Shubhodaya controversy

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Shubhodaya Controversy)
Jump to: navigation, search

The Shubhodaya Controversy is related to the heated debates in India about and a court case that happened in 1919 around a newspaper article in a Kannada language daily namely "Shubhodaya". Under the title "Allama, Basava Vrittantavenu? (What is the Description of Allama and Basava, dated 18 April 1919), R. Shrinivasacharya wrote certain historical details which allegedly tarnished the image of Basavanna and Allama.[who?][1] This article triggered off the wrath of the Lingayaths and resulted in Siddaramappa Pawate, a well known legal practitioner and a Lingayath scholar, suing[why?] Shrinivasacharya in the first grade Magistrate court of Dharwad.

The court case led to series of debates about the history of 12th century Shiva Sharanas and their contribution to Lingayath religion. The controversy was an important historical event for the Lingayaths who were provoked to rethink their image in the public sphere. The controversy threw open several questions related to Lingayath history, literature and philosophy. The Lingayaths had to assert their identity as a community and they accomplished it by actively participating in the debates and discussions. The controversy proved to be a guiding force for scholars like Fa.Gu. Halakatti to refashion Lingayath literature and history. This controversy was one of the turning points for re-imagining the Lingayath history and community in colonial Karnataka.[1][2]


  1. ^ a b Boratti, Vijayakumar (2011). Hiriyara Hiritana Hindenaayitu. Karnataka: Kannada University. pp. 63–68. 
  2. ^ Kannada