Siege of Dunkirk (1944–45)
|Siege of Dunkirk (1944)|
|Part of Western Front, Second World War|
Czechoslovak soldiers on a Cromwell tank near Dunkerque shortly after the German capitulation.
|Commanders and leaders|
| Harry Crerar
| Wolfgang von Kluge
The Siege of Dunkirk, also known as the Second Battle of Dunkirk, during the Second World War, occurred from September 1944 when units of the Second Canadian Division surrounded the heavily fortified city and port of Dunkirk. German units within the fortress withstood initial probing attacks, and as the opening of the port of Antwerp became a higher priority, 21st Army Group commander Bernard Montgomery, decided to merely contain the Germans within Dunkirk without attacking the fortified city. For this task, the 1st Czechoslovak Armoured Brigade was used. The German garrison remained in Dunkirk until the general German surrender in May 1945. In so doing, the garrison denied the Allies the use of the port. The fortress, commanded by Admiral Friedrich Frisius, eventually surrendered unconditionally to Brigade General Alois Liška, the commander of the Czechoslovak brigade group, on 9 May 1945.
The First Canadian Army had been allocated the left of the 21st Army Group's line of advance and General Bernard Montgomery had directed them to clear the Channel Ports before continuing into the Netherlands. Most of these ports, however, had been heavily fortified and, despite the generally poor quality of the garrisons, it was necessary to mount full-scale major assaults.
The ports were needed to supply the Allied armies and the lack of such facilities had halted or slowed much offensive activity. Montgomery had estimated that the Channel Ports would be sufficient for his needs and this view persisted until mid-September. Under pressure from Dwight Eisenhower, the Allied Supreme Commander, Montgomery modified his instructions to the Canadian commander, Henry Crerar, on 13–14 September thus: "Early use of Antwerp so urgent that I am prepared to give up operations against Calais and Dunkirk" and: "Dunkirk will be left to be dealt with later; for the present it will be merely masked."
Action against Calais continued (see Operation Undergo), at least partly due to the need to silence the heavy artillery sited nearby. The forces that might have been used to capture Dunkirk were released to assist on the Scheldt and thus open access to the largely undamaged port of Antwerp. Instead, smaller Allied forces held a perimeter around the city.
In the first weeks of the siege, while Allied forces were being deployed on the Scheldt, several formations took short turns at containing Dunkirk. The 5th Canadian Infantry Brigade, part of 2nd Canadian Division, was relieved by the 4th Special Service Brigade (a Royal Marines Commando formation), which was in turn relieved by the 154th Infantry Brigade. However, the bulk of the siege was performed by the 1st Czechoslovak Armoured Brigade from early October until the final surrender.
The German garrison consisted of a wide variety of men, including Navy and Air Force personnel, as well as Army and Fortress units. There was also a 2,000 strong Waffen-SS detachment. The total strength was in excess of 10,000 men. Many of these were remnants of five Army divisions which had been mauled during the Normandy campaign and had retreated to Dunkirk. The town itself was heavily fortified, and well-supplied for a lengthy siege.
The Canadians approached Dunkirk from the south west. On 7–8 September, the 5th Canadian Infantry Brigade captured Bourbourg, about 13 km (8.1 mi) from the city itself. The German outer perimeter ran through the villages of Mardyck, Loon-Plage, Spycker, Bergues and Bray-Dunes, from 7–12 km (4.3–7.5 mi) from Dunkirk. The Calgary Highlanders attacked Loon-Plage on 7 September against very heavy opposition and suffered enough casualties that each of its companies was reduced to less than 30 men. The village was gained on the 9th only when the Germans withdrew. During the next ten days, Canadian units nibbled away at the German perimeter, taking Coppenaxfort on the 9th, Mardyck on the 17th, both west of the city, Bergues on the 15th and Veurne, Nieuwpoort (greatly aided by precise intelligence received from the Belgian White Brigade, the national resistance movement) and De Panne, east of Dunkirk, in Belgium. Bray Dunes and nearby Ghyvelde, both just within France, were taken on 15 September, with air support after initial attacks had failed.
It had become clear that the German defenders were not about to be expelled without a major assault. Given the need to open up the Scheldt to Antwerp and the likelihood that Dunkirk would be of limited use as a supply port as a result of its demolition, the major Canadian units were redeployed. Nearby Oostende had fallen easily to the Canadians when the Germans withdrew, and its port was partially opened on 28 September, easing the Allies' supply problems. Dunkirk was no longer worth the effort of its capture
The Allied forces around Dunkirk were to contain the German garrison and minimise their inclination to fight on by aggressive reconnaissance, artillery and air bombardment and propaganda. Coastal supply routes used by German E-Boats and air supply drops were to be cut off.
Of all of the German fortress garrisons on the Channel coast, Dunkirk appears to have been the most resilient. They had thwarted early probes by the Canadians with sufficient aggression to dissuade them from a full assault. By this stage, other priorities had come into play, compelling the Canadians to persist in aggressive patrolling and successful local counter-attacks.
On the night of 26–27 September, the Germans attempted to take advantage of the local inexperience of the recently deployed 154th Brigade. Two serious attacks were mounted, against the 7th Black Watch in Ghyvelde and the 7th Argylls at nearby Bray-Dunes Plage. Both were beaten back, but only after the Argylls' headquarters had been partially occupied and houses in Ghyvelde had been destroyed.
On 4 October, a 36-hour truce was agreed between the two sides, at the initiative of the French Red Cross, to allow the evacuation of 18,000 French civilians and Allied and German wounded. This passed without incident and was even extended to allow the Germans to restore defences that had been removed to allow the evacuation.
