- 1 History
- 2 Technical approaches
- 2.2 Ajax
- 2.3 Websockets
- 2.4 SPA with Ajax and Websockets
- 2.5 Server-sent events
- 2.6 Browser plugins
- 2.7 Data transport (XML, JSON and Ajax)
- 2.8 Server architecture
- 3 Running locally
- 4 Challenges with the SPA model
- 5 Page lifecycle
- 6 See also
- 7 References
- 8 External links
The origins of the term single-page application are unclear, though the concept was discussed at least as early as 2003. Stuart (stunix) Morris wrote the Self-Contained website at slashdotslash.com with the same goals and functions in April 2002 and later the same year, Lucas Birdeau, Kevin Hakman, Michael Peachey and Evan Yeh described a single page application implementation in the US patent 8,136,109.
There are various techniques available that enable the browser to retain a single page even when the application requires server communication.
- AngularJS is a fully client-side framework. AngularJS's templating is based on bidirectional UI data binding. Data-binding is an automatic way of updating the view whenever the model changes, as well as updating the model whenever the view changes. The HTML template is compiled in the browser. The compilation step creates pure HTML, which the browser re-renders into the live view. The step is repeated for subsequent page views. In traditional server-side HTML programming, concepts such as controller and model interact within a server process to produce new HTML views. In the AngularJS framework, the controller and model states are maintained within the client browser. Therefore, new pages are capable of being generated without any interaction with a server.
- ExtJS is also a client side framework that allows creating MVC applications. It has its own event system, window and layout management, state management (stores) and various UI components (grids, dialog windows, form elements etc.). It has its own class system with either dynamic or static loader. The application built with ExtJS can either exist on its own (with state in the browser) or with the server (e.g. with REST API that is used to fill its internal stores). ExtJS has only built in capabilities to use localStorage so larger applications need a server to store state.
- Knockout.js is a client side framework which uses templates based on the Model-View-ViewModel pattern.
SPA with Ajax and Websockets
WebSockets are typically used in applications where real time updates are required . WebSockets also enables us to multiplex data on the same connection, thus one can easily implement an 'AJAX library on top of WebSockets' and still use the same WebSocket connection for bi-directional real-time data transfer.
Server-sent events (SSEs) is a technique whereby servers can initiate data transmission to browser clients. Once an initial connection has been established, an event stream remains open until closed by the client. SSEs are sent over traditional HTTP and have a variety of features that WebSockets lack by design such as automatic reconnection, event IDs, and the ability to send arbitrary events.
Data transport (XML, JSON and Ajax)
Thin server architecture
An SPA moves logic from the server to the client, with the role of the web server evolving into a pure data API or web service. This architectural shift has, in some circles, been coined "Thin Server Architecture" to highlight that complexity has been moved from the server to the client, with the argument that this ultimately reduces overall complexity of the system.
Thick stateful server architecture
This approach needs more server memory and server processing, but the advantage is a simplified development model because a) the application is usually fully coded in the server, and b) data and UI state in the server are shared in the same memory space with no need for custom client/server communication bridges.
Thick stateless server architecture
This approach requires that more data be sent to the server and may require more computational resources per request to partially or fully reconstruct the client page state in the server. At the same time, this approach is more easily scalable because there is no per-client page data kept in the server and, therefore, Ajax requests can be dispatched to different server nodes with no need for session data sharing or server affinity.
Some SPAs may be executed from a local file using the file URI scheme. This gives users the ability to download the SPA from a server and run the file from a local storage device, without depending on server connectivity. If such an SPA wants to store and update data, it must use browser-based Web Storage. These applications benefit from advances available with HTML5.
Challenges with the SPA model
Because the SPA is an evolution away from the stateless page-redraw model that browsers were originally designed for, some new challenges have emerged. Each of these problems has an effective solution with:
- Server-side web frameworks that specialize in the SPA model.
- The evolution of browsers and the HTML5 specification designed for the SPA model.
Search engine optimization
Between 2009 and 2015, Google Webmaster Central proposed and then recommended an "AJAX crawling scheme" using an initial exclamation mark in fragment identifiers for stateful AJAX pages (
Alternatively, applications may render the first page load on the server and subsequent page updates on the client. This is traditionally difficult, because the rendering code might need to be written in a different language or framework on the server and in the client. Using logic-less templates, cross-compiling from one language to another, or using the same language on the server and the client may help to increase the amount of code that can be shared.
Because SEO compatibility is not trivial in SPAs, it is worth noting that SPAs are commonly not used in a context where search engine indexing is either a requirement, or desirable. Use cases include applications that surface private data hidden behind an authentication system. In the cases where these applications are consumer products, often a classic "page redraw" model is used for the applications landing page and marketing site, which provides enough meta data for the application to appear as a hit in a search engine query. Blogs, support forums, and other traditional page redraw artifacts often sit around the SPA that can seed search engines with relevant terms.
Both of these do require quite a bit of effort, and can end up giving a maintenance headache for the large complex sites. There are also potential SEO pitfalls. If server-generated HTML is deemed to be too different from the SPA content, then the site will be penalized. Running PhantomJS to output the HTML can slow down the response speed of the pages, which is something for which search engines – Google in particular – downgrade the rankings.
