Sky City (Changsha)
Artist's impression of Sky City
|Architectural style||Supertall skyscraper|
|Location||Changsha, Hunan, China|
9 billion Chinese yuan
|Owner||Broad Sustainable Building|
|Management||Broad Sustainable Building|
|Architectural||838 m (2,749 ft)|
|Tip||838 m (2,749 ft)|
|Roof||727 m (2,385 ft)|
|Top floor||733.5 m (2,406 ft)|
|Observatory||733.5 m (2,406 ft)|
|Structural system||Prefabricated modular|
(6 below ground)
|Floor area||1,050,000 m2 (11,302,106 sq ft)|
|Design and construction|
|Developer||Broad Sustainable Building|
|Main contractor||China State Construction Engineering|
Sky City (Chinese: 天空城市; pinyin: tiānkōng chéngshì), or Sky City One, was an 838-metre-tall (2,749 ft) planned skyscraper in the city of Changsha, Hunan in south-central China. The prospective builders, Broad Sustainable Building, estimated it would take just 90 days to construct. Including the 120 days required for prefabrication before on-site work commences, the sum of time needed is 210 days. Pre-construction activities were halted in August 2013 after government regulators required additional approvals.
Broad Sustainable Building had intended to build a 666-metre (2,185 ft) skyscraper, but the local government wanted the world's tallest building, hence the current plans. The company has constructed 20 buildings in China using the same method and has several franchise partners globally. It has a planned helipad at a height of 739.8 m (2,427 ft) above ground.
On June 8, 2016 it was reported by the People's Daily that the project had been dropped due to protests over environmental damage to the Daze Lake wetland. The People's Daily said, "Central China's Hunan province finally announced a halt on its ambitious plan to build the world's tallest tower within one part of its rare wetland area. The Daze Lake wetland is the location where the world's next tallest tower was originally scheduled to be built. This wetland is now listed as one of the 20 waters to be permanently protected and will follow non-construction zone policies. It is a pristine wetland hailed as the last wetland in Changsha where many rare bird species take habitat. Shelter of these birds would be largely disrupted by the building of this tower." However Broad Group declared: "We will definitely build the tower".
If it is built as planned, Sky City would be the tallest building in the world, until the Jeddah Tower in Jeddah is complete (currently under construction, planned to be opened in 2019), with 202 floors. The construction plan calls for it to be built from pre-fabricated units constructed on site in an unprecedentedly short period of 90 days. BSB's plan is to assemble 95% of the building in its factory before any excavation takes place at the construction site. The fabrication process is due to take around six months before the actual construction begins.
According to the plan, the building's 202 stories will have a hotel accommodating 1000 guests, a hospital, 5 schools, and offices. Of the total space available, nearly 83% will be for residential purposes, housing up to 17,000 people. Another 5% will be for the hotel housing 1000, while 3% each will be dedicated to schools, hospitals, offices and shops. There will be 10 fire escape routes, which will evacuate a given floor within 15 minutes; the building will be fire-resistant for up to three hours. It will also have 17 helipads. Sport facilities will include six basketball courts and 10 tennis courts. Plans include preserving some green space around the building.
For transportation there will be 104 high-speed elevators installed. The safety of these potential elevators has been questioned because they take several minutes to get from bottom to top. The 5000 residential properties will be able to accommodate 17,400 residents. The proposed building will have total floor space of 1.2 million m2 (13 million sq ft). The main building will have 1.05 million m2 (11 million sq ft) of this area, with a basement of 130,000 m2 (1,400,000 sq ft) and a 3 to 7 floor-high annex of 35,000 m2 (380,000 sq ft). The total capacity of the building will be about 30,000.
The 4-layered glass used for the building's windows will keep the temperature of the building constant between 20 to 27 °C (68 to 81 °F). The air indoors will be filtered to be up to 20 times cleaner than the air outside. The lamps used in the building will be made of LEDs. The builders have claimed to be working with some of the same architects who designed the Burj Khalifa, such as Adrian Smith.
The project is planned to consume 270,000 tons of steel. For its assembly factory, sustainable building technology and independent research and development will be required. The main advantages of the building will be its earthquake resistance, energy saving, cleanliness, durability, and materials, which consist of recycled building materials, non-aldehyde / non-lead / non-asbestos building materials, etc. The technology at the core of the whole steel structure is modular construction. The building would have 6 inches (15 cm) of insulated walls and quadruple glazing, contributing greatly to energy efficiency. The building will be designed to resist earthquakes of up to 9.0 on the Richter magnitude scale.
