|This article relies largely or entirely on a single source. (November 2013)|
A quiet PC is a personal computer that makes very little, or no noise. Common uses for quiet PCs include video editing, sound mixing and home theater PCs, but noise reduction techniques can also be used to greatly reduce the noise from servers. There is currently no standard definition for a "quiet PC", and the term is generally not used in a business context, but by individuals and the businesses catering to them.
A proposed general definition is that the sound emitted by such PCs should not exceed 30 dBA, but in addition to the average sound pressure level, the frequency spectrum and dynamics of the sound are important in determining if the sound of the computer is noticed. Sounds with a smooth frequency spectrum (lacking audible tonal peaks), and little temporal variation are less likely to be noticed. The character and amount of other noise in the environment also affects how much sound will be noticed or masked, so a computer may be quiet with relation to a particular environment or set of users.
- 1 History
- 2 Causes of noise
- 3 Measuring noise
- 4 Noise reduction methods
- 5 Individual components in a quiet PC
- 5.1 Motherboards
- 5.2 CPUs
- 5.3 Video cards
- 5.4 Power supplies
- 5.5 Cases
- 5.6 Cooling systems
- 5.7 Secondary storage
- 5.8 External components
- 6 Laptops
- 7 References
- 8 External links
Prior to about 1975, all computers were typically large industrial/commercial machines, often in a centralized location with a dedicated room-sized cooling system. For these systems noise was not an important issue.
The first home computers, such as the Commodore 64, were very low power - and therefore could run fanless or, like the IBM PC, with a low-speed fan only used to cool the power supply, so noise was seldom an issue.
By the mid 1990s as CPU clock speeds increased above 60 MHz, "spot-cooling" was added by means of a fan over the CPU heatsink to blow air onto the processor. Over time, more fans were included to provide spot-cooling in more locations where heat dissipation was needed - including the 3D graphics cards as they grew more powerful. Computer cases increasingly needed to add fans to extract heated air from the case, but unless very carefully designed, this would add more noise.
Energy Star, in 1992, and similar programs led to the widespread adoption of sleep mode among consumer electronics, and the TCO Certification program promoted lower energy consumption. Both added features that allowed systems to only consume as much power as is needed at a particular moment - and helped reduce power consumption. In a similar manner the first low power and energy conserving CPUs were developed for use in laptops; but can be used in any machine to reduce power requirements - and hence noise.
Causes of noise
The main causes of PC noise are:
- Mechanical friction generated by disk drives and fan bearings
- Vibration from disk drives and fans
- Air turbulence caused by obstructions in the flow of air
- Air vortex effects from fan blade edges
- Electrical whine ; noise generated by electrical coils or transformers used in power supplies, motherboards, video cards or LCD monitors.
Many of these causes increase with the power of the computer: more transistors of a given size use more power, which releases more heat - and increasing the rotation speed of fans to address this will, (all things being equal) increase their noise. Similarly, increasing hard disk drives and optical disc drives rotation speeds increases performance - but generally also vibration and bearing friction.
Though standards do exist for measuring and reporting sound power output by such things as computer components, they are often ignored. Many manufacturers do not give sound power measurements. Some report sound pressure measurements, but those that do often do not specify how sound pressure measurements were taken. Even such basic information as measurement distance is rarely reported. Without knowing how it was measured, it is not possible to verify these claims, and comparisons between such measurements (e.g. for product selection) are meaningless. Comparative reviews, which test several devices under the same conditions, are more useful, but even then, an average sound pressure level is only one factor in determining which components will be perceived as quieter.
Noise reduction methods
Common noise reduction methods
- Use large, efficient heat sinks
- Incorporate heat pipes, which have much higher effective thermal conductivity than solid copper.
- Use fans with lower-speed, larger-diameter fans versions
- Use fans with low bearing and motor noise
- Rather than constant-speed fans, use thermostatically controlled variable speed fans that runs at less than maximum speed, and thus runs quieter, most of the time.
