Same-sex marriage in Pennsylvania
|Legal status of same-sex unions|
* Not yet in effect
Same-sex marriage has been legally recognized in Pennsylvania since May 20, 2014, when a U.S. federal district court judge ruled that the Commonwealth's 1996 statutory ban on recognizing same-sex marriage was unconstitutional. The state had prohibited recognition of same-sex marriage by statute since 1996. It had never added such a ban to its state constitution.
- 1 Statutory ban
- 2 Attempts at constitutional ban
- 3 Federal court challenges
- 4 State court challenges
- 5 Economic Impact
- 6 Public opinion
- 7 See also
- 8 Notes
- 9 References
- 10 External links
In September 1996, the Pennsylvania House of Representatives approved Representative Allan Egolf's (R-Perry) amendment to ban the performance and recognition of same-sex marriage by a vote of 177 to 16, after an effort to rule it unconstitutional failed by a vote of 171 to 29. The Senate passed the legislation on October 1 by a vote of 43 to 5. Republican Governor Tom Ridge signed the amendment into law.
On May 8, 1996, Egolf introduced HB 2604 in the House that would ban same-sex marriages and refuse to recognize marriages performed in other states. The bill bypassed the House Judiciary Committee in the hopes of speeding its passage before the next election. On June 28, the House considered a bill to amend Pennsylvania's Domestic Relations Act to allow for grandparents to adopt grandchildren over the objections of their parents. Representative Egolf introduced an amendment to this bill that paralleled his anti-marriage bill. The Republican-controlled House voted to add this anti-marriage amendment to the adoption bill. The vote on the amendment was 177-16. The bill, which had already passed the State Senate, was sent back for a concurrence vote. After this vote, the House recessed for the summer. On October 1, the Republican-controlled Senate voted 43-5 to concur with the anti-marriage language added by the House. Governor Ridge signed the act into law on October 8.
Legislation to extend marriage rights to same-sex couples by amending the statute has been introduced in the Pennsylvania General Assembly several times. In May 2009, State Senator Daylin Leach introduced such a bill in the Senate. State Representative Babette Josephs also introduced a similar bill in the House of Representatives. Both bills remained in committee. In March 2013, Senator Leach introduced SB719. In June 2013, Representatives Brian Sims and Steve McCarter introduced a same-sex marriage bill in the house, following the U.S. Supreme Court ruling in United States v. Windsor.
Attempts at constitutional ban
In 2006, five state representatives, with Pennsylvania State Representative Scott W. Boyd as a main sponsor, introduced House Bill 2381, proposing an amendment to the Pennsylvania Constitution defining marriage as the union of one man and one woman. The bill had 87 cosponsors and was approved June 6, 2006, on a vote of 136–61. The Senate approved the bill 38–12 on June 21, 2006. The bill was referred to the Rules Committee in the House of Representatives on June 22, 2006, where no action was taken.
In 2008, a similar bill with State Senator Mike Brubaker as its main sponsor, Senate Bill 1250, was approved by the Senate Judiciary Committee. It would have banned same-sex marriage and its "functional equivalent". This language led to debate on whether the bill would not only ban same-sex marriage and civil unions, but also prevent hospital visitation, employer health benefits and recognition of a will for same-sex couples. The bill was laid on the table on May 6, 2008 because the House of Representatives in the State Government Committee would not allow Senate Bill 1250 to be considered by the committee in a timely manner. Senator Brubaker requested the bill be laid aside. The Senate agreed to the motion by voice vote.
In 2010, State Senator John Eichelberger introduced Senate Bill 707. This proposed amendment failed in the Judiciary Committee, when all 5 Democrats and 3 Republicans voted to table the amendment, opposed by 6 Republicans.
In 2011, State Representative Daryl Metcalfe introduced House Bill 1434 with 36 cosponsors on May 3. It was referred to the Committee of State Government. The bill would amend the state constitutional to ban same-sex marriage and any substantial equivalent. On March 13, 2012, opponents of the bill claimed victory when Metcalfe delayed a committee vote on the legislation.
