Self-checkout

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

NCR Corporation model of self-service checkouts and fast-lane at a Sainsbury's store.
NCR Corporation model of self-service checkout at an IKEA store.

Self-checkout (also known as self-service checkout and as semi-attended customer-activated terminal, SACAT) machines provide a mechanism for customers to process their own purchases from a retailer. They are an alternative to the traditional cashier-staffed checkout. The customer performs the job of the cashier themselves, by scanning the items' barcodes and then paying for the items by inserting cash into the machine, or entering payment card information.

As of 2013, there were 191,000 self-checkout units worldwide, and the number was estimated to reach 325,000 units by 2019.[1] The machines were invented by David R. Humble.[2][3]

Typical systems[edit]

In self-checkout systems, the customer is typically required to:

  • Scan product barcodes where these exist
  • Weigh products (such as fresh produce) without barcodes and select the variety on a touchscreen display.
  • Place all scanned items into a "bagging area". The weight observed in the bagging area is verified against previously stored information to ensure that the correct item is bagged, allowing the customer to proceed only if the observed and expected weights match.[4]

Machines in different retailers may accept card via EFTPOS, debit/credit cards, electronic food assistance cards, cash via coin slot, bank note scanner, and in-store gift cards (where applicable). Most coupons also have barcodes and can be scanned the same way that items are scanned, although some require entry by a member of staff.

There is typically a staff member supervising a group of self-checkouts who will assist customers when required, and authorise the sale of age-restricted products such as medicines, alcohol, knives and tobacco.

Advantages[edit]

The benefit to the retailer in providing self-checkout machines is in reduced labour costs: one attendant can often run four to six checkout lanes with the work of the cashier now being assumed by the customer. The size of a self-checkout machine is also smaller than a traditional checkout manned by a cashier; thus, a store can save space, which could be used for more shelves, display cabinets, or additional checkouts.[5]

Customers who do not want to interact with the cashier can use the self-checkout.

Self-checkout can also sometimes be faster than using a cashier lane. This can reduce the length of checkout lines and wait times.[6] In a survey by NCR, 42% of customers said they liked the convenience of self-checkout, while 39% said it was faster than the cashier-assisted line. 90% of those surveyed responded as being users of self-checkout, with 7% of respondents saying they will always use self-checkout regardless of store lines and number of items. Survey respondents in Italy and Australia said they "always use self-checkout" at a rate of 13% and 9% respectively.[1]

One advantage is that self-checkouts can, if the necessary investment is made, provide a partly multilingual service. (It cannot be fully bilingual unless the goods themselves are labelled in all the relevant languages, which is often not the case.) For example, Tesco's Welsh stores which can serve customers in Welsh,[7] whereas finding enough fluent Welsh-speakers as staff can be difficult because in some areas only a small proportion of local people have Welsh as their first language.[8]

Disadvantages[edit]

Shoplifting[edit]

Stores may monitor shoplifters using CCTV.

Self-checkout is vulnerable to some shoplifting techniques. In some cases the machine will pick up the attempt to steal, or cause the shopper to alter their behavior (e.g. an item can be put not on the scales but somewhere else where it should not be put, and this may be noticed by the system supervisor). For example, in 2007, a man was charged with replacing the tag of a plasma TV with a $4.88 DVD, and trying to purchase it through self-checkout.[9]

Studies suggest that a large proportion of shoppers are tempted to shoplift due to the relative ease of fooling self-checkouts. For example, a person who (initially without intent to steal) does not scan an item, may remember that this was easy, and fail to scan other items deliberately.[10] A 2012 survey with 4,952 respondents in the UK found that a third of shoppers had stolen this way, with a quarter of the remainder stating they were deterred by the risk of detection. Non-barcode items such as produce, and store staff overriding (or ignoring) checkout alerts, were singled out as vulnerabilities, and poverty was not seen as a major factor.

The founder of one store video surveillance system estimated that "Theft—intentional or not—is up to five times higher with self checkout than when cashiers are working", although behaviour of shoplifters is becoming well known, and stores are now better at shoplifting detection.[11] A 2014 survey in[where?] of 2,634 respondents confirmed the same general findings, but commented that the cost of additional theft was evidently seen as "tolerable" compared to the cost of other processes, such as manned checkouts, and harm due to poorer customer service arising from the slowness of manned versus automated checkouts.[10]

Customer effort[edit]

In 2002, a study was carried out where people with disabilities used self-checkout machines, and found that existing checkout machines were not designed for accessibility.[12]

Customer interaction[edit]

Self-checkouts are also criticized for reducing the possibilities for customers and store staff to interact, and adversely affecting customer service in general.[11] Self-checkout lanes may lack some rather basic customer interactions, like informing the customer that a coupon was not accepted, and why.

