A card held to the edge of a spinning toothed wheel will produce a tone whose pitch varies with the speed of the wheel. A mechanism of this sort, made using brass wheels, allowed Hooke to produce sound waves of a known frequency, and to demonstrate to the Royal Society in 1681 how pitch relates to frequency. For practical purposes Hooke's device was soon supplanted by the invention of the tuning fork.
About a century and a half after Hooke's work, the mechanism was taken up again by Savart for his investigations into the range of human hearing. In the 1830s Savart was able to construct large, finely-toothed brass wheels producing frequencies of up to 24 kHz that seem to have been the world's first artificial ultrasonic generators. In the later 19th century, Savart's wheels were also used in physiological and psychological investigations of time perception.
Nowadays, Savart wheels are commonly demonstrated in physics lectures, sometimes driven and sounded by an air hose (in place of the card mechanism). The principle has also been used by Bart Hopkin to create an experimental musical instrument which is claimed to produce "the most obtrusive, obnoxious and irritating sound ever known."
|Demonstration of Savart wheels with different numbers of teeth|
The basic device consists of a ratchet-wheel with a large number of uniformly spaced teeth. When the wheel is turned slowly while the edge of a card is held against the teeth a succession of distinct clicks can be heard. When the wheel is spun rapidly it produces a shrill tone, whereas if the wheel is allowed to turn more slowly the tone progressively decreases in pitch. Since the frequency of the tone is directly proportional to the rate at which the teeth strike the card, a Savart wheel can be calibrated to provide an absolute measure of pitch. Multiple wheels of different sizes, carrying different numbers of teeth, can also be attached so as to allow several pitches (or chords) to be produced while the axle is being turned at a constant rate.
Hooke began work on his wheel in March 1676, in conjunction with the renowned clockmaker Thomas Tompion, following conversations with the music theorist William Holder. He had a longstanding interest in musical vibrations, and a decade earlier in 1666 had even boasted to Samuel Pepys that he could tell the rate a fly's wings were beating from the sound they made.[n 1] In July 1681, he demonstrated to the Royal Society his new device for producing distinct musical tones by striking the teeth of fast-turning brass wheels. In this way, he was able to generate for the first time sound waves of known frequency, and provide an empirical demonstration of the correspondence between the human perception of pitch and the physical property of sound-wave frequency. Furthermore, by fitting different wheels alongside one another on the same axis, he was able to verify frequency ratios for musical intervals, such as perfect fifths and fourths, etc.[n 2]
Hooke's device was not used again for study purposes for over a century. Its next documented usage was in 1830 when Savart reported his use of a system similar to Hooke's which he developed while investigating the lower range of human hearing. Savart's specific contribution was to attach a tachometer to the axis of the toothed wheel to facilitate calibration of the tooth rate. Savart used his wheel as a practical alternative to John Robison's siren, which was also being adopted at the time by Charles Cagniard de la Tour to test the range of human hearing. By 1834 Savart was constructing brass wheels with a width of 82 cm, containing as many as 720 teeth. These wheels, which could produce frequencies up to 24 kHz, have been tentatively proposed as the first artificial generators of ultrasound.
Use in time perception experiments
In the later 19th century, Savart's wheel was adapted for use in physiological and psychological investigations of the human perception of time. In 1873, the Austrian physiologist Sigmund Exner reported the auditory ability to distinguish successive clicks from the wheel (or, alternatively, rapidly snapped electric sparks) at time intervals as close as 2 milliseconds (1/500 sec). A modified wheel that produced varying numbers of clicks at different intervals was later used by the American psychologists G. Stanley Hall and Joseph Jastrow, who in 1886 reported on the limits to the human perception of acoustic discontinuities. In 1894, French electrical engineer Gustave Trouvé adapted an upright piano to play a series of 88 variously-sized Savart wheels equipping it with an electrical drive system.
Nowadays, Savart wheels are commonly used for demonstrations during physics lectures. In one variant, the wheel can be driven by an air hose blowing on the teeth; in this case, the pitch of the sound produced will vary with the force of the air current.
