Saturn V Dynamic Test Vehicle
Saturn V Dynamic Test Vehicle
The first stage of this Saturn V is hoisted into position for a shake test at the Saturn V Dynamic Test Stand in 1966.
|Architect||NASA-Marshall Space Flight Center; Boeing Aircraft|
|Governing body||Smithsonian Institution|
|NRHP Reference #||78000500|
|Added to NRHP||November 22, 1978|
|Designated NHL||February 10, 1987|
Saturn V Dynamic Test Vehicle, designated SA-500D, is a prototype Saturn V rocket used by NASA to test the performance of the rocket when vibrated to simulate the shaking which subsequent rockets would experience during launch. It was the first full-scale Saturn V completed by the Marshall Space Flight Center (MSFC). Though SA-500D never flew, it was instrumental in the development of the Saturn V rocket which propelled the first men to the Moon as part of the Apollo program. Built under the direction of Dr. Wernher von Braun, it served as the test vehicle for all of the Saturn support facilities at MSFC.
SA-500D is the only Saturn V on display that was used for its intended purpose, and the only one to have been assembled prior to museum display. It is on permanent display at the U.S. Space & Rocket Center, Huntsville, Alabama.
Before a Saturn V could launch, engineers needed to verify that their design had accounted for everything the rocket would encounter on its journey, from assembly to the launchpad and from Earth to the Moon. To validate the Saturn V design and procedures, they created five pre-flight configurations for testing. These configurations were subjected to tests simulating all aspects of flight preparations and flight itself, and all the tests needed to demonstrate satisfactory results before MSFC would certify the Saturn V to fly.
SA-500D was one of the five pre-flight configurations of the Saturn V. This configuration showed the Saturn V's "bending and vibration characteristics" and verified "the adequacy of guidance and control systems' design." The rocket's 7,610,000 pounds-force (33.9 MN) of thrust would generate vigorous shaking and it was important to see that the rocket would not shake apart or vibrate itself off-course.
Other pre-flight configurations were:
- Battleship Test model, used for initial engine firing and design improvements
- Structural Test model, to certify the structure for loads during launch at the anticipated temperatures, and to assess the stiffness of each stage
- SA-500F, the facilities checkout model, verify launch facilities, train launch crews, and develop test and checkout procedures.
- SA-500T, All Systems Test model, for static firing of engines in the flight configuration
Development of the test article
The Saturn V consisted of three stages and an Instrument Unit (IU). The first stage, S-IC, delivered 7,610,000 pounds-force (33.9 MN) thrust and delivered the other stages to 200,000 feet (61 km). Afterwards, it was jettisoned to fall into the Atlantic Ocean and the second stage continued acceleration. The second stage, S-II, was responsible for lifting the remaining parts nearly to Earth orbit. The third stage, S-IVB provided the final push to orbit and the trans-lunar injection burn to set the Apollo spacecraft on a course to the Moon. The IU was the guidance and control computer. SA-500D was the assembly of these components for dynamic testing.
The Saturn V Dynamic Test Stand with "electrodynamic shakers" provided a table capable not only of holding the Saturn V fully assembled and fueled, but also able to simulate the vibrations that would be generated by rocket engines.
The components used for testing were developed from 1964–66, and the tests conducted in 1966-67. Because the Saturn V shared some components with the Saturn IB, some of the components for SA-500D were initially used for dynamic testing with the Saturn IB stack.
In naming the individual stages, MSFC used the stage designation with a suffix indicating its purpose. For example, S-IC-D was the first stage, S-IC, for dynamic testing, and S-IC-1 was the first flight model of the first stage. Suffixes used were S, for structural, F for facilities, T for all-systems test, and D for dynamic testing.
Following is a history of each component of the dynamic test article in order of appearance.