- Use an efficient power supply to minimize waste heat
- Use quieter models of hard drive
- Use solid state devices like compact flash or Solid-state drives rather than traditional hard drives
- Use remote networked via SMB or NFS rather than local disk.
- Place a damping material such as Sorbothane around hard drives or other spinning items
- Use sound insulation material to absorb sound and dampen case resonance.
- Water cooling, although difficult to set up, may be useful in some situations.
A number of methods exist for reducing computer noise at little or no added cost.
- Reduce CPU supply voltage ("undervolting"). Many of today's CPUs can run stably at their stock speed, or even with a slight overclock, at a reduced voltage, which reduces heat output. Power consumption is approximately proportional to V2·f, that is, it varies linearly with the clock frequency and quadratically with the voltage. This means that even a small reduction in voltage can have a large effect in power consumption. Undervolting and underclocking can also be used with chipsets and GPUs.
- Enable Cool'n'Quiet for AMD CPUs or SpeedStep (also known as EIST) on Intel's CPUs.
- Reduce fan speed. For newer computers, the speed of fans can be varied automatically, depending on how hot certain parts of the computer get. Lowering a DC fan motor's supply voltage will reduce its speed while making it quieter and lowering the amount of air the fan moves. Doing this arbitrarily could lead to components overheating; therefore, whenever performing hardware work it is advised to monitor the temperature of system components. Fans with Molex connectors can be modified easily. With 3-pin fans, either fixed inline resistors or diodes, or commercial fan controllers, such as the Zalman Fanmate, can be used. Software like speedfan may allow fan speed control. Many newer motherboards support pulse-width modulation (PWM) control, allowing the fan speed to be set in the BIOS or with software.
- Mount fans on anti-vibration mounts.
- Remove restrictive fan grills to allow easier airflow, or replace noisy fan grills with quieter versions.
- Use software such as Nero DriveSpeed or RimhillEx to reduce the speed of optical drives.
- Isolate hard disk noise, either by using anti-vibration mounts (generally rubber or silicone grommets), or by suspending the hard disk to fully decouple it from the computer chassis by mounting it in a 5.25 inch drive bay with viscoelastic polymer mounts.
- Set the hard disk's AAM value to its lowest setting. This reduces the seek noise produced by the hard drive, but also reduces performance slightly.
- Set operating system to spin down hard drives after a short time of inactivity. This may reduce a drive's life span and commonly conflicts with the OS and running programs, though it can still be useful for drives that are only used for data storage.
- Defragment hard drives to reduce the drive heads' need to search widely for data. This can also improve performance.
- Arrange components and cables to improve airflow. Wires hanging inside the computer can block the airflow, which can increase the temperature. They can be easily moved to the side of the case so that air can pass through more easily
- Remove dust from inside the computer. Dust on computer parts will retain more heat. Fans draw in dust along with outside air, it can build up quickly inside the computer. Dust can be removed with a vacuum cleaner, gas duster or compressed air. Special anti-static vacuum cleaners should be used however to prevent electrostatic discharge (ESD). Ideally, this would be done often enough to prevent a significant amount of dust from ever building up. How frequently this would need to be performed would depend entirely on the environment in which the computer is used.
In some cases an acceptable solution may be to relocate the too-noisy computer outside the immediate working area, and access it either with long-distance HDMI/USB/DVI cables or via remote desktop software from a quiet thin client, e.g. based on a Raspberry Pi, a miniature computer that does not even use a heat sink.
Individual components in a quiet PC
The following are notes regarding individual components in quiet PCs.
The motherboard, CPU, and video card are major energy users in a computer. Components that need less power will be easier to cool quietly. A quiet power supply is selected to be efficient while providing enough power for the computer.
A motherboard based on a chipset that uses less energy will be easier to cool quietly. Undervolting and underclocking generally require motherboard support, but when available can be used to reduce energy use, and heat output - and therefore cooling requirements.