The concept has also been adapted to produce an experimental musical instrument created by Bart Hopkin. This application of Savart's wheel consists of a series of 30 wooden disks of increasing size mounted on a motorized axle. Rasping vibrations are induced in a plectrum when it comes into contact with the ridges that line each disk at regular intervals, and are amplified in a styrofoam cup which acts as a sounding board. The instrument is claimed to make "the most obtrusive, obnoxious and irritating sound ever known."
Notes and references
- According to Pepys, Hooke claimed to be "able to tell how many strokes a fly makes with her wings (those flies that hum in their flying) by the note that it answers to in musique, during their flying."
- In Hooke's own words, he was able to provide demonstrations "by the striking of the teeth of several Brass Wheels, proportionally cut as to their numbers, and turned very fast round, in which it was observable that the equal or proportional stroaks of the Teeth, that is 2 to 1, 4 to 3, etc., made the musical [intervals]."
- "Wave-Action in Nature". The Popular Science Monthly. Volume III: 7–8. May 1873.
- Berg, Richard E. (27 September 2013). "Acoustics - Early experimentation". Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Retrieved 20 February 2014.
- "Experimentos de sonido". Taller de Fisica L1 (in Spanish). Retrieved 28 February 2014.
- Avery, Elroy McKendree (2012) [originally published 1895]. School Physics. HardPress. ISBN 978-1-290-41178-3.
- "Savart's Wheel". Kenyon College. Retrieved 28 February 2014.
- Inwood, Stephen (2011). The Man Who Knew Too Much: The Strange and Inventive Life of Robert Hooke 1653 - 1703. London: Pan Macmillan. p. 320. ISBN 978-0-330-53218-1.
- "The English Precursors of Newton: II". The Popular Science Monthly. Volume 17: 786. October 1880.
- Dostrovsky, Sigalia; Campbell, Murray. "Physics of music - 1. To Mersenne". Grove Music Online. Oxford Music Online. Retrieved 20 February 2014. (subscription required)
- Green, Burdette; Butler, David (2002). "From acoustics to Tonpsychologie". In Thomas Christensen. The Cambridge History of Western Music Theory. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. p. 249. ISBN 978-0-521-62371-1.
- Ampel, Frederick J; Uzzle, Ted (March 1993). The History of Audio and Sound Measurement (PDF). Audio Engineering Society: AES Convention Papers Forum.
- Carterette, Edward (1978). "Some Historical Notes on Research in Hearing". In Edward Carterette. Hearing. Handbook of Perception. Volume IV. New York: Elsevier. p. 28. ISBN 978-0-323-14275-5.
- Graff, Karl F (2012) [originally published 1981]. "A History of Ultrasonics". In Warren P. Mason. Principles and Methods. Physical Acoustics. Volume XV. New York: Elsevier. pp. 4–5. ISBN 978-0-323-15251-8.
- Dostrovsky, Sigalia (2008). "Savart, Félix". Complete Dictionary of Scientific Biography. Encyclopedia.com. Retrieved 23 February 2014.
- Jackson, Myles W (2012). "From Scientific Instruments to Musical Instruments: The Tuning Fork, the Metronome, and the Siren". In Trevor Pinch and Karin Bijsterveld. The Oxford Handbook of Sound Studies. Oxford: Oxford University Press. p. 206. ISBN 978-0-19-538894-7.
- Roeckelein, Jon E. (2000). The Concept of Time in Psychology: A Resource Book and Annotated Bibliography. Westport, CT: Greenwood Publishing Group. p. 65. ISBN 978-0-313-31100-0.
- "Savart's wheel: Toothed wheel and cardboard or air jet". U.C. Berkeley Physics Lecture Demonstrations. University of California, Berkeley. Retrieved 21 February 2014.
- "Savart’s Wheel". Point Reyes Station CA: Experimental Musical Instruments. 12 October 2009. Retrieved 21 February 2014.