Development of the test article started from the top. A boilerplate Apollo spacecraft, BP-27 together with LTA-2, was used for all configurations of dynamic testing. The boilerplate took the place of actual flight hardware. Boilerplate size, shape, mass and center of gravity were the same, but it was not necessary for the entire Apollo spacecraft to be complete to commence dynamic testing. The boilerplate was outfitted with instrumentation to record data for engineering study and evaluation.
BP-27 consisted of hardware specifically built for that configuration and some hardware reassigned from other designations. The Command Module and Launch Escape System were unique to BP-27. The Service Module SM-010 (formerly SM-006) and the Spacecraft Lunar Module Adapters SLA #1 were also assigned to BP-27.
Shortly thereafter, MSFC took delivery of the boilerplate Lunar Module, called a Lunar Test Article and designated LTA-2. LTA-2 is the only part of SA-500D to fly in space. It was refurbished, designated LTA-2R, and flew on Apollo 6.
The third stage, S-IVB-D arrived at MSFC before any other Saturn V stages because it was destined for dynamic testing in the Saturn IB first. It was assembled by Douglas near Los Angeles. With ceremony and dignitaries for the first Douglas-built S-IVB stage, it set out by barge December 8, 1964, and made its way to New Orleans via the Panama Canal, the Mississippi, Ohio, and Tennessee Rivers to MSFC, where it arrived on January 4, 1965. The same day, MSFC took delivery of the first stage of the Saturn IB for dynamic and facilities checkout testing, S-IB-D/F. The parts were assembled together with the instrument unit designated S-IU-200D/500D (see below) and BP-27 for dynamic testing in the Saturn IB configuration from February to September 1965 before it was allocated to the Saturn V configuration.
The Saturn V Instrument Unit served as the electronics hub for the first three stages of the rocket, controlling engine firing, guidance, stage separation, and climate for the three stages below. It consisted of two main parts, a rigid ring for structure, and within that, electronics.
Instrument units had a slightly different numbering scheme than the other parts. S-IU-200D/500D was for use with the SA-200D dynamic test article - a Saturn IB, and also for use with SA-500D, the Saturn V.
The IU's structural ring had two responsibilities: provide a mounting location for IBM's electronics and hold everything on top of it. It needed to be structurally sound enough to hold the weight of the Lunar Module, Service Module, Command Module and the three astronauts during the acceleration provided by three mighty stages of rocket beneath. The rings were all fabricated at MSFC.
S-IU-200D/500D was the second IU to be built, with the ring completed in January 1965 and electronic components from IBM installed by February 1. It was the last piece necessary for dynamic testing in the Saturn IB program. It was stacked together with S-IVB-D, S-IB-D, and BP-27 for Saturn IB testing through much of 1965. On October 8, 1965, it began dynamic testing for the Saturn V program as part of SA-500D.
MSFC built the first three S-IC test first stages for the Saturn V: S-IC-T, the S-IC-S, and the S-IC-F. They also built the first two flight stages, S-IC-1 and S-IC-2. S-IC-D was the first to be built by Boeing at the Michoud Assembly Facility, New Orleans using the tooling that that had been developed in Huntsville.
S-IC-D, was under construction on September 9, 1965 when Hurricane Betsy struck the Michoud Assembly Facility. The building housing the stage sustained severe damage, but the stage itself was repaired promptly.
S-IC-D set out on the maiden voyage of NASA barge Poseidon to Marshall Space Flight Center on October 6, 1965 and arrived at MSFC October 13. The first stage was lifted into place in the Dynamic Test Stand January 13, 1966 in the picture top right. Said one observer, "Fog and clouds hovered around the top of the 360 foot (110 m) tall test stand most of the day while the 300,000 pounds (140,000 kg) stage was being lifted from its transporter into place inside the stand, said to be the tallest building in Alabama."
The second stage of SA-500D had a complex history. The second stage, S-II-D had been on order, but that part was cancelled February 19, 1965. The plan was to use another test article for dynamic testing as well as its other purpose. Two such test articles were destroyed during testing after having been designated for the dynamic test phase. The actual article used in SA-500D was named in the third re-allocation, when S-II-F, the facilities checkout article, was designated S-II-F/D.
