Rape in Germany
Rape in Germany is defined by Section 177 of the Criminal Code of Germany. The definition of rape has changed over time from its original formulation in the penal code established in 1871, as extramarital intercourse with a woman by force or the threat. In 1997 laws were amended to criminalize marital rape, incorporate gender-neutral language, and recognize the effect of psychological coercion. In 2016 German laws were rewritten to remove a previous requirement that a victim physically resist their assailants and be overcome by force. The new law recognized any physical or verbal cue that one party does not consent to sexual contact. It also mandated deportation for migrants convicted of sexual assault, made it easier to prosecute rapes committed by groups, and criminalized other types of unwanted sexual contact, such as groping or fondling. The changes followed a series of high-profile cases that sparked public outrage at the inadequacy of the law.
Incidence of rape in Germany have remained relatively stable, rising from 7.57 in 1995, to 9 per 100,000 people in 2009. Most victims are female and between the ages of 21 and 40. Nearly all perpetrators are male, and about half are current or former partners. Conviction rates have declined, going from 20% in the 1980s to as low as 8% in 2016, prior to major legislative reforms.
Germany was the site of mass rape by invading Allied forces, most notably the Soviet army, during the latter part of World War II, with the estimated number of victims ranging from tens of thousands to as many as two million.
- 1 World War II
- 2 Modern prevalence
- 3 Legal history
- 4 Statutory rape
- 5 Services for victims
- 6 See also
- 7 Notes
- 8 References
- 9 External links
World War II
In the Soviet invasion of Germany during World War II a large number of mass rapes were committed by the Red Army, in Germany as well as in other countries previously occupied by the Nazi army. Estimates range from tens of thousands to as many as two million victims, with non-Slavic and particularly ethnically German women targeted. In the words of one contemporary observer, "the Russian soldiers were raping every German female from eight to eighty." Many victims were mutilated, and subjected to gang rape or repeated rape over the course of several days. The Soviet leadership did little to prevent the violence.[a]
Some have estimated the number of rapes committed by U.S. servicemen in Germany to be 11,000, with the phrase "copulation without conversation is not fraternization" allegedly being used as a motto by United States Army troops.
One survey estimates that the French occupation forces committed "385 rapes in the Constance area; 600 in Bruchsal; and 500 in Freudenstadt." French Moroccan soldiers were alleged to have committed widespread rape in the Höfingen District near Leonberg. According to historian Norman Naimark and colleagues, "the poor discipline and rapacity of soviet soldier was matched in the Western zones only by French Moroccan troops," specifically during the occupations of Baden and Württemberg.
The prevalence of rape in Germany has remained relatively stable, and although the country has the second highest overall number of rapes reported in the EU, the number of reports per capita is average for the region. As of 1995 the recorded incidence of rape in Germany was 7.57 per 100,000 people. In 2009, about 7,314 rape cases were reported, a rate of 9 per 100,000 people. In 2011, there were about 7,539 reported cases of rape.[c]
In a 2005 study by the Federal Ministry of Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth, out of a sample of 10,264 women, 13% had experienced sexual violence after the age of 16, and of these, only 8% had reported the incident to law enforcement.:13 From the same study, 6% reported experiencing rape, 4% attempted rape, 5% forced physical intimacy, and 4% some other form of forced sexual encounter. Nearly all (99%) of perpetrators were male, and half (49%) were current or former partners. For victims of sexual violence, 79% reported psychological symptoms, and 44% physical injuries.
A study into sexual abuse sponsored by the European Commission and conducted by the Vienna-based Fundamental Rights Agency showed 8% of women had experienced sexual violence by partners, and 7% had experienced sexual violence by non-partners. Overall, between 92% and 96% of victims were female, and 70% were aged 21 to 40. Around 25% of victims were non-white, more than half were employed or students, and 6% experienced mental health issues, while 2% had some disability.
