Radioresistance

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search

Radioresistance is the level of ionizing radiation that organisms are able to withstand.

Ionizing-radiation-resistant organisms (IRRO) were defined as organisms for which the dose of acute ionizing radiation (IR) required to achieve 90% reduction (D10) is greater than 1000 gray (Gy) [1]

Radioresistance is surprisingly high in many organisms, in contrast to previously held views. For example, the study of environment, animals and plants around the Chernobyl disaster area has revealed an unexpected survival of many species, despite the high radiation levels. A Brazilian study in a hill in the state of Minas Gerais which has high natural radiation levels from uranium deposits, has also shown many radioresistant insects, worms and plants.[2][3] Certain extremophiles, such as the bacteria Deinococcus radiodurans and the tardigrades, can withstand large doses of ionizing radiation on the order of 5,000 Gy.[4][5][6]

Induced radioresistance[edit]

This is a graph showing the effect of fractionation on the ability of gamma rays to cause cell death. The blue line is for cells which were not given a chance to recover while the red line is for cells which were allowed to stand for a time and recover.

In the graph on left, a dose/survival curve for a hypothetical group of cells has been drawn with and without a rest time for the cells to recover. Other than the recovery time partway through the irradiation, the cells would have been treated identically.

Radioresistance may be induced by exposure to small doses of ionizing radiation. Several studies have documented this effect in yeast, bacteria, protozoa, algae, plants, insects, as well as in in vitro mammalian and human cells and in animal models. Several cellular radioprotection mechanisms may be involved, such as alterations in the levels of some cytoplasmic and nuclear proteins and increased gene expression, DNA repair and other processes.

Many organisms have been found to possess a self-repair mechanism that can be activated by exposure to radiation in some cases. Two examples of this self-repair process in humans are described below.

Devair Alves Ferreira received a large dose (7.0 Gy) during the Goiânia accident, and lived, whereas his wife, who got a dose of 5.7 Gy, died. The most likely explanation[citation needed] is that his dose was fractionated into many smaller doses which were absorbed over a length of time while his wife stayed in the house more and was subjected to continuous irradiation without a break so giving the self repair mechanisms in her body less time to repair some of the damage done by the radiation. This resulted in her death. He also eventually died. In the same way some of the persons who worked in the basement of the wrecked Chernobyl have built up doses of 10 Gy, these workers received these doses in small fractions so the acute effects were avoided.

It has been found in radiation biology experiments that if a group of cells are irradiated then as the dose increases the number of cells which survive decrease. It has also been found that if a population of cells are given a dose before being set aside (without being irradiated) for a length of time before being irradiated again then the radiation has less of an ability to cause cell death. The human body contains many types of cells and a human can be killed by the loss of a single tissue in a vital organ. For many short term radiation deaths (3 days to 30 days) the loss of cells forming blood cells (bone marrow) and the cells in the digestive system (wall of the intestines) cause death.

Inheritance of radioresistance[edit]

There is strong evidence that radioresistance can be genetically determined and inherited, at least in some organisms. Heinrich Nöthel, a geneticist from the Freie Universität Berlin carried out the most extensive study about radioresistance mutations using the common fruit fly, Drosophila melanogaster, in a series of 14 publications.

Radioresistance in radiation oncology[edit]

Radioresistance is also a term sometimes used in medicine (oncology) for cancer cells which are difficult to treat with radiotherapy. Radioresistance of cancer cells may be intrinsic or induced by the radiation therapy itself.

Radioresistance comparison[edit]