In 2013, he reintroduced the bill with 27 cosponsors on May 7, the lowest number of cosponsors the bill has had when introduced.
Federal court challenges
Whitewood v. Wolf
On July 9, 2013, following the U.S. Supreme Court decision in United States v. Windsor, the ACLU filed suit in U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania on behalf of 23 plaintiffs—10 couples, 2 of their children, and a widow—seeking to overturn Pennsylvania's 1996 statutory ban on same-sex marriage. Attorney General Kathleen Kane, a named defendant, said that she would not defend the statute, but Governor Tom Corbett announced he would.
On May 20, 2014, Judge John E. Jones III ruled in that Pennsylvania's same-sex marriage ban is unconstitutional. The ruling was not stayed and same-sex couples in Pennsylvania could request and receive marriage licenses immediately and marry after a mandatory 3-day waiting period. Anticipating legal maneuvers to stay Jones' ruling, dozens of same-sex couples applied for marriage licenses the same day and some obtained waivers of the state's three-day waiting period. At least one couple managed to celebrate their wedding on May 21. Governor Tom Corbett announced on May 21 that he would not appeal Judge Jones' decision, effectively making Pennsylvania the 19th state to recognize same-sex marriage.
The Schuylkill County court clerk responsible for responding to marriage license applications, Theresa Santai-Gaffney, repeatedly sought to intervene to defend the statute without success. She was rebuffed by Judge Jones, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Samuel Alito, and again by the Third Circuit.
Palladino v. Corbett
On September 26, 2013, a same-sex couple lawfully married under Massachusetts law filed suit in U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, seeking to require that Pennsylvania recognize out-of-state marriages between same-sex partners as valid. The couple also seek a declaration that the statute outlawing in-state same-sex marriage is unconstitutional. The case was assigned to U.S. District Judge Mary A. McLaughlin. The defendants, Pennsylvania's governor and attorney general, filed motions to dismiss that November and December, respectively, with the plaintiffs responding in January 2014. The case, Palladino v. Corbett, was docketed number 2:13-cv-05641-MAM.
On January 17, 2014, a group called the Philadelphia Metro Task Force, opposed to same-sex marriage recognition in Pennsylvania, sought to intervene in the lawsuit. This group alleges that, in allowing same-sex marriage, "reverse discrimination is threatened amidst a continual omission of religious and moral freedom." (internal quotes omitted) Judge McLaughlin denied the group's motion to intervene on March 4, 2014, because they "do not identify a sufficient interest they might have at stake in this litigation, nor do they demonstrate why their interests are not adequately represented by an existing party." She also denied the group amicus curiae status, meaning they could not even file a brief as a non-party to the case.
Suspension of proceedings
Oral arguments for summary judgment in the case were held on May 15. The case may have been rendered moot on May 21 when Governor Corbett decided not to appeal the decision in Whitewood v. Wolf, and as a result, same-sex marriage commenced throughout Pennsylvania. On both May 22 and 28, Judge Mary McLaughlin ordered the plaintiff same-sex couples to show cause why their case should not be dismissed because of mootness. Judge McLaughlin issued an order on September 8 suspending further proceedings until "expiration of the deadline to petition the U.S. Supreme Court for a writ of certiorari in Whitewood."
After the Whitewood decision allowed the Palladino plaintiffs to lawfully marry in Pennsylvania, and the state defendants stipulated "that they will take no steps to deprive Plaintiffs of the benefits accorded by the validity and recognition of their marriage under Pennsylvania law", Judge McLaughlin ordered the case voluntarily dismissed as of October 22, 2014.
State court challenges
Montgomery County license issuance
In July 2013, shortly after Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane declined to defend Pennsylvania's prohibition of same-sex marriage in U.S. district court, D. Bruce Hanes, the Montgomery County Register of Wills and Clerk of the Orphans' Court, announced he would issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples. He interpreted his Orphan's Court position as a judicial one and found that denying same-sex couples marriage licenses as the statutes required would violate their rights under the state constitution. Between July 24 and August 9, 2013, he issued marriage licenses to more than 100 same-sex couples. A week later the Pennsylvania Department of Health filed a lawsuit in Commonwealth Court to enjoin Hanes from issuing any more such licenses.
