Sim Lim Square
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (September 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)|
|No. of stores and services||151|
|No. of floors||6|
|Website||Sim Lim Square|
Sim Lim Square (Chinese: 森林商业中心, Wade-Giles: Sen1 lin2 shang1 yeh2 chung1 hsin1), commonly referred to as SLS, is a large retail complex that offers a wide variety of electronic goods and services ranging from DVDs, cameras, phones, video cameras, and computer parts and servicing.
Located at 1 Rochor Canal Road, Singapore, SLS is situated in central Singapore, near historic features such as the Little India district and one of the earliest HDB developments. SLS is accessible via MRT at Rochor MRT Station of Downtown Line.
After several reports of incidents of fraud faced by tourists, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the People's Republic of China and Vietnamese newspapers published a warning about purchasing electronics from Sim Lim Square.
The complex is a six-storey building with a range of varied electronics supply and service shops. The centre operates away from the main shopping areas of Singapore and as such can be seen as an area for bargains to be gained with cheap and inexpensive goods. Examples of this can include phones, laptops, computer parts, cameras and other electronic devices.
CASE (Consumer Association of Singapore) often publishes advisory against rogue vendors in SLS.
Many shops in Sim Lim Square, particularly those on lower levels selling games, cameras and mobiles, resort to scam tactics to reap higher profits. The most recent case of Jover Chew Chiew Loon involve a 33-month prison sentence. In early 2008, some SLS shops were busted by the police for selling counterfeit copies of Microsoft Windows.
Infamy and redress
In April 2013, after Sim Lim Square's management put up lists of recalcitrant shops as a warning to shoppers, some of those stores resorted to shrinking or removing their names from their signboards, or even changing their name. The lists have also been ripped off by unknown culprits. It was reported a month later that retailers had secretly charged extra amounts to customers' credit cards as taxes or transaction fees.
Malaysian diver Ooi Tze Liang, who was participating in the 2014 Singapore Fina Diving Grand Prix, reported paying over S$4,800 for two iPhone 6 phones, despite being quoted a price of $2,500. Ooi was unaware of the cost when he signed a contract for a warranty package amounting to over $2,300. Ooi said that the shopkeeper refused to hand over the phones unless the payment was made. Ooi paid up instead of cancelling the warranty contract, which would have cost him $800. It was reported by The New Paper that there was "little that can be done by the authorities" as the customer signed a contract.
On 4 December, police raided and shuttered two mobile phone retailers, Gadget Terminal, and De.Mac Gadget/Mobile Apps, as part of investigations following reports lodged against them.
The impact on the mall's reputation over customer scams was so serious that in November 2014, management of Sim Lim Square appealed to the authorities to "take a tough stand against the recalcitrant retailers".
Scam victims may seek redress through the Sim Lim Square management (who certifies honest retailers through its Star Retailer programme), CASE (Consumer Association of Singapore) or the Small Claims Court.
14 complaints of impropriety were lodged against Mobile Air between July and September 2014, while 28 charges were brought onto the owner Jover Chew of Mobile Air, of which he pleaded eventually guilty to 12 of them. $12,199 was refunded to 26 victims. Most of the charges involve abetment by conspiracy to cheat customers and criminal intimidation of customers. 2 cases were widely covered by the press and social media:
On 24 September, a Chinese citizen, Miss Zhou, bought an iPhone 6 Plus from the store, but unknowingly signed a contract for two years of "insurance" costing $2,400, bringing the price of the phone to $4,000. After haggling, Zhou paid $3,000. At the time, online Apple stores were selling a similar product for less than $1,500. The next day, Zhou filed a complaint with the Small Claims Tribunal, which ruled that the shop should refund her $1,010. On October 28, Mobile Air returned Zhou and her aunt the $1,010, however, the money was returned in coins of all denominations, including five cents, weighing a total of 18 kg. Zhou and her aunt had to pick up the coins from the floor and count them. Mobile Air owner Jover Chew Chiew Loon refused to answer why he had paid in coins, instead blaming Zhou and her aunt for being difficult customers. Following this incident, CASE investigated the shop after noting the aforementioned 14 complaints of impropriety against Mobile Air.