Many modern motherboard chipsets have hot northbridges which may come with active cooling, in the form of a small, noisy fan. Some motherboard manufacturers have replaced these fans by incorporating large heatsinks or heatpipe coolers, however they still require good case airflow to remove heat. Motherboard voltage regulators also often have heatsinks and may need airflow to ensure adequate cooling.
Motherboards can also produce audible electromagnetic noise.
The heat output of a CPU can vary according to its brand and model or, more precisely, its thermal design power (TDP). Intel's third revision Pentium 4, using the "Prescott" core, was infamous for being one of the hottest-running CPUs on the market. By comparison, AMD's Athlon series and the Intel Core 2 perform better at lower clock speeds, and thus produce less heat.
Modern CPUs often incorporate energy saving systems, such as Cool'n'Quiet, LongHaul, and SpeedStep. These reduce the CPU clock speed and core voltage when the processor is idle, thus reducing heat. The heat produced by CPUs can be further reduced by undervolting, underclocking or both.
Most modern mainstream and value CPUs are made with a lower TDP to reduce heat, noise, and power consumption. Intel's dual-core Celeron, Pentium, and i3 CPUs generally have a TDP of 35–54 W, while the i5 and i7 are generally 64–84 W (in the newest variant, Haswell) or 95W (older versions, such as Sandy Bridge). Older CPUs such as the Core 2 Duo typically had a TDP of 65 W, while the Core 2 Quad CPUs were mostly 65–95 W. AMD's Athlon II x2 CPUs were 65 W, while the Athlon x4 was 95 W. The AMD Phenom ranged from 80 W in the x2 variant to 95 and 125 W in the quad-core variants. The AMD Bulldozer CPUs range from 95–125 W. The APUs range from 65 W for the lower-end dual-core variants, such as the A4, to 100 W in the higher-end quad-core variants, such as the A8. Some processors come in special low power versions. For example, Intel's lower TDP CPUs end in T (35 W) or S (65 W).
Video cards can produce a significant amount of heat. A fast GPU may be the largest power consumer in a computer and because of space limitations, video card coolers often use small fans running at high speeds, making them noisy.
Options to reduce noise from this source include:
- Replace the stock cooler with an aftermarket one.
- Use motherboard video output – typically motherboard video takes less power, but provides lower gaming or HD video decoding performance;
- Select a video card that does not use a fan.
PSUs are made quieter through the use of higher efficiency (which reduces waste heat and need for airflow), quieter fans, more intelligent fan controllers (ones for which the correlation between temperature and fan speed is more complex than linear), more effective heatsinks and through designs which allow air to flow through with less resistance. For a given power supply size, more efficient supplies, such as those certified 80 plus, generate less heat.
A power supply of appropriate wattage for the computer is important for high efficiency and minimizing heat. Power supplies are typically less efficient when lightly or heavily loaded. High wattage power supplies will typically be less efficient when lightly loaded, for instance when the computer is idle or sleeping. Most desktop computers spend most of their time lightly loaded. For example, most desktop PCs draw less than 250 watts at full load, and 200 watts or less is more typical.
Power supplies with thermally controlled fans can be made quieter by providing a cooler and/or less obstructed source of air, and fanless power supplies are available - either with large passive heat sinks or relying on convection or case airflow to dissipate heat. It is also possible to use fanless DC to DC power supplies that operate like those in laptops, using an external power brick to supply DC power, which is then converted to appropriate voltages and regulated for use by the computer. These power supplies usually have lower wattage ratings.
The electrical coils in power supplies can produce audible electromagnetic noise which can become noticeable in a quiet PC.
Powering the PSU with a powercore with a Ferrite bead, can sometimes help to reduce humming from the PSU.
Cases designed for low noise usually include quiet fans, and often come with a quiet power supply. Some incorporate heatsinks to cool components passively.