Commonwealth Court cases
The lead state court case is Commonwealth v. Hanes.[a] Oral arguments were held on September 4, 2013. On September 12, 2013, Judge Dan Pellegrini ordered Hanes to stop issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples "[u]nless and until either the General Assembly repeals or suspends the Marriage Law provisions or a court of competent jurisdiction orders that the law is not to be obeyed or enforced". Hanes had issued 174 licenses to same-sex couples before the court issued its order and he appealed its decision to the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania. Couples that received a marriage license from Hanes filed an amicus curiae brief on his behalf with the state supreme court on December 2, 2013. In the brief, the couples note that the court below never ruled on the substantive issue of same-sex marriage, and they argue for it.
On September 6, 2013, in Cucinotta v. Commonwealth,[b] a Chester County same-sex couple filed a petition in Commonwealth Court asking the court to find Pennsylvania's restrictions on same-sex marriage unconstitutional.
On September 25, 2013, the group of 42 individuals who were married with licenses issued by Montgomery County Clerk Hanes, petitioned the Commonwealth Court in Ballen v. Corbett, later restyled Ballen v. Wolf,[c] after the parties agreed that the respondent would be Pennsylvania's secretary of health instead of its governor. The petitioners sought to overturn the state's same-sex marriage ban on the grounds that it violates both the state and federal constitutions.
Resolution of cases after Whitewood
The cases pending in Pennsylvania's Commonwealth Court were likely rendered moot on May 21 when Governor Corbett decided not to appeal the decision in Whitewood v. Wolf, which left in place the order in that case ending enforcement of Pennsylvania's denial of marriage rights to same-sex couples. On September 30, Judge Dan Pellegrini approved an agreement between the parties in Ballen v. Wolf and ordered the case dismissed. The agreement provided that the Ballen petitioners and similarly-situated intervening parties are married under state law as of the May 20 order in Whitewood, even though the petitioners had received marriage licenses from Clerk Hanes and/or solemnized their marriages before that date.
A UCLA study found that allowing same-sex couples to marry in Pennsylvania will add nearly $100 million to the state's economy. Total spending related to weddings and wedding-related tourism will account for up to $92 million in the first three years, and state and local tax revenues are expected to increase by up to $5 million. Additionally, up to 1,142 new full- and part-time jobs are expected to be created by the additional economic activity.
An April 2011 Public Policy Polling (PPP) survey found that when Pennsylvania voters were asked to choose between same-sex marriage, civil unions, or no legal recognition of homosexual relationships, 30% supported same-sex marriage, 33% supported civil unions, and 35% opposed all legal recognition. 2% were not sure.
A July 2011 PPP survey found that 38% of Pennsylvania voters thought that same-sex marriage should be legal, while 51% thought it should be illegal and 11% were not sure. In a separate question offering voters the option of civil unions, 32% supported same-sex marriage, 36% supported civil unions, and 31% opposed all legal recognition. 1% were unsure.
An August 2011 Franklin & Marshall survey found that 50% of Pennsylvanians supported a constitutional amendment to legalize same-sex marriage, while 42% opposed it and 8% were not sure. A separate question on the same survey found that 62% of respondents supported a law legalizing civil unions for same-sex couples, while 34% opposed it and 5% were not sure.
A November 2011 PPP survey found that 36% of Pennsylvania voters thought that same-sex marriage should be legal, while 52% thought it should be illegal and 12% were not sure. In a separate question offering voters the option of civil unions, 29% supported same-sex marriage, 35% supported civil unions, and 33% opposed all legal recognition; 1% were not sure.