Der Spiegel cited official crime statistics that 9.1% of sexual assaults reported in 2016 with at least one suspect registered had at least one suspect identified as an immigrant, a rise from 1.8% in 2012, and 2.6% in 2014. Some of this rise was attributed to the fact that in 2016, groping was made a criminal offence.[d]
There is little data on rape or other sexual violence directed toward males, with "nearly all" available studies of sexual violence examining women as victims, and sexual violence against men "almost ignored". When taken into consideration, it is mostly concerning abuse of boys, rather than rape or assault as it pertains to adult males. One national study in Germany from 2004, as reported in a 2009 thesis, indicated that between 10% and 20% of boys are in some respect sexually abused, with about 33% of perpetrators being female.
Public debate on migrant crime
In 2018 a 14-year-old German Jewish girl, Susanna Feldmann was raped and murdered on the night of the 22 or 23 May 2018. Ali Bashar, a 20-year-old asylum seeker from Iraqi Kurdistan, was named as a suspect. The murder sparked a political debate in Germany. Ethnologist and head of the Research Centre of Global Islam Susanne Schröter at the Goethe University Frankfurt, said that these were no longer isolated incidents, speaking of a culture clash and suggesting that Germany needed to develop a new approach for dealing with aggressive men shaped by patriarchal cultures. According to Schröter, the norms of Islam legitimise violence and sexual assault against women and therefore men from Islamic countries view women in a completely different way. Far-right parties and social media exploited the case for their own ends. A fact-checking article in Der Spiegel found that fears of immigrant crime had been amplified by far-right propaganda in the public debate beyond the actual increase which was supported by official statistics.
Law enforcement response
According to a national report, the conviction rate for rape in Germany has declined: it was 20% in the 1980s, and by 2000 it was 13%. According to reports from Deutsche Presse-Agentur, prior to legal changes in 2016, 8% of rape trials resulted in a conviction. Conviction rates varied substantially across geographic areas, and according to income, with the three richest states having a conviction rate of 24% and seeing number of cases reduced to nearly 65% of their former levels, and the three poorest states seeing a 40% increase in cases and a 4% conviction rate.
Of those reported to authorities, most (87%) were reported by the victim, 96% were interviewed and provided a witness statement, but only 23% received a forensic medical examination, one of the lowest in the EU.
Discussion of rape has long been a taboo in Germany, with victims, women's rights organizations, and politicians struggling for support on issues pertaining to sexual abuse and violence. There have been recent political discussions of reforming related laws so that they comply with the Istanbul convention, which requires all signatories to ensure that engaging in any non-consensual act of a sexual nature is criminalized.
Rape is generally reported to the police, although it is also allowed to be reported to the prosecutor or District Court. Many urban areas and states have specialist units for rape and sexual assault, but these efforts are not coordinated at the federal level, and the presence of such a unit is dependent on the finances of the area, and such units are absent in many rural areas.
Because of the German statutory maximum sentences, the harshest punishment possible for rape is imprisonment for a period of 15 years. However, because it is not legally a form of punishment, courts may order "subsequent preventive detention" following the completion of a prison sentence for rape, in cases where the perpetrator suffers from a mental disorder, or would represent a serious danger to the public upon release. These may be of an indefinite period, subject to periodic reviews. Officials may also temporarily deny perpetrators access to the household without a court order, put them under a restraining order, and require them to pay damages.
The statute of limitations for severe sexual coercion is 20 years, and that for less serious cases is 10. In cases where the victim is a minor, this tiemframe begins once the child turns 18 years-of-age.
Penal code of 1871
According to the German penal code established in 1871, the definition of rape was to compel "a woman to have extramarital intercourse...by force or the threat of present danger to life or limb," and was punishable by at least two years imprisonment. The law thus excluded any sexual contact between a married couple. Rape was grouped, along with sodomy and incest, as "crimes against personal honor, marriage, and the family." More extensive punishments were provided in cases where the victim (presumed to be female only) was younger than 16, in cases of gang rape, and in cases of "major physical violence".
Post-war legislation and 1973 reforms
The German penal code experienced a number of changes during the Nazi era. Changes considered in keeping with Nazi philosophy were removed by the Allied Control Council during the re-establishment of Germany.
Between 1969 and 1974 the West German penal code was reformed by five different pieces of legislation. The fourth law for the reform of the penal code, dated 23 November 1973 (Viertes Gesetz zur Reform des Strafrechts - 4. StrRG), introduced changes shifting the focus from violations of morality to violations against the individual.
