The Sabatier reaction or Sabatier process produces methane and water from a reaction of hydrogen with carbon dioxide at elevated temperatures (optimally 300–400 °C) and pressures (perhaps 30 bar ) in the presence of a nickel catalyst. It was discovered by the French chemists Paul Sabatier and Jean-Baptiste Senderens in 1897. Optionally, ruthenium on alumina (aluminium oxide) makes a more efficient catalyst. It is described by the following exothermic reaction.
- ∆H = −165.0 kJ/mol
There is disagreement on whether the CO2 methanation occurs by first associatively adsorbing an adatom hydrogen and forming oxygen intermediates before hydrogenation or dissociating and forming a carbonyl before being hydrogenated.
- ∆H = −206 kJ/mol
CO methanation is believed to occur through a dissociative mechanism where the carbon oxygen bond is broken before hydrogenation with an associative mechanism only being observed at high H2 concentrations.
Methanation reaction over different carried metal catalysts including Ni, Ru and Rh has been widely investigated for the production of CH4 from syngas and other power to gas initiatives. Nickel is the most widely used catalyst due to its high selectivity and low cost.
Creation of synthetic natural gas
Methanation is an important step in the creation of synthetic or substitute natural gas (SNG). Coal or wood undergo gasification which creates a producer gas that must undergo methaneation in order to produce a usable gas that just needs to undergo a final purification step.
The first commercial synthetic gas plant opened in 1984 and is the Great Plains Synfuel plant in Beulah, North Dakota. It is still operational and produces 1500 MW worth of SNG using coal as the carbon source. In the years since its opening, other commercial facilities have been opened using other carbon sources such as wood chips.
In France, the AFUL Chantrerie, located in Nantes, started in November 2017 the demonstrator MINERVE. This methanation unit of 14 Nm3 / day was carried out by Top Industrie, with the support of Leaf. This installation is used to feed a CNG station and to inject methane into the natural gas boiler.
It has been seen in a renewable-energy-dominated energy system to use the excess electricity generated by wind, solar photovoltaic, hydro, marine current, etc. to make hydrogen via water electrolysis and the subsequent application of the Sabatier reaction to make methane In contrast to a direct usage of hydrogen for transport or energy storage applications, the methane can be injected into the existing gas network, which in many countries has one to two years of storage capacity. The methane can then be used on demand to generate electricity (and heat—combined heat and power) overcoming low points of renewable energy production. The process is electrolysis of water by electricity to create hydrogen (which can partly be used directly in fuel cells) and the addition of carbon dioxide CO2 (Sabatier process) to create methane. The CO2 can be extracted from the air or fossil fuel waste gases by the amine process, amongst many others. It is a low-CO2 system, and has similar efficiencies of today's energy system.
In ammonia production CO and CO2 are considered poisons to most commonly used catalysts. Methanation catalysts are added after several hydrogen producing steps to prevent carbon oxide buildup in the ammonia synthesis loop as methane does not have similar adverse effects on ammonia synthesis rates.
International Space Station life support
Oxygen generators on board the International Space Station produce oxygen from water using electrolysis; the hydrogen produced was previously discarded into space. As astronauts consume oxygen, carbon dioxide is produced, which must then be removed from the air and discarded as well. This approach required copious amounts of water to be regularly transported to the space station for oxygen generation in addition to that used for human consumption, hygiene, and other uses—a luxury that will not be available to future long-duration missions beyond low Earth orbit.
NASA is using the Sabatier reaction to recover water from exhaled carbon dioxide and the hydrogen previously discarded from electrolysis on the International Space Station and possibly for future missions. The other resulting chemical, methane, is released into space. As half of the input hydrogen becomes wasted as methane, additional hydrogen is supplied from Earth to make up the difference. However, this creates a nearly-closed cycle between water, oxygen, and carbon dioxide which only requires a relatively modest amount of imported hydrogen to maintain.
