SS Princess Alice (1865)
Contemporary engraving of Bywell Castle bearing down on Princess Alice
|Namesake:||Isle of Bute, Scotland; HRH Princess Alice|
|Port of registry:|
|Route:||Wemyss Bay – Rothesay (1865–67), River Thames (1867–78)|
|Builder:||Caird & Company, Greenock|
|Launched:||29 March 1865|
|Out of service:||3 September 1878|
|Fate:||wrecked in collision|
|Length:||219.4 ft (66.9 m)|
|Beam:||20.2 ft (6.2 m)|
|Draught:||8.4 ft (2.6 m)|
|Installed power:||140 NHP 2 cylinder oscillating steam engine|
SS Princess Alice , formerly PS Bute, was a passenger paddle steamer. She was sunk in a collision on the River Thames with the collier Bywell Castle off Tripcock Point in 1878 with the loss of over 650 lives, the greatest loss of life in any Thames shipping disaster.
Caird & Company of Greenock launched Bute in 1865 for the Wemyss Bay Railway Company, for whom she plied between Wemyss Bay and Rothesay. She was sold in 1867 to the Waterman's Steam Packet Co. on the River Thames, who renamed her Princess Alice. She was sold again in 1870 to the Woolwich Steam Packet Co. and in 1875 to the London Steamboat Company, who operated her as an excursion steamer.
This section needs additional citations for verification. (September 2012) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
On 3 September 1878, she was making what was billed as a "Moonlight Trip" to Gravesend and back. This was a routine trip from Swan Pier near London Bridge to Gravesend and Sheerness. Tickets were sold for two shillings. Hundreds of Londoners paid the fare; many were visiting Rosherville Gardens in Gravesend.
By 7:40 PM, the Princess Alice was on her return journey and within sight of the North Woolwich Pier—where many passengers were to disembark—when she sighted the Newcastle bound vessel SS Bywell Castle. Bywell Castle displaced 890 long tons (904 t), much more than the Princess Alice. She usually carried coal to Africa: at the time, she had just been repainted at a dry dock and was on her way to pick up a load of coal. Her Master was Captain Harrison, who was accompanied by an experienced Thames river pilot. The collier was coming down the river with the tide at half speed.
On the bridge of the Bywell Castle, Harrison observed the port light of the Princess Alice; he set a course to pass to starboard of her. However, the Master of Princess Alice, 47-year-old Captain William R.H. Grinsted, labouring up the river against the tide, followed the normal watermen's practice of seeking the slack water on the south side and altered Princess Alice's course to port, bringing her into the path of Bywell Castle. Captain Harrison ordered his ship's engines reversed, but it was too late. Princess Alice was struck on the starboard side; she split in two and sank within four minutes.
Many passengers were trapped within the wreck and drowned: piles of bodies were found around the exits of the saloon when the wreck was raised. Additionally, the twice-daily release of 75 million imperial gallons (340,000 m3) of raw sewage from sewer outfalls at Barking and Crossness had occurred one hour before the collision; the heavily polluted water was believed to contribute to the deaths of those who went into the river. It was noted that the sunken corpses began rising to the surface after only six days, rather than the usual nine. Between 69 and 170 people were rescued while over 650 died. 120 victims were buried in a mass grave at Woolwich Old Cemetery, Kings Highway, Plumstead. A memorial cross was erected to mark the spot, "paid for by national sixpenny subscription to which more than 23,000 persons contributed".
The log of the Bywell Castle described the incident:
The master and pilot were on the upper bridge, and the lookout on the top-gallant forecastle; light airs prevailed; the weather was a little hazy; at 7:45 o'clock P. M. proceeded at half speed down Gallion's Reach; when about at the centre of the reach observed an excursion steamer coming up Barking Reach, showing her red and masthead lights, when we ported our helm to keep out toward Tripcock Point; as the vessels neared, observed that the other steamer had ported her helm. Immediately afterward saw that she had starboarded her helm and was trying to cross our bows, showing her green light close under our port bow. Seeing that a collision was inevitable, we stopped our engines and reversed them at full speed. The two vessels came in collision, the bow of the Bywell Castle cutting into the other steamer with a dreadful crash. We took immediate measures for saving life by hauling up over our bows several passengers, throwing overboard ropes' ends, life-buoys, a hold-ladder, and several planks, and getting out three boats, at the same time keeping the whistle blowing loudly for assistance, which was rendered by several boats from shore, and a boat from another steamer. The excursion steamer, which turned out to be the Princess Alice, turned over and sank under our bows. We succeeded in rescuing a great many passengers, and anchored for the night.
