Solar water heating
|Part of a series about|
Solar water heating (SWH) is the conversion of sunlight into renewable energy for water heating using a solar thermal collector. Solar water heating systems comprise various technologies that are used worldwide increasingly.
In a "close-coupled" SWH system the storage tank is horizontally mounted immediately above the solar collectors on the roof. No pumping is required as the hot water naturally rises into the tank through thermosiphon flow. In a "pump-circulated" system the storage tank is ground- or floor-mounted and is below the level of the collectors; a circulating pump moves water or heat transfer fluid between the tank and the collectors.
SWH systems are designed to deliver hot water for most of the year. However, in winter there sometimes may not be sufficient solar heat gain to deliver sufficient hot water. In this case a gas or electric booster is used to heat the water.
- 1 Overview
- 2 History
- 3 System design requirements
- 4 Types of solar water heating systems
- 5 Collectors used in modern domestic SWH systems
- 6 Heating of swimming pools
- 7 Economics, energy, environment, and system costs
- 8 Do-it-yourself (DIY) systems
- 9 System specification and installation
- 10 Standards
- 11 APPENDIX 1. Worldwide use
- 12 See also
- 13 References
- 14 External links
Water heated by the sun is used in various ways. While perhaps best known in a residential setting to provide domestic hot water, solar hot water also has industrial applications, e.g. to generate electricity. Designs suitable for hot climates can be much simpler and cheaper, and can be considered an appropriate technology for these places. The global solar thermal market is dominated by China, Europe, Japan and India.
In order to heat water using solar energy, a collector, often fastened to a roof or a wall facing the sun, heats a working fluid that is either pumped (active system) or driven by natural convection (passive system) through it. The collector could be made of a simple glass-topped insulated box with a flat solar absorber made of sheet metal, attached to copper heat exchanger pipes and dark-colored, or a set of metal tubes surrounded by an evacuated (near vacuum) glass cylinder. In industrial cases a parabolic mirror can concentrate sunlight on the tube. Heat is stored in a hot water storage tank. The volume of this tank needs to be larger with solar heating systems in order to allow for bad weather[clarification needed], and because the optimum final temperature for the solar collector[clarification needed] is lower than a typical immersion or combustion heater. The heat transfer fluid (HTF) for the absorber may be the hot water from the tank, but more commonly (at least in active systems) is a separate loop of fluid containing anti-freeze and a corrosion inhibitor which delivers heat to the tank through a heat exchanger (commonly a coil of copper heat exchanger tubing within the tank). Copper is an important component in solar thermal heating and cooling systems because of its high heat conductivity, resistance to atmospheric and water corrosion, sealing and joining by soldering, and mechanical strength. Copper is used both in receivers and primary circuits (pipes and heat exchangers for water tanks).
Another lower-maintenance concept is the 'drain-back': no anti-freeze is required; instead, all the piping is sloped to cause water to drain back to the tank. The tank is not pressurized and is open to atmospheric pressure. As soon as the pump shuts off, flow reverses and the pipes are empty before freezing could occur.
Residential solar thermal installations fall into two groups: passive (sometimes called "compact") and active (sometimes called "pumped") systems. Both typically include an auxiliary energy source (electric heating element or connection to a gas or fuel oil central heating system) which is activated when the water in the tank falls below a minimum temperature setting such as 55 °C. Hence, hot water is always available. The combination of solar water heating and using the back-up heat from a wood stove chimney to heat water can enable a hot water system to work all year round in cooler climates, without the supplemental heat requirement of a solar water heating system being met with fossil fuels or electricity.
When a solar water heating and hot-water central heating system are used in conjunction, solar heat will either be concentrated in a pre-heating tank that feeds into the tank heated by the central heating, or the solar heat exchanger will replace the lower heating element and the upper element will remain in place to provide for any heating that solar cannot provide. However, the primary need for central heating is at night and in winter when solar gain is lower. Therefore, solar water heating for washing and bathing is often a better application than central heating because supply and demand are better matched. In many climates, a solar hot water system can provide up to 85% of domestic hot water energy. This can include domestic non-electric concentrating solar thermal systems. In many northern European countries, combined hot water and space heating systems (solar combisystems) are used to provide 15 to 25% of home heating energy.
There are records of solar collectors in the United States dating back to before 1900, comprising a black-painted tank mounted on a roof. In 1896 Clarence Kemp of Baltimore, USA enclosed a tank in a wooden box, thus creating the first 'batch water heater' as they are known today. Although flat-plate collectors for solar water heating were used in Florida and Southern California in the 1920s there was a surge of interest in solar heating in North America after 1960, but especially after the 1973 oil crisis.
See Appendix 1 at the bottom of this article for a number of country-specific statistics on the "Use of solar water heating worldwide". Wikipedia also has country-specific articles about solar energy use (thermal as well as photovoltaic) in Australia, Canada, China, Germany, India, Israel, Japan, Portugal, Romania, Spain, the United Kingdom and the United States.
Israel, Cyprus and Greece are the per capita leaders in the use of solar water heating systems with over 30%–40% of homes using them.
Flat plate solar systems were perfected and used on a very large scale in Israel. In the 1950s there was a fuel shortage in the new Israeli state, and the government forbade heating water between 10 pm and 6 am. Levi Yissar built the first prototype Israeli solar water heater and in 1953 he launched the NerYah Company, Israel's first commercial manufacturer of solar water heating. Despite the abundance of sunlight in Israel, solar water heaters were used by only 20% of the population by 1967. Following the energy crisis in the 1970s, in 1980 the Israeli Knesset passed a law requiring the installation of solar water heaters in all new homes (except high towers with insufficient roof area). As a result, Israel is now the world leader in the use of solar energy per capita with 85% of the households today using solar thermal systems (3% of the primary national energy consumption), estimated to save the country 2 million barrels (320,000 m3) of oil a year, the highest per capita use of solar energy in the world.
In 2005, Spain became the first country in the world to require the installation of photovoltaic electricity generation in new buildings, and the second (after Israel) to require the installation of solar water heating systems in 2006.
The world saw a rapid growth of the use of solar warm water after 1960, with systems being marketed in Japan and Australia. Technical innovation has improved performance, life expectancy and ease of use of these systems. Installation of solar water heating has become the norm in countries with an abundance of solar radiation, like the Mediterranean, Japan, and Australia.