S-II-S, which North American Aviation's Space and Information Systems Division (S&ID) at Seal Beach had completed by January 31, was re-designated as S-II-S/D to be used for dynamic testing. S-II-S/D would not survive its final structural test on September 29, 1965, but the test was exercising considerable margin above the structural integrity required for flight.
In January 1966, the all-systems test S-II-T was re-designated S-II-T/D, so that it might be used for dynamic testing as well as engine firing. S-II-T/D completed integrated checkout of ground support facilities at MTF on February 3, 1966. S-II-T/D's engines were fired five times at MTF from April to May, including a full-duration test. On May 28, 1966, S-II-T/D was undergoing a pressure test to find a hydrogen leak, but the hydrogen pressure sensors and switches had been disconnected unbeknownst to the second-shift crew when they tried to pressurize the tank. Five technicians sustained minor injuries. MSFC convened an investigation that night, and the team completed the report in two days.
After the S-II-T/D destruction, a third article was assigned to dynamic test duties. Facilities checkout article S-II-F became the dynamic test article designated S-II-F/D. S-II-F was shipped from S&ID, Seal Beach, California on February 20, 1966, to Kennedy Space Center where it arrived March 4. It filled in the final part of SA-500F to check out facilities for processing the Saturn V, replacing a dumbbell-shaped temporary stage of the same length and weight as an S-II stage. SA-500F was assembled in the Vehicle Assembly Building where it was mated to S-IC-F on March 28 and S-IVB-F the next day.
Hurricane Alma interrupted exercises as SA-500F was rolled back to the VAB on June 8, though the ground crew supposed the rollback was more of an exercise than necessity because winds remained below critical for the entire storm. It was returned to pad 39-A two days later and finally returned to the VAB October 14, 1966 for disassembly.
After facilities checkout at KSC was completed, the remaining components of SA-500F were then transferred to MSFC for inclusion in SA-500D: the Apollo boilerplate BP-27 and S-II-F/D. The second stage was modified for dynamic testing, and shipped by Posideon from KSC on October 29 to arrive at MSFC November 10, 1966.
Engineers needed a detailed knowledge of the space vehicle's dynamic flight characteristics to design structural, guidance, and flight control systems. They initially used analytical data that had not been substantiated by test for design criteria. The Dynamic Test Vehicle test project determined the dynamic characteristics of the space vehicle and verified earlier analyses.
The objectives of the dynamic tests were to:
- Determine the space vehicle structural dynamic characteristics under conditions simulating flight configuration and environment insofar as practicable.
- Determine the optimum location for flight sensors and obtain experimental transfer functions for the control system.
- Determine the physical mating capability of stages and modules.
- Compare dynamic test results with subsequent flight test results for continuous development of dynamic test techniques and facilities to assure the highest possible degree of accuracy in the development of future vehicle structures prior to flight.
- Determine the space vehicle dynamic characteristics under conditions simulating transport from the Vehicle Assembly Building to the launch pad insofar as practicable.
— NASA, Saturn V Dynamic Test Vehicle Test Project Plan
Dynamic tests came in three configurations, one for each phase of Saturn V-powered flight. Configuration I focused on testing the entire stack, as if the vehicle had just launched. Configuration II exercised the stack as if the first stage had jettisoned and the second stage were firing, and configuration III tested just the third stage and Apollo spacecraft. Tests began with Configuration III in the Saturn IB Dynamic Test Facility, while the Saturn V Dynamic Test Stand, first, and second stages were still under construction. Configuration I testing followed in the Saturn V Dynamic Test Stand, then Configuration II in the same place.
Configuration I dynamic tests required the first stage of the Saturn V, which was loaded into the test stand January 13, 1966. Testing would have to wait for the last piece, the second stage, to arrive.
