|Dates||Various dates during the Summer months|
|Location(s)||Slane Castle, Slane, County Meath, Ireland|
|Years active||1981 - present|
Slane Concert (often referred to as Slane) is a recurring concert held most years since 1981 on the grounds of Slane Castle near Slane, County Meath, Ireland. The castle is owned by The 8th Marquess Conyngham, who was known by the courtesy title the Earl of Mount Charles from 1974 until 2009. Slane lies between Navan and Drogheda, about 45 km northwest of Dublin. Concerts typically occur on a Saturday in August, from 12:00 to 22:00. However, the 2011, 2015 and 2017 concerts occurred on the last weekend in May, and the first concert of 2013 took place on 15 June.
The sloping grounds of Slane Castle form a natural amphitheatre which is ideal for concerts. As many as 70,000–110,000 people usually attend. One of the venue boundaries is the River Boyne. Two people died while trying to swim the river to gain free access to R.E.M.'s concert in 1995. The minimum age of admission to the Slane Concert was reduced in 2006 from 18 to 16 because of complaints.
Aiken Promotions invited artists such as David Bowie, Bob Dylan, Queen, The Rolling Stones, and Bruce Springsteen to perform during the 1980s. 2001 and 2013 are the only years in which two concerts were held in the same year. In 2001, both concerts were headlined by U2. In 2013, the first concert was headlined by Bon Jovi and the second by Eminem, who had controversially cancelled his 2005 Slane appearance after entering drug rehabilitation.
The most recent Slane concert took place on 27 May 2017, with Guns N' Roses as the headliner.
- 1 Multiple appearances
- 2 List of Slane lineups
- 2.1 1980s
- 2.2 1990s
- 2.3 2000s
- 2.4 2010s
- 3 Future
- 4 Controversies
- 5 DVD and video
- 6 References
- 7 External links
Guns N' Roses, the Rolling Stones and U2 are the only bands to have headlined the event more than once, and U2 have played twice in one year. Thin Lizzy are the only band to headline and come back as a support act. Several other acts, listed below, have supported a headliner and returned as a headliner themselves.
|Guns N' Roses||1992, 2017|
|Foo Fighters||2003, 2015|
|Red Hot Chili Peppers||2001, 2003|
|Robbie Williams||1998, 1999|
|The Rolling Stones||1982, 2007|
|Thin Lizzy||1981, 2011|
|U2||1981, 1983, 2001 (twice)|
Some acts, listed below, have appeared more than once but never as a headline act:
|Big Country||1983, 1987|
|The Charlatans||2002, 2007|
1. The second of two concerts that occurred in this year.
List of Slane lineups
The first Slane Concert was held on 16 August 1981 by the Earl of Mount Charles (as The 8th Marquess Conyngham was then known). Concerts followed each year until 1987. The seven concerts of the 1980s were headlined respectively by Thin Lizzy, The Rolling Stones, U2, Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, Queen and David Bowie. For the third concert in 1983, headlined for the first time by U2, Slane Castle was refused permission to hold a concert, so it was held in the Phoenix Park Racecourse in Dublin on 14 August 1983, the only occasion it has been held outside Slane. U2 appeared at Slane in 1981 and 1983, whilst in 1984 Bono performed a duet with Bob Dylan during the latter's encore. This was the last appearance by a member of U2 on the Slane stage until their unique double-headliner in 2001. Thus, Bono has appeared at Slane on a total of five occasions, three of these being in the first four concerts.
1981, 16 August
- Mama´s Boys
- U2 - October Tour
- Hazel O'Connor's Megahype
- Rose Tattoo
- Sweet Savage
- The Bureau
- Thin Lizzy (headliner)
1982, 24 July
- The J. Geils Band
- The Chieftains
- George Thorogood and the Destroyers
- The Rolling Stones (headliner)
1983, 14 August
This year, the concert was held at the Phoenix Park Racecourse in Dublin.
- Perfect Crime 
- Steel Pulse
- Big Country
- Simple Minds
- U2 - War Tour (headliner)
- after the show the fans went on to sing 40 for over 15 minutes
1984, 8 July
- In Tua Nua
- Bob Dylan (headliner) with guests Carlos Santana, Van Morrison, and Bono during encores.