Client/Server code partitioning
With an SPA being, by definition, "a single page", the model breaks the browser's design for page history navigation using the Forward/Back buttons. This presents a usability impediment when a user presses the back button, expecting the previous screen state within the SPA, but instead, the application's single page unloads and the previous page in the browser's history is presented.
Analytics tools such as Google Analytics rely heavily upon entire new pages loading in the browser, initiated by a new page load. SPAs do not work this way.
After the first page load, all subsequent page and content changes are handled internally by the application, which should simply call a function to update the analytics package. Failing to call said function, the browser never triggers a new page load, nothing gets added to the browser history, and the analytics package has no idea who is doing what on the site.
Adding page loads to an SPA
It is possible to add page load events to an SPA using the HTML5 history API; this will help integrate analytics. The difficulty comes in managing this and ensuring that everything is being tracked accurately – this involves checking for missing reports and double entries. Some frameworks provide open source analytics integrations addressing most of the major analytics providers. Developers can integrate them into the application and make sure that everything is working correctly, but there is no need to do everything from scratch.
Speed of initial load
Single Page Applications have a slower first page load than server-based applications. This is because the first load has to bring down the framework and the application code before rendering the required view as HTML in the browser. A server-based application just has to push out the required HTML to the browser, reducing the latency and download time.
Speeding up the page load
There are some ways of speeding up the initial load of an SPA, such as a heavy approach to caching and lazy-loading modules when needed. But it's not possible to get away from the fact that it needs to download the framework, at least some of the application code, and will most likely hit an API for data before displaying something in the browser. This is a "pay me now, or pay me later" trade-off scenario. The question of performance and wait-times remains a decision that the developer must make.
An SPA is fully loaded in the initial page load and then page regions are replaced or updated with new page fragments loaded from the server on demand. To avoid excessive downloading of unused features, an SPA will often progressively download more features as they become required, either small fragments of the page, or complete screen modules.
In this way an analogy exists between "states" in an SPA and "pages" in a traditional website. Because "state navigation" in the same page is analogous to page navigation, in theory, any page-based web site could be converted to single-page replacing in the same page only the changed parts result of comparing consecutive pages in a non-SPA.
The SPA approach on the web is similar to the Single Document Interface (SDI) presentation technique popular in native desktop applications.
- "Fixing the Back Button: SPA Behavior using Location Hash". Falafel Software Blog. Retrieved 2016-01-18.
- "Inner-Browsing: Extending Web Browsing the Navigation Paradigm". Retrieved 2011-02-03.
- "Slashdotslash.com: A self contained website using DHTML". Retrieved 2012-07-06.
- "US patent 8,136,109". Retrieved 2002-04-12.
- "Meteor Blaze".
Meteor Blaze is a powerful library for creating live-updating user interfaces. Blaze fulfills the same purpose as Angular, Backbone, Ember, React, Polymer, or Knockout, but is much easier to use. We built it because we thought that other libraries made user interface programming unnecessarily difficult and confusing.
- Introducing DDP, March 21, 2012
- "Server Side Rendering for Meteor". Archived from the original on 20 March 2015. Retrieved 31 January 2015.
- blak-it.com, BLAKIT, (2017-10-17). "Single-page applications vs. multiple-page applications: pros, cons, pitfalls - BLAKIT - IT Solutions". BLAKIT - IT Solutions. Retrieved 2017-10-19.
- "Real-Time Monitoring using AJAX and WebSockets". www.computer.org. Retrieved 2016-06-01.
- "AJAX over WebSockets". /makoserver.net. Retrieved 2018-11-01.
- "Server-Sent Events". W3C. 17 July 2013.
- "Using InnerHTML". www.webrocketx.com. Retrieved 2016-01-21.
- "Unhosted web apps".
- "The Single Page Interface Manifesto". Retrieved 2014-04-25.
- "Derby". Retrieved 2011-12-11.
- "Sails.js". Retrieved 2013-02-20.
- "Tutorial: Single Page Interface Web Site With ItsNat". Retrieved 2011-01-13.
- "What the user sees, what the crawler sees". Retrieved January 6, 2014.
- "Making Ajax Applications Crawlable". Retrieved January 6, 2014.
Historically, Ajax applications have been difficult for search engines to process because Ajax content is produced
- "Proposal for making AJAX crawlable". Google. October 7, 2009. Retrieved July 13, 2011.
- "(Specifications) Making AJAX Applications Crawlable". Google. Retrieved March 4, 2013.
- "Hash URIs". W3C Blog. May 12, 2011. Retrieved July 13, 2011.
- "Deprecating our AJAX crawling scheme". Official Google Webmaster Central Blog. Retrieved 2017-02-23.
- "ItsNat v1.3 release Notes". Retrieved 2013-06-09.
- Holmes, Simone (2015). Getting MEAN with Mongo, Express, Angular, and Node. Manning Publications. ISBN 978-1-6172-9203-3