Noise pollution[edit]

Customers have often complained about the repeated robotic-sounding messages coming from self-service checkouts. In 2015, supermarket Tesco replaced the robotic announcements with more human-sounding voice prompts.[13]

Retailers have been known to use novelty voices for their self-service checkouts. For example, discount store Poundland has used the voices of Yoda[14], Elvis Presley, Count Dracula and Father Christmas on various occasions.[15] In 2019, Marks & Spencer replaced its regular checkout announcers with the voices of Ant McPartlin, Declan Donnelly, Alisha Dixon and Amanda Holden during the 2019 edition of Britain's Got Talent.[16] The new voices led to an increase in customer complaints about the automated system, with many questioning the appropriateness of some of the comments.[17]

Low reliability[edit]

Being more complex, self-checkouts are more prone to failure. For example, they use scales to weigh goods in the bagging area, and, if the scale fails, the machine does not work. Also, in a manned checkout lane, any simple problems like lack of receipt paper would be immediately fixed by the operator, while self-checkouts may not be fixed for quite some time. This lack of reliability can be compensated for by having excess lanes available or enough staff on hand to perform immediate maintenance.[citation needed] They can also be prone to false “Unexpected item in bagging area” alerts when an item that was scanned gets put into the bagging area and after that it comes up with a message saying the item that was just placed was unexpected, or a coat flapping onto it and causing the error that way.

Scanning while shopping[edit]

"Scan It" kiosk at Giant Food store.

An alternative system (self-scanning) consists of a portable barcode scanner that is used by the customer to scan and bag items while shopping.[18] When the customer has finished shopping, the scanner is brought to a checkout kiosk, where the information from the barcode scanner is downloaded to the kiosk, usually in conjunction with a customer loyalty card. The customer pays and receives a receipt at the checkout kiosk. The integrity of the system is maintained through the use of random audits or RFID. The Walmart-owned warehouse club, Sam's Club, allows customers to download an app and scan items into their cart using a mobile application.[19] In summer 2018, Walmart China launched its Wechat-based "Scan and Go" program, allowing customers to scan items into their carts without downloading another mobile app, while paying through Wechat Payment or Alipay. The "Scan and Go"program carried 30% of all payments made in Chinese stores, and even improved sales in certain markets by 10%.[20]

In December 2016, Amazon announced a bricks and mortar store in Seattle under the name Amazon Go, which uses a variety of cameras and sensors in order to see what customers are putting into their shopping bags.[21] The customers scan a QR code when they enter the store through a companion app, which is linked to their Amazon.com account.[22] When the customer exits the store, the items in their bag are automatically charged to the account.[23]

Hybrid systems[edit]

Suppliers like ITAB, NCR, Wincor-Nixdorf, and others have manufactured hybrid checkout systems that allows the checkout counter to be switched between either a cashier operated mode or a customer self-service mode.[24][25]

Open systems[edit]

In 2010, the open-source-self-check project was announced. By using hardware and open source software, this library self-checkout system costs less than one-tenth of the commercial version.[26][27]

A Java-based open source self check client for libraries, which has been used at the University of Oxford,[28] is also available under a GPL v3 license.[29]

RFID based system[edit]

Several experimental stores in China use a combination of RFID and cameras to determine which products a customer has picked. Upon leaving, the customer passes through an RFID-reading gate and only has to pay the bill to checkout.[30][31][32][33]

Regulation[edit]

An appeal court in California confirmed in September 2013 a bill banning sales of alcoholic beverages in self-service checkouts. The law requires alcohol only to be sold in face-to-face transactions with store clerks.[34]

The AFL-CIO has backed a proposed ballot measure in Oregon to prohibit stores from operating more than two self-checkout machines.[35]

