This is a good article. Follow the link for more information.

Queer (song)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Single by Garbage
from the album Garbage
  • "Trip My Wire"
  • "Butterfly Collector"
ReleasedOctober 23, 1995 (Australia & New Zealand)
November 20, 1995 (UK)
Format7", 12",
CD maxi, cassette single
Recorded1994–1995, Smart Studios (Madison, Wisconsin)
GenreAlternative rock,[1] downtempo,[2] alternative pop,[3] trip hop
LabelMushroom Records UK
Almo Sounds (North America)
Garbage singles chronology
"Only Happy When It Rains"
"Stupid Girl"
Alternative cover
CD2 cover
CD2 cover
Music video
"Queer" on YouTube

"Queer" is a song written and produced by alternative rock band Garbage for the band's self-titled debut album. The song started as a demo during sessions between band members Butch Vig, Duke Erikson, and Steve Marker, and had its composition finished after singer Shirley Manson joined the band. Manson rewrote the sexualized lyrics to be more ambiguous, and rearranged the song into a subdued trip hop and rock crossover structure.

In 1995, "Queer" was issued as the band's fourth single in the United Kingdom and second internationally. The song quickly became a modern rock success for the fledgling band, with positive reviews from music journalists, and becoming their first top 20 hit in both the UK Singles Chart and Billboard's Hot Modern Rock Tracks chart. It also earned attention with its music video by Stéphane Sednaoui, which featured Manson detaining, stripping and shaving a man from a first-person perspective. The video earned much airplay on MTV and was nominated for Breakthrough Video at the 1996 MTV Video Music Awards.


"Queer" began as a rough demo around January 1994, recorded during informal studio sessions between Butch Vig, Duke Erikson, and Steve Marker in Marker's home basement recording studio in Madison, Wisconsin.[4] The band had been jamming using an ADAT eight-track, AKAI samplers, and a small drum kit.[5] The band had written around five songs that they felt were pretentious and lyrically simple and literal. They did not want Erikson to sing, even though he was a competent singer, because they wanted to avoid sounding like their previous band Spooner. Vig and Marker were uncomfortable with their vocals so tended to bury them deep in the mix or distort them with effects; on "Queer", Vig recorded a "scratch vocal" consisting of him screaming his way through. The recorded work was later discarded, which Vig explained was because the trio discovered that the musical experiments they were attempting "[don't] work when you're trying to write a song and put it in a context that works".[6] Vig's inspiration for "Queer" came from a novel he had read "about this woman who was hired to go and make this guy's son a 'man'. The kid is missing a few marbles. But then he realizes that the women [sic] who came to his room is also fucking his father."[7]

After Marker saw Shirley Manson's group Angelfish on 120 Minutes, the band invited her to Vig and Marker's Smart Studios to sing on a couple of songs. One of the compositions was "Queer", whose incomplete lyrics forced Manson to ad-lib in an audition that was described as "dreadful". The singer afterwards returned to Angelfish, which folded shortly later.[8][9] Manson eventually returned to Smart for a successful second audition and then began working on the songs Vig, Marker and Erikson had created. Manson rewrote "Queer" into a trip hop arrangement[10] and added ambiguous lyrics that allowed the listener to make up their own mind about what the song meant. She also re-sang the "Queer" vocal in an understated style.[6] It was then that the band knew that Garbage was going to work.[11]

Garbage incorporated a sample of the drumline from Australian band Single Gun Theory's track "Man of Straw" on "Queer";[12] this loop was layered with an additional drum part performed by Madison percussionist Clyde Stubblefield, who was known for being the most sampled drummer in history for his uncredited part on James Brown's "Funky Drummer".[13] Vig opted to hire Stubblefield to play on the record rather than sample him as "you don't use a sample when the genius who played the sample lives down the street from you", and the drummer also contributed to album cut "Not My Idea".[14] Bass guitar parts were completed by Milwaukee session bassist Mike Kashou.[15] The band wanted to sample a clarinet part from a Frank Sinatra record, but the licensing for the sample would have been prohibitively expensive. Mulling over some options, such as having a session musician interpolate the part themselves still led to having to pay large royalties. The idea was dropped.[16] The band still liked the idea of using a clarinet, and recorded a part by Les Thimming on the final mix.[15]