Ignoring other results of respiration, this cycle looks like:
The released hydrogen would then be recycled back into the Sabatier reactor, leaving an easily removed deposit of pyrolytic graphite. The reactor would be little more than a steel pipe, and could be periodically serviced by an astronaut where the deposit is chiselled out.
The Bosch reaction would present a completely closed hydrogen and oxygen cycle which only produces atomic carbon as waste. However, difficulties maintaining its temperature of up to 600 °C and properly handling carbon deposits mean significantly more research will be required before a Bosch reactor could become a reality. One problem is that the production of elemental carbon tends to foul the catalyst's surface (coking), which is detrimental to the reaction's efficiency.
Manufacturing propellant on Mars
The Sabatier reaction has been proposed as a key step in reducing the cost of human mission to Mars (Mars Direct, SpaceX Starship) through in-situ resource utilization. Hydrogen is combined with CO2 from the atmosphere, with methane then stored as fuel and the water side product electrolyzed yielding oxygen to be liquefied and stored as oxidizer and hydrogen to be recycled back into the reactor. The original hydrogen could be transported from Earth or separated from Martian sources of water.
Importing a small amount of hydrogen avoids searching for water and just uses CO2 from the atmosphere.
"A variation of the basic Sabatier methanation reaction may be used via a mixed catalyst bed and a reverse water gas shift in a single reactor to produce methane from the raw materials available on Mars, utilising carbon dioxide in the Martian atmosphere. A 2011 prototype test operation that harvested CO2 from a simulated Martian atmosphere and reacted it with H2, produced methane rocket propellant at a rate of 1 kg/day, operating autonomously for 5 consecutive days, maintaining a nearly 100% conversion rate. An optimised system of this design massing 50 kg "is projected to produce 1 kg/day of O2:CH4 propellant ... with a methane purity of 98+% while consuming ~17 kWh per day of electrical power (at a continuous power of 700 W). Overall unit conversion rate expected from the optimised system is one tonne of propellant per 17 MWh energy input."
Stoichiometry issue with importing hydrogen
The stoichiometric ratio of oxidiser and fuel is 2:1, for an oxygen:methane engine:
However, one pass through the Sabatier reactor produces a ratio of only 1:1. More oxygen may be produced by running the water-gas shift reaction (WGSR) in reverse (RWGS), effectively extracting oxygen from the atmosphere by reducing carbon dioxide to carbon monoxide.
Another option is to make more methane than needed and pyrolyze the excess of it into carbon and hydrogen (see above section), where the hydrogen is recycled back into the reactor to produce further methane and water. In an automated system, the carbon deposit may be removed by blasting with hot Martian CO2, oxidizing the carbon into carbon monoxide (via the Boudouard reaction), which is vented.
This reaction is slightly exothermic, and when the water is electrolyzed, an oxygen to methane ratio of 2:1 is obtained.
Regardless of which method of oxygen fixation is utilized, the overall process can be summarized by the following equation:
Looking at molecular masses, we have produced 16 grams of methane and 64 grams of oxygen using 4 grams of hydrogen (which would have to be imported from Earth, unless Martian water was electrolysed), for a mass gain of 20:1; and the methane and oxygen are in the right stoichiometric ratio to be burned in a rocket engine. This kind of in-situ resource utilization would result in massive weight and cost savings to any proposed manned Mars or sample-return missions.
- In situ resource utilization – Astronautical use of materials harvested in outer space
- Microlith (catalytic reactor)
- Timeline of hydrogen technologies
- Steam reforming
- Methane pyrolysis (for Hydrogen)
- Fischer–Tropsch process – Chemical reactions that convert carbon monoxide and hydrogen into liquid hydrocarbons
- Electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide
- "Methanation process". HELMETH Project. Retrieved 2020-11-13.
