Psychiatric disorders of childbirth

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

This article covers the complications of childbirth (parturition, labour, delivery,) not those of pregnancy or the postpartum period. Even with modern obstetrics and pain control, childbirth is still an ordeal for many women. During delivery, or immediately afterwards, dramatic complications are occasionally seen - delirium, stupor, rage, acts of desperation or neonaticide. These complications will be briefly reviewed in turn [1]. With the great improvement in obstetric care, most of them have become rare. There is, however, a great contrast between Europe, North America, Australia, Japan and some other countries with advanced medical care, and the rest of the world. The wealthiest nations produce only 10 million children each year, from a total of 135 million. They have a maternal mortality rate (MMR) of 6–20/100,000. Some poorer nations with high birth rates have an MMR more than 100 times as high,[2] and, presumably, a corresponding prevalence of severe morbidity. In Africa, India & South East Asia, and Latin America, these complications of parturition may still be as important as they have been throughout human history.

Three settings for childbirth[edit]

Modern childbirth[edit]

In nations with state-of-the-art obstetric services, childbirth is always supervised by a midwife or obstetrician. Pain can be relieved by nitrous oxide, pethidine or an epidural anaesthetic, and complications can be dealt with promptly, if necessary by emergency Caesarean section. These services are now standard procedure in many countries. Even so, parturition can still be a severe ordeal, and at least one third find it a traumatic experience [3]. Although women spend only a few days, sometimes only a few hours, in labour, it is often an extreme experience, as shown by the frequency of post-traumatic stress disorder. The complications listed below, though rare, can still occur.

Historic childbirth[edit]

This is a term used here to describe the birth of children before the introduction (in 1847) of effective pain relief [4]. During that time psychiatric complications were clearly described, well recognized and common in countries with the best health services. Those conditions still exist in nations with high birth rates and a dearth of trained staff. At the beginning of this century only about one third of births in tropical Africa and South-East Asia were attended by doctors or midwives [5]. Although there has been some improvement since then [6] [7], it is still true that about half the births in many nations are not supervised by skilled attendants.

Clandestine labour[edit]

The third setting is concealed labour, endured by a woman who has dissembled her pregnancy. Not only is there no analgesia or skilled attendance, but there is no emotional support; on the contrary, the mother’s mental state is disturbed by anger, fear, shame or despair. Most neonaticides occur in this setting. Perpetrators have rarely given a personal account, but experienced obstetricians have attempted a graphic description of their state of mind [8] [9]. There is objective evidence that complications are much more common [10].

Tocophobia[edit]

The word comes from the Greek tokos, meaning parturition. Early authors like Ideler[11] wrote about this fear, and, in 1937, Binder[12] drew attention to a group of women who sought sterilization because of tocophobia. In the last 40 years there have been a series of papers published mainly from Scandinavia. Tocophobia can be primary (before the first child is born) or secondary (typically after extremely traumatic deliveries). Elective Caesarean section is one solution, but psychotherapy can also help these women to give birth vaginally.[13]

Obstetric factitious disorder[edit]

Factitious disorder (self-induced illness) can take many forms, and, during pregnancy, they include obstetric complications such as antepartum bleeding and hyperemesis [14] [15]. They also include simulation of labour by contractions of the abdominal muscles [16] or manipulation of tocodynamometry [17] [18] [19]. Other women have induced premature labour by rupture of the membranes or by prostaglandin suppositories or both [20]. These extreme cases illustrate the strong wish that some women have to bring pregnancy to an end; occasionally they importunately demand premature delivery, whatever the risk to the infant.

Delirium during labour[edit]

Under the name ‘parturient delirium’, this is defined [21] as an acute (usually sudden) clouding of consciousness, lasting minutes or hours, with full recovery. Onset is usually towards the end of labour, and recovery after the birth. Any of the following may be observed – incoherent speech, misidentification of persons, visual hallucinations, inappropriate behaviour such as singing, or memory loss for the episode. A phasic course, with alternate delirium and clarity, continuation into the puerperium, and recurrence after another pregnancy have been described in a few cases.

