Radical mastectomy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Radical mastectomy
William Stewart Halsted, Surgical papers Wellcome L0004968.jpg
Radical Mastectomy

Radical mastectomy is a surgical procedure involving the removal of breast, underlying chest muscle (including pectoralis major and pectoralis minor), and lymph nodes of the axilla as a treatment for breast cancer. Breast cancer is the most common cancer among women today, and is primarily treated by surgery, particularly during the early twentieth century when the mastectomy was developed with success.[1] However, with the advancement of technology and surgical skills, the extent of mastectomies has been reduced. Less invasive mastectomies are employed today in comparison to those in the past.[2] Nowadays, a combination of radiotherapy and breast conserving mastectomy are employed to optimize treatment.

Radical mastectomy[edit]

Portrait of William Halsted
Pectoralis Major

Halsted and Meyer were the first to achieve successful results with the radical mastectomy, thus ushering in the modern era of surgical treatment for breast cancer. In 1894, William Halsted published his work with radical mastectomy from the 50 cases operated at Johns Hopkins between 1889 and 1894.[3] Willy Meyer also published research on radical mastectomy from his interactions with New York patients in December 1894.[4] The en bloc removal of the breast tissue became known as the Halsted mastectomy before adopting the title "the complete operation" and eventually, "the radical mastectomy" as it is known today.[5]

Radical mastectomy was based on the medical belief at the time that breast cancer spread locally at first, invading nearby tissue and then spreading to surrounding lymph ducts where the cells were "trapped". It was thought that hematic spread of tumor cells occurred at a much later stage.[1] Halsted himself believed that cancer spread in a "centrifugal spiral", solidifying this opinion in the medical community at the time.[6]

Radical mastectomy involves removing all the breast tissue, overlying skin, the pectoralis muscles, and all the axillary lymph nodes. Skin was removed because the disease involved the skin, which was often ulcerated.[3][7] The pectoralis muscles were removed not only because the chest wall was involved, but also because it was thought that removal of the transpectoral lymphatic pathways were necessary. It was also thought, at that time, that it was anatomically impossible to do a complete axillary dissection without removing the pectoralis muscle.[3][4]

William Halsted accomplished a three-year recurrence rate of 3% and a locoregional recurrence rate of 20% with no perioperative mortality. The five-year survival rate was 40%, which was twice that of untreated patients.[3] However, post-operation morbidity rates were high as the large wounds were left to heal by granulation, lymphedema was ubiquitous, and arm movement was highly restricted. Thus, chronic pain became a prevalent sequela. Because surgeons were faced with such large breast cancers that seemed to need drastic treatment methods, the quality of patient life was not taken into consideration.[7][8][9][10][11][12][13][excessive citations]

Nonetheless, due to Halsted and Meyer's work, it was possible to cure some cases of breast cancer and knowledge of the disease began to increase. Standardized treatments were created, and controlled long-term studies were conducted. Soon, it became apparent that some women with advanced stages of the disease did not benefit from surgery. In 1943, Haagensen and Stout reviewed over 500 patients who had radical mastectomy for breast cancer and identified a group of patients who could not be cured by radical mastectomy thus developing the concepts of operability and inoperability.[14] The signs of inoperability included ulceration of the skin, fixation to the chest wall, satellite nodules, edema of the skin (peau d'orange), supraclavicular lymph node enlargement, axillary lymph nodes greater than 2.5 cm, or matted, fixed lymph nodes.[14] This contribution of Haagensen and his colleagues would eventually lead to the development of a clinical staging system for breast cancer, the Columbia Clinical Classification, which is a landmark in the study of biology and treatment of breast cancer.[citation needed]

Today, surgeons rarely perform radical mastectomies, as a 1977 study by the National Surgical Adjuvant Breast and Bowel Project (NSABP), led by Bernard Fisher, showed that there was no statistical difference in survival or recurrence between radical mastectomies and less invasive surgeries.[15][16]

Extended radical mastectomies[edit]

