Rivalries in the Australian Football League

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Rivalries in the Australian Football League exist between many teams, most of which typically draw large crowds and interest regardless of both teams' positions on the ladder. The AFL encourages the building of such rivalries, as a method of increasing publicity for the league, to the point of designating one round each year as Rivalry Round where many of these match-ups are held on the one weekend.[1] Whilst some rivalries, such as between teams from adjacent areas, are still strong, the designation of an entire round of fixtures as Rivalry Round is often criticised due to some arbitrary match-ups, or ignoring stronger, more recent rivalries.[2]

With a 22-game season and 18 teams (16 teams from 1995 until 2010 with the introduction of the Gold Coast Football Club and the Greater Western Sydney Giants in 2011 and 2012 respectively), the AFL fixtures are not equal with each team playing seven other teams twice and eight teams once. Choosing to play certain games twice, such as the local derbies and blockbusters (games between the Big 4 Victorian clubs of Collingwood, Carlton, Essendon and Richmond, are known as blockbuster games), results in a skewed fixture which is rarely evened out over time.

Victorian rivalries[edit]

Locations of AFL teams in Melbourne prior to 1965

Carlton v Collingwood[edit]

Argued by some to be the greatest and longest standing rivalry in the competition.[1] Two clubs in close proximity, fuelled by the rivalry between white (Carlton) and blue collar (Collingwood) suburbs; the rivalry is intensified because the teams have met in six memorable grand finals (Carlton winning five, Collingwood one), including Carlton's 44-point comeback in 1970, and the famous Harmes-Sheldon goal in 1979. Games between these two clubs regularly attract large crowds regardless of whether they are in finals contention or not.

Essendon v Carlton[edit]

As is the case with two successful sides in any competition, fans of each club love to defeat the other.[1] The two clubs share the record for the most premierships with 16, with the clubs meeting in 6 grand finals ( with each team having won 3 flags against the other) including a 1 point victory by Carlton against Essendon in 1947 and a drought-breaking flag in 1968 in which Carlton became the first team to have kicked fewer goals than the loser. [3]

In the 1980s and 1990s, the rivalry went to new levels with the two teams competing in several memorable contests. In 1981 the clubs would meet in the Escort cup grand final which Essendon would win. Later on in the season in Round 20 in 1981, with Carlton leading by 26 points with 10 minutes left to play, with goals from Neale Danniher helping get the Bombers across the line by 1 point. The game is most famous for Carlton skipper Mike Fitzpatrick having the ball taken off him for wasting time. In 1993 Carlton and Essendon met in quite a few memorable affairs, including the 1993 Grand Final in which the Baby Bombers got up to win the game by 44 points against a favoured Carlton side most remembered for Michael Longs dashing goal in the first quarter, a few weeks earlier the Blues had beaten the Bombers in the first night qualifying final by 2 points and in round 2 the two teams both drew the game, after Stephen Kernahan had a chance to win the game for Carlton only to kick it out on the full in what was the highest draw game in AFL/VFL history[4]. Carlton famously upset the heavily favoured Essendon side by 1 point in the 1999 Preliminary Final.

In 2007 Essendon led Carlton by 48 points deep into the second quarter of their Round 3 2007 match at the MCG, only to be overrun by Carlton in what would go down as their greatest ever come from behind victory; however, Essendon went on to defeat Carlton over the next 6 encounters, with Carlton finally breaking Essendon's winning streak with an emphatic 76 point win in Round 19, 2010.

Following the 2000 Preliminary final the two teams wouldn't meet in a final until the 2011 Elimination Final and would be Carlton's first finals win in 10 years[5]. In 2018 after Carlton's worst start to the season in the clubs 121 years in the competition, the Blues would secure their first win for the season in Round 8 against Essendon.[6]

Melbourne v Collingwood[edit]

A traditional white collar (Melbourne) v blue collar (Collingwood) rivalry, additionally fuelled by a narrow loss to Collingwood which stopped Melbourne from winning a fourth flag in a row in 1958 and Melbourne restricting Collingwood to 14 points in the 1960 grand final. Half of Melbourne's twelve premierships came against Collingwood and the teams have met in seven grand finals, the most of any pairing. Since 2001, Melbourne has hosted Collingwood in an annual match at the MCG on the Queen's Birthday public holiday Monday in June.

