Politics of Hamilton, Ontario
Politically, Hamilton is known for producing groundbreaking, colourful and left-wing politicians. Locally, though, the big political stories have included the controversial amalgamation of Hamilton with its suburbs in 2001, and the destruction of green space around the Red Hill Valley to make way for the Red Hill Creek Expressway.
The municipal politics of Hamilton, Ontario function within a framework council-manager government with considerable autonomy despite constitutionally-mandated oversight from the Province of Ontario. Hamilton’s mayor is the ceremonial leader of council, with other councillors accepting the role of Deputy Mayor, and thus chair of council, on a rotating basis. The city elects members to its council independently of political parties, though many have strong ties to federal and provincial parties, as well as slates, which have historically been an important part of municipal elections. Hamilton’s politics has been influenced by all major Canadian political parties and, to a certain extent, by the Communist/Labor-Progressive parties and smaller special interest groups.
Presently, Hamilton, Ontario City Council is composed of 15 councillors, elected from each of the city’s wards and one mayor, elected in a city-wide poll. The current composition of council has existed since 2000. The most recent election was held on Monday, October 25th, 2010.
In 1973, the City of Hamilton and the towns of Flamborough, Ancaster, Dundas, Glanbrook, and Stoney Creek were merged into the Region of Hamilton-Wentworth by the government of Bill Davis. The creation of the region sparked a special municipal election that deviated from the two-year terms that Hamilton City Council had observed from 1954. Following the region's establishment, Hamilton’s city council was composed of two aldermen from each of the city’s eight wards and a mayor, elected in a city-wide poll. Hamiltonians were also represented at regional council by the mayor, Board of Control, and one aldermen from each ward, whereas other municipalities in the region were represented by their mayors and an additional regional councillor. Until 1988, the regional chair was appointed by the Ontario government, after which the position was elected in a region-wide poll until the council was dissolved in 2000.
When the city was incorporated in 1846, two aldermen were elected from each of the city's five original wards. The wards constituted the city's original Gore District settlement, and were divided by major streets:
- St. George's - from Paradise Road to John Street, south of King Street to the Niagara Escarpment
- St. Patrick's - from John Street to Emerald Street, south of King Street to the Niagara Escarpment
- St. Lawrence - from Emerald Street to John Street, north of King Street to Hamilton Harbour
- St. Andrew's - from John Street to MacNab Street, north of King Street to Hamilton Harbour
- St. Mary's - from MacNab Street to Paradise Road, north of King Street to Hamilton Harbour
In 1875, the city's growth necessitated the establishment of a new ward, which was done in conjunction with abandoning named wards in favour of numbered divisions. Ward Seven was added in 1881, and Ward Eight was formed in 1910. Though the location and population of each ward would change, the city would retain the same number of wards for 90 years, until amalgamation in 2000.
Hamilton's mayors have been politically diverse, ranging from left-wing trade unionists to Conservative Members of Parliament. From 1943 to 1949, Hamilton's mayor was Sam Lawrence, a stonecutter and prominent member of the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation who is affectionately referred to as Hamilton's 'Labour Mayor'. In a testament to Hamilton's political diversity, prior to Lawrence's election, the city's preceding mayor, William Morrison, had been a Conservative MPP and his predecessor, Herbert Wilton, sat as a federal Conservative MP.
Hamilton's working-class neighbourhoods elected prominent members of the Communist Party and its legal entity during the sixteen years it was outlawed, the Labor-Progressive Party, during the 1930s and 1940s. Ward Seven, which, until 1950, was the area between Sherman Avenue and Ottawa Street, north of King Street to Hamilton Harbour, elected party activists Harry Hunter (1938-1940, 1942-1944), Helen Anderson Coulson (1944-1946) and Peter Dunlop (1946-1949).
Hamilton has traditionally been represented by four to six Members of Provincial Parliament (MPPs) or Members of the Legislative Assembly (MLAs) in the Legislative Assembly of Ontario. Old Hamilton was always suspicious of its larger neighbour and provincial capital, Toronto and had a reputation for being highly unionized. These factors combined to electing working class and left-wing MPPs, often from the New Democratic (NDP) and Liberal parties.