It was one of the first psychiatric disorders, related to childbearing, to be described [22], and its importance in the early 19th century is indicated by an early classification, stating that it was one of two recognized forms of puerperal insanity [23]. More than 50 cases have been described, most of them in the epoch when parturition was endured without effective pain relief. The disorder has almost disappeared in nations with advanced obstetrics, with only two early 20th century reports [24] [25]. But, within the last ten years, there were 28 nations in which fewer than half the births were attended by skilled birth attendants; they included Nigeria, Pakistan, Ethiopia and Bangladesh, each with more than 3 million births/year [26] . In 2012, it was estimated that 130-180 million infants would be delivered in the quinquennium 2011-2015 without skilled birth attendance [27] . There are still many countries where parturition in the 21st century is like that in Europe in the early 19th century, and women are at risk of becoming delirious during labour.

Unconscious delivery[edit]

Childbirth can occur during natural sleep [28], and under excessively heavy sedation, including alcohol intoxication [29]. A diverse list of medical disorders have led to delivery during coma, including head injury, antepartum bleeding, severe hypotension and hypothermia [30]. Of these the commonest is eclampsia [31]. There are ten cases in the literature of unexplained stupor or coma, including cases with features of catatonia [32].

Acts of desperation[edit]

In women facing death during obstructed labour, panic or despair can drive them to take desperate remedies. There are about twenty cases of suicide attempts or completed suicide [33]. The suicidal motive is not depression or shame, but unbearable pain and despair. The methods – throwing themselves out of the window, hanging or drowning – show the extremity of the mother’s suffering.

There are more than 20 descriptions of auto-Caesarean section [34]. In a few cases the apparent motive has been the destruction of an unwanted child, or psychiatric illness, but the majority have been desperate remedies when the infant cannot be delivered and the nearest obstetric unit was beyond reach. Most of these cases have been reported from poor countries, where contributions to literature are scarce, and they may be more common there. The mother usually survives, but few infants survive.

Psychosis during labour[edit]

Various psychoses can start during labour [35]. Of the organic psychoses, eclamptic, Donkin, epileptic and infective psychoses have all started during labour, although postpartum onset is usual. These differ from parturient delirium in their duration, lasting at least a few days, not a few hours. In addition, there are 19 cases of bipolar episodes with onset during labour; they differ from parturient delirium in their symptomatology (mania rather than delirium) and a duration measured in weeks. These cases are evidence that, on the balance of probability, the trigger of bipolar/cycloid episodes is already active during parturition.

Parturient rage[edit]

During the final painful contractions which lead to the expulsion of the infant, some women have become extremely angry. Before the introduction of effective pain relief (1847), obstetricians were familiar with this, and referred to it under names like parturient rage, furor uterinus, Wut der Gebärenden and colère d’accouchées. Some mothers lost control and attacked their husband, obstetricians, midwives or other attendants. At one time it was common, and clearly described [36] [37]. It still occurs occasionally under modern obstetric conditions.

The infant is at risk, because angry mothers have reached down to haul the baby out, or made a dangerous assault on the new-born; for example, a 40-year old mother, at the end of her 1st pregnancy, kicked away the midwife, tore out the infant, and killed it by striking its head against the bedpost [38]. If this can occur during supervised labours, how much more often will it occur in clandestine births, where the mother has no pain relief or support, and is already bitterly angry about the behaviour of the child’s father. In most neonaticides, the infant is killed by suffocation, drowning or exposure. But in a minority there is extraordinary brutality – the head smashed with multiple fractures or splintering of bone, the head cut or torn off, the infant stabbed many times, or a combination of these. The pathology bears witness to the mother’s mental state. Nowadays, this phenomenon would not regarded as a mental illness, and the only diagnosis could be ‘unspecified disorder of adult personality and behaviour’ [39]. But this has not always been so. In France, Esquirol mentioned a mother who stabbed her infant 26 times with a pair of scizzors; she was acquitted because the judges considered that she was suffering from mental derangement [40]. There is an insoluble judicial problem, because violence is sometimes a feature of delirium; in a clandestine birth, it is impossible to know whether consciousness was clouded or not.