A May 2012 PPP survey found that 39% of Pennsylvania voters thought that same-sex marriage should be legal, while 48% thought it should be illegal and 13% were unsure. Offered the option of civil unions, 35% supported same-sex marriage, 33% supported civil unions, and 28% opposed all legal recognition, 3% were unsure.
A June 2012 Franklin & Marshall survey found that 48% of Pennsylvanians supported a constitutional amendment to legalize same-sex marriage, while 49% were against such an amendment, an increase of 6% in support since 2009. A separate question on the same survey found that 63% of respondents favored a law legalizing civil unions for same-sex couples, while 33% were against such a law, an increase in support of 5% since 2009.
A January 2013 Quinnipiac University poll found that 47% supported same sex marriage, while 43% were opposed to the idea. The poll also found that white Catholics in the state supported same sex marriage by a 50/40 margin, while white Protestants in the state opposed same sex marriage by a 60/31 margin.
A March 2013 PPP survey found that 45% of Pennsylvanians supported same-sex marriages and 47% opposed them; asked on the question of marriage or civil unions for same-sex couples in the state, over 74% of respondents indicated support for either (with 38% supporting marriage rights and 36% supporting civil unions but not marriage), with only 24% of respondents opposed to any civil recognition of same-sex couples and 2% not sure.
A May 2013 Franklin & Marshall College poll found that 54% supported same sex marriage, while 41% were opposed.
A December 2013 Public Religion Research Institute survey found that 61% of Pennsylvania residents support same-sex marriage, while 35% opposed, and 3% didn't know or refused to answer.
A November–December 2014 Morning Call/Muhlenberg College poll found that 62% of respondents supported same-sex marriage, while 32% were opposed and 6% were undecided.
- Pa. Supreme Court Docket No. 77 MAP 2013, Pa. Commonwealth Court Docket No. 379 MD 2013, accessible here.
- Pa. Commonwealth Court Docket No. 451 MD 2013
- Pa. Commonwealth Court Docket No. 481 MD 2013
- Botelho, Greg (May 20, 2014). "Federal judge rules same-sex marriage ban in Pennsylvania is unconstitutional". CNN. Retrieved May 21, 2014.
- Heller, Karen (October 24, 2013). "Pennsylvania stands alone on yet another issue". Philly.com. Retrieved December 3, 2013.
- "Since Pennsylvania's gay marriage ban in 1996, minds have changed". Associated Press. July 13, 2013. Retrieved May 21, 2014.
- Geidner, Chris (May 21, 2014). "Former Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Ridge Says Current Governor "Needs Some Support" For Marriage Decision". Buzzfeed. Retrieved July 7, 2014.
- Barnes, Tom (May 28, 2009). "Senator pushes bill to allow same-sex marriage". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
- Worden, Amy (March 15, 2012). "Gay-marriage bills stalled in Pennsylvania". The Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved April 4, 2012.
- "Senate Bill 719, Regular Session 2013-2014". Legis.state.pa.us. October 1, 2013. Retrieved December 2, 2013.
- "Gay marriage bill introduced in state House". Philly. June 27, 2013. Retrieved July 12, 2013.
- "Pennsylvania Constitution". Pennsylvania General Assembly. Retrieved January 24, 2009.
- Barnes, Tom (June 7, 2006). "Pa. House passes gay marriage ban". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Retrieved January 24, 2009.
- "The Pennsylvania General Assembly". Legis.state.pa.us. March 20, 2006. Retrieved December 1, 2011.
- Barnes, Tom (March 19, 2008). "Panel OKs constitutional ban on gay marriage". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Retrieved January 24, 2009.
- "The Pennsylvania General Assembly". Legis.state.pa.us. March 18, 2008. Retrieved December 1, 2011.
- "The Pennsylvania General Assembly". Legis.state.pa.us. Retrieved December 1, 2011.
- "The Pennsylvania Senate - Senate Committee Roll Call Votes". Legis.state.pa.us. March 16, 2010. Retrieved December 1, 2011.
