. 31 August 2009. Retrieved 17 August 2012.
16. ^ "Planck first light yields promising results". European Space Agency. 17 September 2009.
17. ^ "Planck sees tapestry of cold dust". European Space Agency. 17 March 2010.
18. ^ "New Planck images trace cold dust and reveal large-scale structure in the Milky Way". European Space Agency. 17 March 2010. Retrieved 17 August 2012.
19. ^ "Planck unveils the Universe — now and then". European Space Agency. 5 July 2010. Retrieved 22 March 2013.
20. ^ "2011 Planck Conference". Retrieved 22 March 2013.
21. ^ "Planck Legacy Archive". European Space Agency.
22. ^ Crockett, Christopher (9 May 2014). "Milky Way's magnetic field mapped". Science News. Retrieved 10 May 2014.
23. ^ a b "Planck Mission Brings Universe Into Sharp Focus". Jet Propulsion Laboratory. 21 March 2013. Retrieved 21 March 2013.
24. ^ "Mapping the Early Universe". The New York Times. 21 March 2013. Retrieved 23 March 2013.
25. ^ a b c See Table 9 in Planck Collaboration (2013). "Planck 2013 results. I. Overview of products and scientific results". arXiv: [astro-ph.CO].
26. ^ "Planck 2013 Results Papers". European Space Agency.
27. ^ Planck Collaboration (2013). "Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters". arXiv: [astro-ph.CO].
28. ^ "Planck reveals an almost perfect Universe". European Space Agency. 21 March 2013. Retrieved 21 March 2013.
29. ^ Overbye, Dennis (21 March 2013). "Universe as an Infant: Fatter Than Expected and Kind of Lumpy". The New York Times. Retrieved 21 March 2013.
30. ^ Boyle, Alan (21 March 2013). "Planck probe's cosmic 'baby picture' revises universe's vital statistics". NBC News. Retrieved 21 March 2013.
31. ^ http://arxiv.org/pdf/1303.5076v1.pdf
32. ^ a b Cowen, Ron; Castelvecchi, Davide (2 December 2014). "European probe shoots down dark-matter claims". Nature. doi:10.1038/nature.2014.16462. Retrieved 6 December 2014.
33. ^ a b "Planck Publications: Planck 2015 Results". European Space Agency. February 2015. Retrieved 9 February 2015.
34. ^ BICEP2/Keck and Planck Collaborations (February 2015). "A Joint Analysis of BICEP2/Keck Array and Planck Data". arXiv: [astro-ph.CO].
35. ^ Planck Collaboration (2015). "Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters". arXiv: [astro-ph.CO].