According to the Halsted-Meyer theory, the major pathway for breast cancer dissemination was through the lymphatic ducts. Therefore, it was thought that performing wider and more mutilating surgeries that removed a greater number of lymph nodes would result in greater chances of cure.[17] From 1920 onwards, many surgeons performed surgeries more invasive than the original procedure by Halsted. Sampson Handley noted Halsted's observation of the existence of malignant metastasis to the chest wall and breast bone via the chain of internal mammary nodes under the sternum and employed an "extended" radical mastectomy that included the removal of the lymph nodes located there and the implantation of radium needles into the anterior intercostal spaces.[18] This line of study was extended by his son, Richard S. Handley, who studied internal mammary chain nodal involvement in breast cancer and demonstrated that 33% of 150 breast cancer patients had internal mammary chain involvement at the time of surgery.[19] The radical mastectomy was subsequently extended by a number of surgeons such as Sugarbaker and Urban to include removal of internal mammary lymph nodes.[20][21] Eventually, this "extended" radical mastectomy was extended even further to include removal of the supraclavicular lymph nodes at the time of mastectomy by Dahl-Iversen and Tobiassen.[22] Some surgeons like Prudente even went as far as amputating the upper arm en bloc with the mastectomy specimen in an attempt to cure relatively advanced local disease.[23] This increasingly radical progression culminated in the ‘super-radical’ mastectomy which consisted of complete excision of all breast tissue, axillary content, removal of the latissimus dorsi, pectoralis major and minor muscles and dissection of the internal mammary lymph nodes.[24] After retrospective analysis, the extended radical mastectomies were abandoned as these massive and disabling operations proved to be not superior to those of the standard radical mastectomies.[citation needed]