Although structural details are not available, outside architects have expressed doubts that a modular design would have the stiffness on lower floors to withstand the wind loads imposed by such a height, without unacceptable amounts of sway, or that the building could be built without high-strength concrete, whose curing time would preclude such a rapid construction rate. Most of the construction and production of materials will take place on site so as to benefit the local economy of Changsha.
As currently planned, Sky City would cost RMB 9 billion ($1.46 billion) to build. A cost estimate of $1,500 per square meter of floor space would make Sky City considerably cheaper than the similarly tall Burj Khalifa ($4,500 per square meter). Broad Sustainable Group has purchased 67,300 m2 (724,000 sq ft) of land, for a cost of 390 million yuan ($63 million).
The start date for the project has been moved back several times due to delays in getting government approval to start construction, and amidst multiple conflicting announcements about whether the project has received final approvals. In October 2012, the group announced that they had received approval from the local government and that construction would begin in November, but announced a new build time of 210 days. This meant completion of the project in June 2013. On November 16, 2012, Juliet Jiang, senior vice president of Broad Group, said in an interview that the company would adhere to its previous time table of building five floors a day and completing the building in a 90-day time frame. She also said the building was still waiting for government approval. Later that month the company announced January 2013 as the start for the construction.
The final architectural renderings had been completed and the project was to be approved by the central government in early December 2012. Construction was scheduled to begin at some point in 2013 and plans still called for the 90 day timetable to complete.
On June 17, 2013, Broad Sustainable Building Group Chairman Zhang Yue said that construction would commence in August 2013 with the first four months spent for prefabrication and the next three months for installation onsite. The expected date of completion was March 2014.
On July 20, 2013, pictures of the groundbreaking ceremony, at which Zhang Yue arrived by helicopter, along with several dignitaries, started to circulate on Chinese websites and Skyscy. These reports suggest that China State Construction Engineering is the main contractor, that the building was expected to be complete by April, and that it would open in May or June 2014.
On July 25, 2013, it was reported that construction was halted by the authorities because the building did not receive adequate permission. On August 14, 2013, China Daily USA reported that the actual onsite assembly won't start until April 2014, according to Wang Shuguang, general manager of Broad Group's US operation. On September 4, 2013, China.com.cn reported that the project had begun environmental assessment, the first of a number of stages in obtaining official planning approval for the project. By October 30, the building was in the final approval phases, according to Broad Group.
As of October 2014[update] there appear to be no reliable reports that even offsite prefabrication has started. The company has recently confirmed that it is still actively seeking to develop the tower, pending government approvals.
In February 2015 the developer attracted attention when Mini Sky City, also located in Changsha, topped out, the 204 metre tower was built in two bursts, the first twenty floors went up in a week but was then halted by red tape, the second phase of thirty-seven storeys was completed in twelve working days. The developer has reiterated his determination to build the full-size Sky City and stated that construction would start by early 2016, however buildings of 350m need to be approved at the national level in Beijing thus the official start date is unclear.
In July 2015, it was reported that no work had been done on the site for more than two years. The excavated foundation pits were being used by local villagers as fish ponds. The developer stated that there was no further news on securing approval for the building. Furthermore, the project was scrapped in June 2016 due to environmental concerns. The no-construction zone will span a total of 199.5 square kilometers.
In 2017 Sky City renderings show a different site has been chosen near waterfront area.
Simon Lake from AECOM asked "Is the Sky City an inevitable response to the needs of the many from the East against designers from the west who has spent the last few years designing for the perceived desires of the rich few and if that is the case and given that 7 billion are going to be living in cities by 2050 and that most of those people are going to be from the poor end of the income spectrum rather than the rich. Does that make the future for tall buildings Sky City rather than glass and other fancy icons that we see at the moment". In response Zhang Yue of BSB Changsha stated during the CTBUH conference that he believes buildings over 100 stories tall, between 100 and 200 should be appropriate for China's large scale urbanization, because there's not enough land for building and infrastructure.
Bob Lang, Director, Arup seemed relatively scared according to Ken Shuttleworth, Founder of Make Architects who encouraged the initiatives of Zhang Yue as he sees it pushing the boundaries of construction. Panel moderator spokesman stated that he thinks the application in places that are a lot less sophisticated than China that are going to have huge population expansions into cities like Bangladesh, Pakistan, Nigeria places like that.