Richmond v Collingwood[edit]

Arising from the fact that the two areas neighbour each other, Richmond and Collingwood were both highly successful in the late 1920s to the early 1930s; the clubs played against each other in five grand finals between 1919 and 1929 (Collingwood won in 1919, 1927, 1928 and 1929, while Richmond won in 1920). In the 1980 Grand Final, Richmond handed Collingwood an 81-point defeat, a record at the time, causing Collingwood to lose an 8th Grand Finals in a row.

Both clubs continue to draw large crowds to their meetings in each season, and the two were the subject of a 'recruiting war' throughout the 1970s and 1980s, with David Cloke, Geoff Raines, Brian Taylor, Wally Lovett, Phillip Walsh, Steven Roach, Gerald Betts, Neil Peart, Peter McCormack, Kevin Morris, Craig Stewart, Ross Brewer, Michael Lockman, Rod Oborne, Allan Edwards, John Annear, Noel Lovell and Bob Heard all exchanging clubs, as well as coach Tom Hafey (moving to Collingwood in 1977 following four flags at Punt Road).

Melees have been fought between the teams in two recent matches – Round 20, 2009, and Round 2, 2012 – with almost all players from both teams involved in the altercations.

Both teams played each other 3 times during 2018, with all three games pulling off massive crowds. Crowds of 72,157 and 88,180 was attended between both home and away games with Richmond winning both times, until Collingwood unexpectedly pulled off a massive upset, smashing Richmond in the preliminary final in front of a crowd of 94,959 which caused the rivalry to reach its highest point since 1980. Games between these two clubs regularly attract large crowds regardless of whether they are in finals contention or not.

Hawthorn v Essendon[edit]

Games between the Hawks and the Bombers have proved spectacular, due to wild brawls

The clubs contested the Grand Final in three consecutive seasons between 1983 and 1985, and the rough nature of these games and other matches between the clubs made them strong rivals during the 1980s. In 1992, Hawthorn inflicted a record MCG score of 32.24 216 against Essendon. In the 2000s, the clubs have played two matches which saw bench-clearing brawls: the "Line in the Sand Match" in 2004, which resulted in four players being suspended and $70,700 in fines; and the final round of 2009, a match which would decide eighth place between the two teams, in which four players were suspended for a total of seven matches and $27,000 in fines being handed out. The latter brawl was famously sparked by Matthew Lloyd who applied a very hard bump, knocking out Brad Sewell, in what would be Lloyd's last game.

Richmond v Carlton[edit]

A rivalry based on geographical proximity and large supporter bases, the rivalry intensified as both clubs contested several grand finals between 1969 and 1982,[1] including the 1972 Grand Final where Richmond equalled the highest score ever in a grand final, only to be bettered by Carlton in the same match. The following year Richmond won the 1973 Grand Final in an even more physically bitter contest than in recent encounters between the two sides; Carlton got their revenge in 1982 by defeating Richmond in their last grand final appearance until their win over Adelaide in 2017. In 2013, Carlton beat Richmond by 20 points in an elimination final, which was Richmond's first final since 2001, and third final since 1982.

Since 2008, the first game of each season played at the Melbourne Cricket Ground has been played between Carlton and Richmond on a Thursday night early in the season, with an average crowd of 80,000 and a monster 90,000 crowd in 2018 when Richmond unflured their 2017 premiership flag. A record crowd of 94,690 attended the 2013 Elimination Final between these two traditional rivals. It was the largest crowd for the 2013 season excluding the grand final, and the largest week one finals crowd since 1972. Carlton has never beat Richmond in a game since this final. [7] Carlton has also received more finals losses (16) to Richmond than any other team. Richmond has also inflicted a total of four grand final losses on Carlton (1921, 1932, 1969 and 1973). Carlton has only beaten Richmond in two grand finals (1972 and 1982). Games between these two clubs regularly attract large crowds regardless of whether they are in finals contention or not.[8]

Essendon v Collingwood[edit]