1985, 1 June
- Bruce Springsteen and the E Street Band played their debut Irish concert in front of 100,000 people, and performed for nearly three hours. Springsteen at Slane - Full Concert
While Springsteen sang The River, footage of the nearby River Boyne was shown on video screens; the footage was retained for the rest of his tour. Elvis Costello and members of Spandau Ballet and U2 were the then Lord Mount Charles's guests who enjoyed smoked salmon and champagne on the day.
After a five-year absence, the longest since the event began in 1981, Slane Concert returned in 1992. The five concerts of the 1990s were headlined respectively by Guns N' Roses, Neil Young, R.E.M., The Verve and Robbie Williams. The 1995 concert, headlined by R.E.M., was notable for the death of someone who attempted to swim the nearby River Boyne to reach the concert area. The same concert marked the debut of Oasis on the Slane stage; they returned in 2009 to headline the event. The 1998 event was headlined by The Verve, their last appearance in Ireland until Oxegen 2008; in 1998 the band appeared alongside special guests Manic Street Preachers and also Robbie Williams who would return the following year to headline. Stereophonics played support in 1999 and returned to headline in 2002. No members of U2 performed in the 1990s, the only decade in which this has been the case.
On 22 July 1995, R.E.M. played Slane on their first concert following Mike Mills's appendectomy. They were supported by Oasis, whose album (What's the Story) Morning Glory? would be released 3 months later and would return to headline the event in 2009. One fan threw a rock at the stage as Oasis prepared to play "Roll with It". This provoked Liam Gallagher to say, "If you don't like it, go fucking hang yourself". In 2009, this performance was described as being by "a lairy mob with attitude and half a dozen memorable songs to their credit".
The following performed at Slane Concert in 1995:
- Finlay Quaye
- The Seahorses
- Robbie Williams
- Special Guests Manic Street Preachers
- The Verve (headliner)
28 August 1999
The eight concerts of the 2000s were headlined respectively by Bryan Adams, U2 (twice), Stereophonics, Red Hot Chili Peppers, Madonna, The Rolling Stones and Oasis. Unusually, two concerts were held during 2001 (the Taoiseach asked the Minister for the Environment to fast-track some new legislation to allow the second concert to happen), both headlined by U2 and both featuring an entirely different set of support acts that brought the Slane debuts of Coldplay, Nelly Furtado, Ash, Kelis, The Walls and JJ72 whilst offering returns to Moby and Dara. Red Hot Chili Peppers also appeared for the first time and would return to headline the 2003 event.
The 2005 concert was intended to centre on rap instead of rock music, but Eminem cancelled his appearance (due on 17 September that year with support from 50 Cent, D-12, Obie Trice, Lloyd Banks, Young Buck, Olivia, Atlanta's Stat Quo and Flipsyde) after the event sold out. The promoter, MCD Productions, sought damages in the High Court. The resultant two-year break in 2005 and 2006 was followed by a return to Slane by The Rolling Stones, only the second artist after U2 to headline the event in two different years, and marking the twenty-fifth anniversary of their first appearance in 1982. Henry Conyngham's delay in the picking of suitable acts led to no concert in 2008; however Oasis headlined the final concert of Slane's third decade in 2009 with support from The Prodigy, Kasabian, Glasvegas and The Blizzards.
U2's headlining appearance sold out in 45 minutes. The first concert occurred the week after Bono's father died. The second concert coincided with the 2002 FIFA World Cup qualification – UEFA Group 2 match between the Republic of Ireland and the Netherlands, and was shown between Nelly Furtado and Ash at the request of fans. The second show was also filmed for the live video U2 Go Home: Live from Slane Castle, Ireland.
25 August 2001
Saturday 1 September 2001
- Ocean Color Scene
- Counting Crows
- The Revs
- The Charlatans, special guests
- Stereophonics (headliner)
- PJ Harvey
- Queens of the Stone Age
- Foo Fighters
- Red Hot Chili Peppers - By the Way World Tour (headliner)
The Madonna concert at Slane was compared to a football match by one manager, Johnny McDonnell. The Irish Times selected "This is the big time, it's like Madonna coming to Slane" as one of its quotes of that year.