On 3 November, Mr Pham Van Thoai, a Vietnamese tourist, paid S$950 for an iPhone 6 from Mobile Air. However, Mobile air staff refused to let Pham leave with the phone unless he paid an additional $1,500 in warranty fees. Pham had signed for an agreement, but failed to scrutinise it due to his lack of fluency in English. After the intervention of the police and CASE, Pham was refunded $400, but did not receive the iPhone, incurring a loss of $550. Pham said that his monthly earnings as a factory worker amounted to about $200. This case sparked nationwide sympathy and outrage in Singapore after the publishing of a photo of a tearful Pham and the online circulation of a video of him begging on his knees for a refund. The backlash resulted in the personal particulars and photos of Mobile Air owner Jover Chew being circulated online.
In response, a crowdfunding campaign was started on IndieGoGo to buy Pham an iPhone 6 by Mr Gabriel Kang, a Singaporean technology entrepreneur. The campaign saw over a thousand donations and raised over US$11,000. Despite the campaign, Pham said that a businessman had already donated $550 to him and that he had bought a phone with it, so he did not want to take more than what he lost. As a result of the campaign, which far exceeded the initial target of US$1,350, Kang presented Pham with an iPhone before Pham left Singapore. Pham refused the iPhone as "a matter of principle", but accepted gifts of local cuisine from Kang. The remaining money from the campaign would be awarded to portioned out, some going to 20 verified victims of mobile phone scams in Singapore, some going to charity and some reserved for Pham to have another holiday in Singapore.
After closure and injunction of Mobile Air, Chew is now serving a 33 months sentence, while Kam and three other employees are now serving a 4 to 14 months imprisonment for their roles in the scam that saw unprecedented success in raising awareness via the social media and internet platform.
- Wee, Cheryl Faith. "Chinese and Vietnamese tourists warned to be careful when buying electronics in Singapore". The Straits Times. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- "Recent CASE Advisory against rogue vendors at Sim Lim Square". Sep 1, 2013.
- Chong, Elena. "Jover Chew, former boss of Mobile Air, jailed 33 months for conning customers, also fined $2,000". Straits Times. Retrieved 1 December 2015.
- "Blog on Sim Lim Square scams". May 23, 2012.
- "I'm not visiting Sim Lim Square ever again". December 9, 2008.
- "Sim Lim Square and Lucky Plaza: Bargain heaven or rip-off joint?". May 26, 2010.
- "Microsoft Warns of High-end Pirated Software Retail Outlets". May 12, 2008.
- "5 recent infamous incidents at Sim Lim Square". The Straits Times. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Koh, Hui Theng. "Shamed Sim Lim Square retailers change signboards". The New Paper. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Lim, Jeremy. "M'sian diving champ paid more than $4k for two iPhones from Sim Lim Square shop". The New Paper. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Diane Leow; Marcus Mark Ramos; Loke Kok Fai. "Two Sim Lim Square mobile phone retailers under investigation". Channel News Asia. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Abu Baker, Jalelah (4 November 2014). "Sim Lim Square: 5 reasons it is infamous". Straits Times. Retrieved 5 November 2014.
- Wee, Cheryl Faith (4 November 2014). "Five recent infamous incidents at Sim Lim Square". Straits Times. Retrieved 5 November 2014.
- Ronald, Loh. "Sim Lim Square shop pays $1,010 refund in coins". The New Paper. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Law, Elizabeth. "Sim Lim Square shop owner can't explain why he paid in coins". The New Paper. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- "CASE to probe Sim Lim mobile shop after coin incident". AsiaOne. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Chew, Hui Min. "iPhone 6 incident at Sim Lim Square goes viral in Vietnam, makes international headlines". The Straits Times. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Chew, Hui Min. "Vietnamese tourist kneels and begs for refund of iPhone 6 at Sim Lim Square". The Straits Times. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- "China warns of Singapore scams amid tourism controversy". BBC News. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Xue, Jianyue. "http://www.channelnewsasia.com/news/singapore/sim-lim-square-store-s/1456014.html". Channel News Asia. Retrieved 9 December 2014. External link in
- "Crowdfunders pitch in after tourist caught in Singapore phone scam". Agence France-Presse. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Jalelah Abu Baker. "Vietnamese tourist in Sim Lim Square incident says he is not accepting any more help". The Straits Times. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Aw Cheng Wei; Jalelah Abu Baker. "Vietnamese tourist ripped off in Sim Lim Square declines iPhone from fundraiser, leaves Singapore". The Straits Times. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- Kang, Gabriel. "We need to make this right, send him an iphone6!". IndieGoGo. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- "Mobile Air shop reopens with new name". Channel News Asia. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
- "CASE to start injunction proceedings against Mobile Air". Channel News Asia. Retrieved 9 December 2014.
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Sim Lim Square.|