Since 1995, the rivalry has been defined by the Anzac Day clash, a match generally draws a crowd in excess of 90,000. The inaugural Anzac Day Clash in 1995 was famously drawn, the 2009 match was won by Essendon in the final minute with a goal from youngster David Zaharakis, and the 2012 match was won by Collingwood by one point after Jarryd Blair's game-winning goal was reviewed by video replay before being awarded.[9]

Essendon v Richmond[edit]

A rivalry born out of the fact that the two clubs are both part of the "Big 4" clubs in Melbourne as the highly supported teams. Since 2005, Essendon and Richmond have contested the annual Dreamtime at the 'G match, a celebration of Aboriginal players and their contribution to the league, typically held near the midway point of the season. These games usually tend to get a crowd of 80,000 or above.

North Melbourne v Hawthorn[edit]

Both teams entered the VFL in the 1925 expansion, and were generally unsuccessful through the first few decades, but the two teams were both very strong through the 1970s, sparking a rivalry between the clubs. The clubs played three Grand Finals against each other in four years, with North Melbourne winning their first ever premiership in 1975 by 55 points, Hawthorn winning in 1976 by five goals, and Hawthorn winning in 1978 by three goals.

Melees have been fought between the two teams in recent matches – Round 16, 2014, and Round 5, 2015 – with almost all players in both teams involved in the altercations.

Hawthorn v Geelong[edit]

The rivalry between Hawthorn and Geelong is defined by two Grand Finals: those of 1989 and 2008. In the 1989 Grand Final, Geelong played the man, resulting in major injuries for several Hawks players, Mark Yeates knocking out Dermott Brereton at the opening bounce; Hawthorn controlled the game, leading by approximately 40 points for most of the match; in the last quarter, Geelong almost managed to come from behind to win, but fell short by six points. In 2008 Grand Final, Geelong was the heavily backed favourite and had lost only one match for the season, but Hawthorn upset Geelong by 26 points; Geelong won its next eleven matches against Hawthorn over the following five years, under a curse, which was dubbed the "Kennett curse" which was attributed to disrespectful comments made by Hawthorn president Jeff Kennett following the 2008 Grand Final. It was later revealed that after the 2008 grand final, Paul Chapman initiated a pact between other Geelong players to never lose to Hawthorn again. The curse was broken in a preliminary final in 2013, after Paul Chapman played his final match for Geelong the previous week.[10]

Essendon v North Melbourne[edit]

Essendon and North Melbourne share a rivalry that has its roots during the formation of the VFL in 1896. North were denied by Essendon to join the breakaway competition because both clubs drew supporters from the same area and Essendon felt threatened by North's proximity to them which in turn drummed up fears that North could drain Essendon's talent pool if they were allowed to participate in the VFL. Essendon and North Melbourne were both strong in the latter part of the 1990s and early 2000s, and built a bigger rivalry during that time. The defining moment of this rivalry came in Round 16 of 2001, when Essendon came from 69 points down in the second quarter to win by 12 points. Essendon and North Melbourne have played in one Grand Final, in 1950, which Essendon won by 38 points.

Collingwood v Geelong[edit]

Geelong won their first flag in 1925 over Collingwood, in 1930 Collingwood defeated Geelong in the grand final making it four flags in-a-row for the Pies. Geelong would later deny Collingwood three successive premierships in 1937, winning a famous grand final by 32 points.

The two sides played against each other in 6 finals between 1951 and 1955, including the 1952 Grand Final when Geelong easily beat Collingwood by 46 points. In 1953, Collingwood ended Geelong's record 23-game winning streak in the home and away season, and later defeated them by 12 points in the grand final, denying the Cats a third successive premiership.

Since 2007, the clubs have again both been at the top of the ladder and have met regularly in finals. Geelong won a memorable preliminary final by five points on their way to their first flag in 44 years. In 2008, Collingwood inflicted Geelong's only home-and-away loss, by a massive 86 points, but the teams did not meet in the finals. They would meet in preliminary finals in 2009 and 2010, each winning one en route to a premiership. They finally met in a Grand Final in 2011, which Geelong won by 38 points; Geelong inflicted Collingwood's only three losses for the 2011 season.[11]

Local derbies[edit]

There are four 'local derbies' in the AFL, with each of the clubs competing against their cross-town rivals at least twice every year.