Colombia developed a local solar water heating industry thanks to the designs of Las Gaviotas, directed by Paolo Lugari. Driven by a desire to reduce costs in social housing, the team of Gaviotas studied the best systems from Israel and made adaptations as to meet the specifications set by the Banco Central Hipotecario (BCH) which prescribed that the system must be operational in cities like Bogotá where there are more than 200 days overcast. The ultimate designs were so successful that Las Gaviotas offered a 25-year warranty on any of its installations in 1984. Over 40,000 were installed and still function a quarter of a century later.
Solar water heating systems have become popular in China, where basic models start at around 1,500 yuan (US$235), much cheaper than in Western countries (around 80% cheaper for a given size of collector). It is said that at least 30 million Chinese households now have one and that the popularity is due to the efficient evacuated tubes which allow the heaters to function even under gray skies and at temperatures well below freezing.
System design requirements
The type, complexity, and size of a solar water heating system is mostly determined by:
- Changes in ambient temperature and solar radiation between summer and winter.
- The changes in ambient temperature during the day-night cycle.
- The possibility of the potable water or collector fluid overheating.
- The possibility of the potable water or collector fluid freezing.
The minimum requirements of the system are typically determined by the amount or temperature of hot water required during winter, when a system's output and incoming water temperature are typically at their lowest. The maximum output of the system is determined by the need to prevent the water in the system from becoming too hot.
Freeze protection measures prevent damage to the system due to the expansion of freezing transfer fluid. Drainback systems drain the transfer fluid from the system when the pump stops. Many indirect systems use antifreeze (e.g. Propylene glycol) in the heat transfer fluid.
In some direct systems, the collectors can be manually drained when freezing is expected. This approach is common in climates where freezing temperatures do not occur often, but is somewhat unreliable since the operator can forget to drain the system. Other direct systems use freeze-tolerant collectors made with flexible polymers such as silicone rubber.
A third type of freeze protection is freeze-tolerance, where low pressure polymer water channels made of silicone rubber simply expands on freezing. One such collector now has European Solar Keymark accreditation, following extra durability testing.
When no hot water has been used for a day or two, the fluid in the collectors and storage can reach very high temperatures in all systems except for those of the drainback variety. When the storage tank in a drainback system reaches its desired temperature, the pumps are shut off, putting an end to the heating process and thus preventing the storage tank from overheating.
One method of providing over heat protection is to dump the heat into a hot tub[further explanation needed].
Some active systems deliberately cool the water in the storage tank by circulating hot water through the collector at times when there is little sunlight or at night, causing increased heat loss. This is most effective in direct or thermal store plumbing and is virtually ineffective in systems that use evacuated tube collectors, due to their superior insulation. No matter the collector type, however, they may still overheat. High pressured sealed solar thermal systems versions ultimately rely on the operation of temperature and pressure relief valves. Low pressure, open vented ones have simpler, more reliable safety controls, typically an open vent.
Types of solar water heating systems
Direct and indirect systems
Direct or open loop systems circulate potable water through the collectors. They are relatively cheap but can have the following drawbacks:
- They offer little or no overheat protection unless they have a heat export pump.
- They offer little or no freeze protection, unless the collectors are freeze-tolerant.
- Collectors accumulate scale in hard water areas, unless an ion-exchange softener is used.
Until the advent of freeze-tolerant solar collectors, they were not considered suitable for cold climates since, in the event of the collector being damaged by a freeze, pressurized water lines will force water to gush from the freeze-damaged collector until the problem is noticed and rectified.
Indirect or closed loop systems use a heat exchanger that separates the potable water from the fluid, known as the "heat-transfer fluid" (HTF), that circulates through the collector. The two most common HTFs are water and an antifreeze/water mix that typically uses non-toxic propylene glycol. After being heated in the panels, the HTF travels to the heat exchanger, where its heat is transferred to the potable water. Though slightly more expensive, indirect systems offer freeze protection and typically offer overheat protection as well.
Passive and active systems
Passive systems rely on heat-driven convection or heat pipes to circulate water or heating fluid in the system. Passive solar water heating systems cost less and have extremely low or no maintenance, but the efficiency of a passive system is significantly lower than that of an active system. Overheating and freezing are major concerns.
Active systems use one or more pumps to circulate water and/or heating fluid in the system.
Though slightly more expensive, active systems offer several advantages:
- The storage tank can be situated lower than the collectors, allowing increased freedom in system design and allowing pre-existing storage tanks to be used.
- The storage tank can be hidden from view.
- The storage tank can be placed in conditioned or semi-conditioned space, reducing heat loss.
- Drainback tanks can be used.
- Superior efficiency.
- Increased control over the system.
Modern active solar water systems have electronic controllers that offer a wide range of functionality, such as the modification of settings that control the system, interaction with a backup electric or gas-driven water heater, calculation and logging of the energy saved by a SWH system, safety functions, remote access, and informative displays, such as temperature readings.
The most popular pump controller is a differential controller that senses temperature differences between water leaving the solar collector and the water in the storage tank near the heat exchanger. In a typical active system, the controller turns the pump on when the water in the collector is about 8–10 °C warmer than the water in the tank, and it turns the pump off when the temperature difference approaches 3–5 °C. This ensures the water always gains heat from the collector when the pump operates and prevents the pump from cycling on and off too often. (In direct systems this "on differential" can be reduced to around 4 °C because there is no heat exchanger impediment.)
Some active SWH systems use energy obtained by a small photovoltaic (PV) panel to power one or more variable-speed DC pump(s). To ensure proper performance and longevity of the pump(s), the DC-pump and PV panel must be suitably matched. Some PV pumped solar thermal systems are of the antifreeze variety and some use freeze-tolerant solar collectors. The solar collectors will almost always be hot when the pump(s) are operating (i.e., when the sun is bright), and some do not use solar controllers. Sometimes, however, a differential controller (that can also be powered by the DC output of a PV panel) is used to prevent the operation of the pumps when there is sunlight to power the pump but the collectors are still cooler than the water in storage. One advantage of a PV-driven system is that solar hot water can still be collected during a power outage if the sun is shining. Another advantage is that the operational carbon clawback of using mains pumped solar thermal (which typically negates up to 23% of its carbon savings) is completely avoided.
