Samuel Montagu, 1st Baron Swaythling
Samuel Montagu, 1st Baron Swaythling (21 December 1832 – 12 January 1911) was a British banker who founded the bank of Samuel Montagu & Co. He was a philanthropist and Liberal politician who sat in the House of Commons from 1885 to 1900, and was later raised to the peerage. Montagu was a pious Orthodox Jew, and devoted himself to social services and advancing Jewish institutions.
Montagu was born in Liverpool as Montagu Samuel, the second son of Louis Samuel, a watchmaker of Liverpool, and his wife, Henrietta Israel, daughter of Israel Israel of Bury Street, St. Mary Axe, London. He was educated at the High School of Liverpool Mechanics' Institute as Samuel Montagu. In 1853 he founded the bank of Samuel Montagu as a foreign banker.
Montagu's commitment to Jewish causes included both initiatives aimed at improving the lot of Jews in England, and his participation in the proto-Zionist "Lovers of Zion" movement. He was involved in founding new synagogues, and in establishing the Federation of Synagogues in 1887, which was an umbrella body for the small Orthodox congregations in the East End of London. By 1911, the Federation represented 51 London congregations (6,000 male members), which made it the largest synagogal body in UK (larger, by around 1,000 male seat-holders, than the United Synagogue). This rapid growth brought Montagu into conflict with Nathan Rothschild, 1st Baron Rothschild and the United Synagogue. Montagu's funding helped the Federation secure the services of distinguished rabbinical scholars such as Dr Mayer Lerner of Wurzheim in 1890 and the Maggid of Kamenitsk Chaim Zundel Maccoby.
Geoffrey Alderman has argued that the Federation represented the ‘largest single instrument of Anglicization, as well as social control, that Anglo-Jewry possessed’, with Montagu arguing in 1889 that ‘one of the principal objects of the Federation was to endeavour to raise the social condition of the Jews in East London and to prevent anything like anarchy and socialism…The blessings of the Patriarchs that they would increase their cattle and amass wealth, and the prophecy would never cease out of the land, were in themselves evidence that Judaism did not recognise anything like social equality amongst all classes of people’.
He was elected at the 1885 general election Liberal Member of Parliament (MP) for Whitechapel, and held the seat until he stood down at the 1900 general election. His campaign in 1885 was run against his brother-in-law, Lionel Louis Cohen, who was controversially running as a Conservative. As a Yiddish-speaker, Montagu was able to appeal to the many immigrants within his constituency on religious grounds, arguing in 1886 that he hoped "not a single Jew would vote Conservative". From 1887 to 1890, he was a member of the Gold and Silver Commission. He was created a Baronet, of South Stoneham House in the County of Southampton and of Kensington Palace Gardens in the County of London, on 23 June 1894.
In September 1888, after the murder of Annie Chapman at the hands of an unknown man later called Jack the Ripper, he tried to offer a reward of £100 for the discovery and conviction of the criminal. The Home Office did not accept the offer because that practice had been discontinued. Montagu offered it because the Whitechapel murders created some anti-semitic incidents in the East End population.
In 1893, Montagu presented on behalf of the "Lovers of Zion" in England a petition in favour of Jewish colonisation in Palestine to the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, with the request that he forward it to the Turkish Sultan. The petition did not lead to any concrete result, but it showed that what was to become political Zionism had already taken roots in the minds of both the Christian researchers of Palestine, and the Jewish activists in search for solutions to the so-called "Jewish question".
Land owned by Montagu in Jeremys Green Lane, Edmonton—now known as Montagu Road—was presented to the Federation of Synagogues as a burial strip. At that time he was aware of the overcrowding in his constituency, and was especially keen to see Jewish families move out to the suburbs. In 1898, therefore, he proposed that land south of Salmons Brook, Edmonton—some 25 acres (100,000 m2) in all—be used for 700 houses, to house between 3000 and 4000 people. The houses were to have low rents and to include small gardens, with preference given to those currently living in Whitechapel. The project was first offered to the LCC, and then Edmonton UDC; both prevaricated. In 1899 the proposals were rejected and Montagu subsequently gave £10,000 (equivalent to £1033,000 in 2017) towards LCC housing on the White Hart Lane estate, Tottenham.
Montagu died in January 1911, aged 78.
Montagu married Ellen Cohen, daughter of Louis Cohen, in 1862.