In preparation for their third studio album, Celtic Woman performed at Slane Castle in County Meath, Ireland, on 23 and 24 August 2006, with this show airing on PBS during December 2006. The studio album, titled Celtic Woman: A New Journey, was released on 30 January 2007. As with their debut, the live performance was released on DVD simultaneously. This album immediately hit the Billboard 200 at #4 and the Billboard World Music chart at #1, moving their previous two releases down a notch and securing the top three positions on that chart for the group.
The Irish Independent described The Rolling Stones playing to "a mostly middle-aged crowd who were content to stand back, shielded from the rain in their wax jackets, and let the concert wash over them".
- Frankie Gavin
- The Hold Steady
- The Charlatans
- The Rolling Stones (headliner, in front of 68,647 people)
Oasis were joined by family members, including their mother Peggy, for the show. They began their performance with "Rock 'N' Roll Star" and finished with "Live Forever" and then returned for an encore of "Don't Look Back in Anger", "Falling Down", "Champagne Supernova" and "I Am the Walrus".Liam Gallagher shouted at the fans: "Slane Castle, you've been fucking biblical". Several Irish celebrities attended the concert, including footballers Gary Kelly, Stephen Ireland and John O'Shea and solicitor Gerald Kean.
Ten people were detained on public order offences throughout the day of the concert, including two people who were arrested on suspicion of drunk driving. MCD Productions asked fans to report any problems after complaints regarding transport facilities. Fiach Kelly, writing in The Irish Independent, reported on the "yoof element" where "you could be forgiven for thinking you had arrived at a rather large teenage disco".
- The Blizzards 
- Glasvegas 
- Kasabian 
- The Prodigy 
- Oasis (headliner)
There was no concert in 2010. Henry Conyngham had written in an Evening Herald column in February that Slane 2010 would take place in August and that it would involve an "international artist" but that he was still organising the event with Denis Desmond. However, he said during an interview in April on RTÉ Radio that there would not be a concert that year.
- The Whigs
- Thin Lizzy
- White Lies
- Kings of Leon (headliner)
In April 2012, Slane Castle's official Facebook page announced there would be no concert in 2012. The message read: "Good Morning guys, Lord Henry has announced this morning 'there will be no Slane this year, but 2013 will be busy'".
15 June 2013
17 August 2013
On 13 February 2014, Lord Henry Mountcharles announced that there would be no concert in 2014 as he could not find a good enough act.
Lord Henry stated the reason for the break in 2014 was that "there really wasn't an act that grabbed my imagination for this year." He went on to say that Slane would be back in 2015.
On 26 November 2014, it was announced that Foo fighters, along with Kaiser Chiefs, Hozier and two other unannounced bands would play Slane on 30 May 2015.
There was no concert at Slane in 2016. There were persistent rumours in 2015 and early 2016 of either AC/DC, Coldplay or the then newly reunited classic line up of Guns N' Roses featuring original members Axl Rose, guitarist Slash and bassist Duff McKagan playing a concert at Slane during Summer 2016.
However, on 15 February 2016, it was announced that no concert would take place at Slane Castle in 2016 due to difficulties in staging the concert as construction work on the Slane Castle Distillery was taking place at the castle.
It was announced that a concert would take place in Summer 2017 once construction work on the Distillery is complete.
In early December 2016, promotional posters for the rock band Guns N' Roses appeared in Dublin City. This fueled speculation of a forthcoming announcement that the band were going to play at Slane in Summer 2017.
On 5 December 2016, after many months of rumours and speculation, it was officially announced that Guns N' Roses would headline Slane 2017. The announcement was made by Lord Henry Mountcharles's son Alex and daughter Tamara during a press conference at Bruxelles pub in Dublin City Centre. It was the second time that Guns N' Roses played at Slane, having first played there 25 years previously, in 1992.
On 4 April 2017 the full lineup for the 2017 concert was announced, it featured:
The Irish Independent positively reviewed the concert and commented that "Twenty-five years after they first played Ireland's biggest gig, Guns N' Roses came, saw and conquered Slane Castle all over again."
Green Day's Billie Joe Armstrong has spoken to Hot Press magazine of his admiration for U2's shows at Slane and, in relation to his band performing there in 2010, commented: "It's something that's being looked at". However, the rumour, a recurring one in recent years, was dismissed for 2010 when the band opted to play a show in Marlay Park instead. Green Day played at the lower capacity Royal Hospital Kilmainham venue in Dublin on their Revolution Radio Tour in 2017. It is becoming increasingly unlikely that the band will ever play at Slane.