In 1997, a broader definition was adopted, making the law gender neutral, abolishing the marital exemption, recognizing sexual violence which did not include penetration, and expanding the definition of force to include psychological coercion. This was done through the 13th criminal amendment, section 177–179, which deals with sexual abuse. The 1997 reform (due to the Dreiunddreißigstes Strafrechtsänderungsgesetz, 33rd law to change the penal code) created a new system by combining sexual assault and rape into one statue, with sexual assault as the "base" crime. Rape, which was now defined as involving penetration, was made into a subset of sexual assault, as a particularly serious form.
Reflecting the law's emphasis on the requirement for the use of force, a 2006 decision by the Federal Court of Justice of Germany overturned a lower court's conviction for rape, on the grounds that the "accused ripped off the clothes from the body of the co-plaintiff and had sexual intercourse with her against her explicitly expressed will”, but had not “forced the victim with violence". According to a study performed in 2014, by an organization of women's counseling and rape crisis centers, out of 107 studied cases of rape, the majority of perpetrators were not prosecuted, because their actions fell outside the legal definition at the time.
The Sixth Criminal Law Reform Act, passed in 1998 included a number of changes intended to harmonize sentencing for sexual, and non-sexual offenses, and generally resulted in increases in severity for sexual offenses. It also included provisions related to the protection of children, the disabled, the institutionalized, and drug addicts.
2002 Violence Protection Act
The 2002 Violence Protection Act (Gewaltschutzgesetz) focussed broadly on all forms of domestic violence. While the previous assumption was that victims should leave their joint residence, the introduction of this law gave civil courts the power to serve orders on the perpetrator to vacate the residence.
On September 23, 2016, the law was reformed again, with a new focus on lack of consent rather than resistance on the part of the victim. It broadened the legal definition to include "any sexual act that a victim declines through verbal or physical cues, whereas the previous law required the victim fight back," and other forms of non-consensual sexual contact, such as groping and fondling, were not illegal. The new law strengthened penalties for all perpetrators of sexual assault, mandated deportation for convicted migrants, and made it easier to prosecute assaults committed by large groups.
The law also provided equal punishment under the following circumstances, if the perpetrator:
- Exploits the fact that the person cannot consent
- Exploits the fact that the person is significantly impaired because of a physical or mental condition, unless there is prior consent
- Exploits an element of surprise
- Exploits a situation in which the victim is threatened with serious harm in case of resistance
- Coerces the person to actively engage in or tolerate sexual acts by threatening serious harm
Although the law dropped the previous requirement for the use of coercion or force by the perpetrator, it incorporated these elements as an aggravating factor, along with situations where the victim is incapacitated due to disease or disability.
The changes followed a series of cases that sparked public outrage, and the popularity of the #NeinHeisstNein (no means no) campaign. These included the acquitall of two men changed with drugging and raping Gina-Lisa Lohfink, and posting video of it online, a video in which "she reportedly says 'stop it' and 'no' as they force themselves on her". It also followed the events of the 2015/2016 New Year's Eve, mainly in the city of Cologne, where hundreds of women were sexually assaulted, but through actions which, it was ultimately determined, were not illegal under the current law. Other high-profile cases included the 2016 Murder of Maria Ladenburger and 2018 Killing of Susanna Feldmann, which gained attention because the attacks were alleged to have been carried out by immigrants[e]
Consensual sex is legal from the age of 14 in most cases. There is an exception if the older partner is above the age of 18, and is “exploiting a coercive situation” or offering compensation, and the younger partner is under 16. It is also illegal for someone older than 21 to have sex with someone under the age of 16 if the older person “exploits the victim’s lack of capacity for sexual self-determination.”
Services for victims
Beginning in 1984, victims may access government funded legal services according to means tested eligibility criteria. More commonly, victims who cannot afford legal representation may be appointed a lawyer; however, prosecutors are obliged to pursue the case regardless of whether the victim is a party to the proceedings. Victims may also receive services from privately run Weisser Ring or White Ring victim support organizations, or Notruf and Wildwasser rape crisis centers located throughout the country. Representatives from these organizations my accompany the victims in filing reports, during interviews, and throughout legal proceedings.