Manson later explained, "It's not, as you might think, to do with being gay, but tolerance. My granny has the expression 'Or's queer, except thee and me, and sometimes even thee's queer', that is that you think you are normal and the rest of the world is freaky, but we're all equally to blame".[17] Garbage did not write the song to particularly appeal to the gay community, however Erikson stated: "As musicians, we're totally open to [the song's gay appeal]. There's been enough exposure to gay issues in the mainstream media that people are finally ready to deal with it. Even if it's something controversial, people are still beginning to open up".[11] Erikson added: "The song isn't about sex at all, it's about the loss of innocence".[11]

Single release[edit]

Almo Sounds released "Queer" as the band's second single to alternative radio in the United States at the end of August 1995, upfront of August 15 North American release date of Garbage. The song debuted at the end of September on the Modern Rock Tracks chart at number 30.[18] The following week, Garbage debuted on the Billboard 200 at number 193,[19] having spent the previous four weeks as a rising Heatseekers title.[20] At the beginning of October, "Queer" debuted at number 62 on the Hot 100 Airplay chart,[21] peaking a week later at number 57.[22] In mid-November, remixes of "Queer" were sent to clubs.[23] "Queer" peaked at 12th on the Modern Rock chart in its ninth week,[24] but did not earn enough airplay to chart in the Billboard Hot 100.[9] The song eventually finished its run on the Modern Rock chart in December 1995, for a total of 14 weeks.[25]

On October 23, 1995, "Queer" was issued as the band's second single in Australia[26] and New Zealand. White issued a three-track CD single and cassette single backed with two newly recorded tracks, "Girl Don't Come" and "Sleep",[27] which had been recorded for the UK release of "Only Happy When It Rains".[28] "Queer" peaked at number 55 in Australia, spending twelve weeks on the ARIA top 100 singles chart.[29] In New Zealand, "Queer" debuted on the RIANZ charts at number 45 at the start of November, rising to a number 37 peak three weeks later.[30] Across Europe, "Queer" was issued by BMG in a similarly configured CD single; a three-track release backed with "Girl Don't Come" and "Sleep".[31] In Belgium's Wallonia-region, "Queer" peaked at number 24 at the end of January 1996.[32] "Queer" debuted and peaked at 7th in Iceland the following month.[33] In Spain, "Queer" peaked at number 33 on the airplay chart.[34] In April 1996, performed "Queer" live on French television show Nulle Part Ailleurs and headlined a show at the Élysée Montmartre in Paris;[35] BMG France released a three-track CD single of "Queer" featuring "Trip My Wire" and the Rabbit in the Moon remix.[36]

Initially, Mushroom Records had scheduled "Queer" to be the lead single for the UK release of the debut album Garbage, matching the international single release strategy. At last minute, it was decided to release "Only Happy When It Rains" upfront of the album, with "Queer" rescheduled to later in 1995 to coincide with the band's first UK live show.[37] "Queer" was quickly picked up by radio, and was B-listed by Radio One, whose breakfast slot DJ Chris Evans championed it as his "Single of the Week",[38] and playlisted by Virgin Radio.[39] "Queer" reached number 35 on the airplay chart.[39] Mushroom issued the single on a limited edition 7" vinyl and a gold and silver CD single set on November 20, 1995.[38] Each CD single was backed with a newly recorded track—"Trip My Wire" on the first and a cover version of The Jam's "Butterfly Collector" on the second (the cover later featured in The Jam compilation album Fire and Skill).[38] Four remixes of the title track were spread out across the CDs, with one also appearing on the flipside of the vinyl.[37] Early indications showed that the single had a midweek position of 10,[40] however at the end of its first week on-sale, "Queer" debuted on the UK Singles Chart at number 13.[41] That week, Garbage made a live appearance to perform the single on Top of The Pops,[42] and performed both "Queer" and "Only Happy When it Rains" on MTV's Most Wanted.[43]

Collector's format[edit]