- Rönsch, Stefan; Schneider, Jens; Matthischke, Steffi; Schlüter, Michael; Götz, Manuel; Lefebvre, Jonathan; Prabhakaran, Praseeth; Bajohr, Siegfried (2016-02-15). "Review on methanation – From fundamentals to current projects". Fuel. 166: 276–296. doi:10.1016/j.fuel.2015.10.111.
- Miao, Bin; Ma, Su Su Khine; Wang, Xin; Su, Haibin; Chan, Siew Hwa (2016-06-13). "Catalysis mechanisms of CO2 and CO methanation". Catalysis Science & Technology. 6 (12): 4048. doi:10.1039/C6CY00478D. ISSN 2044-4761.
- K.O. Xavier, «Doping effects of cerium oxide on Ni/Al2O3 catalysts for methanation», Catalysis Today, 1999, p. 17-21
- Toshimasa Utaka, «CO removal from reformed fuels over Cu and precious metal catalysts», Applied Catalysis A: General, 2003, p. 117-124 ([10.1016/S0926-860X(03)00048-6 lire en ligne])
- Paraskevi Panagiotopoulou, « Selective methanation of CO over supported noble metal catalysts: Effects of the nature of the metallic phase on catalytic performance», Applied Catalysis A: General, 2008, p. 45-54 ([10.1016/j.apcata.2008.03.039 lire en ligne])
- Kopyscinski, Jan; Schildhauer, Tilman J.; Biollaz, Serge M. A. (2010-08-01). "Production of synthetic natural gas (SNG) from coal and dry biomass – A technology review from 1950 to 2009". Fuel. 89 (8): 1763–1783. doi:10.1016/j.fuel.2010.01.027.
- "Un démonstrateur Power to gas en service à Nantes". Lemoniteur.fr (in French). 2018. Retrieved 9 February 2018..
- Bioenergy and renewable power methane in integrated 100% renewable energy system, ,
- scénario négaWatt 2011 (France), ,
- Eberle, Ulrich; Mueller, Bernd; von Helmolt, Rittmar. "Fuel cell electric vehicles and hydrogen infrastructure: status 2012". Energy & Environmental Science. Retrieved 2014-12-16.
- "Underground Natural Gas Working Storage Capacity - U.S. Energy Information Administration".
- Khorsand, Kayvan (2007). "Modeling and simulation of methanation catalytic reactor in ammonia unit". Petroleum & Coal. 49: 46–53.
- Harding, Pete (October 9, 2010). "Soyuz TMA-01M docks with ISS as crews conduct hardware installation". NASASpaceFlight.com.
- Methane generator on-board the ISS
- "METHANE PYROLYSIS AND DISPOSING OFF RESULTING CARBON" (PDF).
Hydrogen may be obtained from methane by pyrolysis in the temperature range 1000°-1200°C. The main reaction products are hydrogen and carbon, though very small amounts of higher hydrocarbons, including aromatic hydrocarbons are formed. The conversion efficiency is about 95% at 1200°C. One needs to distinguish between thermodynamic equilibrium conversion and conversion limited by kinetics in a finite reactor
- "Third Generation Advanced PPA Development". International Conference on Environmental Systems 2014.
- "Regenerative Life Support: Water Production". settlement.arc.nasa.gov. Archived from the original on 2010-06-13. Retrieved 2015-05-16.
- Bryner, Jeanna (15 March 2007). "Giant Pool of Water Ice at Mars' South Pole". Space.com.
- Extraction of Atmospheric Water on Mars
- Zubrin, Robert M.; Muscatello, Berggren (2012-12-15). "Integrated Mars In Situ Propellant Production System". Journal of Aerospace Engineering. 26: 43–56. doi:10.1061/(asce)as.1943-5525.0000201. ISSN 1943-5525.
- Speight, James G. (March 1, 2019). "Chapter 13 - Upgrading by Gasification". Heavy Oil Recovery and Upgrading. doi:10.1016/B978-0-12-813025-4.00013-1. ISBN 978-0-12-813025-4.
- Compact and Lightweight Sabatier Reactor for Carbon Dioxide Reduction