- Upon crossing into East Prussia, the orders given to Soviet troops offered the guidance, 'on German soil there is only one master – the Soviet soldier, that he is both the judge and the punisher for the torments of his fathers and mothers, for the destroyed cities and villages... ‘remember your friends are not there, there is the next of kin of the killers and oppressors.'"
- According the footnote accompanying the related table of statistics in the original study, "The 6th Act on Criminal Law Reform regulates rape and sexual duress together in one provision. Therefore, as of 1998 the Police Crime Statistics count other serious forms of sexual duress alongside rape in this category, which probably explains the rise between 1997 and the following years.
- Historical data on the prevalence of rape may be affected by a number of factors. Some data sets may only account for West Germany and/or a portion of Berlin prior to German Reunification. Substantial amendments to broaden the legal definition of rape, such as that which occurred in 1997, are also reflected in historical data. As of 2013, there are no regularly conducted national level surveys conducted in Germany on female victimization.
- "Immigrants" in this context included: "asylum-seekers; those who have been allowed to stay temporarily despite not having received asylum status, illegal immigrants; and refugees who have been brought into Germany on the basis of quotas. Suspects whose asylum applications have been approved are not included." Other foreigners are also not included.
- See also European migrant crisis
- Johnson, Daniel (24 January 2002). "Red Army troops raped even Russian women as they freed them from camps". Telegraph.co.uk. Retrieved June 21, 2018.
- Wood, Jean (2004). "Sexual Violence During War: Explaining Variation" (PDF). Presented at the Order, Conflict and Violence Conference at Yale University. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- Roberts, Geoffrey (21 August 2013). Victory at Stalingrad: The Battle That Changed History. Routledge. pp. 152–3. ISBN 978-1-317-86891-0. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Beevor, Antony (May 2002). "They raped every German female from eight to 80". The Guardian. Retrieved 2014-04-14.
- Schrijvers, Peter (1998). The Crash of Ruin: American Combat Soldiers in Europe During World War II. New York: New York University Press. p. 183. ISBN 0-8147-8089-X.
- Lilly, J. Robert (7 June 2007). Taken by Force: Rape and American GIs in Europe during World War II. Palgrave Macmillan. p. 12. ISBN 978-0-230-50647-3. OCLC 226093243. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- Biddiscombe, Perry (2001). "Dangerous Liaisons: The Anti-Fraternization Movement in the U.S. Occupation Zones of Germany and Austria, 1945–1948". Journal of Social History. 34 (3): 611–647. doi:10.1353/jsh.2001.0002. JSTOR 3789820. OCLC 703952384.
- Stephenson, Jill (2006) Hitler's Home Front: Württemberg under the Nazis London: Continuum. p. 289. ISBN 1-85285-442-1.
- Naimark, Norman M.; Naimark, Robert and Florence McDonnell Professor of East European Studies Norman M (1995). The Russians in Germany: A History of the Soviet Zone of Occupation, 1945-1949. Harvard University Press. p. 106. ISBN 978-0-674-78405-5. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Jehle, Jörg-Martin (2005). "Criminal Justice in Germany: Facts and Figures" (PDF). Federal Ministry of Justice. p. 56. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Seith, C.; Lovett, J.; Kelly, L. (2009). "Different systems, similar outcomes? Tracking attrition in reported rape cases in eleven countries" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on March 16, 2014. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- Oberwittler, Dietrich; Höfer, Sven (October 1, 2005). "Crime and Justice in Germany An Analysis of Recent Trends and Research". European Journal of Criminology. 2 (4): 465–508. doi:10.1177/1477370805056058. OCLC 4769546304.
Nevertheless, violent offences – particularly bodily injury and robbery – have also increased especially during the last fifteen years (figure 2). However, the rate for the most serious violent crimes – murder and rape – is relatively stable over time or even declining.