Pathological mental states immediately after the birth[edit]

Immediately after the birth, an exhausted mother, fainting or in shock, may not be able to care for the new-born, who often needs resuscitation, and can suffocate in mucus or blood. Exhaustion alone, without syncope or delirium, can prevent a mother from helping a dying infant; in clandestine labours, it can be fatal to the new-born, without mens rea.

Brief states of delirium have been described with onset after the birth, less common but similar to those that occur during parturition. There are about 20 in the literature [41]. Several of them have been accompanied by violence, and, after recovery a few hours later, followed by amnesia. Occasionally mothers have had recurrent episodes.

Postpartum stupor has been described [42] [43], beginning immediately or very shortly after the birth. The mother remains speechless, immobile and unresponsive to any stimuli for hours or even a day or more [44]. These stupors differ in duration and clinical features from postpartum bipolar disorder. They have been phasic, with recovery and relapse. Their cause is unknown.

Childbirth-related post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)[edit]

Postpartum PTSD was first described in 1978.[45] Since then more than 100 papers have been published. After excessively painful labours, or those with a disturbing loss of control, fear of death or infant loss, or complications requiring forceps delivery or emergency Caesarean section, some mothers suffer symptoms similar to those occurring after other harrowing experiences; these include intrusive memories (flashbacks), nightmares, and a high-tension state, with avoidance of triggers such as hospitals or words associated with parturition [46]. The frequency depends on criteria and severity, but figures of 2-4% are representative [47]; these symptoms can last for many months [48]. Some avoid further pregnancy (secondary tocophobia), and those who become pregnant again may experience a return of symptoms, especially in the last trimester. These mothers can be helped by counseling soon after the birth [49] or a variety of trauma-focused psychological therapies [50].

Complaining reactions[edit]

Another reaction to a severe experience of childbirth is pathological complaining (paranoia querulans in the International Classification of Diseases) [51]. These mothers complain bitterly about perceived mismanagement. The complaints, directed at midwives or other staff members, vary from lack of pain relief, unnecessary epidural anaesthesia, poor condition of the baby, humiliation or ‘dehumanization’, excessive use of technology, student examinations, or lack of explanation and sympathy [52]. Occasionally the content is truly absurd – one mother’s intense resentment was her husband suggesting the wrong name for the infant. In response to these ‘outrages’, mothers may harangue the midwives repeatedly or write critical letters, and are preoccupied with fantasies of revenge – ‘beating the midwives to pulp’, ‘smashing the doctor’s head in’, ‘burning the hospital down’. Angry rumination may continue for weeks, months or more than a year. The frequency is similar to post-traumatic stress disorder [53], and there is an association between the two complications. The effect on child care is like that of severe depression, but the emotional state (furious anger, not sadness and despair) and treatment strategy are different. Psychotherapy is directed at distracting the mother from her grievances, and reinforcing productive child-centered activity; a diary is a useful focus – the therapist listens with sympathy to her complaints, then turns to the written record, expressing pleasure and interest in the mother’s achievements in spite of them.