Developing buildings around 400m will become like shipbuilding of the current generation many of which are around 400m. As such it's inevitably also likely that skyscrapers construction would become outsourced to lower cost countries where sections and modules would be manufactured in prefabricated parts and shipped for assembly at various construction sites around the world just like the way major sections of bridges, ships, larger than 600m oil platforms, ship to shore cranes and container, cargo, petroleum and passenger ships.
The project faces a great deal of skepticism due to the nature of its claims, and doubts have been expressed about Broad Group's ability to complete such a project in such a short time. There is also speculation that it is a marketing ploy rather than an actual project. The head of structures for WSP Middle East (the company behind The Shard in London), Bart Leclercq, jokingly said that he would give up structural engineering if the project were completed on time. Even so, he and others have commended the project for its use of innovative prefabrication techniques.
Doubts have also been cast by critics over the ability of the Broad Group to achieve such a grand scale project, especially since they had previously constructed only two buildings, neither of which is over 30 floors. A tower of such height requires stiffness, which in turn would require enormous amounts of concrete and steel and a lengthy period of time for it to settle. The ability of the engineers to understand the complexity of a project this size has also come into question. (The later Mini Sky City is 57 stories, and took 19 days of actual build time, see above.)
Another factor that may have been overlooked in the designs, according to engineers,[who?] is the wind factor. A building with such a height and shape will need to deal with large horizontal forces, but a wind strategy seems to be absent from the Broad Group's blueprint on the tower. Because of a lack of stiffness, winds would generate a huge draft around the building and would cause it to sway, making it potentially unstable.
Other concerns by critics have related to the tower's ability to deal with emergencies. In case of a fire, there might not be means to douse it or to evacuate people as fire rescue crews are generally not equipped to reach such heights. Also, the elevators might be too slow to transport people who need emergency treatment to the hospital in time (though the building is planned to include a hospital). Finally, the structure may also cause subsidence in the local soil.
While Dr. Sang Dae Kim, chairman of the Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat, has claimed that towers up to 2 kilometers are possible with modern technology, he has said that the floor to elevator ratio at that height would be impractical.
- Liu, Evie (July 25, 2013). "Sky City China: China Starts Work On World's Tallest Building". CNN. Retrieved August 23, 2013.
- "Why Sky City?" (PDF). Broad Group. 20 July 2013. Archived from the original (PDF) on 11 September 2015. Retrieved 18 August 2013.
- "Sky City Facts - CTBUH Skyscraper Database". CTBUH. Retrieved 21 July 2014.
- "Broad Global | 远大集团". Bsb.broad.com. Archived from the original on 2013-05-11. Retrieved 2012-12-07.
- "Broad Global | 远大集团". Bsb.broad.com. Archived from the original on 2013-06-07. Retrieved 2012-12-07.
- China builds 'world's tallest building'- China.org.cn
- "Huilongzhou Village is witnessing a paradigm shift".
- "Plans for Changsha's 838-Meter Sky City Officially Scrapped Amid Environmental Concerns".
- "Sky City - The Skyscraper Center".
- Chang, Gordon G. (2012-06-17). "Visit China's Changsha, See World's Tallest Building". Forbes.com. Retrieved 2012-06-29.
- Holloway, James (18 June 2012). "World's tallest building to be built in only 90 days". Gizmag.
- "Sky City: China plans world's tallest building". CNN. 11 June 2012.
- "World's tallest tower in China will be ready by March 2014". emirates247.com. 2013-06-17. Retrieved 2013-06-17.
- Bradsher, Keith (August 28, 2013). "Across China, Skyscrapers Brush the Heavens". The New York Times. p. B1. Retrieved August 30, 2013.
- "Update On Sky City One: Interview With Architect Xian Min Zhang".
- "Broad sticks to 90-day completion target | The Malay Mail". Mmail.com.my. 2012-11-16. Archived from the original on 2013-05-09. Retrieved 2012-12-23.
- "Planned skyscraper plot in China repurposed as fish farm". Dezeen. 2015-07-20. Retrieved 2016-05-21.
- F_200788. "Hunan drops ambition on world's tallest building amid protests - People's Daily Online".
- Staff, WSJ. "China's Edifice Complex: A Setback Delays World's Tallest Tower".
- "Chine Plan To Construct World's Tallest Building Very Quickly". 20 June 2012.
- China Daily USA article on Sky city
- Qian, Wang; Zhiwei, Feng (November 29, 2012). "Sky City falls short in safety features: Critics". China Daily. Retrieved December 4, 2012.