The Marquess Conyngham insists that the venue be played by rock bands and will not allow so-called 'manufactured bands' such as Westlife, Take That or Boyzone to play at his castle grounds. Westlife and Boyzone manager Louis Walsh maintains that Westlife have no interest in playing at Slane, saying a Croke Park concert would be a "dream come true" for his band and that it would be "a far better venue than a field in Meath".
The 2004 concert attracted protests from the people of Slane, as it was to be held on a Sunday. The inhabitants were afraid of repeats of the civil unrest that had occurred the last time a concert was held on a Sunday, in 1984. This was due to concert-goers arriving the day before, Saturday, and consuming large amounts of alcohol before the Sunday concert. The matter was resolved by postponing the start of the concert and having a notably smaller lineup than other years.
In 2009, Dublin Bus did not provide enough transport for those who purchased a return ticket, and there were no Garda Síochána near the buses. The concert ended between 22.30 and 23:00, yet thousands did not get a bus seat until 03:00. Lord Conyngham expected improvements for 2010.
2013 "Slanegirl" incident
After the 2013 Eminem concert, photographs were posted to social media websites showing a 17-year-old schoolgirl from the west of Ireland fellating two men in public at the concert and kissing one of them while he fondled her vulva. Video footage posted at the YouTube website showed men groping and jeering the girl as she kissed another man, while male and female teenagers encouraged her to fellate him. As the images spread quickly and widely across social media sites under the hashtag "#slanegirl," posters directed a barrage of abusive and mocking online comments at the young woman, who became so distraught that she was hospitalized and sedated. One of the men pictured in the photographs, a 19-year-old former amateur boxer from Belfast, went into hiding to escape media attention. The incident received international publicity, sparking intense debate about issues such as teenage sexual behaviour, double standards, cyberbullying, and slut-shaming. Lord Conyngham refused to comment, saying that it would be inappropriate for him to do so.
The Garda Síochána investigated the incident, while social media companies including Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram moved to curb circulation of the photographs by deleting pages or suspending user accounts for violating their terms of service. It later emerged that the girl had reported a sexual assault at the concert venue, unrelated to any incidents depicted online, and that she had been treated at a sexual assault unit. Gardaí subsequently confirmed that the girl had given a statement to them in the days following the concert, but said that she had made no official complaint and that no charges would be issued over the matter.
DVD and video
- Bob Dylan: 1984 45 minute audience video
- Bryan Adams: Live at Slane Castle (DVD)
- Celtic Woman: live at Slane Castle (DVD)
- Foo Fighters: Everywhere but Home (UMD, partial concert)
- Guns 'n' Roses: 1 hour 51 minute audience video
- Madonna: I'm Going to Tell You a Secret
- Neil Young: 1993 81 minute audience video
- Queen: 1986 63 minute audience video
- Red Hot Chili Peppers: Live at Slane Castle (DVD)
- Robbie Williams: Live at Slane (DVD)
- The Rolling Stones: 2007 1 hour audience video
- U2: U2 Go Home: Live from Slane Castle (DVD)
- U2: 2001 25 August first night 1 hour audience video
- Kings of Leon 2011 34 minute video
- Henry Vivien Pierpont Conyngham, 8th Marquess Conyngham thePeerage.com. Retrieved: 2011-05-31.
- U2 and Slane Castle gear up for 20-year reunion. RTÉ.
- "Kings of Leon Slane gig to go ahead, despite the death of their beloved uncle". The Daily Edge. 2011-05-27. Retrieved 2011-10-10.
- "Music Trivia Yesterdays: July". Phil Brodie Band. Retrieved 2011-10-10.
Two R.E.M. fans died during the bands Dublin's Slane Castle gig. One drowned in the River Boyne and the other was allegedly pushed from a bridge.
- "Jim Aiken dies at his home in Belfast". Hot Press. 2007-02-28. Retrieved 2009-04-18.
- Irish Examiner Archived 13 March 2007 at the Wayback Machine.
- U2 October Tour: 1 October leg: Europe: 1981-08-16: Slane Castle - Slane, Ireland U2gigs.com. Retrieved: 2013-07-19.
- "Rainy days & festivals". Irish Independent. 10 July 2004.