As the band had received significant attention from the special packaging of their first three releases, "Queer" was also released in this manner.[37] Mushroom's product manager had a longer time to design the package than the other singles; this was a result of "Queer" being held back three months so that "Only Happy When It Rains" could launch the album.[44] Garbage's original suggestion for "Queer" was to create a jade velvet box, but Mushroom vetoed the idea over the cost.[44] The label sourced a plastics company to create the case, which was made from injection-molded polystyrene, similar to the process of manufacturing jewel cases. The company charged Mushroom £10,000 to have the mould created. The end product was finished with frosted effect for the "G" logo, which was stickered, and within placed the vinyl record in a card picture sleeve; this cost Mushroom £2.21 per unit (a loss of 95p for each sale). This special single had only 5,000 copies issued.[37]

Critical reception[edit]

Upon both the release of Garbage and the release of "Queer" as a single, the song received a positive reception from music journalists. Leo Finlay, in a Music Week article highlighting the campaign for the debut album's release wrote, "'Queer' is eerily reminiscent of Magazine's stranger moments".[45] A reviewer for NME wrote that the single was "an ode to recognising and tolerating those mis-shapen ones among us",[46] and when reviewing the album, their own Shannon O'Connell wrote, "there is a bit of Pat Benatar in [this songs] back-alley swagger".[47] A reviewer for VOX described "Queer" as "Voice of the Beehive roughing up L7",[48] Jackie Hinden of Hot Press wrote that the song was "a slinky work-out against a restrained work-to-rule industrial backing",[49] and the publication later made it their Single of the Fortnight, describing it as "Almost indecently brilliant. There's an intelligence at work here in the lyrics and in the music which makes "Queer" a unique proposition, and Garbage utterly indispensable".[50] A writer for Melody Maker wrote that "Queer" was "sleek, cultivated perversion... sinister and menacing",[51] while Raw's review described it as "brilliant, Seductive and slow-burning",[52] and the single reviewer for NME considered that Manson's performance "elevates a sing-song shuffle into a lullaby to sexual non-conformity".[53] Rolling Stone described the song as a "more roundly shaped tune orchestrated with this same love of junk and command of finesse."[54] Kerrang! rated "Queer" as their Single of the Week, stating "an incredible knee-trembling fuck tune... the dirtiest pop tune you'll hear all year. [You'll be] sucked into dark satin sexiness and you'll never want to leave. Gorgeously decadent and utterly fabulous."[55]

Track listings and formats[edit]

"Queer" was the first Garbage single to include remixes as a commercial b-side; Mushroom spread four across the UK formats. These were completed by producers Adrian Sherwood, Danny Saber, Depeche Mode's Martin Gore, and Florida-based group Rabbit in the Moon.[38] In 2007, the Heftybag mix by Rabbit in the Moon was remastered and included on the limited edition of greatest hits collection Absolute Garbage.[56]

Music video[edit]

Garbage attacking the detained protagonist of the "Queer" video.

The music video for "Queer" directed by Stéphane Sednaoui for Propaganda Films and was filmed in July 1995 in Los Angeles.[63] Sedanoui's video concept developed from his own personal experience of being "shredded into pieces" by a beautiful woman. Garbage loved his storyboard for "Queer", feeling it matched the ambiguous nature of the song.[64] Manson had chosen Sednaoui as director after she saw the "Big Time Sensuality" music video he directed for Björk, and later said that Sednaoui "doesn't just take an idea and apply it to different artists, he seems to be able to figure out where the artist is coming from and make the photographs and the videos unique to that group."[64]

The black and white storyline of the video saw a young male's first person perspective of exiting an elevator onto a Los Angeles street and meeting Manson. She coyly entices him to follow her to her home where the men from Garbage are waiting. They detain him inside, forcing him up onto the second-level of the house, where Manson throws him to the floor, strips him of his clothing and blinds him with gaffer tape. He recovers to find Manson shaving his head, before she drags him outside by his legs. He is then seen strangely happy, and in full colour, leaving the street.[63]

Director Stéphane Sednaoui shot the whole video himself with a hand-held camera. Here singer Shirley Manson spins him.