Larger cases provide more space for airflow, larger coolers and heatsinks and sound dampening material.
Cases designed to be quiet typically have wire grills or honeycombed fan grills; both are far superior to the older-style of stamped grill.
Features that facilitate neat cable management, such as brackets and space to run cables behind motherboard tray, help increase cooling efficiency.
Air filters can help to prevent dust from coating heatsinks and surfaces, thereby impeding heat transfer, making fans spin faster. However the filter itself can increase noise if it restricts airflow too much, or is not cleaned, requiring a larger or faster fan to handle the pressure drop behind the filter.
The inside of a case can be lined with dampening materials to reduce noise by:
- attenuating the vibration of the case panels via extensional damping or constrained-layer damping
- reducing the amplitude of the vibration of the case panels by increasing their mass
- absorbing airborne noise, such as with foam
If they use fans at all, quiet PCs typically use larger-than-usual low-speed fans with quiet-running motors and bearings. The 120 mm size is common, and 140 mm fans are used where cases or heatsinks allow them. Quiet fan manufacturers include Nexus, EBM-Papst, Yate Loon, Scythe, and Noctua. Extensive comparative surveys have been posted by SPCR and MadShrimps.
Fan noise is often proportional to fan speed, so fan controllers can be used to slow down fans and to precisely choose fan speed. Fan controllers can produce a fixed fan speed using an inline resistor or diode; or a variable speed using a potentiometer to supply a lower voltage. Fans speed can also be reduced more crudely by plugging them into the power supply's 5 volt line instead of the 12 volt line (or between the two for a potential difference of 7 volts, although this cripples the fan's speed sensing). Most fans will run at 5 volts once they are spinning, but may not start reliably at less than 7 V. Some simple fan controllers will only vary the fans' supply voltage between 8 V and 12 V to avoid this problem entirely. Some fan controllers start the fan at 12 V, then drop the voltage after a few seconds.
Pulse Width Modulation (PWM) fan control however is the easiest and most efficient option for modern motherboards which have PWM fan headers. PWM fan control rapidly cycles between feeding the fan full voltage and no voltage to control rotational speed. Typically the motherboard chipset provides temperature data from sensors on the CPU itself to control speed.
Bearing and motor noise is an important consideration. Soft mounting fans (e.g. with rubber or silicone fan isolators) can help reduce transfer of fan vibrations to other components.
Piezoelectric fans are often quieter than rotating fans and may consume less power,. and Intel, Murata and others have recently done development on use of piezoelectric fans in desktop PCs.
Water-cooling is a method of heat-dissipation by transferring the heat through a conductive material which is in contact with a liquid, such as demineralised water with an additive to prevent bacterial growth. This water travels in a loop which usually contains a reservoir, radiator and pump. Modern 12v DC pump technologies allow extremely powerful and quiet designs.
By efficiently transferring device heat to a separate heat exchanger which can use larger heat sinks or fans, water cooling can allow quieter overall operation. Devices such as GPUs, Northbridges, Southbridges, hard disk drives, memory, voltage regulator modules (VRMs), and even power supplies can be separately water-cooled; in fact the whole PC can be immersed in some cases.
The smaller 2.5" form-factor hard drives generally vibrate less, are quieter, and use less power than traditional 3.5" drives, but often have lower performance and less capacity, and cost more per gigabyte.
To minimize vibrations from a hard drive being transferred to, and amplified by, the case, hard drives can be mounted with soft rubber studs, suspended with elastics or placed on soft foam or Sorbothane. Hard disk enclosures can also help reduce drive noise, but care must be taken to ensure that the drive gets adequate cooling - with disk temperatures often be monitored by SMART software.
Solid-state drives have no moving mechanical components and run silently, but (as of 2016[update]) are still roughly four times more expensive per unit of storage than consumer-grade HDDs.