West Coast v Fremantle[edit]

The two Western Australian-based teams contest the Western Derby. The West Coast Eagles won the first nine derbies, stretching from the inaugural derby in May 1995 until July 1999, but the Fremantle Dockers managed a seven match consecutive winning streak in derby matches, commencing in August 2007 and ending in May 2011. Of the 50 derbies played, West Coast holds a 30–20 advantage. The best performed player in each Western Derby is awarded the Glendinning-Allan Medal.

Adelaide v Port Adelaide[edit]

The two teams based in South Australia, the Adelaide Crows and the Port Adelaide Power, contest the Showdown. The first showdown occurred in April 1997, following the introduction of Port Adelaide into the league that year. Of the 45 Showdowns that have been contested, Adelaide holds a 23–22 advantage over Port. The best performed player in each showdown is awarded the Showdown Medal. Following the death of then coach of Adelaide Crows and assistant coach of Port Adelaide Power for 11 years, Phil Walsh, the Showdown medal was renamed after Walsh to commemorate his life, in the highest attended game between the two and the lowest ever margin. Adelaide Crows won 116 - 113.

Brisbane Lions v Gold Coast[edit]

The QClash is a derby between the only two Queensland clubs. The Gold Coast Suns won the first QClash, held in 2011, by eight points, but the Brisbane Lions has dominated the rivalry, leading the head-to-head tally 7-5. The best performed player in each QClash is awarded the Marcus Ashcroft Medal.

Sydney v Greater Western Sydney[edit]

The Sydney Derby is the newest local derby in the AFL, following the introduction of Greater Western Sydney in the 2012 AFL season. The best performed player in each derby is awarded the Brett Kirk Medal. The Sydney Swans have dominated most of the rivalry, holding an 11-5 advantage over the Giants and winning six of the sixteen games by at least 30 points, however, the tide has turned in recent times, with the last fourteen meetings being evenly split since the start of 2014, with the Giants winning a historic qualifying final in 2016,[12][13] as well as an elimination final in 2018.[14][15]

Recent rivalries[edit]

West Coast v Sydney[edit]

A rivalry between Sydney and West Coast developed during the first decade of the 2000s, due to an unusually high number of close games, many in finals. The teams met each other six times between September 2005 and March 2007, including both Grand Finals and two Qualifying Finals; the final margins of these games were: 4, 4, 2, 1, 1 and 1, with Sydney winning the 2005 Grand Final, and West Coast winning the 2006 Grand Final. The sum of margins of 13 points across six consecutive meetings is by far the narrowest in VFL/AFL history, with 28 points (South Melbourne vs Melbourne, 28 points, 1898–1900) the nearest challenger.

West Coast v Collingwood[edit]

The rivalry between the West Coast Eagles and Collingwood Magpies steams from a series of finals matches since the VFL became the AFL [16]. With it routes in the 1990 Qualifying Final in which West Coast and Collingwood drew the match, requiring a replay the following week, the two sides drew a final on another occasion in 2007 which went into extra time which Collingwood won. The two clubs have met 8 times in finals since 1990, including a 2 point victory by the Eagles in the 1994 Qualifying final.The two clubs met for the first time in a Grand Final in 2018, with the Eagles winning by 5 points to claim their fourth premiership.[17]. The two clubs also share a common coach in Mick Malthouse who led West Coast to their first two flags in 1992 and 1994 and took Collingwood to their 15th and most recent premiership in 2010.[18]

Brisbane Lions v Collingwood[edit]