Sednaoui operated the camera for the whole shoot.[64] To capture the victim's struggle, Sednaoui positioned the camera at ground-level facing upwards towards Garbage, who were standing on a rotating platform. To suggest the victim was almost hallucinating, strobe lighting was combined with the rotation of the platform, however the effect caused the band to suffer from vertigo after a number of takes.[63] Manson later claimed that the video helped establish her group; "He really defined for us who we were visually. Stéphane was able to look at the band and listen to the music and figure out what was the perfect visual partner for the band. People think we're a very stylish band, and it's all to do with him". She added, "I'm really proud of "Queer", I think it's one of our best videos."[64]

The "Queer" video premiered on North American networks on August 14, 1995;[65] where it was given heavy support by MTV, who certified it a Buzz Clip.[9][66] MTV requested an edit to obscure the shot of Manson blinding the video's protagonist before playlisting it.[63] The music video for "Queer" was nominated in the Breakthrough Video category at the 1996 MTV Video Music Awards,[67] losing to Smashing Pumpkins' "Tonight, Tonight".[68] The silver dress Manson wore in the video was later donated to the Hard Rock Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas, Nevada for indefinite display.[69]

The "Queer" video was first commercially released, accompanied with out-take footage from the shoot, on 1996's Garbage Video VHS and Video-CD.[70] A remastered version was included on Garbage's 2007 greatest hits DVD Absolute Garbage[56] and made available as a digital download via online music services the same year.[71]

Release history[edit]

Release date Territory Record label Format(s)
August 1995 United States Almo Sounds Airplay: Modern rock
October 23, 1995 Australia White Records CD single, cassette single
Europe BMG CD maxi
November 11, 1995 United States Almo Sounds Club play (12" promos)
November 20, 1995 United Kingdom Mushroom Records UK 7" single, 2×CD single set
April 1996 France BMG France CD single
May 5, 1997 United Kingdom Mushroom Records UK 12" vinyl (as Queer Remixes)

Comprehensive charts[edit]

Chart (1995) Peak
Australia (ARIA)[29][72] 55
Canada Alternative 30 (RPM)[73] 6
New Zealand (RIANZ)[30] 37
Scotland (Official Charts Company)[74] 20
UK (Official Charts Company)[41] 13
US Billboard Hot 100 Airplay[22] 57
US Billboard Modern Rock Tracks[24] 12
Chart (1996) Peak
Belgium (Ultratop 50 Wallonia)[32] 24
Iceland Singles (IFPI)[33] 7
Spain Airplay (AFYVE)[34] 33