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Brockington I F (2017) The Psychoses of Menstruation and Childbearing. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  2. ^ Hill K, AbouZahr C, Wardlaw T (2001) Estimates of maternal mortality for 1995. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 79: 182-192.
  3. ^ Soet J E, Brack G A, Dilorio C (2003) Prevalence and predictors of women’s experience of psychological trauma during childbirth. Birth 30: 36-46.
  4. ^ Simpson J Y (1847) A new anaesthetic agent, more efficient than sulphuric ether. Lancet 50: 549-560.
  5. ^ AbouZahr C, Wardlaw T (2001) Maternal mortality at the end of the decade. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 79: 561-573.
  6. ^ Prata N, Passano P, Rowen T, Bell S, Walsh J, Potts M (2011) Where there are (few) skilled birth attendants. Journal of Health Population and Nutrition 29: 81-91.
  7. ^ Crowe S, Utley M, Costello A, Pagel C (2012) How many births in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia will not be attended by a skilled birth attendant between 2011 and 2015? BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth 12: 4.
  8. ^ Gall F J (1822). Sur l'Origine des Qualités Morales et des Facultés Intellectuelles de l'Homme. Paris, Boucher, page 390.
  9. ^ Anonymous (1831-1832) Über die bei dem Verdachte eines Kindermords höchst nötige Vorsicht in der Beurtheilung der die Schwangerschaft und Geburt begleitenden Umstände der Mutter, rücksichtlich ihrer Beziehung zu dem Tode des Kindes. Wildberg’s Magazin für der Gerichtlichen Arzneiwissenschaft 1: 82-88.
  10. ^ Freyer M (1887) Die Ohnmacht bei der Geburt vom gerichtsärzlichen Standpunkt. Berlin, Springer.
  11. ^ Ideler K W (1856) Über den Wahnsinn der Schwangeren. Charité-Annalen 7: 28-47.
  12. ^ Binder H (1937) Psychiatrische Untersuchungen über die Folgen der operativen Sterilisierung der Frau durch partielle Tubenresektion. Schweizer Archiv für Neurologie und Psychiatrie 40: 1-49.
  13. ^ Nerum H, Halvorsen L, Sørile T, Øian P (2006) Maternal request for Cesarean section due to fear of birth: can it be changed through crisis-orientated counseling? Birth 33: 221-228.
  14. ^ Goodlin R C (1985) Pregnant women with Munchausen syndrome. American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology 153: 207-210.
  15. ^ Jureidini J (1993) Obstetric factitious Disorder and Munchausen syndrome by proxy. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease 181: 135-137.
  16. ^ Lyman D (2004) Pseudolabor: a new conversion disorder subtype? A case presentation and literature review. Primary Care Companion Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 6: 61-64.
  17. ^ Lee C Y, Lau M P H (1983) Manipulation of external tachodynomometer by the patient: case report. Henry Ford Hospital Medical Journal 31: 170-172.
  18. ^ Bayer-Zwirello L A, Keroack E, O’Grady J P, Gimovsky M L (1994) Fetal heart rate monitoring casebook. Journal of Perinatology 14: 77-79.
  19. ^ Brink J N, Emerick L E, Caplan J P, Chambliss L R (2014) Use of real-time ultrasonography to diagnose pseudolabor. Psychosomatics 55: 392-395.
  20. ^ Feldman F D, Hamilton J C (2006) Serial factitious disorder and Munchausen syndrome by proxy in pregnancy. International Journal of Clinical Practice 60: 1675-1678.
  21. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p94-100."
  22. ^ Kirkland T (1774) Treatise on childbed fevers and on the methods of preventing them. London, Baldwin and Dawson, pages 60-62.
  23. ^ Reid J (1848) On the causes, symptoms and treatment of puerperal insanity. Journal of Psychological Medicine 1: 128-151.
  24. ^ Pollack (1929) Psychosisok a terhesség, szülés és gyermekágy alatt. Orvosi Hetilap 44: 1110-1104.
  25. ^ Ciulla U (1940) Disturbi psichici e psicosi nello stato puerperale. Monitore Ostetrico-Ginecologico 12: 577-626.
  26. ^ Prata N, Passano P, Rowne T, Bell S, Walsh J, Potts M (2011) Where there are (few) skilled birth attendants. Journal of Health, Population and Nutrition 29: 81-91.
  27. ^ Crowe S, Utley M, Costello A, Pagel C (2012) How many births in sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia will not be attended by a skilled birth attendant between 2011 and 2015? BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth 12: 4.