An active solar water heating system can be equipped with a bubble pump (also known as geyser pump) instead of an electric pump. A bubble pump circulates the heat transfer fluid (HTF) between collector and storage tank using solar power, without any external energy source, and is suitable for flat panel as well as vacuum tube systems. In a bubble pump system, the closed HTF circuit is under reduced pressure, which causes the liquid to boil at low temperature as it is heated by the sun. The steam bubbles form a geyser pump, causing an upward flow. The system is designed such that the bubbles are separated from the hot fluid and condensed at the highest point in the circuit, after which the fluid flows downward toward the heat exchanger caused by the difference in fluid levels. The HTF typically arrives at the heat exchanger at 70 °C and returns to the circulating pump at 50 °C. In frost-prone climates the HTF is water with propylene glycol anti-freeze added, usually in the ratio of 60 to 40. Pumping typically starts at about 50 °C and increases as the sun rises until equilibrium is reached, which depends on the efficiency of the heat exchanger, the temperature of the water being heated, and the total solar energy available.
Passive direct systems
An integrated collector storage (ICS or Batch Heater) system uses a tank that acts as both storage and solar collector. Batch heaters are basically thin rectilinear tanks with a glass side facing the position of the sun at noon. They are simple and less costly than plate and tube collectors, but they sometimes require extra bracing if installed on a roof (since they are heavy when filled with water [400–700 lbs],) suffer from significant heat loss at night since the side facing the sun is largely uninsulated, and are only suitable in moderate climates.
A convection heat storage unit (CHS) system is similar to an ICS system, except the storage tank and collector are physically separated and transfer between the two is driven by convection. CHS systems typically use standard flat-plate type or evacuated tube collectors, and the storage tank must be located above the collectors for convection to work properly. The main benefit of a CHS systems over an ICS system is that heat loss is largely avoided since (1) the storage tank can be better insulated, and (2) since the panels are located below the storage tank, heat loss in the panels will not cause convection, as the cold water will prefer to stay at the lowest part of the system.
Active indirect systems: drainback and antifreeze
Pressurized antifreeze or pressurized glycol systems use a mix of antifreeze (almost always non-toxic propylene glycol) and water mix for HTF in order to prevent freeze damage.
Though effective at preventing freeze damage, antifreeze systems have many drawbacks:
- If the HTF gets too hot (for example, when the homeowner is on vacation,) the glycol degrades into acid. After degradation, the glycol not only fails to provide freeze protection, but also begins to eat away at the solar loop's components: the collectors, the pipes, the pump, etc. Due to the acid and excessive heat, the longevity of parts within the solar loop is greatly reduced.
- Most do not feature drainback tanks, so the system must circulate the HTF – regardless of the temperature of the storage tank – in order to prevent the HTF from degrading. Excessive temperatures in the tank cause increased scale and sediment build-up, possible severe burns if a tempering valve is not installed, and, if a water heater is being used for storage, possible failure of the water heater's thermostat.
- The glycol/water HTF must be replaced every 3–8 years, depending on the temperatures it has experienced.
- Some jurisdictions require double-walled heat exchangers even though propylene glycol is non-toxic.
- Even though the HTF contains glycol to prevent freezing, it will still circulate hot water from the storage tank into the collectors at low temperatures (e.g. below 40 °F (4 °C)), causing substantial heat loss.
A drainback system is an indirect active system where the HTF (almost always pure water) circulates through the collector, being driven by a pump. The collector piping is not pressurized and includes an open drainback reservoir that is contained in conditioned or semi-conditioned space. If the pump is switched off, the HTF drains into the drainback reservoir and none remains in the collector. Since the system relies upon being able to drain properly, all piping above the drainback tank, including the collectors, must slope downward in the direction of the drainback tank. Installed properly, the collector cannot be damaged by freezing or overheating. Drainback systems require no maintenance other than the replacement of failed system components.
Powering a heat-pump hot water heater via Solar PV panels
With the drastic drop in the prices of Photovoltaics circa 2010 it became increasingly popular in residential settings with low hot-water demands to consider heating water via an electric heat pump hot water heater powered by a solar PV array. This has the following advantages: 1) simpler/cheaper installation and maintenance, 2) excess energy collected can be used for household electricity use or put back into the grid, and 3) the heat-pump dehumidifies the living space. See for example: Getting into Hot Water — Part 1 - Marc Rosenbaum
A rough comparison of solar hot water systems
|Characteristic||ICS (Batch)||Thermosiphon||Active direct||Active indirect||Drainback||Bubble Pump|
|Survives freezing weather|
|Simple: no ancillary control|
|Retrofit potential to existing store|
|Space saving: no extra storage tank|
Collectors used in modern domestic SWH systems
Solar thermal collectors capture and retain heat from the sun and use it to heat a liquid. Two important physical principles govern the technology of solar thermal collectors:
- Any hot object ultimately returns to thermal equilibrium with its environment, due to heat loss from the hot object. The processes that result in this heat loss are conduction, convection and radiation. The efficiency of a solar thermal collector is directly related to heat losses from the collector surface (efficiency being defined as the proportion of heat energy that can be retained for a predefined period of time). Within the context of a solar collector, convection and radiation are the most important sources of heat loss. Thermal insulation is used to slow down heat loss from a hot object to its environment. This is actually a direct manifestation of the Second law of thermodynamics but we may term this the 'equilibrium effect'.
- Heat is lost more rapidly if the temperature difference between a hot object and its environment is larger. Heat loss is predominantly governed by the thermal gradient between the temperature of the collector surface and the ambient temperature. Conduction, convection, and radiation all occur more rapidly over large thermal gradients. We may term this the 'delta-t effect'.
The most simple approach to solar heating of water is to simply mount a metal tank filled with water in a sunny place. The heat from the sun would then heat the metal tank and the water inside. Indeed, this was how the very first SWH systems worked more than a century ago. However, this setup would be inefficient due to an oversight of the equilibrium effect, above: as soon as heating of the tank and water begins, the heat gained starts to be lost back into the environment, and this continues until the water in the tank reaches the ambient temperature. The challenge is therefore to limit the heat loss from the tank, thus delaying the time when thermal equilibrium is regained.