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b "SELF-CHECKOUT: A GLOBAL CONSUMER PERSPECTIVE" (PDF). NCR Whitepaper. Retrieved 20 December 2016.
  2. ^ "Self-Checkout Reaches Critical Mass - LPM". losspreventionmedia.com.
  3. ^ "Self-service distribution system".
  4. ^ Daniella Miletic (22 April 2008). "A new way to shop — check it out for yourself". Melbourne: The Age. Retrieved 2 September 2008.
  5. ^ Manfred Krafft; Murali K. Mantrala (17 December 2009). Retailing in the 21st Century: Current and Future Trends. Springer Science & Business Media. p. 189. ISBN 978-3-540-72003-4.
  6. ^ "The Pros and Cons of Using Self-Checkouts - BusinessBee". BusinessBee. 7 August 2013. Retrieved 5 June 2016.
  7. ^ Hosford, Paul. "Tesco is looking at introducing Irish-speaking self-service checkouts". Retrieved 28 August 2016.
  8. ^ "Home Truths: the decline of the Welsh language". Retrieved 28 August 2016.
  9. ^ Meg, Maco (29 June 2007). "Guy Switches Price Tag On Walmart Plasma TV, Tries To Buy It For KES423". tips@consumerist.com. Consumerist. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  10. ^ a b Carter, Clare (31 January 2014). "Self-scan fail: Supermarkets lose billions as thieving customers help themselves". canberratimes.com.au. Fairfax Media. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  11. ^ a b "Self-checkout lanes boost convenience, theft risk". USA Today. 8 April 2012. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  12. ^ Bajaj, Komal; Mirka, Gary A.; Sommerich, Carolyn M.; Khachatoorian, Haig (31 March 2006). "Evaluation of a Redesigned Self-Checkout Station for Wheelchair Users". Assistive Technology. 18 (1): 15–24. doi:10.1080/10400435.2006.10131903.
  13. ^ Chester, Tom (30 July 2015). "Tesco replacing 'irritating' self-checkout robo-voice". Mashable UK. Retrieved 3 January 2020.
  14. ^ "Jedi Master Yoda is set to help out at the tills at Ballymena's Poundland – he must!". The Ballymena Daily. 21 July 2019. Retrieved 21 September 2019.
  15. ^ "WATCH: Elvis, Dracula and Santa entertain customers at Poundland store in Derry". Derry Now. 1 November 2018. Retrieved 30 August 2019.
  16. ^ Nazir, Sahar (12 April 2019). "Retail Gazette Loves: M&S tills voiced by Ant & Dec and BGT judges". Retail Gazette. Retrieved 3 January 2020.
  17. ^ Kalia, Ammar (23 April 2019). "Chummy automation: why no one wants Ant and Dec to voice the M&S tills". The Guardian. Retrieved 3 January 2020.
  18. ^ Zimmerman, Ann (18 May 2011). "Check Out the Future of Shopping". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 7 December 2016.
  19. ^ Sozzi, Brian (22 September 2016). "Walmart's sam's club scan-and-go app may make cash registers obsolete". TheStreet. Retrieved 7 December 2016.
  20. ^ "南方都市报:边逛边扫移动支付,沃尔玛推进门店升级,记者带你体验"扫码购"". www.oeeee.com. Retrieved 23 September 2018.
  21. ^ Stevens, Laura; Safdar, Khadeeja (6 December 2016). "Amazon Working on Several Grocery-Store Formats, Could Open More Than 2,000 Locations". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 7 December 2016.
  22. ^ Wingfield, Nick (5 December 2016). "Amazon Moves to Cut Checkout Line, Promoting a Grab-and-Go Experience". The New York Times. Retrieved 7 December 2016.
  23. ^ Garun, Natt (5 December 2016). "Amazon just launched a cashier-free convenience store". The Verge. Vox Media. Retrieved 7 December 2016.
  24. ^ Barwick, Hamish. "Coles trials hybrid self-checkout system in Victoria". computerworld.com.au. IDG Communication. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  25. ^ "Wincor Nixdorf to present 'Always Open' checkout solution at NRF Big Show". kioskmarketplace.com. Networld Media Group. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  26. ^ "open-source-self-check". google.com. Google Project Hosting. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  27. ^ "Self-Check Kiosk from Scratch: Iowa Librarian's Coding Skills Prove Valuable". Archived from the original on 11 May 2011.
  28. ^ Oxford Developments at GAUG 2002 Archived from the original on 24 November 2012
  29. ^ "Ceridwen Self Issue Client". ceridwen.com. Ceridwen Limited. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  30. ^ "A store without cashiers opens in China's "future city"". Abacus.
  31. ^ "Alibaba's 'Futuremart' is a High-Tech Cashierless Store in China". www.altaviawatch.com.
  32. ^ "Tencent beats Amazon to launch unmanned shop in Shanghai". South China Morning Post. 22 January 2018.
  33. ^ Horwitz, Josh. "China is both ahead of and behind Amazon in cashier-less stores". Quartz.
  34. ^ Egelko, Bob (20 September 2013). "Alcohol can't be sold at self-checkout lines". sfgate.com. SFGate. Retrieved 3 April 2014.
  35. ^ Withycome, Claire. "Measure to limit self-checkout gets nod from Oregon Supreme Court". Corvallis Gazette Times. Retrieved 24 January 2020.