With all the components at MSFC as of November 10, 1966, the second stage was stacked atop the first inside the Dynamic Test Stand on November 23. The third stage was added to the stack November 30, and the Instrument Unit and boilerplate Apollo were installed in December. The rocket was stacked and ready for "Configuration One" testing.
Configuration One Testing ran from January through March. Testing produced "several minor irregularities indicating the need for possible engineering changes" which were addressed during March, 1967.
Configuration Two testing followed, in which the first stage was removed from the stack to simulate conditions after the first stage had jettisoned.
Dynamic testing examined "the vehicle's response to lateral, longitudinal, and torsional excitation, simulating those that would be experienced in flight. The vehicle was "mounted on a hydrodynamic support system made up of four hydraulic/pneumatic pedestals to permit a simulated unrestrained reaction." Engineers tested vibrations in one plane at a time with different amounts of ballast simulating "fuel load at critical time points in the flight trajectory." 
NASA historian Mike Wright summarizes the testing:
|“||Combined, the tests involved 450 hours of shaking to gather data from some 800 measuring points. A simulated Apollo capsule with the same weight and same center of gravity as the spacecraft being checked out for launch at Kennedy Space Center were placed on top of the rocket. Forces were applied to the tail of the rocket to simulate engine thrusting, and various other flight factors were fed to the vehicle to test reactions. During some of the shaking tests, the rocket moved as much as 6 inches at the top and up to 3 inches at the bottom. The tests were mandatory before the Center could certify that the guidance system would hold the rocket on course when it was launched.||”|
On August 3, 1967, MSFC announced the successful completion of the dynamic test program, thereby declaring dynamics and structures of the Saturn V ready for its first launch later in the year. The dynamic testing resulted in "several slight modifications" to the final flight vehicle.
After dynamic testing, the second stage returned to KSC for a time for launchpad B checkout.
After all tests were complete, the SA-500D was assembled again in Huntsville, this time for public exhibition at the Alabama Space Science Center, on land carved out of the north edge of Marshall Space Flight Center. Transport of the rocket, along with the Saturn I which would be erected vertically, to the museum, took place June 28, 1969. The rocket would be displayed lying down on the southern edge of a rocket park with its predecessor rockets, near a Saturn 1 standing erect and a moonscape complete with model Lunar Module and a flag. SA-500D was installed in 1969, and the (renamed) Alabama Space and Rocket Center opened in 1970 showcasing articles that could otherwise only be seen by NASA and Army workers at Redstone Arsenal. The first stage sat on a low-boy trailer and the others in cradles. The instrument unit was put on display inside the museum, and connector rings were given roofs and converted to educational rides for the museum.
SA-500D was added to the List of Historic Mechanical Engineering Landmarks by the American Society of Mechanical Engineers in 1980 and declared a National Historic Landmark by the National Park Service in 1987.
After decades of the vehicle resting unprotected outdoors, the U.S. Space & Rocket Center commissioned the restoration of the vehicle in 2005. Analysis by Conservation Solutions, Incorporated determined significant damage from both weather and pest infestations. Various materials comprising the vehicle, including metal alloys and non-metal materials such as polyurethane foam and fiberglass, exhibited significant deterioration. After conducting the analysis, full restoration of the Saturn V vehicle began in June 2005.
Restoration culminated in July 2007 when the Saturn V was moved into a building designed as protection for the artifact and to provide additional museum facilities. The move took place from July 10 to approximately the 17th, starting with the first stage. The Davidson Center for Space Exploration opened in January 2008.
On May 3, 2012, an unknown person shot three .308 caliber bullets from Interstate 565 at the Davidson Center, breaking three windows. Two bullets struck SA-500D's third stage marring paint and leaving dents. No people were harmed. The damage was repaired within two months.
Components on display
BP-23 launched for A-002 to test the Launch Escape System and recovery parachutes on December 8, 1964. It was refurbished, designated BP-23A, and exercised the Launch Escape System again in Launch Pad Abort Test 2, June 29, 1965.