ICS or batch collectors reduce heat loss by placing the water tank in a thermally insulated box. This is achieved by encasing the water tank in a glass-topped box that allows heat from the sun to reach the water tank. However, the other walls of the box are thermally insulated, reducing convection as well as radiation to the environment. In addition, the box can also have a reflective surface on the inside. This reflects heat lost from the tank back towards the tank. In a simple way one could consider an ICS solar water heater as a water tank that has been enclosed in a type of 'oven' that retains heat from the sun as well as heat of the water in the tank. Using a box does not eliminate heat loss from the tank to the environment, but it largely reduces this loss.
Standard ICS collectors have a characteristic that strongly limits the efficiency of the collector: a small surface-to-volume ratio. Since the amount of heat that a tank can absorb from the sun is largely dependent on the surface of the tank directly exposed to the sun, it follows that a small surface would limit the degree to which the water can be heated by the sun. Cylindrical objects such as the tank in an ICS collector inherently have a small surface-to-volume ratio and most modern collectors attempt to increase this ratio for efficient warming of the water in the tank. There are many variations on this basic design, with some ICS collectors comprising several smaller water containers and even including evacuated glass tube technology, a type of ICS system known as an Evacuated Tube Batch (ETB) collector.
Flat plate collectors are an extension of the basic idea to place a collector in an 'oven'-like box with glass in the direction of the Sun. Most flat plate collectors have two horizontal pipes at the top and bottom, called headers, and many smaller vertical pipes connecting them, called risers. The risers are welded (or similarly connected) to thin absorber fins. Heat-transfer fluid (water or water/antifreeze mix) is pumped from the hot water storage tank (direct system) or heat exchanger (indirect system) into the collectors' bottom header, and it travels up the risers, collecting heat from the absorber fins, and then exits the collector out of the top header. Serpentine flat plate collectors differ slightly from this "harp" design, and instead use a single pipe that travels up and down the collector. However, since they cannot be properly drained of water, serpentine flat plate collectors cannot be used in drainback systems.
The type of glass used in flat plate collectors is almost always low-iron, tempered glass. Being tempered, the glass can withstand significant hail without breaking, which is one of the reasons that flat-plate collectors are considered the most durable collector type.
Unglazed or formed collectors are similar to flat-plate collectors, except they are not thermally insulated nor physically protected by a glass panel. Consequently these types of collectors are much less efficient for domestic water heating. For pool heating applications, however, the water being heated is often colder than the ambient roof temperature, at which point the lack of thermal insulation allows additional heat to be drawn from the surrounding environment.
Evacuated tube collectors (ETC) are a way in which heat loss to the environment, inherent in flat plates, has been reduced. Since heat loss due to convection cannot cross a vacuum, it forms an efficient isolation mechanism to keep heat inside the collector pipes. Since two flat sheets of glass are normally not strong enough to withstand a vacuum, the vacuum is rather created between two concentric tubes. Typically, the water piping in an ETC is therefore surrounded by two concentric tubes of glass with a vacuum in between that admits heat from the sun (to heat the pipe) but which limits heat loss back to the environment. The inner tube is coated with a thermal absorbent. Life of the vacuum varies from collector to collector, anywhere from 5 years to 15 years.
Flat plate collectors are generally more efficient than ETC in full sunshine conditions. However, the energy output of flat plate collectors is reduced slightly more than evacuated tube collectors in cloudy or extremely cold conditions. Most ETCs are made out of annealed glass, which is susceptible to hail, breaking in roughly golf ball -sized hail. ETCs made from "coke glass," which has a green tint, are stronger and less likely to lose their vacuum, but efficiency is slightly reduced due to reduced transparency.
Heating of swimming pools
Both pool covering systems floating atop the water and separate solar thermal collectors may be used for pool heating.
Pool covering systems, whether solid sheets or floating disks, act as insulation and reduce heat loss. Much of a pool's heat loss occurs through evaporation, and using a cover provides a barrier against evaporation. Using a pool cover will supplement the solar thermal collectors discussed below. See Swimming Pool Covers for a detailed discussion.
Solar thermal collectors for nonpotable pool water use are often made of plastic. Pool water, mildly corrosive due to chlorine, is circulated through the panels using the existing pool filter or supplemental pump. In mild environments, unglazed plastic collectors are more efficient as a direct system. In cold or windy environments evacuated tubes or flat plates in an indirect configuration do not have pool water pumped through them, they are used in conjunction with a heat exchanger that transfers the heat to pool water. This causes less corrosion. A fairly simple differential temperature controller is used to direct the water to the panels or heat exchanger either by turning a valve or operating the pump. Once the pool water has reached the required temperature, a diverter valve is used to return pool water directly to the pool without heating. Many systems are configured as drainback systems where the water drains into the pool when the water pump is switched off.
The collector panels are usually mounted on a nearby roof, or ground-mounted on a tilted rack. Due to the low temperature difference between the air and the water, the panels are often formed collectors or unglazed flat plate collectors. A simple rule-of-thumb for the required panel area needed is 50% of the pool's surface area. This is for areas where pools are used in the summer season only, not year 'round. Adding solar collectors to a conventional outdoor pool, in a cold climate, can typically extend the pool's comfortable usage by some months or more if an insulating pool cover is also used. An active solar energy system analysis program may be used to optimize the solar pool heating system before it is built.
Economics, energy, environment, and system costs
The amount of heat delivered by a solar water heating system depends primarily on the amount of heat delivered by the sun at a particular place (the insolation). In tropical places the insolation can be relatively high, e.g. 7 kW.h/m2 per day, whereas the insolation can be much lower in temperate areas where the days are shorter in winter, e.g. 3.2 kW.h/m2 per day. Even at the same latitude the average insolation can vary a great deal from location to location due to differences in local weather patterns and the amount of overcast. Useful calculators for estimating insolation at a site can be found with the Joint Research Laboratory of the European Commission and the American National Renewable Energy Laboratory.
Below is a table that gives a rough indication of the specifications and energy that could be expected from a solar water heating system involving some 2 m2 of absorber area of the collector, demonstrating two evacuated tube and three flat plate solar water heating systems. Certification information or figures calculated from those data are used. The bottom two rows give estimates for daily energy production (kW.h/day) for a tropical and a temperate scenario. These estimates are for heating water to 50 °C above ambient temperature.