Angst between supporters of Collingwood and Brisbane had been caused by plenty of history between the two clubs, despite the Brisbane Lions having a relatively short existence as a merged club. Pre-merger Fitzroy was a neighbouring suburb to Collingwood, with the boundary being based on Smith Street,[19] along with the fact that Fitzroy and Collingwood topped the VFL/AFL premiership tally during the early existence of what was then the VFL competition. The Brisbane Bears also had a bit of beef with the Magpies as the Bears' number one draft pick Nathan Buckley famously defected to Collingwood after one season on the Bears list, citing that he wanted to win premierships and play finals footy, and that Brisbane had no future.[20] The Bears also lost their final regular season match in their final season (1996) to the Magpies, costing the Bears the minor premiership that season.[21] However the rivalry between the Lions and the Magpies was properly ignited post-merger, it began in late 1999 when Collingwood played their last ever VFL/AFL game at their spiritual home ground, Victoria Park with the Lions emerging 42 point victors that day and consigning the Magpies to their second wooden spoon in their VFL/AFL history that day.[22] The rivalry between the two clubs went to the next level as the clubs played off in two consecutive Grand Finals in 2002 and 2003, with the Lions emerging victors on both occasions.[23][24] These grand final results further fueled the hatred that Collingwood supporters have towards the Brisbane Lions to this day, despite the Lions having a poor decade on the field after their golden era.

Hawthorn v Sydney[edit]

From 2011 until 2014 these two clubs shares a heated rivalry and have met four times in do or die games in the finals. In the 2011 Semi Final which Hawthorn won, 2012 Grand Final won by Sydney, 2013 Qualifying Final won by Hawthorn and 2014 Grand Final which was won by Hawthorn.

St Kilda v Geelong[edit]

While the St Kilda Football Club have tasted little success in the history of Australian Rules football, only acquiring one premiership in 1966 against the Collingwood Football Club, St Kilda have been a strong team in the modern era of the AFL. This is demonstrated no better than the clashes with Geelong during the 2000s and 2010s. The seasons between 2005-2011, both clubs were powerhouses, with St Kilda and Geelong both at the top of the AFL ladder during the 2009 Home and Away season. Both teams, still undefeated after 13 matches so far in the season, would finally meet in Round 14 at Etihad Stadium. This match, which broke the Etihad Stadium record of attendance at a Home and Away match in Etihad Stadium, would be known as one of the famous regular season matches in AFL history. The game also broke the record set in Round 8, 1991 between West Coast and Essendon as being the latest into a season that two undefeated teams had played against each other. St Kilda narrowly defeated Geelong, and asserted themselves atop alone in the AFL standings. These two teams would eventually meet again in the 2009 AFL Grand Final, but Geelong would defeat St Kilda late into the last quarter.

This rivalry would continue into the 2010-2011 seasons, and was still present in 2016, with the last three matches between the teams resulting in one win each for St Kilda and Geelong, with a draw in 2015.

Overall head to head[edit]

All clubs head to head win percentages. Games only include premiership matches in the VFL/AFL. Correct to the end of the 2015 AFL season.[25]

Ade Bri Car Col Ess Fre GC Gee GWS Haw Mel NM PA Ric StK Syd WB WCE
Ade 51.72 52.94 64.10 52.94 44.12 0.00 54.05 16.67 51.35 35.29 47.37 53.85 36.36 39.74 38.89 53.66 54.76
Bri 48.28 48.28 37.04 51.92 54.17 40.00 51.72 50.00 53.57 40.00 51.56 46.67 66.00 42.86 64.06 45.45 64.29
Car 47.06 51.72 49.40 48.76 58.62 20.00 45.83 60.00 37.42 43.27 36.18 55.36 41.40 24.19 41.44 37.32 48.78
Col 35.90 62.96 50.60 44.40 42.31 40.00 42.76 0.00 40.00 35.71 32.48 46.15 42.61 26.85 37.00 29.47 51.09
Ess 47.06 48.08 51.24 55.60 37.93 20.00 45.77 20.00 39.24 38.86 36.93 57.69 46.19 32.38 39.58 39.49 44.90
Fre 55.88 45.83 41.38 57.69 62.07 0.00 64.71 0.00 75.00 38.24 61.54 54.84 53.13 54.84 53.23 53.85 52.38
GC 100.00 60.00 80.00 60.00 80.00 100.00 83.33 42.86 100.00 57.14 50.00 83.33 40.00 39.57 100.00 71.43 92.86
Gee 45.95 48.28 54.17 57.24 54.23 35.29 16.67 0.00 45.89 40.09 39.94 32.76 45.77 39.57 44.70 36.13 51.04
GWS 83.33 50.00 40.00 100.00 80.00 100.00 57.14 100.00 75.00 50.00 100.00 80.00 100.00 60.00 87.50 80.00 100.00
Haw 48.65 46.43 62.58 60.00 60.76 25.00 0.00 54.11 25.00 46.84 44.71 58.06 55.56 47.37 43.75 48.41 54.35
Mel 64.71 60.00 56.73 64.29 61.14 61.76 42.86 59.91 50.00 53.16 46.82 62.07 55.91 43.03 54.41 46.89 68.09
NM 52.63 48.44 63.82 67.52 63.07 38.46 50.00 60.06 0.00 55.29 53.18 30.00 53.85 50.33 53.18 50.00 54.35
PA 46.15 53.33 44.64 53.85 42.31 45.16 16.67 67.24 20.00 41.94 37.93 70.00 40.38 38.46 73.08 48.00 37.04
Ric 63.64 34.00 58.60 57.39 53.81 46.88 60.00 54.23 0.00 44.44 44.09 46.15 59.62 39.17 44.76 47.68 60.00
StK 60.26 57.14 75.81 73.15 67.62 45.16 37.50 60.42 40.00 52.63 56.97 49.67 61.54 60.83 62.97 47.76 60.23
Syd 61.11 35.94 58.56 63.00 60.42 46.77 0.00 55.30 12.50 56.25 45.59 46.82 26.92 55.24 37.03 50.65 43.48
WB 46.34 54.55 62.68 70.53 60.51 46.15 28.57 63.87 20.00 51.59 53.11 50.00 52.00 52.32 52.24 49.35 65.63
WCE 45.24 35.71 51.22 48.91 55.10 47.62 7.14 48.96 0.00 45.65 31.91 45.65 62.96 40.00 39.77 56.52 34.38

