There are four types of shomrim: shomer ḥinnam, shomer sakhar, shoel, and sokher, corresponding to an unpaid custodian, a paid custodian, a borrower, and a renter respectively. Each shomer has specific distinct laws that apply to it. In halacha there are two major factors that determine a guardian's liability: the ability to use the item, and the exchange of money. In general the ability to use the item (in the case of a renter and a borrower) or being paid to watch the item (in the case of the paid watchman) increases the guardian's liability, while paying for use of the item (i.e. a renter) decreases the guardian's liability.
Types of shomrim
|Negligence||Theft||Loss||Accidental Damage||Damage from Normal Wear|
A shomer Chinam (Hebrew: שומר חנם, pl. שומרי חנם, shomrei chinam), or unpaid watchman, is one who watches an item without receiving payment for his watching. Shomrei cḥinnam are liable only for damages that result from their own negligence. They must pay for damages that result from their negligence.
The shomer cḥinnam does not have permission to use the item he or she is entrusted with.
A shomer shakhar (Hebrew: שומר שכר, pl. שומרי שכר, shomrei shakhar), or paid watchman, also known as a noseh shakhar (Hebrew: נושא שכר, one who receives payment) is one who watches an item in exchange for compensation. In addition to the obligations of the shomer ḥinnam, shomrei sakhar are liable if the item is stolen. Armed robbery is exempted from this responsibility, however, as it is considered beyond the custodian's reasonable control.
Shomrei shakhar are also liable if the item is lost or misplaced, even if the loss was not a result of negligence.
In addition to the paid watchman's heightened level of liability, in certain ways the shomer sakhar is expected to perform a higher level of custodianship. A shomer sakhar, for example, cannot watch an item in a way that would only protect it from a reasonable wind, but rather must watch an item in a way as to protect it from any possible wind, and the absence of such would make the shomer liable.
The shomer sakhar also may not use the item entrusted.
A sokher (Hebrew: שוכר) is a renter. The liabilities of a sokher are the same as those of a shomer sakhar.
A shoel (Hebrew: שואל) is a borrower. The shoel is liable for the entrusted item in all circumstances, including those that are not the shoel's fault, known as Onsim (Hebrew: אונסים, sing. אונס, Ones). The shoel's only exemption is for damage resulting from the normal use of the item, for example if a borrowed ox dies as a result of normal plowing.
Biblical sources for shomrim
The gemara in tractate Bava Metzia discusses the biblical sourcing of each of the categories of shomrim. The gemara concludes that Shemot 22:6-8 refers to the shomer ḥinnam, 22:9-12 to the shomer sakhar, 22:13-14 to the shoel, and 22:14 to the sokher.
Becoming a shomer
Generally, one must be willing to become a shomer in order to assume liability, and as such cannot be forced to watch an item. In certain circumstances, such as when one encounters a lost item, the Torah dictates that until the item is returned, the person assumes the liability and responsibility of a shomer sakhar.
The Shomrim's Oath
In order for a shomer to verify the circumstances of the entrusted item's loss, shomrim are required to swear a group of oaths in Beit Din. The oaths required of a shomer typically include swearing how the item was lost, swearing that the shomer had not been negligent, and swearing that the shomer had not misappropriated the item.
- Mishnah, Bava Metzia 93a
- Bava Metzia, 82
- DafYomi.co.il chart of biblical source for each liability