  1. ^ "GARBAGE/ NOT YOUR KIND OF PEOPLE". Bangkok Post. May 8, 2012. Retrieved October 21, 2014. They produced a string of alternative rock anthems including Queer...
  2. ^ Peak, Alex (July 18, 2012). "Garbage Was Always Good". Retrieved January 28, 2015.
  3. ^ Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. "Garbage – Garbage review". Allmusic. Retrieved October 3, 2014.
  4. ^ Malins, Steve (September 1, 1996). "What's Our Problem?". Q. Detroit, Michigan: 50–53.
  5. ^ "Garbage (Butch Vig Q&A)". GearSlutz. Retrieved August 26, 2010.
  6. ^ a b Kaufman, Gil (1995). "Garbage Rise From The House That Grunge Built". Addicted to Noise. Archived from the original on December 18, 2002. Retrieved July 20, 2011.
  7. ^ "Garbage: Nevermind where they bin' where they goin'?". Top 40: 3. March 1996. Archived from the original on February 12, 2001.
  8. ^ "Garbage: Behind The Music, VH1, aired March 31, 2002"
  9. ^ a b c Borzillo, Carrie (March 23, 1996). "Garbage's Serendipitous Success; Popularity Falls into Place for Almo Act". Billboard. Los Angeles: 9, 97.
  10. ^ Simpson, Dave (March 18, 1995). Modern Life is Rubbish. UK: Melody Maker. pp. 42–43.
  11. ^ a b c P., J. (May 1, 1996). "Queerest of the Queer". Scene. USA: 81.
  12. ^ "AOL Garbage Interview". AOL Online. August 20, 1995. Archived from the original on April 13, 2009. QUEER is several different loops- There is loop from the Single Gun Theory, Clyde Stubblefield – a great drummer who played with James Brown and lives in Madison,
  13. ^ Aaron, Charles (June 1, 1997). Disco-techs and the Sex-O-Lette. USA: Spin. pp. 56–58, 60, 62, 64, 128–129.
  14. ^ "THE COALITION FOR CLYDE STUBBLEFIELD". Chip In. Retrieved July 26, 2011.
  15. ^ a b Garbage (booklet). Almo Records. 1995. p. 3. AMSSD-80004. Bass: Mike Kashou; Additional drums: Clyde Stubblefield; Clarinet: Les Thimmig
  16. ^ Bardin, Brantley (November 1995). "Beyond the Pail". Details. Archived from the original on February 12, 2001. Retrieved July 20, 2011.
  17. ^ Aston, Martin (December 20, 1995). Scary! Cooing! Loving!. UK: Raw. pp. 22–25.
  18. ^ Modern Rock Tracks. Billboard. September 23, 1995. p. 99.
  19. ^ Billboard 200. Billboard. September 30, 1995. p. 105.
  20. ^ Billboard's Heatseekers. Billboard. September 30, 1995. p. 17.
  21. ^ Hot 100 Airplay. Billboard. October 7, 1995. p. 107.
  22. ^ a b Billboard Hot 100 Airplay. Billboard. October 14, 1995. p. 81. Retrieved February 8, 2011.
  23. ^ "Queer / Garbage". United States Copyright Office. November 11, 1995. SR0000232502 1996-11-11 Queer / Garbage. PRO-A-4827 33 1/3 rpm; 12 in; 4 versions; ℗ Almo Sounds
  24. ^ a b Hot Modern Rock Tracks. Billboard. November 18, 1995. p. 85.
  25. ^ "Modern Rock Tracks". Billboard. December 30, 1995.
  26. ^ "New Release Summary – Product Available from: 23/10/95 (from The ARIA Report Issue No. 297)". (original document published by ARIA). Retrieved March 31, 2017.
  27. ^ a b Queer (Australian CD/cassette Single liner notes). Garbage. White. 1996. D1211/C1211.CS1 maint: others (link)
  28. ^ Sampson, Dave (September 30, 1995). It's a Pity About Garbage. UK: Melody Maker.
  29. ^ a b Ryan, Gavin (2011). Australia's Music Charts 1988–2010. Mt. Martha, VIC, Australia: Moonlight Publishing.
  30. ^ a b "Garbage – Queer". Retrieved January 19, 2011.
  31. ^ a b Queer (European CD Maxi Single liner notes). Garbage. BMG. 1995. 74321 32776 2.CS1 maint: others (link)
  32. ^ a b "GARBAGE – QUEER (CHANSON)". , Retrieved January 19, 2011.
  33. ^ a b Islenski Listinn. Dagblaðið Vísir. February 10, 1996. p. 38. Retrieved July 26, 2011.
  34. ^ a b Salaverrie, Fernando (2002). Sólo éxitos. Año a año. 1959–2002. Madrid: Foundation Author of the General Society of Authors and Editores (SGAE).
  35. ^ Marker, Steve (May 10, 1996). "Planes, Food Poisoning and Smelly Buses". Addicted to Noise. Archived from the original on October 3, 1999. Retrieved July 27, 2011.
  36. ^ a b Queer (French CD Maxi Single liner notes). Garbage. BMG. 1996. 74321 38220 2.CS1 maint: others (link)
  37. ^ a b c d Davis, Andy (1997). "Three Men and A Babe; Welcome to Spooner Town; Goodbye Angelfish". Record Collector. London (#209).