With most solar water heating systems, the energy output scales linearly with the surface area of the absorbers. Therefore, when comparing figures, take into account the absorber area of the collector because collectors with less absorber area yield less heat, even within the 2 m2 range. Specifications for many complete solar water heating systems and separate solar collectors can be found at Internet site of the SRCC.
|Daily energy production (kWth.h) of five solar thermal systems. The evac tube systems used below both have 20 tubes|
|Technology||Flat plate||Flat plate||Flat plate||Evac tube||Evac tube|
|Configuration||Direct active||Thermosiphon||Indirect active||Indirect active||Direct active|
|Overall size (m2)||2.49||1.98||1.87||2.85||2.97|
|Absorber size (m2)||2.21||1.98||1.72||2.85||2.96|
|Energy production (kW.h/day):
– Insolation 3.2 kW.h/m2/day (temperate)
– e.g. Zurich, Switzerland
|– Insolation 6.5 kW.h/m2/day (tropical)
– e.g. Phoenix, USA
The figures are fairly similar between the above collectors, yielding some 4 kW.h/day in a temperate climate and some 8 kW.h/day in a more tropical climate when using a collector with an absorber area of about 2m2 in size. In the temperate scenario this is sufficient to heat 200 litres of water by some 17 °C. In the tropical scenario the equivalent heating would be by some 33 °C. Many thermosiphon systems are quite efficient and have comparable energy output to equivalent active systems. The efficiency of evacuated tube collectors is somewhat lower than for flat plate collectors because the absorbers are narrower than the tubes and the tubes have space between them, resulting in a significantly larger percentage of inactive overall collector area. Some methods of comparison calculate the efficiency of evacuated tube collectors based on the actual absorber area and not on the 'roof area' of the system as has been done in the above table. The efficiency of the collectors becomes lower if one demands water with a very high temperature.
In sunny, warm locations, where freeze protection is not necessary, an ICS (batch type) solar water heater can be extremely cost effective. In higher latitudes, there are often additional design requirements for cold weather, which add to system complexity. This has the effect of increasing the initial cost (but not the life-cycle cost) of a solar water heating system, to a level much higher than a comparable water heater of the conventional type. The biggest single consideration is therefore the large initial financial outlay of solar water heating systems. Offsetting this expense can take several years and the payback period is longer in temperate environments where the insolation is less intense. When calculating the total cost to own and operate, a proper analysis will consider that solar energy is free, thus greatly reducing the operating costs, whereas other energy sources, such as gas and electricity, can be quite expensive over time. Thus, when the initial costs of a solar system are properly financed and compared with energy costs, then in many cases the total monthly cost of solar heat can be less than other more conventional types of water heaters (also in conjunction with an existing water heater). At higher latitudes, solar heaters may be less effective due to lower solar energy, possibly requiring larger and/or dual-heating systems. In addition, government incentives can be significant.
The calculation of long term cost and payback period for a household SWH system depends on a number of factors. Some of these are:
- Price of purchasing solar water heater (more complex systems are more expensive)
- Efficiency of SWH system purchased
- Installation cost
- Price of electricity use for mains pumping (if this is used)
- Price of water heating fuel (e.g. gas or electricity) saved per kW.h
- Amount of water heating fuel used per month by a household
- Upfront state or government subsidy for installation of a solar water heater
- Recurrent or annual tax rebates or subsidy for operating renewable energy
- Annual maintenance cost of SWH system (e.g. antifreeze or pump replacements)
- Savings in annual maintenance of conventional (electric/gas/oil) water heating system
The following table gives some idea of the cost and payback period to recover the costs. It does not take into account annual maintenance costs, annual tax rebates and installation costs. However, the table does give an indication of the total cost and the order of magnitude of the payback period. The table assumes an energy savings of 200 kW.h per month (about 6.57 kW.h/day) due to SWH. Unfortunately payback times can vary greatly due to regional sun, extra cost due to frost protection needs of collectors, household hot water use etc. so more information may be needed to get accurate estimates for individual households and regions. For instance in central and southern Florida the payback period could easily be 7 years or less rather than the 12.6 years indicated on the chart for the US.
|Costs and payback periods for residential SWH systems with savings of 200 kW.h/month (using 2010 data)|
|Country||Currency||System cost||Subsidy(%)||Effective cost||Electricity cost/kW.h||Electricity savings/month||Payback period(y)|
Two points are clear from the above table. Firstly, the payback period is shorter in countries with a large amount of insolation and even in parts of the same country with more insolation. This is evident from the payback period less than 10 years in most southern hemisphere countries, listed above. This is partly because of good sunshine, allowing users in those countries to need smaller systems than in temperate areas. Secondly, even in the northern hemisphere countries where payback periods are often longer than 10 years, solar water heating is financially extremely efficient. This is partly because the SWH technology is efficient in capturing irradiation. The payback period for photovoltaic systems is much longer. In many cases the payback period for a SWH system is shortened if it supplies all or nearly all of the warm water requirements used by a household. Many SWH systems supply only a fraction of warm water needs and are augmented by gas or electric heating on a daily basis, thus extending the payback period of such a system.
Solar leasing is now available in Spain for solar water heating systems from Pretasol with a typical system costing around 59 euros and rising to 99 euros per month for a system that would provide sufficient hot water for a typical family home of six persons. The payback period would be five years.
Australia has instituted a system of Renewable Energy Credits, based on national renewable energy targets. This expands an older system based only on rebates.
Operational carbon/energy footprint and life cycle assessment
- Operational energy footprint (OEF) is also called energy parasitics ratio (EPR) or coefficient of performance (CoP).
- Operational carbon footprint (OCF) is also called carbon clawback ratio (CCR).
- Life cycle assessment is usually referred to as LCA.
The source of electricity in an active SWH system determines the extent to which a system contributes to atmospheric carbon during operation. Active solar thermal systems that use mains electricity to pump the fluid through the panels are called 'low carbon solar'. In most systems the pumping cancels the energy savings by about 8% and the carbon savings of the solar by about 20%. However, some new low power pumps will start operation with 1W and use a maximum of 20W. Assuming a solar collector panel delivering 4 kW.h/day and a pump running intermittently from mains electricity for a total of 6 hours during a 12-hour sunny day, the potentially negative effect of such a pump can be reduced to about 3% of the total power produced.