Other Apollo and Saturn artifacts on display include the Apollo 16 Command Module, the Apollo 12 Mobile Quarantine Facility, a Lunar Lander with a test article landing stage (MSFC 76545) and a replica ascent stage, and another Instrument Unit.
- SA-500F, the Saturn V Facilities Integration Vehicle
- "National Register Information System". National Register of Historic Places. National Park Service. 2007-01-23.
- "Saturn V Launch Vehicle". National Historic Landmark summary listing. National Park Service. Retrieved October 28, 2007.
- Wright, Mike. "Three Saturn Vs on Display Teach Lessons in Space History". Marshall Space Flight Center History Office. Retrieved 10 February 2011.
- "Saturn V Dynamic Test Vehicle Test Project Plan" (PDF). NASA. April 16, 1965. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
- "Saturn V Rocket, US Space and Rocket Center". Conservation Soltutions, Inc. Retrieved 9 February 2011.
- NASA (February 1967). "Saturn V Quarterly Report #17 Dec 1966-Feb 1967 part 1 of 2". NASA. Retrieved February 12, 2011.
- NASA (1968). "Saturn V Flight Manual - SA-503" (PDF). NASA – George C. Marshall Space Flight Center. Retrieved February 22, 2011. §4.
- Roger E. Bilstein (August 1999). Stages to Saturn: A Technological History of the Apollo/Saturn Launch Vehicle. DIANE Publishing. p. 184. ISBN 978-0-7881-8186-3. Retrieved 19 February 2011.
- NASA (March 1965). "Saturn V Quarterly Report #9 December 1964 - February 1965". NASA MSFC
- "Apollo/Saturn V facilities Test Vehicle and Launch Umbilical Tower". NASA. 1966-05-25. Retrieved 2011-02-26.
An Apollo/Saturn V facilities Test Vehicle and Launch Umbilical Tower (LUT) atop a crawler-transporter move from the Vehicle Assembly Building (VAB) on the way to Pad A. This test vehicle, designated the Apollo/Saturn 500-F, is being used to verify launch facilities, train launch crews, and develop test and checkout procedures.
- "Saturn V Vehicle Configuration". NASA. 1967. Retrieved 2011-02-26.
- NASA (1968). "Saturn V Flight Manual - SA-503" (PDF). NASA – George C. Marshall Space Flight Center. Retrieved February 22, 2011. §5.
- NASA (1968). "Saturn V Flight Manual - SA-503" (PDF). NASA – George C. Marshall Space Flight Center. Retrieved February 22, 2011. §6.
- "Saturn instrument unit". IBM. Retrieved February 27, 2011.
- NASA (December 1964). "Saturn V Quarterly Report #8 September, October, November 1964". NASA MSFC
- NASA (February 1967). "Saturn V Quarterly Report #16 Sep-Nov 1966 Part 1 of 2". NASA. Retrieved February 12, 2011.
- "The Apollo Spacecraft: A Chronology. Appendix 6: Hardware Manufacture and Acceptance". NASA. Retrieved February 13, 2011.LCCN 69-60008
- NASA (December 1965). "Saturn V Quarterly Report #12 September, October, November 1965". NASA MSFC
- "CSM Contract" (PDF). NASA. Retrieved March 28, 2011.
- Richard W. Orloff; David Michael Harland (2006). Apollo: the definitive sourcebook. Springer Science & Business. ISBN 978-0-387-30043-6.
- "Apollo Program Summary Report" (PDF). NASA JSC. April 1975. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- Elchert, Ken. "50 th Anniversary Celebration 1947-1997: The Apollo Era at the Space Division: 1960 to 1975" (PDF). Boeing. Retrieved February 28, 2011.
- Wade, Mark. "LM Structural". Encyclopedia Astronautica. Retrieved March 29, 2011.
- Aikens, David. "Saturn Illustrated Chronology - Part 5: January 1964 through December 1964". NASA-Marshall Space Flight Center. Retrieved March 5, 2011.