The comparison in the table below is only meant to give approximate indications of radioresistance for different species and should be taken with great caution. There are generally big differences in radioresistance for one species among experiments, due to the way radiation affects living tissues and to different experimental conditions. We should for example consider that because radiation impedes cell division, immature organisms are less resistant to radiations than adults, and adults are sterilized at doses much lower than that necessary to kill them. For example, for the insect parasitoid Habrobracon hebetor, the LD50 for haploid embryo during cleavage (1-3 hours of age) is 200 R, but about 4 hours later it is of 7,000 R (for X-ray intensity of 110 R/minute), and haploid (= male) embryos are more resistant than diploid (= female) embryos.[7] The mortality of adults H. hebetor exposed to a dose of 180,250 R is the same to this of a non-irradiated control group (food was not provided to either groups) (for 6,000 R/minute).[8][9] However, a lower dose of 102,000 R (for 6,000 R/minute) is sufficient to induce a state of lethargy in H. hebetor that is manifested by a complete cessation of activity, including cessation of feeding, and these individuals eventually let themselves starve to death.[9] And an even lower dose of 4,858 R (for 2,650 R/minute) is sufficient to sterilize adult female H. hebetor (sterility arises 3 days post-exposure).[10] Other important factors that influence the level of radioresistance include: The length of time during which a dose of radiation is delivered—with doses delivered during longer periods, or at time intervals, being associated with greatly reduced negative effects;[10][11] The feeding state of individuals—with pre-fed and post-fed individuals being more resistant to radiations compared to starved individuals;[10][11] The type of radiation used (e.g., tardigrades Milnesium tardigradum irradiated with heavy ions have a higher survival than when irradiated with gamma rays, for a same irradiation dose);[12] The physiological state of individuals (e.g., the tardigrade species Richtersius coronifer and Milnesium tardigradum are more resistant to gamma-ray radiation when in the hydrated state, and Macrobiotus areolatus is more resistant to X-ray radiation when in the anhydrobiotic state).[12] The way lethality is measured is also source of variation for the estimated radioresistance of a species. Irradiated specimens are not instantly killed, unless exposed to a very high dose (acute dose).[13] Therefore, irradiated specimens die over a certain period of time and lower irradiation doses correspond to longer survival. This means that the radiation dose LD50 fluctuates with the time at which it is measured. For example, the β radiation dose that causes 50% mortality in the American cockroach at 25 days post-exposure is 5,700 R, but to reach 50% mortality at 3 days post-exposure, 45,610 R are needed.[11] 25 days can represent a long survival period for short lived species, such as insects, but would represent a very short survival time for long lived species, such as mammals, so comparing survival of different species after the same amount of time post-exposure also poses some challenges of interpretation. These examples illustrate the many issues associated with comparison of radioresistance among species and the need for caution when doing so.

Lethal radiation doses (Gray)
Organism Lethal dose LD50 LD100 Class/Kingdom
Dog   3.5 (LD50/30 days)[14]   Mammals
Human 4–10[15] 4.5[16] 10[17] Mammals
Rat   7.5   Mammals
Mouse 4.5–12 8.6–9   Mammals
Rabbit   8 (LD50/30 days)[14]   Mammals
Tortoise   15 (LD50/30 days)[14]   Reptile
Goldfish   20 (LD50/30 days)[14]   Fish
Escherichia coli 60   60 Bacteria
German cockroach   64[15]   Insects
Shellfish   200 (LD50/30 days)[14]   -
Common fruit fly 640[15]     Insects
C. elegans   160-200 [18] ≫ 500-800[19][20] Nematode
Amoeba   1,000 (LD50/30 days)[14]   -
Habrobracon hebetor 1,800[8][9]     Insects
Milnesium tardigradum 5,000[12]     Eutardigrade
Deinococcus radiodurans 15,000[15]     Bacteria
Thermococcus gammatolerans 30,000[15]     Archaea

∗ While an LD50 has been reported for wild type C. elegans individuals, an upper lethal limit has not been established, rather "nearly all animals were alive with no indication of excess lethality up to 800 Gy, the highest dose... measured."[20]

See also[edit]

Notes and references[edit]