The carbon footprint of such household systems varies substantially, depending on whether electricity or other fuels such as natural gas are being displaced by the use of solar. Except where a high proportion of electricity is already generated by non-fossil fuel means, natural gas, a common water heating fuel, in many countries, has typically only about 40% of the carbon intensity of mains electricity per unit of energy delivered. Therefore the 3% or 8% energy clawback in a gas home referred to above could therefore be considered 8% to 20% carbon clawback, a very low figure compared to technologies such as heat pumps.
However, PV-powered active solar thermal systems typically use a 5–30 W PV panel which faces in the same direction as the main solar heating panel and a small, low power diaphragm pump or centrifugal pump to circulate the water. This reduces the operational carbon and energy footprint: a growing design goal for solar thermal systems.
Work is also taking place in a number of parts of the world on developing alternative non-electrical pumping systems. These are generally based on thermal expansion and phase changes of liquids and gases, a variety of which are under development.
Life cycle carbon/energy assessment
Now looking at a wider picture than just the operational environmental impacts, recognised standards can be used to deliver robust and quantitative life cycle assessment (LCA). LCA takes into account the total environmental cost of acquisition of raw materials, manufacturing, transport, using, servicing and disposing of the equipment. There are several aspects to such an assessment, including:
- The financial costs and gains incurred during the life of the equipment.
- The energy used during each of the above stages.
- The CO2 emissions due to each of the above stages.
Each of these aspects may present different trends with respect to a specific SWH device.
Financial assessment. The table in the previous section as well as several other studies suggest that the cost of production is gained during the first 5–12 years of use of the equipment, depending on the insolation, with cost efficiency increasing as the insolation does.
In terms of energy, some 60% of the materials of a SWH system goes into the tank, with some 30% towards the collector (thermosiphon flat plate in this case) (Tsiligiridis et al.). In Italy, some 11 GJ of electricity are used in producing the equipment, with about 35% of the energy going towards the manufacturing the tank, with another 35% towards the collector and the main energy-related impact being emissions. The energy used in manufacturing is recovered within the first two to three years of use of the SWH system through heat captured by the equipment according to this southern European study.
Moving further north into colder, less sunny climates, the energy payback time of a solar water heating system in a UK climate is reported as only 2 years. This figure was derived from the studied solar water heating system being: direct, retrofitted to an existing water store, PV pumped, freeze tolerant and of 2.8 sqm aperture. For comparison, a solar electric (PV) installation took around 5 years to reach energy payback, according to the same comparative study.
In terms of CO2 emissions, a large degree of the emissions-saving traits of a SWH system is dependent on the degree to which water heating by gas or electricity is used to supplement solar heating of water. Using the Eco-indicator 99 points system as a yardstick (i.e. the yearly environmental load of an average European inhabitant) in Greece, a purely gas-driven system may be cheaper in terms of emissions than a solar system. This calculation assumes that the solar system produces about half of the hot water requirements of a household. The production of a test SWH system in Italy produced about 700 kg of CO2, with all the components of manufacture, use and disposal contributing small parts towards this. Maintenance was identified as an emissions-costly activity when the heat transfer fluid (glycol-based) was periodically replaced. However, the emissions cost was recovered within about two years of use of the equipment through the emissions saved by solar water heating. In Australia, the life cycle emissions of a SWH system are also recovered fairly rapidly, where a SWH system has about 20% of the impact of an electrical water heater and half of the emissions impact of a gas water heater.
Analysing their lower impact retrofit freeze-tolerant solar water heating system, Allen et al. (qv) report a production CO2 impact of 337 kg, which is around half the environmental impact reported in the Ardente et al. (qv) study.
Where information based on established standards are available, the environmental transparency afforded by life cycle analysis allows consumers (of all products) to make increasingly well-informed product selection decisions. As for identifying sectors where this information is likely to appear first, environmental technology suppliers in the microgeneration and renewable energy technology arena are increasingly being pressed by consumers to report typical CoP and LCA figures for their products.
In summary, the energy and emissions cost of a SWH system forms a small part of the life cycle cost and can be recovered fairly rapidly during use of the equipment. Their environmental impacts can be reduced further by sustainable materials sourcing, using non-mains circulation, by reusing existing hot water stores and, in cold climates, by eliminating antifreeze replacement visits.
Do-it-yourself (DIY) systems
People have begun building their own (small-scale) solar water heating systems from scratch or buying kits. Plans for solar water heating systems are available on the Internet. and people have set about building them for their own domestic requirements. DIY SWH systems are usually cheaper than commercial ones, and they are used both in the developed and developing world.
System specification and installation
- Except in rare instances it will be insufficient to install a SWH system with no electrical or gas or other fuel backup. Many SWH systems have a back-up electric heating element in the integrated tank, the operation of which may be necessary on cloudy days to ensure a reliable supply of hot water.
- The temperature stability of a system is dependent on the ratio of the volume of warm water used per day as a fraction of the size of the water reservoir/tank that stores the hot water. If a large proportion of hot water in the reservoir is used each day, a large fraction of the water in the reservoir needs to be heated. This brings about significant fluctuations in water temperature every day, with possible risks of overheating or underheating, depending on the design of the system. Since the amount of heating that needs to take place every day is proportional to hot water usage and not to the size of the reservoir, it is desirable to have a fairly large reservoir (i.e. equal to or greater than daily usage,) which will help prevent fluctuations in water temperature.
- If ample storage is pre-existing or can otherwise be reasonably acquired, a large SWH system is more efficient economically than a small system. This is because the price of a system is not linearly proportional to the size of the collector array, so the price per square meter of collector is cheaper in a larger system. If this is the case, it pays to use a system that covers nearly all of the domestic hot water needs, and not only a small fraction of the needs. This facilitates more rapid cost recovery.
- Not all installations require new replacement solar hot water stores. Existing stores may be large enough and in suitable condition. Direct systems can be retrofitted to existing stores while indirect systems can be also sometimes be retrofitted using internal and external heat exchangers.