- Simon, Rita James (2001). A Comparative Perspective on Major Social Problems. Lexington Books. p. 20–1. ISBN 978-0-7391-0248-0. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- Krahé, Barbara (22 January 2013). The Social Psychology of Aggression. Psychology Press. ISBN 978-1-84169-875-5. OCLC 880824101. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- "Germany 2013 Crime and Safety Report". Osac.gov. 2013-10-03. Retrieved 2014-04-10.
- Temkin, Jennifer; Krahé, Barbara (15 April 2008). Sexual Assault and the Justice Gap: A Question of Attitude. Bloomsbury Publishing. ISBN 978-1-84731-420-8. Retrieved 22 June 2018.:16
- List, Katrin (2013). "Sexual violence and harassment against female students in Germany" (PDF). Rivista di Criminologia, Vittimologia e Sicurezza. 7 (2): 80–99. ISSN 1971-033X. OCLC 7181566419. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- Federal Ministry for Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth (2005). "Health, Well-Being and Personal Safety of Women in Germany" (PDF). Retrieved 25 June 2018.CS1 maint: Multiple names: authors list (link)
- "Violence against Women: every day and everywhere". European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights. 5 March 2015.
- "One in three women are victims of physical or sexual abuse in the EU". Deutsche Welle. 5 March 2015.
- Laura Backes; Anna Clauss; Maria-Mercedes Hering (2018-01-17). "Fact-check:Is There Truth To Refugee Rape Reports?". Spiegel Online. Retrieved 20 June 2018.
In some instances, neither prosecutors nor police had ever heard of the purported crime
- Kappler, Karolin Eva (2009). "Living with Paradoxes: Victims of Sexual Violence in Germany and the Conduct of Everyday Life" (PDF). Doctoral Thesis, Universitat de Barcelona. OCLC 804339833. Retrieved 25 June 2018.
- "Murder of Jewish Girl in Germany Fuels an Anti-migrant Backlash". Haaretz. 13 June 2018. Archived from the original on 11 December 2018. Retrieved 13 January 2019.
- "Refugees still welcome? How one girl's murder is dividing Germany". the local de. Archived from the original on 13 June 2018. Retrieved 13 January 2019.
- WELT (2018-06-09). "Forscherin zum Fall Susanna F.: „Das ist jetzt kein Einzelfall mehr"". DIE WELT. Retrieved 2018-06-09.
- Laura Backes and other Der Spiegel staff (17 January 2018). "Fact-Check: Is There Truth To Refugee Rape Reports?". Der Spiegel. Archived from the original on 11 January 2019. Retrieved 13 January 2019.
- "'No means no': Germany broadens definition of rape under new law". Deutsche Welle. July 7, 2016. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Overdorf, Jason (May 19, 2014). "In Germany, no means yes". Public Radio International. Retrieved 25 June 2018.
- Hofmann, Sarah (8 March 2015). "Still far to go for women in Germany". Deutsche Welle. Retrieved June 21, 2018.
- Connolly, Kate (June 23, 2002). "German rape victims find a voice at last". The Guardian. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- "German justice minister announces harsher punishment against sexual assault". Deutsche Welle. July 20, 2015.
- "Germany: Overhaul of Criminal Law Relating to Sexual Offenses". Library of Congress. 2016-04-11. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Bacik, Ivana; Maunsell, Catherine; Gogan, Susan (1998). The Legal Process and Victims of Rape: A comparative analysis of the laws and legal procedures relating to rape, and their impact upon victims of rape, in the fifteen member states of the European Union (PDF). Cahill Printers Limited. OCLC 969890198. Retrieved 25 June 2018.