In some cases, other solid state storage methods may be suitable:
- Compact Flash (CF) cards can be used as secondary storage. Because they use a slightly modified Parallel ATA (PATA) interface, a simple adapter is all that is needed to connect CF cards to function as an PATA or PC Card hard disk. CF cards are also small, allowing SFF PCs to be made, produce no noise, use very little power (further reducing heat output in the AC/DC conversion in the PSU), and an insignificant amount of heat. However, they are very expensive per GB and are only available in small capacities and there are also issues regarding the maximum number of writes to each sector.
- USB flash drives can be used if a motherboard supports booting from USB. They are based on flash memory, so have the same advantages and disadvantages as CF cards, except that speed is limited by the USB bus.
- i-RAM is a solid-state disk which has four DIMM slots to allow regular PC RAM to be used like a disk. It is much faster than a hard disk, does not have the write cycle limitations of flash memory, however it requires power continuously in order to maintain its contents (from standby power or a battery when the system is off), uses more power than many laptop hard drives, has maximum capacity of 4 GiB, and is expensive.
All forms of solid-state storage are more expensive that traditional disk, so some quiet PC designs use them in conjunction with a secondary hard drive which is only accessed when needed, or with network-attached storage, where less-quiet traditional hard drives are kept remote.
Optical drives can be slowed down by software to quiet them, such as Nero DriveSpeed, or emulated by virtual drive programs such as Daemon Tools to eliminate their noise entirely. Notebook optical drives can be used, which tend to be quieter, however this may be because they tend to run slower (typically 24× CD speed, 8× DVD speed). Some DVD drives have a feature, commonly called Riplock, which reduces drive noise by slowing the drive during video playback. For playback operations only 1x (or real time) speed is required.
CRT monitors can produce coil noise, as can the external power supply for an LCD monitor or the voltage converter for the monitor's backlight. LCD monitors tend to produce the least noise (whine) when at full brightness. Reducing brightness using the video card does not introduce whine, but may reduce color accuracy. An LCD monitor with an external power supply tucked out of the way will produce less noticeable noise than one with the power supply built into the screen housing.
In the past, particularly noisy printers such as dot matrix and daisy wheel designs were often housed in soundproofed boxes or cabinets, and the same technique can be used with modern printers to reduce their perceived noise. Another solution is to network the printer, and locate it physically away from the immediate work area.
In contrast to desktop PCs, laptops and netbooks typically do not have power supply fans or video card fans, generally use physically smaller hard drives and lower power components. However, laptop CPU fans are usually smaller, so may not necessarily be quieter than their desktop counterparts - and limited space, limited access and proprietary components make silencing them more difficult.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2006-09-21). "What is a "Silent" Computer". Silent PC Review (SPCR). Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Thompson, Robert Bruce; Thompson, Barbara Fritchman (2004-12-01). "Building the Perfect PC". Dev hardware. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- "TCO takes the initiative in comparative product testing". 2008-05-03. Retrieved 2008-05-03.
- JIANG, LIXIN. "Fundamentals of Harddisk Drive Acoustics" (PDF). www.roush.com. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
- Noise Generation Mechanisms
- "Acoustic noise", jmcproducts.com
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2008-11-05). "How to stop the whining noise of your LCD monitor". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-11-05.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2003-10-28). "A Primer on Noise in Computing". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2005-04-06). "Power Supply Fundamentals". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Rabaey, JM (1996), Digital Integrated Circuits, Prentice Hall.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2002-03-26). "Get 12V, 7V or 5V for your Fans". SPCR. Retrieved 10 October 2008.
- VM, Mich (2006-08-12). "Motherboard Chipset Cooler Roundup". BE: Mad shrimps. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2002-07-16). "Recommended Heatsinks". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Stepin, Alexey; Lyssenko, Yaroslav; Shilov, Anton (2007-05-24). "Almost a Champion: ATI Radeon HD 2900 XT Gaming Performance Review". X bit labs. Retrieved 10 October 2008.