Once deployed, Czechoslovak forces executed frequent raids into Dunkirk's eastern suburbs, for nuisance effect and to take prisoners. There was a flurry of attacks and retaliatory counter-attacks, mostly on Dunkirk's eastern side, in November 1944. Conditions for besiegers and besieged were difficult in the winter. The low-lying ground outside the city had been flooded to form part of the defences and adjacent land easily became water-logged, hampering movement and making life unpleasant. Canadian artillerymen reported that gun-pits needed to be bailed out, the sides of dugouts collapsed and transport became mired. This was mitigated by leave in nearby towns and in Lille. The defenders were stuck with poor food, deficient health care and harsh discipline.
Between the 28 April and 2 May 1945, the Germans were able to deliver a limited amount of supplies to the besieged garrison using Seehund, two-man midget submarines. These craft were normally armed with two torpedoes mounted on the outside. For the supply missions, the torpedoes were replaced with special food containers (nicknamed "butter torpedoes"). On the return voyages, they used the containers to carry mail from the Dunkirk garrison.
After the general German surrender, the garrison surrendered unconditionally to Alois Liška on 9 May 1945.
Substantial reserves of food and ammunition remained in Dunkirk.
Order of battle
- 5th Canadian Infantry Brigade (until 18 September)
- The Black Watch (Royal Highland Regiment) of Canada
- Le Régiment de Maisonneuve
- The Calgary Highlanders
- 5 Canadian Infantry Brigade Ground Defence Platoon (Lorne Scots)
- 154th British Infantry Brigade (from 26 September – 9 October 1944)
- 7th Battalion Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders
- 1st and 7th Battalions Black Watch
- 1st Czechoslovak Armoured Brigade (from 9 October until surrender on 9 May 1945)
- 1st Czechoslovak Tank Battalion
- 2nd Czechoslovak Tank Battalion
- 1st Czechoslovak Motorised Infantry Battalion (two companies)
- Field Artillery Regiment (two battalions)
- anti-tank battalion
- Armoured Reconnaissance Squadron
- Field Engineers Company
- Plus attached British, French and Canadian units:-
- 7th Royal Tank Regiment
- 2nd Canadian Heavy Anti-aircraft Regiment
- 109th Heavy Anti-Aircraft Regiment, Royal Artillery
- 125th Light Anti-aircraft Regiment, Royal Artillery
- French 51st Infantry Regiment (two battalions formed from the FFI)
Elements of the following formations:
- 49th Infantry Division
- 226th Infantry Division
- 346th Infantry Division
- 711th Infantry Division
- 97th Infantry Division
- 26th Fortress Battalion
- 1046th Fortress Battalion
- Waffen-SS Reinecke group
- Operation Astonia: capture of Le Havre
- Operation Wellhit: capture of Boulogne
- Operation Undergo: capture of Calais
- Ammentorp, Steen (2000–2009). "von Kluge, Wolfgang, Lieutenant-General". The Generals of WWII. Retrieved 12 Dec 2009.
- (in Czech) Czech army page
- Stacey, p336
- Report 84, p99
- Dunkirk;The Last outpost Archived 14 July 2011 at the Wayback Machine. J Hyrman at nasenovitny.com
- Stacey, p327
- Stacey, p328
- Copp, Legion Magazine
- Whereas the defenders of other Channel Ports, particularly Calais and Boulogne, and also those of the gun sites at Cap Gris Nez were easily persuaded to surrender, those in Dunkirk were more determined and capable of successful offensive action.
- "154 Brigade – Dunkirk 23rd September 1944 to 9th October 1944". 51 Highland Division. 2 November 2009. Retrieved 12 Nov 2009.
- Dudley, Gavin W S (9 December 2004). "Travels of a Captain R.A. (Searchlight) – Part three". People's War. BBC. Retrieved 14 Dec 2009.
- Report 184, p.113
- Report 184, p.119
- Rohwer, Jürgen; Gerhard Hummelchen (1992). Chronology of the War at Sea 1939-1945. Naval Institute Press. p. 344. ISBN 1-55750-105-X.
- Davis, Jason (2006–2009). "4th Special Service Brigade, Royal Marine Commandos in Normandy – The Breakout". Flames of War. Retrieved 13 Nov 2009.
- Michalon, Roger. Les Grandes Unités Françaises, Volume 6, p. 891. Paris: Imprimerie Nationale, 1980.
- Report 84, p101
- Stacey, C P. "Clearing the Coastal Belt and the Ports – September 1944". Official History of the Canadian Army. Department of National Defence. Retrieved 3 July 2009.
- Copp, Terry (1 May 2001). "2nd Division In September 1944: Army, Part 36". Legion Magazine. Retrieved 14 Dec 2009.
- Copp, Terry (2006). Cinderella army: the Canadians in northwest Europe, 1944–1945. University of Toronto Press. ISBN 0-8020-3925-1.
- "2 Cdn Inf Div Invests Dunkirk (Report 183)" (pdf). CANADIAN PARTICIPATION IN THE OPERATIONS IN NORTH-WEST EUROPE 1944. PART IV: First Canadian Army in the Pursuit, 23 Aug – 30 Sep. Historical Section, Canadian Military Headquarters. Retrieved 15 November 2009.
- "The Containing of Dunkirk (Report 184)" (pdf). CANADIAN PARTICIPATION IN THE OPERATIONS IN NORTH-WEST EUROPE 1944. PART V: CLEARING THE CHANNEL PORTS, 3 SEP 44 – 6 FEB 45. Historical Section, Canadian Military Headquarters. Retrieved 13 October 2009.
- Hyrman, Jan. "The port of Dunkirk in WWII". Naše Noviny. Archived from the original on 14 July 2011. Retrieved 13 Nov 2009.