In March 2013, Reynolds signed with new expansion franchise VSI Tampa Bay FC for their first season in the USL Pro. On April 2, Reynolds made his debut for VSI Tampa Bay against the Los Angeles Blues in which came on in the 77th minute for Bitielo Jean Jacques as VSI won the match 1–0. He then scored his first professional goal of his career later that month on 21 April 2013 against the Los Angeles Blues in which he scored in the 53rd minute as VSI won the game 3–2.
After VSI Tampa Bay folded in November 2013, Reynolds signed for FH of the Úrvalsdeild in Iceland after a successful trial. He made his debut for FH on May 18, 2014 against IBV.