  1. ^ a b Zurrida, Stefano; Bassi, Fabio; Arnone, Paolo; Martella, Stefano; Castillo, Andres Del; Martini, Rafael Ribeiro; Semenkiw, M. Eugenia; Caldarella, Pietro (2011-06-05). "The Changing Face of Mastectomy (from Mutilation to Aid to Breast Reconstruction)". International Journal of Surgical Oncology. 2011: 980158. doi:10.1155/2011/980158. ISSN 2090-1402. PMC 3263661. PMID 22312537.
  2. ^ Plesca M, Bordea C, El Houcheimi B, Ichim E, Blidaru A (2016). "Evolution of radical mastectomy for breast cancer". J Med Life. 9 (2): 183–6. ISSN 1844-3117. PMC 4863512. PMID 27453752.
  3. ^ a b c d Halsted, William S. (1894-11-01). "I. The Results of Operations for the Cure of Cancer of the Breast Performed at the Johns Hopkins Hospital from June, 1889, to January, 1894". Annals of Surgery. 20 (5): 497–555. doi:10.1097/00000658-189407000-00075. ISSN 0003-4932. PMC 1493925. PMID 17860107.
  4. ^ a b W. Meyer, "An improved method of the radical operation for carcinoma of the breast", New York Medical Record, vol. 46, pp. 746–749, 1894.
  5. ^ Sakorafas, G.h.; Safioleas, Michael (2010-01-01). "Breast cancer surgery: an historical narrative. Part II. 18th and 19th centuries". European Journal of Cancer Care. 19 (1): 6–29. doi:10.1111/j.1365-2354.2008.01060.x. ISSN 1365-2354. PMID 19674073.
  6. ^ Newmark, J.J. (2016). "No ordinary meeting': Robert McWhirter and the decline of radical mastectomy". The Journal of the Royal College of Physicians of Edinburgh. 46 (1): 43–48. doi:10.4997/jrcpe.2016.110. PMID 27092369.
  7. ^ a b HALSTED, WILLIAM STEWART (1913-02-08). "Developments in the Skin-Grafting Operation for Cancer of the Breast". JAMA: The Journal of the American Medical Association. 60 (6): 416. doi:10.1001/jama.1913.04340060008004. ISSN 0002-9955.
  8. ^ Riddell, V. H. (2017-04-21). "The Technique of Radical Mastectomy: With Special Reference to the Management of the Skin Short Case and the Prevention of Functional Disability". British Journal of Cancer. 4 (3): 289–297. doi:10.1038/bjc.1950.27. ISSN 0007-0920. PMC 2007674. PMID 14783660.
  9. ^ Neumann, Charles G.; Conway, Herbert (1948-01-01). "Evaluation of skin grafting in the technique of radical mastectomy in relation to function of the arm". Surgery. 23 (3): 584–90. ISSN 0039-6060. PMID 18906044.
  10. ^ Bard, Morton (2017-04-21). "The sequence of emotional reactions in radical mastectomy patients". Public Health Reports. 67 (11): 1144–1148. doi:10.2307/4588308. ISSN 0094-6214. JSTOR 4588308. PMC 2030852. PMID 12993982.
  11. ^ Parker, Joe M.; Russo, P. E.; Oesterreicher, D. L. (1952). "Investigation of Cause of Lymphedema of the Upper Extremity After Radical Mastectomy". Radiology. 59 (4): 538–545. doi:10.1148/59.4.538. PMID 12983584.
  12. ^ JR, VON RONNEN (1955-01-01). "[Spontaneous rib fractures after radical mastectomy]". Journal Belge de Radiologie. 38 (4): 525–34. ISSN 0302-7430. PMID 13331884.
  13. ^ Fitts WT, Keuhnelian JG, Ravdin IS, Schor S (March 1954). "Swelling of the arm after radical mastectomy; a clinical study of its causes". Surgery. 35 (3): 460–64. PMID 13146467.
  14. ^ a b Townsend, Courtney; Abston, Sally; Fish, Jay (May 1985). "Surgical Adjuvant Treatment of Locally Advanced Breast Cancer". Ann Surg. 201 (5): 604–10. doi:10.1097/00000658-198505000-00009. PMC 1250769. PMID 3994434.
  15. ^ Fisher, B.; Montague, E.; Redmond, C.; Barton, B.; Borland, D.; Fisher, E. R.; Deutsch, M.; Schwarz, G.; Margolese, R. (June 1977). "Comparison of radical mastectomy with alternative treatments for primary breast cancer. A first report of results from a prospective randomized clinical trial". Cancer. 39 (6 Suppl): 2827–2839. doi:10.1002/1097-0142(197706)39:6<2827::aid-cncr2820390671>3.0.co;2-i. ISSN 0008-543X. PMID 326381.
  16. ^ Mukherjee, Siddhartha (2011). The Emperor of All Maladies. New York, NY: Simon & Schuster. pp. 200–201. ISBN 978-1-4391-0795-9.
  17. ^ Carey, J.M.; Kirklin, J.W. (1952-10-01). "Extended radical mastectomy: a review of its concepts". Proceedings of the Staff Meetings of the Mayo Clinic. 27 (22): 436–40. ISSN 0092-699X. PMID 13004011.
  18. ^ Schachter, Karen; Neuhauser, Duncan (1981). Surgery for breast cancer. DIANE Publishing. ISBN 9781428924581.
  19. ^ Handley, R. S.; Thackray, A. C. (1954-01-09). "Invasion of Internal Mammary Lymph Nodes in Carcinoma of the Breast". British Medical Journal. 1 (4853): 61–63. doi:10.1136/bmj.1.4853.61. ISSN 0007-1447. PMC 2093179. PMID 13106471.
  20. ^ Sugarbaker, E. D. (1953-09-01). "Radical mastectomy combined with in-continuity resection of the homolateral internal mammary node chain". Cancer. 6 (5): 969–979. doi:10.1002/1097-0142(195309)6:5<969::aid-cncr2820060516>3.0.co;2-5. ISSN 0008-543X. PMID 13094645.
  21. ^ Urban, J. A. (1964-03-01). "Surgical excision of internal mammary nodes for breast cancer". The British Journal of Surgery. 51 (3): 209–212. doi:10.1002/bjs.1800510311. ISSN 0007-1323. PMID 14129436. S2CID 5680572.
  22. ^ Dahl-Iversen, E.; Tobiassen, T. (1969-12-01). "Radical mastectomy with parasternal and supraclavicular dissection for mammary carcinoma". Annals of Surgery. 170 (6): 889–891. doi:10.1097/00000658-196912000-00006. ISSN 0003-4932. PMC 1387715. PMID 5352643.
  23. ^ PACK, GEORGE T. (1961-11-01). "Interscapulomammothoracic Amputation for Malignant Melanoma". Archives of Surgery. 83 (5): 694–9. doi:10.1001/archsurg.1961.01300170050010. ISSN 0004-0010. PMID 14483062.
  24. ^ "Super Radical Mastectomy". TheFreeDictionary.com. Retrieved 2017-04-02.