- The installation of a SWH system needs to be complemented with efficient insulation of all the water pipes connecting the collector and the water storage tank, as well as the storage tank (or "geyser") and the most important warm water outlets. The installation of efficient lagging significantly reduces the heat loss from the hot water system. The installation of lagging on at least two meters of pipe on the cold water inlet of the storage tank reduces heat loss, as does the installation of a "geyser blanket" around the storage tank (if inside a roof). In cold climates the installation of lagging and insulation is often performed even in the absence of a SWH system.
- The most efficient PV pumps are designed to start very slowly in very low light levels, so if connected uncontrolled, they may cause a small amount of unwanted circulation early in the morning – for example when there is enough light to drive the pump but while the collector is still cold. To eliminate the risk of hot water in the storage tank from being cooled that way this is very important. solar controller may be required.
- The modularity of an evacuated tube collector array allows the adjustment of the collector size by removing some tubes or their heat pipes. Budgeting for a larger than required array of tubes therefore allows for the customisation of collector size to the needs of a particular application, especially in warmer climates.
- Particularly in locations further towards the poles than 45 degrees from the equator, roof mounted sun facing collectors tend to outperform wall mounted collectors in terms of total energy output. However, it is total useful energy output which usually matters most to consumers. So arrays of sunny wall mounted steep collectors can sometimes produce more useful energy because there can be a small increase in winter gain at the expense of a large unused summer surplus.
- EN 806: Specifications for installations inside buildings conveying water for human consumption. General.
- EN 1717: Protection against pollution of potable water in water installations and general requerements of devices to prevent pollution by backflow.
- EN 60335: Specification for safety of household and similar electrical appliances. (2–21)
- UNE 94002:2005 Thermal solar systems for domestic hot water production. Calculation method for heat demand.
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) Act 2000
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) (Large-scale Generation Shortfall Charge) Act 2000
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) (Small-scale Technology Shortfall Charge) Act 2010
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) Regulations 2001
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) Regulations 2001 - STC Calculation Methodology for Solar Water Heaters and Air Source Heat Pump Water Heaters
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) Amendment (Transitional Provision) Regulations 2010
- Renewable Energy (Electricity) Amendment (Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2009
All relevant participants of the Large-scale Renewable Energy Target and Small-scale Renewable Energy Scheme must comply with the above Acts.
APPENDIX 1. Worldwide use
Top countries worldwide
Solar heating in European Union + Switzerland
|* = estimation, F = France as a whole|
- Australia: Solar hot water in Australia
|Wikimedia Commons has media related to Solar water heating.|
- Solar thermal collector
- Solar air heating
- Solar air conditioning
- Concentrating solar power
- Passive solar
- Renewable heat
- Solar combisystem
- Solar energy
- Solar thermal energy
- Renewable energy commercialization
- Sustainable design
- C. Marken (2009). "Solar collectors: Behind the glass". HomePower 133: 70–76.
- Brian Norton (2011) Solar Water Heaters: A Review of Systems Research and Design Innovation, Green. 1, 189–207, ISSN (Online) 1869-8778
- 2011 global status report by Renewable Energy Policy Network for the 21st Century (REN21)
- Gulland, John. "Heating water with a wood stove". woodheat.org. Wood Heat Organization Inc. Retrieved 29 March 2012.
- Solar Evolution – The History of Solar Energy, John Perlin, California Solar Center
- Del Chiaro, Bernadette and Telleen-Lawton, Timothy (April 2007). "Solar Water Heating (How California Can Reduce Its Dependence on Natural Gas)" (PDF). Environment California Research and Policy Center. Retrieved 29 September 2007.
- John Christopher Bacher (2000). Petrotyranny. Dundurn. p. 70. ISBN 978-0-88866-956-8.
- "Israel's Solar Industry: Reclaiming a Legacy of Success". Climate.org. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- Minicy Catom Software Engineering Ltd. www.catom.com. "The Samuel Neaman Institute for Advanced Studies in Science and Technology – Publications – Solar energy for the production of heat Summary and recommendations of the 4th assembly of the energy forum at SNI". Neaman.org.il. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- Israeli Section of the International Solar Energy Society, edited by Gershon Grossman, Faculty of Mechanical Energy, Technion, Haifa; Final draft.
- "Renewables Global Status Report: Energy Transformation Continues Despite Economic Slowdown". ren21.net. 13 May 2009. Retrieved 20 May 2010.
- "Chromagen’s Solar Water Heating Systems". heatingcentral.com.
- "5 Star Housing – Performance Based Building Regulation Delivers". Docstoc.com. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- "Buildings – Think Change". Environment.gov.au. 1 November 2010. Retrieved 10 February 2012.[dead link]
- Israel del Mundo and Ian Wills (2005) The Economics of the Mandatory Renewable Energy Target (MRET), Department of Economics Monash University, Australia.
- Energy-Hungry China Warms to Solar Water Heaters discusses China Himin Solar Energy Group in Dezhou. Reuters article, posted on Planet Ark site
- A van Houten (Sunnovations), How a Geyser Pump works
- Wilfried C. Sorensen (1985) Autogeneous solar water heater, US Patent 4607688.
- Bubble pump description at bubbleactionpumps.com
- Lane, T. and Olson, K. (2002). "Solar hot water for cold climates: Part II – Drainback systems". Homepower Magazine 86: 62–70.
- Solar Water Heating Basics. homepower.com
- Norton, Brian (2013). Harnessing Solar Heat. Springer. ISBN 978-94-007-7275-5.
- W.M. Rohsenow, J.P. Harnett, Y.I. Cho (1998). Handbook of heat transfer 3rd Ed.. McGraw-Hill, Chicago, USA.
- C. Schmidt, A. Goetzberger A. (1990). "Single-tube integrated collector storage systems with transparent insulation and involute reflector". Solar Energy 45 (2): 93. doi:10.1016/0038-092X(90)90033-9.
- M. Smyth, P.C. Eames, B. Norton (2006). "Integrated collector storage solar water heaters". Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 10 (6): 503. doi:10.1016/j.rser.2004.11.001.