- http://www.irishrock.org/irodb/bands/perfectcrime.html Perfect Crime page at IrishRock.org
- U2's War 3rd leg: European Summer Festivals U2gigs.com. Retrieved: 2013-07-19.
- "Still On The Road: 1984 Europe Tour 7070". Bjorner. Retrieved 2013-07-19.
- "Springsteen draws 100,000 in Ireland" The Montreal Gazette, 1985-06-03.
- Marsh, Dave (2004). Bruce Springsteen: Two Hearts : The Definitive Biography, 1972-2003. New York: Routledge. p. 552. ISBN 0-415-96928X.
- Marsh, David. "Bruce Springsteen: two hearts : the definitive biography, 1972-2003", p. 558.
- remtimeline.com Archived 21 May 2011 at the Wayback Machine.. "1995 Concert Chronology".
- "Oasis Play Slane Castle Tomorrow!". 'entertainment.ie. 2009-06-19. Archived from the original on 15 June 2011. Retrieved 2009-06-19.
- "Review of the week: Oasis/The Prodigy * * *". Irish Independent. 2009-06-26. Retrieved 2009-07-02.
- "Date announced for Slane '99". RTÉ. 4 January 1999.
- Pierre Perrone (2000-04-16). "The infinite shades of Gray". The Independent. Retrieved 2009-09-26.
- "Taoiseach intervenes in Slane concert row". RTÉ. 13 March 2001
- "U2 fans could get second day out". RTÉ. 14 March 2001.
- "Eminem's Slane concert is sold out". RTÉ. 10 June 2005.
- "Concert promoter seeks €1.5m over Eminem pull-out". Irish Independent. 2006-12-05. Retrieved 2008-12-26.
- "Slane 2008 cancelled". Phantom FM. 2008-04-10. Archived from the original on 4 March 2009. Retrieved 2008-04-11.
- "Slane soccer fans will get their fix". RTÉ. 31 August 2001.
- "Second U2 Slane date sold out". RTÉ. 9 July 2001.
- "Walls to support U2 at Slane". RTÉ. 10 August 2001.
- "Stereophonics to play Slane?". RTÉ. 23 April 2002.
- "60,000 expected at Slane 2002". RTÉ. 23 August 2002.
- "Feeder are added to '03 Slane bill". RTÉ. 6 March 2003.
- "Chili Peppers Slane show confirmed". RTÉ. 26 February 2003.
- "Halite to join line-up for Slane". RTÉ. 30 April 2003.
- "Planet Football". The Irish Times Alternative link here. 2004-08-08. Retrieved 2009-07-17. External link in
- "Quotes of the year". The Irish Times Alternative link here. 2004-12-12. Retrieved 2009-07-17. External link in
- "Castle rocks in throwback to a 1990s teenage disco". Irish Independent. 2009-06-22. Retrieved 2009-06-22.
- "Oasis rock 80,000 at Slane". The Irish Times. 2009-06-21. Retrieved 2009-06-21.
- "Slane support line-up confirmed". Hot Press. 2009-05-05. Retrieved 2009-05-06.
- "Slane stage times announced". Hot Press. 2009-06-16. Retrieved 2009-06-17.
- "Etc". The Irish Times. 2009-06-19. Retrieved 2009-06-19.
- "The Prodigy added to Slane line-up". Hot Press. 2008-10-21. Retrieved 2008-10-22.
- Oasisinet Archived 29 October 2008 at the Wayback Machine.
- Lord Henry Mountcharles (12 February 2010). "Celebrity Diary: Lord Henry Mountcharles". Evening Herald. Archived from the original on 4 August 2012. Retrieved 12 February 2010.
At the moment, I'm putting a concert together with Denis for this August. It will be an international artist, but I have a reputation for being very secretive. Unless I'm convinced that the i's are dotted and the t's are crossed, I'm not saying anything, and that's been my policy for 30 years.
- No concert at Slane Castle this year. RTÉ. Archived 6 April 2010 at the Wayback Machine.
- Clayton Lea, Tony."Kings at home in castle". The Irish Times. Retrieved on 29 May 2011.
- "Kings of Leon headline at Slane" (including video footage). RTÉ News, 2011-05-28.
- "Full line-up for Slane is confirmed". RTÉ. 5 April 2011.
- "Revised times for Slane sets". RTÉ. 27 May 2011.
