|Directed by||Natalie Newell|
|Produced by||Natalie Newell|
Science Moms is a 2017 American documentary film about mothers who advocate for science-based decision-making concerning the health and nutrition of children. The film covers vaccines, autism, celebrity-endorsed health fads, cancer, allergies, organic food, GMOs, homeopathy, and the appeal to nature fallacy.
Inception and production
In 2015, a group of bloggers[a] wrote an open letter to several celebrity mothers, including Sarah Michelle Gellar and Gwyneth Paltrow, criticizing their anti-GMO stance, and explaining the safety and benefits of GMOs. The letter, in part, read:
Please, don't co-opt motherhood and wield your fame to oppose beneficial technologies like genetic engineering. Certain celebrities have misled thousands of parents into thinking that vaccines are harmful, and we see the same pattern of misinformation repeating itself here. When GMOs are stigmatized, farmers and consumers aren't able to benefit from much-needed advancements like plants with increased nutrients, or plants that can adapt to changing environmental stresses.
This letter caught the attention of Natalie Newell, who said "I was so impressed to see this group of intelligent, relatable and reasonable moms standing up for science and against the fear-based culture that seems to have infected the world of parenting." Newell contacted one of the letter's writers, Jenny Splitter, about possibly making a short documentary about science-based parenting. Following discussion with Splitter and others, Newell went on to produce the film, along with executive producer Stephen Hupp, a professor of psychology at Southern Illinois University Edwardsville. Newell also served as the director on the documentary.
Featured in the film are writer Jenny Splitter, neuroscientist Alison Bernstein, plant geneticist Anastasia Bodnar, molecular geneticist Layla Katiraee, and science communicator Kavin Senapathy. As reported by the Center for Inquiry: "Through interviews with five... moms with careers in science, we get both an idea of what the modern parent has to contend with, as well as some clarity on some of the more hot-button issues around food and health."
According to one of the science moms featured in the film, Kavin Senapathy, the film's goal is to provide a counterpoint to wide-spread anti-science misinformation affecting parenting, including anti-GMO and anti-vaccine propaganda. In an interview with Susan Gerbic for the Center for Inquiry, Senapathy said that for many moms parenthood becomes a large part of their identity. When that happens, "it is easy for purveyors of misinformation to exploit [them]."
According to Katiraee, another science mom in the film, “Celebrities are beautiful, with aspirational lifestyles... but we shouldn’t take their parenting advice without scrutiny. Giving birth doesn’t mean our ‘mommy instinct’ is correct. That requires evidence.”
Producer/director Newell has said, "The goal of the movie is to provide a counter-narrative to the anti-GMO, anti-vax, pro-alternative medicine culture that has popped up in the world of parenting." She also said that critical thinking is very important, and she hopes Science Moms could act as a springboard to that end.
In her book, Whitewash: The Story of a Weed Killer, Cancer, and the Corruption of Science, Carey Gillam accused the Science Moms team of having ties to Monsanto, alleging that they "post favorable industry information on an array of websites while appearing to be independent of industry influence.":34:00 In a December 10, 2017 interview on the Serious Inquires Only podcast, Natalie Newell speculated as to where Gillam got the idea that the creation of Science Moms was influenced by Monsanto. Newell thinks that it may be due to an email written by biologist Kevin Folta which was obtained through a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request, in which Folta wrote "Moms are people to talk to about this stuff.":35:40
- MYTH: Celebrities are authorities
- MYTH: "Chemical" is a bad word
- MYTH: Organic means pesticide-free
- MYTH: GMO's should terrify you
- MYTH: Fear of food is healthy
Science Moms debuted at QED in Manchester on October 14, 2017. The American premiere of the film was held at the scientific skepticism conference, CSICon 2017, run by the Center For Inquiry, on October 28, 2017 in Las Vegas.
Upon its initial release, the film was made available for a fee by direct download from the Science Moms website, but on May 11, 2018, the full film was posted to the Science Moms YouTube channel for free viewing.
Harriet Hall reviewed the documentary and described it as taking a novel approach, saying that it "features scientist moms who are just like other moms except that they understand the science... They provide the facts to counteract unreasonable fears." She concluded that "The 30-minute film is scientifically accurate, persuasive, and well-designed, with good production values." and "A lot of people really need to watch this documentary."
The film was reviewed by Jennifer Muirhead of Weekend Notes, who said that it "invites discussion about how to find quality information amid the sea of opinions and conjecture at our fingertips and encourages fellow parents to seek out the facts and not to let fear control their lives. It's a great resource for all parents and anyone wanting to learn more about GMOs and organic food."
As reported in the NB Herard, "A group of scientifically literate 'moms' is fighting the flood of misinformation on the Internet with a documentary film. 'Science Moms,' a 29-minute crowdfunded documentary, enjoyed a well-received world premiere at the QED conference in Manchester, UK in mid October, followed by the U.S. premiere at CSIcon in Las Vegas, NV on October 28, 2017."
In its Spotlight on Science section, Psyongames.com recommended Science Moms as a film that would "give a voice to the science-minded moms – the women who are too often drowned out by the fear mongers, the shamers, and the CelebMoms."
In May 2018, Hemant Mehta reported on the release of the film to YouTube, and said "It's such a relief to know these mothers are out there, raising their kids with reason instead of giving in to the irrational nonsense people constantly throw in their direction."