- Hörnle, Tatjana (2013-03-20). "Moderate and Non-Arbitrary Sentencing Without Guidelines: The German Experience". Law and Contemporary Problems. 76 (1): 189–210. OCLC 7374991341. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- "Germany 2015 Human Rights Report" (PDF). United States Department of State, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights and Labor. 2015. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- Individual criminal responsibility and superior responsibility: Article 7(1) and Article 7(3) of the Statute
- Randall, Melanie; Koshan, Jennifer; Nyaundi, Patricia (19 October 2017). The Right to Say No: Marital Rape and Law Reform in Canada, Ghana, Kenya and Malawi. Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 68. ISBN 978-1-78225-862-9. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Poley, Jared (2007). Decolonization in Germany: Weimar Narratives of Colonial Loss and Foreign Occupation. Peter Lang. p. 161. ISBN 978-3-03911-330-9. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Morgan, Robin (8 March 2016). Sisterhood Is Global: The International Women's Movement Anthology. Open Road Media. ISBN 978-1-5040-3324-4. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Beck, Tobias A. (2016-09-30). Die Auswirkungen der Großen Strafrechtsreform auf die Gesetzgebung im Kernstrafrecht seit 1975: Fortführung oder Aufgabe der Reformgrundsätze? (in German). Logos Verlag Berlin GmbH. ISBN 9783832543150.
- ": „Die älteren Herren tun sich hart"". Der Spiegel. 27. 1987-06-29. Retrieved 2018-06-24.
- "STRAFRECHTSREFORM: Kloß m Magen". Der Spiegel. 12. 1973-03-19. Retrieved 2018-06-24.
- "Women as Victims - Germany's ongoing rape debate". Deutsche Welle. 24 January 2013.
- Smith, Merril D. (2004). Encyclopedia of Rape. Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 169. ISBN 978-0-313-32687-5. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Goedelt, Katja (2010). Vergewaltigung und sexuelle Nötigung: Untersuchung der Strafverfahrenswirklichkeit. Universitätsverlag Göttingen. ISBN 9783941875289 – via Google Books.
- Müting, Christina (2010). Sexuelle Nötigung: Vergewaltigung ([Paragraph] 177 StGB) : Reformdiskussion und Gesetzgebung seit 1870. Walter de Gruyter. pp. 181–196. ISBN 9783110247947 – via Google Books.
- Kieler, Marita (2002). Tatbestandsprobleme der sexuellen Nötigung, Vergewaltigung sowie des sexuellen Mißbrauchs widerstandsunfähiger Personen. Tenea Verlag Ltd. p. 200. ISBN 9783865040336 – via Google Books.
- Richter-Montpetit, Melanie (June 26, 2016). "Germany Rape Laws Put Into Question by a Controversial Case". The Wire. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Nelson, Soraya Sarhaddi. "In Germany, Lawmakers Pass 'No Means No' Law For Cases Of Rape". NPR. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Bohlander, Michael (18 December 2008). Principles of German Criminal Law. Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 195. ISBN 978-1-84731-479-6. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Vergewaltigung in der Ehe - Strafrechtliche Beurteilung im europäischen Vergleich (PDF). Deutscher Bundestag, Wissenschaftlicher Dienst. 2008. p. 11.
- "Germany rape law: 'No means No' law passed". BBC News. July 7, 2016. Retrieved June 22, 2018.
- Beulke, Felix (2016-10-03). "Germany: Heavier Sanctions Against Sexual Offenders Adopted". Library of Congress. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Cauterucci, Christina. "Germany Finally Updated Its Archaic Rape Law After a "No Means No" Activist Campaign". Slate. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Kirchner, Stephanie; Noack, Rick. "New stricter sexual-assault laws in Germany are making refugee activists uneasy". The Washington Post. Retrieved 21 June 2018.
- Karen Van Eyken (7 June 2018). "Germany in shock again: Susanna (14) raped and killed by an asylum seeker". Het Laatste Nieuws (in Dutch). Retrieved 19 June 2018.
Not a one-off— At the end of 2016 Germany was already in turmoil when it turned out that an Afghan refugee had raped and murdered Maria Ladenburger in Freiburg.
- Heribert Prantl (7 June 2018). "Murder of Susanna F. - Radical Revenge Reflex". Süddeutsche Zeitung (in German). Retrieved 19 June 2018.
One would like to have simple solutions to prevent such crimes, such as "If the borders were tight, Susanna F. would still be alive". We know that's not true
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Rape in Germany.|
- "The Policy on Gender Equality in Germany" (PDF). European Parliament Directorate-General for Internal Policies. 2015. Retrieved 22 June 2018.
- "Final Report of the Federal Government of Germany to the CoE Campaign against Violence against Women, Including Domestic Violence". Council of Europe. Retrieved 22 June 2018.