- "No concert at Slane Castle this year". RTÉ News. 19 April 2012. Retrieved 19 April 2012.
- "Facebook Message". Facebook.com. 19 April 2012. Retrieved 19 April 2012.
- Eminem delivers to the marshalled masses Irish Times, 2013-08-18.
- Garda probe incident at Slane Castle involving teenage girl Irish Independent, 2013-08-19.
- Lord Henry announces Slane will not go ahead in 2014 Irish Mirror, 2014-02-13.
- "We'll be Red Hot at Slane again, vow Chili Peppers". Evening Herald. 2009-06-26. Retrieved 2009-07-03.
- "Green Day for Slane?". Hot Press. 2009-10-07. Retrieved 2009-10-07.
- "Green Day to play Marlay Park, June 2010". Hot Press. 2009-12-15. Retrieved 2009-12-18.
The announcement should definitively end speculation that the band will play Slane, which has been rumoured for a number of years now.
- Kevin Doyle (2009-12-15). "Green Day return to play summer Marlay Park gig". Evening Herald. Archived from the original on 17 February 2013. Retrieved 2009-12-18.
- "Westlife plan concert at Croke Park". RTÉ Mobile. 2002-08-20. Archived from the original on 4 March 2009. Retrieved 2008-12-13.
- "Efforts to prevent Slane concert". RTÉ. 9 April 2004.
- Carr, Aoife. "Crowds at Oasis show critical of transport". The Irish Times. Monday, 22 June 2009.
- "Lord Henry's response to this year's Slane concert". Hot Press. 2009-07-03. Retrieved 2009-07-03.
- Foy, Ken (19 August 2013). "Garda probe incident at Slane Castle involving teenage girl". Irish Independent. Retrieved 20 August 2013.
- Keogh, Elaine; Ó Fátharta, Conall (20 August 2013). "Gardaí probe Slane sex act". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 20 August 2013.
- "Gardaí investigate 'Slane girl' images". UTV News. 20 August 2013. Archived from the original on 20 August 2013. Retrieved 20 August 2013.
- Lally, Conor (21 August 2013). "Gardaí expect formal complaint from girl in sex act video". Irish Times. Retrieved 21 August 2013.
- Ó Fátharta, Conall (22 August 2013). "Gardaí to question Slane teenager "in the next day or so"". Irish Examiner. Retrieved 26 August 2013.
- Foy, Ken (21 August 2013). "Gardai investigate new Slane video showing schoolgirl 'groped' by gang". Irish Independent. Retrieved 21 August 2013.
- Gye, Hugo (20 August 2013). "'Distraught' girl, 17, faces humiliation on the web after explicit pictures of her performing sex acts at Eminem gig go viral on Twitter and Instagram". Daily Mail. Retrieved 21 August 2013.
- Donald, Niall (26 August 2013). "Young man in hiding after Slane backlash". Sunday World. Archived from the original on 29 August 2013. Retrieved 29 August 2013.
- Ditum, Sarah (19 August 2013). "Why it's different for girls: slut-shaming in the digital age". New Statesman. Retrieved 20 August 2013.
- Carbery, Genevieve (20 August 2013). "Sharers of Slane sex act photo 'just as bad' as uploader, group says". Irish Times. Retrieved 20 August 2013.
- Murphy, Doyle (21 August 2013). "'Slane Girl' - concert-goer who was photographed performing sex acts - hospitalized after vicious cyberbullying". New York Daily News. Retrieved 22 August 2013.
- Wiseman, Eva (1 September 2013). "The Slane Girl Twitter scandal proves that women can't make mistakes". The Observer. Retrieved 1 September 2013.
- McDonough, Katie (20 August 2013). "Sexual double standards, slut-shaming and #Slanegirl". Salon.com. Retrieved 26 August 2013.
- Keogh, Elaine (20 August 2013). "Social media firms try to block images of Slane sex act". Irish Times. Retrieved 20 August 2013.
- Foy, Ken (8 November 2013). "No charges in 'Slane Girl' case". Irish Independent. Retrieved 6 December 2013.
- Official website for Slane concerts
- Hot Press photo albums: "Oasis for Slane: Noel and Gem helicopter in to the Castle" "Oasis live @ Slane 09"
- 'Slain' 2009 review