- New Arctic Accelero Hybrid 7970 graphics card cooler, Hexus, 2012-10-08, retrieved 2012-09-18.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2004-07-16). "Fanless VGA Cards list – a start!" (forum). SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2006-12-01). "Recommended Power Supplies". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2005-04-06). "Power Supply Fundamentals". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2006-05-09). "Tiny, Silent and Efficient: The picoPSU". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2006-02-23). "Fanless Ultra Powerhouse PC by EndPCNoise". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Antec P180, SPCR.
- Antec P150, SPCR.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2003-03-12). "Cases: Basics & Recommendations". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2006-01-10). "Quiet PC for Torrid Thailand". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- jmke (2009-12-07). "All Heatsink Tests Done by Madshrimps In One Place (CPU Heatsink Comparison Database)". BE: Madshrimps. Retrieved 2013-11-21.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2005-06-17). "Scythe SCNJ-1000 Ninja heatsink". SPCR. Retrieved 2013-11-21.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2002-07-16). "Recommended Heatsinks". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- EBM Papst.
- Scythe, EU
- Baranov, Viktor (2006-05-23). "New coolers Noctua NH-U9 and NH-U12 – quiet and effective cooling". Digital daily. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2006-11-27). "Fan Round-Up". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2007-03-04). "Recommended Fans". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- "120mm Fan Roundup: 17 Fans Compared". BE: Madshrimps. 2002-07-16. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- "120mm Fan Roundup: 35 Fans Compared". BE: Mad shrimps. 2008-02-13. Retrieved 2009-02-13.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2005-08-11). "AcoustiProducts Vibration Dampers". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Sauciuc, Ioan (February 2007). "Piezo actuators for electronics cooling". Electronics Cooling Magazine. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- braun, Rob. "Compact Mac Upgrades". mac69k.info. Retrieved 3 April 2016.
- Acosta, Jeremy. "Water Cooling or Air Cooling For PC". Games and Gears Elite.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2002-09-18). "Recommended Hard Drives". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-08-02.
- Chin, Michael ‘Mike’ (2005-08-16). "Seagate Momentus 5400.2 120GB SATA notebook drive". SPCR. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- STEC."SSD Power Savings Render Significant Reduction to TCO." Retrieved October 25, 2010.
- Whittaker, Zack. "Solid-state disk prices falling, still more costly than hard disks". Between the Lines. ZDNet. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- "What is solid state disk? - A Word Definition From the Webopedia Computer Dictionary". Webopedia. ITBusinessEdge. Retrieved 14 December 2012.
- Vamsee Kasavajhala (May 2011). "SSD vs HDD Price and Performance Study, a Dell technical white paper" (PDF). Dell PowerVault Technical Marketing. Retrieved 15 June 2012.
- Lucas Mearian (3 March 2016). "SSD prices plummet again, close in on HDDs". Computerworld.
- "Where to find EWF Information". msdn.com. 2005-10-26. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Nadel, Brian (2005-04-28). "Dell Latitude X1 Laptop Reviews". CNET. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- "Panasonic CF-W5 Specification Sheet" (PDF). EU: Toughbook. Archived from the original (PDF) on February 24, 2007. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- "Panasonic CF-T5 Specification Sheet" (PDF). EU: Toughbook. Archived from the original (PDF) on February 16, 2007. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- Beeler, Brian (2006-01-03). "Fujitsu P7120 (P7120D)". Notebook Review. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
|The Wikibook How To Assemble A Desktop PC has a page on the topic of: Silencing|
- How To Silence A Computer, US: Quiet PC.
- Build A Quiet PC, End PC noise.
- Cooling The Silent PC, End PC noise.
- Silent PC Review – articles on various aspects of PC acoustics.
- PC, SE: Silent.
- Parekh, Alan, Homebuilding of a PWM Fan controller (project).