- "The Pennsylvania General Assembly". Legis.state.pa.us. Retrieved December 1, 2011.
- "Regular Session 2011-2012 House Bill 1434 P.N. 1724". Legis.state.pa.us. May 3, 2011. Retrieved December 1, 2011.
- "Bills against gay bias on move in Harrisburg". philly.com. May 8, 2013. Retrieved May 9, 2013.
- "A.C.L.U. Lawsuit Aims to Overturn Pennsylvania's Ban on Gay Marriage". New York Times. July 9, 2013. Retrieved November 18, 2013.
- Eilperin, Juliet (July 11, 2013). "Pa. attorney general says she won’t defend state's gay marriage ban". Washington Post. Retrieved July 11, 2013.
- Lindstrom, Natasha (July 30, 2013). "Corbett to defend Pennsylvania's gay marriage ban". Herald-Standard (Uniontown). Retrieved July 30, 2013.
- Reuters (May 20, 2014). "Federal judge strikes down gay marriage ban in Pennsylvania". Retrieved May 20, 2014.
- Fox News (May 20, 2014). "Pa. same-sex couples rush to get marriage licenses after judge overturns marriage ban". Retrieved May 21, 2014.
- Riely, Kaitlynn (May 21, 2014). "Allegheny County marries its first same-sex couple amid smiles, tears". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. Retrieved July 25, 2014.
- Madej, Patricia (May 23, 2014). "Wedding bells ring at art museum steps for same-sex couple". Philadelphia Magazine. Retrieved July 25, 2014.
- "Pennsylvania governor: I won't appeal court's gay marriage ruling". The Guardian. Associated Press. May 21, 2014.
- John E. Jones III (June 18, 2014). "Memorandum and order, Whitewood v. Wolf, No. 1:13-CV-1861" (PDF). Court. U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania. Retrieved June 18, 2014.
- Marchiano, Amy (July 5, 2014). "County official vows appeal after same-sex marriage setback". The Standard Speaker (Hazelton, PA).
- Associated Press (July 9, 2014). "Justice Alito denies clerk's bid to halt same-sex marriage in Pennsylvania". LBGTQ Nation.com.
- Middleton, Josh (July 18, 2014). "Theresa Santai-Gaffney Strikes Again, Filing an 'En Banc' Motion With the Third Circuit". Philadelphia Magazine. Retrieved July 24, 2014.
- Patty Shwartz, Circuit Judge (August 4, 2014). "Sur Petition for Rehearing Whitewood v. Secretary Pa. Dep't of Health, No. 14-3048" (PDF). U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit (PACER Document 3111697838). Scribd.com.
- "Memorandum Opinion, Palladino v. Corbett. Civil Action No. 13-5641.". March 4, 2014.
- Roebuck, Jeremy (May 15, 2014). "Federal court hears case on recognizing same-sex marriage". Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved May 23, 2014.
- Coulombilis, Angela; Warden, Amy (May 22, 2014). "U.S. judge strikes down same-sex marriage ban in Pa.". Philadelphia Inquirer. Retrieved May 23, 2014.
- McLaughlin, Mary, U.S. District Judge (September 8, 2014). "Order (Suspending Proceedings), Palladino v. Corbett, No. 13-5641". U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania (Plainsite.org). PACER Document 80.
- McLaughlin, Mary (U.S. District Court Judge) (October 22, 2014). "Stipulated Order of Voluntary Dismissal, Pallidino v. Corbett, No. 2:13-cv-05641-MAM". U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania (Scribd.com).
- Eilperin, Juliet (July 11, 2013). "Who is Kathleen Kane?". The Washington Post. Retrieved August 8, 2013.
- Parks, Jessica (July 23, 2013). "Montgomery County will issue same-sex marriage licenses". Pittsburgh Post Gazette. Retrieved July 24, 2013.
- "Pennsylvania county clerk goes rogue for marriage equality". July 25, 2013.
- Gibbons, Margaret (July 24, 2013). "Same sex couples receiving marriage licenses in Montco in defiance of state ban". phillyburbs.com. Retrieved July 24, 2013.