- "220 Story Sky City Close To Breaking Ground".
- "Chinese company plans to build world's tallest skyscraper - in just THREE MONTHS".
- Ephgrave, Oliver (2012-08-08). "Can China build its Burj beater in 90 days?". ArabianBusiness.com. Retrieved 2012-11-20.
‘If they manage to build this structure in three months then I will give up structural engineering. I will hang my hat and retire. I will be eating humble pie as well.’
- Zeveloff, Julie (November 26, 2012). "Why China's Plan To Build The World's Tallest Skyscraper In 90 Days Is 'Madness'". Business Insider. Retrieved December 4, 2012.
- Coonan, Clifford (2012-11-21). "China to build world's tallest building - in just 90 days - Asia - World". The Independent. Retrieved 2012-12-07.
- "World's Tallest Skyscraper to Be Built in 210 Days Instead of 90 as Originally Planned".
- China Plans to Build the World's Largest Skyscraper in Just 90 Days. Retrieved 2012-11-22.
- Deulgaonkar, Parag (November 25, 2012). "Will really Sky City, China, overtake Dubai's Burj Khalifa by March 2013?". Emirates 24/7. Retrieved December 3, 2012.
- Blua, Antoine (2012-11-21). "China To Build Tallest Building 'In 90 Days'". Rferl.org. Retrieved 2012-12-07.
- "China Plans to Build the World's Tallest Building in Just 90 Days | TIME.com". Newsfeed.time.com. 2012-11-20. Retrieved 2012-12-07.
- "One Building, One City: World's tallest prefab, Sky City, is breaking ground in June". treehugger.com. 2013-05-14. Retrieved 2013-05-17.
- [htty.com/showthread.php?p=105477315&posted=1#post105477315 CHANGSHA | Sky City | 838m | 2749ft | 202 fl | Prep - Page 82 - SkyscraperCity]
- 338. "六大释疑详解长沙"世界最高楼" 能保9级地震不倒 - 头条新闻 - 湖南在线 - 华声在线".
- "China blocks world's tallest skyscraper but not the curse | beyondbrics". Blogs.ft.com. 2013-07-25. Retrieved 2013-08-17.
- "Sky City aims high on many levels". 2013-08-14.
- "長沙世界第一高樓"天空城市"開始環評 Changsha's World's Tallest Building "Sky City" begins environmental assessment". China.com.cn. 2013-09-04. Archived from the original on 2013-11-13. Retrieved 2013-11-13.
- "Sky City to Possibly Begin Construction, BSB Makes Plans for Sky City II". ctbuh.org. Council on Tall Buildings and Urban Habitat. October 30, 2013. Retrieved January 22, 2014.
- Aberdein, Finn (11 June 2015). "Chairman Zhang's flatpack skyscrapers". BBC.co.uk. Retrieved 14 June 2015.
- Xie, Changgui (14 July 2015). "Sky City halted for more than 2 years, villagers place wire cages in foundation pits to raise fish (天空城市停摆2年 村民在大楼基坑中放网箱养鱼)". Southern.com. Retrieved 14 July 2015.
- en.people.cn. June 2016 http://en.people.cn/n3/2016/0608/c90000-9069800.htm. Retrieved 18 September 2016. Missing or empty
- "Syed Mokhtar AlBukhary". www.facebook.com. Retrieved 2017-12-23.
- Ephgrave, Oliver (2012-07-16). "Engineer to retire if China achieves super-quick tower | Design Middle East". Designmena.com. Retrieved 2012-12-23.
- Ephgrave, Oliver (2012-08-09). "The need for Speed | Design Middle East". Designmena.com. Retrieved 2012-12-23.
- Wheeler, Carolynne (2012-09-28). "World's tallest tower plan raises eyebrows". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved 2013-01-22.
- Deulgaonkar, Parag (5 July 2012). "Another world's tallest? Now 2-km high tower is coming up..."
- Ephgrave, Oliver (2012-09-08). "The need for Speed, page 2 | Design Middle East". Designmena.com. Retrieved 2012-12-23.
- Ephgrave, Oliver. "Skyscraper expert says 2km tower is now possible - ConstructionWeekOnline.com".
- Sky City Videos
- BBC News: Chairman's Zhang's flatpack skyscrapers 
- Skyrise Cities: http://skyrisecities.com/news/2016/06/environmental-concerns-halt-plans-worlds-tallest-building