  28. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p94."
  29. ^ Clay C (1841) On the prevalence of almost unconscious parturition in manufacturing districts. Lancet, pages 404-407.
  30. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p104."
  31. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p101 & 103."
  32. ^ Van Rooy (1908) Een geval van bewusteloosheid tijdens de baring. Verslag van het behandelde in de Vergarderomgem vam Januari to Mei 1908, der Nederlandsche Gynaecologische Vereeniging te Amsterdam door Dr. Catharine van Tussenbroek. Nederlander Tijdschrift voor Verloskunde en Gynaecologie 18: 284-287.
  33. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p114."
  34. ^ Szabo A, Brockington I F (2014) Auto-Caesarean section: a review of 22 cases. Archives of Women’s Mental Health 17: 79-81.
  35. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p115-6."
  36. ^ Kluge M (1833) Mania parturientium transitoria. Medizinische Zeitung 2: 97-98.
  37. ^ Scanzoni F W (1855) Franz A Kiwisch Ritter von Rotterau’s Klinische Vorträge über specielle Pathologie und Therapie der Krankheiten des weiblischen Geschlechtes. Prage, Calve, page 520.
  38. ^ Albert, of Euerdorf (1850) Wut der Gebarenden und Wöchnerinnen. Medizinisches Correspondenzblatt Bayerischer Ärzte 11: 737-738.
  39. ^ World Health Organization. The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders: Clinical Descriptions and Diagnostic Guidelines. Geneva, WHO, F69, page 224.
  40. ^ Gall F J (1822). Sur l'Origine des Qualités Morales et des Facultés Intellectuelles de l'Homme, et sur les Conditions de leur Manifestation. Paris, Boucher, volume 1, pages 391-391.
  41. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p118-9."
  42. ^ Kelso J (1840) Nervous exhaustion dependent on and complicating the puerperal state with cases. Lancet i: 945-948.
  43. ^ Tott C A (1844) Fälle von melancholia attonita bei Neuenbunderen. Neue Zeitschrift für Geburtskunde 16: 187-190.
  44. ^ name="Cambridge 2017, p119-122."
  45. ^ Bydlowski M, Raoul-Duval A (1978) Un avatar psychique méconnu de la puerperalité: la névrose traumatique post obstétricale. Perspectives Psychiatriques 4: 321-328.
  46. ^ James S (2015) Women’s experiences of symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) after traumatic childbirth: a review and critical appraisal. Archives of Women’s Mental Health 18: 761-771.
  47. ^ Alcorn K L, O’Donavan A, Patrick J C, Creedy D, Devilly G J (2010) A prospective longitudinal study of the prevalence of PTSD resulting from childbirth events. Psychological Medicine 40: 1849-1859.
  48. ^ Sentilhes L, Maillard F, Brun S, Madar H, Merlot B, Goffinet F, Deneux-Tharaux C (2017) Risk factors for chronic post-traumatic stress disorder development one year after vaginal delivery: a prospective, observational study. Scientific Reports – Nature 7: 8724; doi: 10.1038/s41598-017-09314x.
  49. ^ Asadzadeh L, Jafari E, Khraghani R, Taremian F (2020) Effectiveness of midwife-led brief counseling intervention on post-traumatic stress disorder, depression and anxiety symptoms of women experiencing a traumatic childbirth: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth 20: 142; doi.org/10.1186/s12884-020-2826-1.
  50. ^ Furuta M, Horsch A, Ng E S W, Bick D, Spain D, Sin J (2018) Effectiveness of trauma-focused psychological therapies for treating post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms in women following childbirth: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Frontiers in Psychiatry 9: 591; doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00591.
  51. ^ The ICD-10 Classication of Mental and Behavioural Disorders: clinical descriptions and diagnostic guidelines. Geneva, World Health Organization, pages 97 & 98.
  52. ^ Brockington I F (1996) Motherhood and Mental Health. Oxford, Oxford University Press, pages 154-156.
  53. ^ Brockington I F, Macdonald E, Wainscott G (2006) Anxiety, obsessions and morbid preoccupations in pregnancy and the puerperium. Archives of Women’s Mental Health 9: 253-263.