- "Montco issues 100th license to same-sex couple". Philly.com. August 11, 2013.
- Cole, Jeff; Wilson, Shawnette (July 30, 2013). "Pennsylvania Sues To Stop Montco's Same-Sex Marriage Licenses". Philadelphia, PA: WTXF-TV. Retrieved July 30, 2013.
- "Montgomery County Same-Sex Marriage Licenses". Cases of Public Interest. The Unified Judicial System of Pennsylvania. Retrieved May 22, 2014.
- "Pa. court to hear gay marriage arguments on Sept. 4". Observer Reporter. August 20, 2013.
- "Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Department of Health v. D. Bruce Hanes, in his official capacity as the Clerk of the Orphans’ Court of Montgomery County" (PDF). September 13, 2013. Retrieved September 13, 2013.
- "County clerk in Pennsylvania ordered to stop issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples". Equality on Trial. September 12, 2013.
- Jackson, Peter (December 2, 2013). "Montco clerk urges state to allow him to issue gay marriage licenses". The Mercury. Retrieved December 3, 2013.
- "Brief of Amicus Curiae Same-Sex Couples, Commonwealth v. Hanes" (PDF). Supreme Court of Pa., Docket No. 77 MAP 2013. December 2, 2013.
- "Brief of Respondent Wolf, Ballen v. Wolf" (PDF). Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court, Docket No. 481 M.D. 2013. February 18, 2014.
- "New court challenge from 21 couples filed to overturn gay marriage ban". PennLive. September 25, 2013.
- Pellegrini, Dan, Presiding Judge (September 30, 2014). "Stipulation of Settlement and Dismissal, Ballen v. Wolf, No. 481 MD 2013". Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court (Scribd.com).
- "Estimating the Economic Boost of Marriage for Same-Sex Couples in Pennsylvania" (PDF). UCLA. Retrieved May 25, 2014.
- "Same-sex marriage will add nearly $100 million to Pennsylvania's economy". UPI. Retrieved May 25, 2014.
- "Pennsylvanians favor civil unions for gay couples" (PDF). Retrieved June 21, 2012.
- Pennsylvania supports Civil Unions at record breaking 36% http://www.publicpolicypolling.com/pdf/PPP_Release_PA_714.pdf
- "Survey of Pennsylvanians: Summary of Findings" (PDF). Retrieved June 21, 2012.
- Pennsylvania still supports Civil Unions http://www.publicpolicypolling.com/pdf/2011/PPP_Release_PA_1129513.pdf
- "PA blacks shift quickly in favor of gay marriage". Public Policy Polling. Retrieved May 23, 2012.
- "Poll: Corbett Net Loss, Gay Marriage Net Gain" (PDF). June 6, 2012. Retrieved August 31, 2012.
- "Muhlenberg College/Morning Call 2012 Pennsylvania Presidential" (PDF). September 28, 2012. Retrieved December 25, 2012.
- "Pennsylvania Voters Want Stricter Gun-Control, Quinnipiac University Poll Finds; Voters Lean Slightly To Same-Sex Marriage". Quinnipiac University. Retrieved January 30, 2013.
- "Franklin & Marshall College Poll" (PDF). Retrieved December 2, 2013.
- "New Poll Shows Majority in Pennsylvania Support Marriage Equality". Towleroad.com. Retrieved December 2, 2013.
- "Support for gay marriage in Pennsylvania on the rise". Public Policy Polling. March 13, 2013.
- "Franklin & Marshall College Poll". Keystonepolitics.com. May 8, 2013. Retrieved December 2, 2013.
- A Shifting Landscape
- "Pennsylvania Results". Quinnipiac University Polling. Retrieved March 3, 2014.
- "Wolf with hefty lead in Governor's race" (PDF). June 3, 2014. Retrieved June 10, 2014.
- "New Pa. poll shows dramatic rise in support of gay marriage". Morning Call. December 22, 2014.