Liberal MPP Lily Munro was caught in the Patti Starr affair which contributed to Premier David Peterson's electoral defeat in 1990. So often under- or unrepresented in at Queen's Park, the old city of Hamilton boasted three MPPs who were ministers in the NDP government of Bob Rae in the 1990s.
By contrast, the suburbs and rural precincts of old Hamilton vote for Progressive Conservative representatives, including government backbenchers for Rae's successor, Mike Harris. The Harris government's forced amalgamation of Hamilton was highly controversial among suburban and urban Hamilton voters. It also made provincial riding boundaries and names automatically coincide with those at the federal level, reducing new Hamilton's representation at Queen's Park, the Provincial Legislature in Toronto, by one member.
Progressive Conservative Prime Minister John Diefenbaker appointed the late Ellen Fairclough as Secretary of State, making her Canada's first female cabinet minister, in 1957. A downtown provincial office building is named in her honour.
John Munro, a Trudeau-era Liberal cabinet minister and husband of Lily Munro, was the subject of political innuendo and criminal allegations dismissed after a Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) probe. He came in fourth in the first mayoral election for amalgamated Hamilton. The Hamilton International Airport was renamed in his honour.
Progressive Conservative Prime Minister Joe Clark appointed Lincoln "Linc" Alexander, the first Black Canadian Member of Parliament, as Minister of Labour in his short-lived government. Alexander later became Lieutenant Governor of Ontario, another first for blacks in Ontario and Canada. Linc was honoured by having the Mountain east-west expressway named after him.
Sheila Copps, daughter of Victor and Geraldine, was a Liberal candidate, first for the Ontario legislature and then for the House of Commons, where she represented Hamilton East from 1984 until 2004. She was a leading member of the Liberal "Rat Pack" while the Liberals were in opposition until 1993. An early and strong supporter of the leadership of Jean Chrétien, she held several posts during her career including Deputy Prime Minister. When Paul Martin became prime minister, however, Copps' star began to wane: she was excluded from cabinet and lost her nomination campaign to Tony Valeri in her re-districted riding.
In the 2006, 2008 and 2011 federal elections, all three of Hamilton's main urban ridings were won by New Democrats Wayne Marston, David Christopherson and Chris Charlton. In those same elections, Hamilton's two predominantly rural ridings were both won by Conservatives David Sweet and Dean Allison.
- "Municipal Act, 2001" S.O. 2001, Chapter 25, Last amendment: 2011, c. 6, Sched. 1, s. 187. (accessed June 2, 2013)
- Florence Sicoli. "Pressure groups are a strong election force," Hamilton Spectator, Monday, November 1, 1982, News, A7
- ”Mayor and Councillors,” City of Hamilton, (accessed June 2, 2013).
- Eric McGuinness. "The Family: 28 members to govern our region," Hamilton Spectator, Saturday, September 29, 1973, pp. 8
- "Elected to the region," Hamilton Spectator, Tuesday, October 2, 1973, pp. 6
- "Region's boss talks harmony," Hamilton Spectator, Tuesday, November 15, 1988, News, A1.
- "Election of city councillors," The Hamilton Spectator and Journal of Commerce, Volume 1, No. 23, Wednesday, September 30, 1846, pg 2.
- "Voters Name Sam Lawrence As Hamilton's Next Mayor," Hamilton Spectator, Tuesday, December 7, 1943, Local News, Pg 11.
- "Herbert Earl Wilton," Parliament of Canada (accessed June 2, 2013)
- "William Morrison, MPP," Legislative Assembly of Ontario (accessed June 2, 2013)
- "Electors Return Most of 1944 Council," Hamilton Spectator Tuesday, December 5, 1944, Local News, pg 11.
- "Sitting Members Of Council Are All Re-Elected," Hamilton Spectator, Tuesday, December 4, 1945, Local News, pg 11.
- "Surprises Feature City Council Race, Dillon, Dunlop Out," Hamilton Spectator, Thursday, December 8, 1949, Local News, pg 19.