- Aikens, David. "Saturn Illustrated Chronology - Part 6: January 1965 through December 1965". NASA-Marshall Space Flight Center. Retrieved February 13, 2011.
- Bilstein, Roger E. (2004-08-06). "Stages to Saturn". SP-4206. NASA. Retrieved March 4, 2011.
- Bilstein, Roger E. (2004-08-06). "Stages to Saturn". SP-4206. NASA. Retrieved March 4, 2011.
- "Dynamics S-IC Moved (photo caption)". Marshall Star (MSFC). January 19, 1966. p. 8. quoted in Wright, Mike. "Three Saturn Vs on Display Teach Lessons in Space History". Marshall Space Flight Center History Office. Retrieved 10 February 2011.
- Aikens, David. "Saturn Illustrated Chronology - Part 7: January 1966 through December 1966". NASA-Marshall Space Flight Center. Retrieved February 17, 2011.
- Lawrie, Alan; Pearlman, Robert (January 7, 2008). "Untold Apollo:How tennis shoes and tug-of-war toppled the mighty Saturn V". CollectSpace.com. Retrieved February 12, 2011.
- Aikens, David. "Saturn Illustrated Chronology - Part 6: January 1967 through December 1967". NASA-Marshall Space Flight Center. Retrieved February 13, 2011.
- PAO Press Release No. 67-161, August 3, 1967; Press Release No. 67-162, August 4, 1967.
- "Alabama Space Science Center". Times Daily. (Florence, Alabama) Times Daily. February 23, 1969. Retrieved February 12, 2011.
- von Braun, Wernher (2010). Buckbee, Ed, ed. The Rocket Man: Wernher von Braun: The Man Who Took America to the Moon: His Weekly Notes: 1961-1969 (DVD). Steward & Wise Music Publishing. p. NOTES 6–30–69 SIEBEL. ISBN 978-1-935001-27-0.
- Brandau, Jean. "In the Beginning: US Space & Rocket Center". About.com. Retrieved 10 February 2011.
- Buckbee, Edward O. (August 23, 1977). "National Register of Historic Places Inventory-Nomination: Saturn V Launch Vehicle" (pdf). National Park Service. and PDF (664 KB)
- "Saturn V". U.S. Space & Rocket Center. February 14, 2008. Retrieved February 13, 2011.
- ASME Landmarks Page "Landmarks". American Society of Mechanical Engineers.
- "Google news search showing old and new names". Retrieved March 6, 2011.
- "Topic: Davidson Center for Space Exploration (AL)". CollectSpace. Retrieved March 6, 2011.
- Jean Brandau (July 2007). "Saturn V: National Historic Landmark". About.com. Retrieved 8 February 2011.
- Jean Brandau (February 7, 2008). "Saturn V: National Historic Landmark". About.com. Retrieved 8 February 2011.
- Clines, Keith (May 4, 2012). "Police may have identified bullet caliber in Saturn V shooting". Huntsville Times. Retrieved May 4, 2012.
- Clines, Keith (May 3, 2012). "Shooting of Saturn V rocket in Davidson Center could be a federal offense". Huntsville Times. Retrieved May 3, 2012.
- Pearlman, Robert Z. "Gunshots Damage Historic Saturn V Moon Rocket". Space.com. Retrieved May 4, 2012.
- Lyons, Wes (June 20, 2012). "Sprocket Saturn V In Process Of Having Bullet Scratches Patched Up". sprocketeers.org. Retrieved October 18, 2012.
- "Brenice Report - T Flight Instrumentation" (PDF). NASA JSC. March 1974. Retrieved February 26, 2011.
- Jim Belfiore (2009-09-23). U.S. Space and Rocket Museum - Apollo 16 Capsule. Vimeo.
- Gerard, Jim (2007-07-09). "Lunar Module Engineering Model MSFC". A Field Guide to American Spacecraft. Retrieved March 8, 2011.
- Jetzer, Mike. "LM (MSFC 76545)". Heroic Relics. Retrieved March 8, 2011.