Also see[edit]


  1. ^ a b c d Lonergan, Dan; AFL arch rivals - a thing of the past; 2007-04-13
  2. ^ Baum, G;Footy's drowning in a sea of medals; The Age; 2008-04-12
  3. ^ http://www.blueseum.org/Grand+Final%2C+1968
  4. ^ https://afltables.com/afl/seas/1993.html
  5. ^ https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_match_statistics?mid=5337
  6. ^ https://www.afl.com.au/match-centre/2018/8/carl-v-ess
  7. ^ http://www.afl.com.au/news/2013-09-08/record-crowd-rocks-the-mcg-during-tigersblues-final
  8. ^ http://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/2013-09-02/a-great-traditional-rivalry
  9. ^ Edmond, Sam (25 April 2012). "Collingwood defeats Essendon by one point in Anzac Day epic". Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 26 April 2012.
  10. ^ http://finalsiren.com/PreviousGames.asp?Team1ID=4&Team2ID=16&Go=Go
  11. ^ http://www.collingwoodfc.com.au/news/2013-05-14/an-epic-rivalry
  12. ^ "GWS Giants come of age to upset Sydney Swans in first qualifying final". News.com.au. 10 September 2016.
  13. ^ "AFL lands NRL huge blow with bumper crowd for Sydney Swans v GWS Giants qualifying final". The Sydney Morning Herald. 10 September 2016.
  14. ^ De Silva, Chris (8 September 2018). "GWS Giants humiliate Sydney Swans in elimination final". Wide World of Sports. Retrieved 14 September 2018.
  15. ^ http://afltables.com/afl/teams/gws/allgames_tm.html
  16. ^ https://www.afl.com.au/news/2018-09-23/eagles-v-magpies-an-incredible-finals-rivalry
  17. ^ https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/west-coast-vs-collingwood-the-rivalry.1206603/
  18. ^ https://www.abc.net.au/news/2019-06-05/coach-mick-malthouse-inductees-australian-football-hall-of-fame/11180666
  19. ^ http://www.yarracity.vic.gov.au/About-Yarra/Maps/
  20. ^ http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/buckley-still-haunted-by-flag-failures-20120116-1q38x.html
  21. ^ https://forever.collingwoodfc.com.au/matches/1996-collingwood-vs-brisbane-round-22/
  22. ^ http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_match_statistics?mid=1086
  23. ^ http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_match_statistics?mid=1654
  24. ^ http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_match_statistics?mid=1839
  25. ^ http://afltables.com/afl/teams/allteams/overall_wl.html