The subsequent Board of Trade enquiry blamed Captain Grinsted (who died in the disaster), finding that "the Princess Alice was not properly and efficiently manned; also, that the numbers of persons aboard were more than was prudent and that the means of saving life on board the paddle steamer was inadequate for a vessel of her class". The jury of the Coroner's Inquest, held at the same time on the opposite bank of the river, said "that the Bywell Castle did not take the necessary precaution of easing, stopping and reversing her engines in time and that the Princess Alice contributed to the collision by not stopping and going astern, that all collisions in the opinion of the jury might in future be avoided if proper and stringent rules and regulation were laid down for all steam navigation on the River Thames". But the jury agreed that the number of persons aboard the Princess Alice was more than was prudent and that the means of lifesaving were inadequate.
Locals had a different point of view to the enquiry: "Many Thames watermen considered that, as all experienced Thames pilots were well aware that 'working the slack' on the south side of the river was a common and accepted practice of the day, the pilot of Bywell Castle should have realised the situation and acted accordingly, but no watermen were called to give evidence at the inquest or subsequent enquiry". The Thames Conservancy had published by-laws in 1872 which mandated the 'port to port' rule and there was no provision for exceptions.
The press also railed against the captain of the collier, with endless speculation and the Illustrated London News publishing a full-spread picture showing the Princess Alice facing in the opposite direction, being 'run down'. Despite the verdict exonerating him, Captain Harrison's health broke down and he was never able to go to sea afterwards.
At this time there was no official body responsible for marine safety in the Thames. The subsequent inquiry resolved that the Marine Police Force, based at Wapping, be equipped with steam launches, to replace their rowing boats and make them better able to perform rescues. A new plan for dumping sewage far out at sea via boat, rather than simply releasing it downriver, was also formulated, but not implemented.
Six ensigns of the 30th Regiment of Foot, including Charles O'Brien, later a prominent colonial administrator, missed the Princess Alice (and likely death) by a matter of seconds. Elizabeth Stride, one of the victims of Jack the Ripper, claimed to have survived the disaster, though her husband and children were killed: in fact her husband died of tuberculosis, and they were childless.
The Princess Alice accident also produced a change to the Burial of Drowned Persons Act to include all navigable waters. Payments were not made for the recovery of corpses and bodies were allowed to float up and down rivers.
- Cameron, Stuart; Asprey, David. "PS Bute". Clydebuilt Database. Retrieved 20 June 2011.
- White, Jerry (2007). London in the 19th Century. Vintage. p. 264.
- Dix, Frank L. (1985). Royal River Highway. David & Charles, Newton Abbot. p. 96.
- "Log of the Steamer Bywell Castle". New York Times (6 September 1878). Retrieved 7 June 2012.
- Thames Police. "Thames Police: History - Princess Alice Disaster 'Inquest findings'". Retrieved 21 Apr 2012.
- Dix 1985, p. 97
- Thames Police
- "official history". Metropolitan Police. Archived from the original on 16 July 2007. Retrieved 26 Jan 2007.
- "Obituary of Sir Charles O'Brien". The Times (2 December 1935).
- "DROWNED PERSONS (DISCOVERY AND INTERMENT) BILL. SECOND READING". HANSARD 1803–2005. 24 March 1886 – via UK Parliament.
- "The Collision On The Thames". Times [London, England]. 1 October 1878. p. 7 – via The Times Digital Archive.
- Thames Police Museum record
- The Princess Alice Disaster from The Records of the Woolwich District by W. T. Vincent
- the Stride discussion thread of 13 August 2004
- Lacey, R. (2007), Great Tales from English History. ISBN 978-0-349-11731-7.
- Whymper, Frederick. (1880), The Sea : its stirring story of adventure, peril & heroism, (4 vols), iv, 282.