  1. ^ Sghaier, H., Ghedira, K., Benkahla, A., and Barkallah, I. (2008) Basal DNA repair machinery is subject to positive selection in ionizing-radiation-resistant bacteria. BMC Genomics 9: 297.
  2. ^ Cordeiro, AR; Marques, EK; Veiga-Neto, AJ (1973). "Radioresistance of a natural population of Drosophila willistoni living in a radioactive environment". Mutation research. 19 (3): 325–9. PMID 4796403. doi:10.1016/0027-5107(73)90233-9. 
  3. ^ Moustacchi, E (1965). "Induction by physical and chemical agents of mutations for radioresistance in Saccharomyces cerevisiae". Mutation research. 2 (5): 403–12. PMID 5878261. doi:10.1016/0027-5107(65)90052-7. 
  4. ^ Moseley BEB; Mattingly A (1971). "Repair of irradiated transforming deoxyribonu- cleic acid in wild type and a radiation- sensitive mutant of Micrococcus radiodu- rans". J. Bacteriol. 105 (3): 976–83. PMC 248526Freely accessible. PMID 4929286. 
  5. ^ Murray RGE. 1992. The family Deino- coccaceae. In The Prokaryotes, ed. A Ballows, HG Truper, M Dworkin, W Harder, KH Schleifer 4:3732–44. New York: Springer-Verlag
  6. ^ Ito H; Watanabe H; Takeshia M; Iizuka H (1983). "Isolation and identification of radiation-resistant cocci belonging to the genus Deinococcus from sewage sludges and animal feeds. Agric". Biol. Chem. 47: 1239–47. doi:10.1271/bbb1961.47.1239. 
  7. ^ Clark, AM; Mitchell, CJ (1952). "Effects of X-Rays upon Haploid and Diploid Embryos of Habrobracon". Biological Bulletin. 103 (2): 170–177. 
  8. ^ a b Sullivan, R; Grosch, D (1953). "The radiation tolerance of an adult wasp". Nucleotics. 11: 21–23. 
  9. ^ a b c Grosch, DS (1954). "Induced lethargy and the radiation control of insects". Journal of Economic Entomology. 49 (5): 629–631. 
  10. ^ a b c Grosch, DS; Sullivan, RL (1954). "The quantitative aspects of permanent and temporary sterility induced in female Habrobracon by X-Rays and β radiation". Radiation Research. 1 (3): 294–320. 
  11. ^ a b c Wharton, DRA; Wharton, ML (1959). "The effect of radiation on the longevity of the cockroach, Periplaneta americana, as affected by dose, age, sex, and food intake". Radiation Research. 11: 600–615. 
  12. ^ a b c Horikawa DD; Sakashita T; Katagiri C; Watanabe M; et al. (2006). "Radiation tolerance in the tardigrade Milnesium tardigradum". International Journal of Radiation Biology. 82 (12): 843–8. PMID 17178624. doi:10.1080/09553000600972956. 
  13. ^ Heidenthal, G (1945). "The occurrence of X-ray induced dominant lethal mutations in Habrobracon". Genetics. 30: 197–205. 
  14. ^ a b c d e f Radiochemistry and Nuclear Chemistry, G. Choppin, J-O. Liljenzin and J. Rydberg, edition three, page 481, ISBN 0-7506-7463-6
  15. ^ a b c d e "Cockroaches & Radiation". Retrieved 2006-05-13. 
  16. ^ "Radiation Notes: Radiation Damage and Dose Measurement". Retrieved 2006-05-13. 
  17. ^ "CDC Radiation Emergencies, Acute Radiation Syndrome: A Fact Sheet for Physicians". 
  18. ^ Hartman, P; Goldstein, P; Algarra, M; Hubbard, D; Mabery, J (1996). "The nematode Caenorhabditis elegans is up to 39 times more sensitive to gamma radiation generated from 137Cs than from 60Co". Mutat Res. 363 (3): 201–208. PMID 8765161. doi:10.1016/0921-8777(96)00012-2. 
  19. ^ Weidhaas, J.B.; Eisenmann, D.M.; Holub, J.M.; Nallur, S.V. (2006). "A Caenorhabditis elegans tissue model of radiation-induced reproductive cell death". Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 103 (26): 9946–51. PMC 1502559Freely accessible. PMID 16788064. doi:10.1073/pnas.0603791103. 
  20. ^ a b Krisko, A.; Magali, L.; Radman, M.; Meselson, M. (2012). "Extreme anti-oxidant protection against ionizing radiation in bdelloid rotifers". Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 109 (7): 2354–2357. PMC 3289372Freely accessible. PMID 22308443. doi:10.1073/pnas.1119762109. 

Further reading[edit]