- Genetically modified organisms
- Genetically modified food controversies
- Causes of autism
- Vaccine controversies
- The signature field of the letter to the celebrity moms was as follows (with bold added to indicate those who went on to be featured in Science Moms):
* Kavin Senapathy: Freelance writer, science popularizer, co-founder of March Against Myths, mother of two (ages 4 and 2),
* Dr. Layla Katiraee: Scientist, writer at FrankenFoodFacts and Biology Fortified, and mother of a 3-year-old,
* Dr. Anastasia Bodnar: Scientist, co-founder of the non-profit Biology Fortified, Inc., and mother of a 15-month-old,
* Dr. Alison Bernstein: Scientist, writer, mother of two (ages 7 and 2), AKA “Mommy PhD”,
* Julie Borlaug: Associate Director for external relations at the Norman Borlaug Institute for International Agriculture, and Strategic Initiatives, Texas A&M AgriLife Research, and mother of a 6-year-old,
* Dr. Alison Van Eenennaam: University researcher and animal biotechnology specialist, and mother of two (ages 15 and 17),
* Sarah Schultz: Nurse, wife of a farmer, writer at Nurse Loves Farmer, mother of two (ages 5 and 2),
* Sara, science communicator and blogger at It’s Momsense, mother of two (ages 5 and 7),
* Jenny Splitter: Writer at Grounded Parents, storyteller, mother of two (ages 11 and 4), Science Activist and food allergy parent,
* Joni Kamiya: Biotech papaya farmer’s daughter, blogger at Hawaii Farmer’s Daughter. Mother of three (ages 7 months, 5, and 10),
* Jennie Schmidt, MS, RD – Farmer & Registered Dietitian, AKA “The Foodie Farmer”, mother of two (ages 15 and 17),
* Dr. Denneal Jamison-McClung: University biotechnology educator, program administrator and mother of an 11-year-old,
* Krista Stauffer: Dairy farmer, writer, blogger at The Farmer’s Wifee, [sic] Founder of Ask the Farmers and mother of three (ages 8, 5, and 3)."
- Mamone, Trav. "Meet the Science Moms". Paste Magazine. Archived from the original on 18 November 2017. Retrieved 18 November 2017.
- "SIUE's Hupp produces skeptical film premiering this weekend". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 21 November 2017. Retrieved 21 November 2017.
- "Science Moms: Full Film!". YouTube.com. Science Moms. 11 May 2018. Retrieved 14 May 2018.
- Mehta, Hemant (27 May 2018). "Watch This Film About Moms Who, Unlike Gwyneth Paltrow, Are Committed to Science". Patheos.com. Patheos. Archived from the original on 2018-06-03. Retrieved 3 June 2018.
It’s such a relief to know these mothers are out there, raising their kids with reason instead of giving in to the irrational nonsense people constantly throw in their direction.
- Gunlock, Julie. "Scientist and Advocate Moms to Celeb Moms: Weigh GMO Food with Facts Not Fear". Independent Women's Forum. Archived from the original on 23 November 2017. Retrieved 23 November 2017.
- Miller, Matthew (19 March 2018). "'Science Moms,' a documentary on 'fact-based parenting,' to screen at MSU". Lansingstatejournal.com. Lansing State Journal. Retrieved 21 March 2018.
- Hall, Harriet A. "Science Moms Fight Fears with Facts". Science-Based Medicine. Archived from the original on 28 November 2017. Retrieved 28 November 2017.
- Senapathy, Kavin. "Science Moms Documentary Aims To Shift Parenting Narrative From Fear To Facts". Forbes. Retrieved 18 November 2017.
- Fidalgo, Paul. "A Conversation, Not a Lecture, with the Science Moms". CFI. Archived from the original on 18 November 2017. Retrieved 18 November 2017.
- Gerbic, Susan. "An Interview with CSICon Speaker Kavin Senapathy". CFI. Archived from the original on 18 November 2017. Retrieved 18 November 2017.
- Brunner, Carrie (2 December 2017). "'Science Moms' Documentary Targets Scientific Misinformation in Parenting". New Brunswick Herard. Archived from the original on 2017-12-02. Retrieved 2 December 2017.
- Gerbic, Susan. "Addressing the Fear-Based Narrative Around GMOs with Natalie Newell". CFI. Archived from the original on 18 November 2017. Retrieved 18 November 2017.
- Gillam, Carey. Whitewash: The Story of a Weed Killer, Cancer, and the Corruption of Science (First ed.). p. 128. ISBN 978-1610918329.
- "SIO101: Science Mom Natalie Newell". seriouspod.com. Serious Pod. 10 December 2017. Archived from the original on 13 December 2017. Retrieved 13 December 2017.
- Kuzemchak, Sally. "5 Food Myths It's Time to Stop Believing". Parents.com. Parents.com. Archived from the original on 9 February 2018. Retrieved 9 February 2018.
- Kuzemchak, Sally. "Facts not fear: Science Moms' documentary debunks common food myths about GMOs, organic farming". Geneticliteracyproject.org. Genetic literacy project. Archived from the original on 9 February 2018. Retrieved 9 February 2018.
- Muirhead, Jennifer (29 November 2017). "Science Moms - Film Review: Replace Fear with Facts". Weekend Notes. Archived from the original on 9 December 2017. Retrieved 9 December 2017.
- "Spotlight on Science". Psyongames. Archived from the original on 23 November 2017. Retrieved 23 November 2017.