- M. Souliotis, S. Kalogirou, Y. Tripanagnostopoulos (2009). "Modelling of an ICS solar water heater using artificial neural networks and TRNSYS". Renewable Energy 34 (5): 1333. doi:10.1016/j.renene.2008.09.007.
- Y. Tripanagnostopoulos, M. Souliotis, T. Nousia (1999). "Solar ICS systems with two cylindrical storage tanks". Renewable Energy 16: 665. doi:10.1016/S0960-1481(98)00248-1.
- D. Lane (2003). "Solar pool heating basics, Part 1". HomePower 94: 70–77.
- Yong Kim, Taebeom Seo (2007). "Thermal performances comparisons of the glass evacuated tube solar collectors with shapes of absorber tube". Renewable Energy 32 (5): 772. doi:10.1016/j.renene.2006.03.016.
- Shi Yueyan, Yang Xiaoji (1999). "Selective absorbing surface for evacuated solar collector tubes". Renewable Energy 16: 632. doi:10.1016/S0960-1481(98)00240-7.
- "Solar Pool Heating – Control and Automation". rimstar.org. Retrieved 16 August 2010.
- D. Lane (2003). "Solar pool heating basics, Part 2". HomePower 95: 60–67.
- "interactive maps". Sunbird.jrc.it. 30 October 2008. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- "A Performance Calculator for Grid-Connected PV Systems". Rredc.nrel.gov. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- "National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) Home Page". Nrel.gov. 6 February 2012. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- SRCC Certification Programs. solar-rating.org
- ISO 9806-2:1995. Test methods for solar collectors – Part 2: Qualification test procedures. International Organization for Standardization, Geneva, Switzerland
- H. M. Healey (2007). "Economics of Solar". Cogeneration & Distributed Generation Journal 22 (3): 35–49. doi:10.1080/15453660709509122.
- R. H. Crawford; G. J. Treloar; B. D. Ilozor; P. E. D. Love (2003). "Comparative greenhouse emissions analysis of domestic solar hot water systems". Building Research & Information 31: 34. doi:10.1080/09613210210160800.
- C. Marken, J. Sanchez (2008). "PV vs. Solar Water Heating: Simple Solar Payback". HomePower 127: 40–45.
- Simplified Residential Solar Hot Water System Calculator, Florida Solar Energy Center (2007).
- Milton S. & Kaufman S. (2005). Solar Water Heating as a Climate Protection Strategy: The Role for Carbon Finance. Green Markets International. Arlington MA, USA
- "Eskom". Eskom. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- "Hills Solar Evacuated Tube Solar Hot Water Systems". Enviro-friendly.com. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- Energy Efficient Homes Package. environment.gov.au
- "AER issues report on high electricity prices in South Australia". Aer.gov.au. 4 March 2008. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- WAT kost een zonneboiler? vlaanderen.be, 30 April 2008.
- "Premies voor energiebesparende maatregelen | Vlaanderen.be: uw link met de overheid". Vlaanderen.be. Retrieved 10 February 2012.[dead link]
- "No aspx | Electrabel". Electrabel.be. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- "SRP EarthWise Solar Energy for your home". Srpnet.com. Retrieved 10 February 2012.
- "Federal Tax Credits for Energy Efficiency : ENERGY STAR". Energystar.gov. 2012-01-03. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- "Average Retail Price of Electricity to Ultimate Customers by End-Use Sector, by State".
- "Solar water heating systems explained – benefits, costs, savings, earnings, suitability". Energysavingtrust.org.uk. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- "Electricity Running Cost Calculator | Electricity Prices | Electricity Costs". Ukpower.co.uk. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- April 17, 2009 (2009-04-17). "Solar Leasing Pretasol". Pretasol.com. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- C. Martin and M. Watson (2001). Side by side testing of eight solar water heating systems. DTI publication URN 01/1292. London, UK
- "DC Solar Pumps". lainginc.itt.com. Retrieved 5 November 2010.
- "Nominaties VSK Awards" [Laing ITT Ecocirc pump nominated for prestigious VSK award in heating category]. bouwwereld.nl (in Dutch). Retrieved 5 November 2010.
- G. Tsilingiridis, G. Martinopoulos and N. Kyriakis (2004). "Life cycle environmental impact of a thermosyphonic domestic solar hot water system in comparison with electrical and gas water heating". Renewable Energy 29 (8): 1277. doi:10.1016/j.renene.2003.12.007.
- F. Ardente, G. Beccali, M. Cellura (2005). "Life cycle assessment of a solar thermal collector: Sensitivity analysis, energy and environmental balances". Renewable Energy 30 (2): 109. doi:10.1016/j.renene.2004.05.006.
- S.R. Allen, G.P. Hammond, H. Harajli1, C.I. Jones, M.C. McManus and A.B. Winnett (2008). "Integrated appraisal of micro-generators: Methods and applications". Proceedings of the ICE – Energy 161 (2): 5, Fig. 1. doi:10.1680/ener.2008.161.2.73.
- "DMOZ DIY Solar water heating collector". Dmoz.org. 2010-05-03. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- Technical Information Online. "DIY solar water heating in the developing world". Practicalaction.org. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- "Solar Rating & Certification Corporation – System Ratings". solar-rating.org. 2012. Retrieved September 19, 2012.
- "RET Compliance". Australian Government, Clean Energy Regulator. 2 Jan 2013. Retrieved 2014-09-25.
- RENEWABLES GLOBAL STATUS REPORT 2009 Update. Deutsche Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit. ren21.net
- "Renewables Global Status Report 2010" (PDF). REN21. Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- Solar thermal energy barometer 2010 EurObserv’ER Systèmes solaires Le journal des énergies renouvelables n° 197, 5/2010
- Werner Weiss and Franz Mauthner (May 2011). "Solar Heat Worldwide" (PDF). Retrieved 2012-06-23.
- Werner Weiss and Franz Mauthner Solar Heat Worldwide Markets and Contribution to the Energy Supply 2010. iea-shc.org
- Solar thermal and concentrated solar power barometer. EurObserv’ER n° 209 (May 2012).
- Solar thermal market in Europe 2010 Trends and Market Statistics, ESTIF 6/2011
- Solar thermal market grows strongly in Europe 2009 ESTIF 2010
- Solar thermal market grows strongly in Europe 2008 ESTIF 5/2009