  38. ^ a b c d "Queer (Garbage Communication Number 2)" (Press release). Mushroom Records. 1995. Retrieved July 27, 2011.
  39. ^ a b "Garbage Album Campaign History" (Press release). Mushroom Records (NCM Group). 2001. Retrieved February 3, 2008.
  40. ^ O'Connell, Shannon (December 2, 1995). Trash on Delivery. UK: Melody Maker.
  41. ^ a b "TOP 40 OFFICIAL UK SINGLES ARCHIVE (2nd December 1995)". The Official Charts Company. Retrieved January 17, 2010.
  42. ^ "December 1, 1995 Episode". Top of the Pops. December 1, 1995. BBC One.
  43. ^ "November 22, 1995 Episode". MTV's Most Wanted. November 22, 1995. MTV Europe.
  44. ^ a b Gar-barge Press Conference. London, UK: Here Be Monsters. July 25, 1995. As told by Butch Vig
  45. ^ Finlay, Leo (September 30, 1995). "Talent; Garbage". Music Week.
  46. ^ "Single Reviews; Queer". New Musical Express. UK. November 11, 1995.
  47. ^ O'Connell, Shannon (September 30, 1995). "What A Waste!". New Musical Express. UK.
  48. ^ "Album Reviews; Garbage". VOX. UK. October 1, 1995.
  49. ^ Binden, Jackie (September 27, 1995). "Dump It Up". Hot Press. Ireland.
  50. ^ "Single Reviews; Queer". Hot Press (Vol 19; No.23 ed.). Ireland. November 29, 1995.
  51. ^ "Singles of The Year; No. 48 "Queer"". Melody Maker. UK. December 9, 1995.
  52. ^ "Single Reviews". Raw. UK. November 15, 1995.
  53. ^ "Single Reviews". New Musical Express. November 18, 1995.
  54. ^ Hunter, James (September 21, 1995). "Garbage Album Review". Rolling Stone. Retrieved October 12, 2014.
  55. ^ "Singlez; Queer". Kerrang!. UK. November 25, 1995. {{Rating|5|5}}
  56. ^ a b "New Best of Album". Archived from the original on June 20, 2009. Retrieved July 22, 2011.
  57. ^ Queer (UK 7-inch Vinyl Single liner notes). Garbage. Mushroom Records UK. 1995. SX1237.CS1 maint: others (link)
  58. ^ Queer (UK CD Single liner notes). Garbage. Mushroom Records UK. 1995. D1237.CS1 maint: others (link)
  59. ^ Queer (UK CD Single liner notes). Garbage. Mushroom Records UK. 1995. DX1237.CS1 maint: others (link)
  60. ^ Queer (US promotional 12" vinyl Single liner notes). Garbage. Almo Sounds. 1995. PRO-A-4827.CS1 maint: others (link)
  61. ^ Queer (US promotional CD Single liner notes). Garbage. Almo Sounds. 1995. PRO-CD-4778.CS1 maint: others (link)
  62. ^ Queer Remixes (UK 12-inch Vinyl Single liner notes). Garbage. Mushroom Records UK. 1997. TRASH12.CS1 maint: others (link)
  63. ^ a b c d Atwood, Brett (September 16, 1995). "Bowie Gets Graphic, Garbage Clips 'Queer'; Garbage in, Garbage out". Billboard. Los Angeles.
  64. ^ a b c d Stéphane Sednaoui & Shirley Manson (2005). Stephane Sednaoui & Shirley Manson: Filming 'Queer' (DVD). Director's Label: The Work of Director Stéphane Sednaoui: PALM Pictures. Retrieved September 23, 2006.
  65. ^ "Queer / Stephane Sednaoui". United States Copyright Office. August 14, 1995. Retrieved July 27, 2011. PA0000704796; Queer / Stephane Sednaoui; Videocassette; 3/4 in; Music video performed by Garbage; Almo Sounds
  66. ^ Aston, Martin (October 1995). "New to Q; Garbage". Q. UK: 23.
  67. ^ Atwood, Brett (August 12, 1996). "Pumpkins Lead Video Music Award Noms". Billboard magazine: 76. Retrieved January 19, 2011.
  68. ^ "MTV Video Music Awards | 1996". Viacom, MTV. Retrieved July 27, 2011. Among the awards they nabbed were Breakthrough Video and Video of the Year for "Tonight, Tonight,"
  69. ^ "Garbage Fast Facts". Archived from the original on October 7, 2000. Retrieved May 21, 2007. On October 6, the Hard Rock Hotel & Casino in Las Vegas, NV received a donated piece of Garbage memorabilia. The outfit Shirley Manson wore in the "Queer" video – from the band's multi-platinum debut album – will be on display indefinitely.
  70. ^ The Screens Are Full of Garbage. UK: Melody Maker. December 7, 1996.
  71. ^ "Garbage – Queer video". iTunes. Retrieved July 16, 2011.
  72. ^ "The ARIA Australian Top 100 Singles Chart – Week Ending 28 Jan 1996". Retrieved June 2, 2016.
  73. ^ "Queer in Canadian Rock/Alternative Singles Chart". Library and Archives Canada. Retrieved June 4, 2013.
  74. ^ "Official Scottish Singles Chart Top 100; 26 November 1995 – 02 December 1995". Official Charts Company. Retrieved February 22, 2015.

External links[edit]