His second son Edwin Samuel Montagu followed his father into politics, becoming Secretary of State for India. In 1915 Edwin Montagu married Venetia Stanley (1887-1948), who in accordance with the will of the 1st Baron Swaythling converted to Judaism upon her marriage.
Styles of address
- 1832–1885: Mr Samuel Montagu
- 1885–1894: Mr Samuel Montagu MP
- 1894–1900: Sir Samuel Montagu Bt MP
- 1900–1907: Sir Samuel Montagu Bt
- 1907–1911: The Right Honourable The Lord Swaythling[a]
- Although The Lord Swaythling was a baronet, by custom the post-nominal of "Bt" is omitted, as Peers of the Realm do not list subsidiary hereditary titles.
Located in Kidbrooke, South London, the Samuel Montagu Youth Centre provides recreational opportunities for young people. Montagu is remembered in Edmonton at Montagu Road, Montagu Gardens, Montagu Crescent, Montagu Road School (demolished) and Swaythling Close.
- Debretts Guide to the House of Commons 1886
- Alderman, Geoffrey. Modern British Jewry. Oxford: Clarendon, 1992, p. 154.
- Alderman, Geoffrey. Modern British Jewry. Oxford: Clarendon, 1992, p. 162.
- Alderman, Geoffrey. Modern British Jewry. Oxford: Clarendon, 1992, p. 166.
- Craig, F. W. S. (1989) . British parliamentary election results 1885–1918 (2nd ed.). Chichester: Parliamentary Research Services. p. 57. ISBN 0-900178-27-2.
- Alderman, Geoffrey. Modern British Jewry. Oxford: Clarendon, 1992, p. 158.
- "No. 26526". The London Gazette. 26 June 1894. p. 1894.
- Philip Sudgen (3 January 2014). Complete History of Jack the Ripper. Constable & Robinson Limited. pp. 121–123. ISBN 978-1-78033-709-8.
- Nahum Sokolow (1919). History of Zionism: 1600-1918. 1. London: Longmans, Green & Co.; republished by Forgotten Books, London 2013. p. 231.
In brief, all these English Christian authorities put forward in the most definite and clearest terms what we know as political Zionism. These testimonies of English authorities concerning Palestine encouraged the "Lovers of Zion" in England to carry on their philanthropic work, and also to take certain political steps. A great and far-reaching step was taken by them in 1893, when a petition to Abdul Hamid, Sultan of Turkey (1876-1909), was presented by Mr. Samuel Montagu, M.P. (afterwards Lord Swaythling) (1832-1911), to the Earl of Rosebery, with a request to transmit it to Constantinople (Appendix Ixxiv). The petition was signed by the officers of the Executive Committee and the secretaries of each Tent of the "Lovers of Zion." It had no effect, because negotiations with the Turkish Government are generally very tardy, and the circumstances of the time were not favourable. There were obstacles, difficulties, uncertain political influences, currents and counter-currents which could not be got rid of immediately. But at any rate the English "Lovers of Zion" endeavoured to do precisely what the Zionists did at a later period.
- Federation of Synagogues Retrieved 12 January 2013
- History of Tower Gardens Retrieved 12 January 2013
- Godfrey A. (notes to) Old Ordnance Survey Maps: London Sheet 4, Edmonton (SE) 1894 Alan Godfrey Maps, ISBN 0-85054-969-8 Retrieved 12 March 2008
- William Page (editor). "Parishes: South Stoneham". A History of the County of Hampshire: Volume 3. Retrieved 2 November 2009.
- "No. 28043". The London Gazette. 23 July 1907. p. 5029.
- The Times, Hon. Lilian Montagu Social Improvement And Religion, 24 January 1963; pg 15 col B
- Sybil Oldfield, ‘Franklin , Henrietta [Netta] (1866–1964)’, Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004; online edn, May 2015 accessed 22 Nov 2017
- The Independent. Obituary 30 Jan 1995. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/people/obituarieswalter-darcy-hart-1570446.html
- Samuel Montagu Youth Centre Retrieved 12 January 2013
- Works written by or about Samuel Montagu, 1st Baron Swaythling at Wikisource
- Hansard 1803–2005: contributions in Parliament by Samuel Montagu
|Parliament of the United Kingdom|
before: Tower Hamlets
|Member of Parliament for Whitechapel
1885 – 1900
Sir Stuart Samuel
|Peerage of the United Kingdom|
|New title||Baron Swaythling