Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument (Manhattan)
The Soldiers' and Sailors' Memorial Monument[note 1] commemorates Union Army soldiers and sailors who served in the American Civil War. It is located at 89th Street and Riverside Drive in Riverside Park in the Upper West Side of New York City.
The monument was first suggested in 1869. However, little was done to create the monument until 1893, when the New York State legislature established a Board of Commissioners for a monument to the soldiers and sailors who had served in the Union Army during the American Civil War. Originally set to be built at fifty-ninth Street and Fifth Avenue then at Mount Tom (83rd Street & Riverside Drive) the project was delayed for many years because many organizations in the city could not agree on a site for the monument. When the final site was selected, the winning design for the monument had to be redesigned for the new site.
Ground was broken for the monument on September 21, 1900. Mr. Guggenheimer turned the first spadeful of dirt. About 200 people were present at the ground breaking ceremony. The first stone was laid in January 1901. On the cornerstone was a simple inscription saying that the monument was erected by the citizens of New York. It was finally dedicated on Memorial Day, 1902 with President Theodore Roosevelt officiating. During the dedication, the monument was unveiled following a parade of Civil War veterans up Riverside Drive. The memorial bears the simple inscription: "To the memory of the brave soldiers and sailors who saved the Union". The monument cost $300,000 to erect. Granite quarried from the Lacasse Quarry located at Derby, Orleans County, Vermont, was used in the construction.
The white marble monument was designed after a public competition won by architects Charles and Arthur Stoughton. Their design was known as the “Temple of Fame.” The ornamental features were carved by Paul E. Duboy (1857–1907), who also was the architect of The Ansonia, an apartment building also on the Upper West Side. Inspired by Greek antiquity, it is based on the Choragic Monument of Lysicrates in Athens. The monument takes the form of a peripteral Corinthian temple raised on a high base, with a tall cylindrical rusticated cella, that carries a low conical roof like a lid, ringed by twelve Corinthian columns. Plinths at the entrance to the raised terrace are incised with the names of the New York volunteer regiments and the battles in which they served, as well as Union generals.
Repairs and reconstruction
By 1907, there were already reports by Mayor George B. McClellan, Jr., that the Monument was in need of repair. At that time there were marble slabs in danger of falling from their place; three had already fallen. The building badly leaked, cement was constantly falling from the walls and ceiling, and stone was chipped in many places. He requested $20,000 for the repair of the monument.
A large adjustment to the monument took place in the 1930s, when the plaza's yellow brick, which nicely contrasted with the white marble trim, was replaced with the orange-colored stone common to Parks Department projects of the period. However, these have since chipped and are splitting. The memorial was also given a complete coating of protective paraffin, used at that time to preserve the memorial. In 1962, the City spent over $1 million in extensive repairs to the monument, including a new roof, which had deteriorated, and portions of the monument were replaced with more durable granite.
The Parks Department had proposed a $1.2 million restoration in 2002. The effort was to restore the monument's steps and sidewalks. It does not appear this was ever completed, because the effort failed when a private donor pulled out. In July 2005, the New York Times reported "up close the dilapidation is clearly visible. Pave-stones, many damaged by skateboarding and soccer playing, need replacing. The paint covering the many splotches of graffiti is tacky. And the tomblike interior, which is leaking, has long been closed to the public. Major work last took place in 1962."
In 2007, Gale Brewer, a member of the City Council, committed $650,000 in city money to a redesign of the potholed asphalt plaza south of the monument, with its three Civil War-era cannons. However, that effort bogged down in disagreement on the exact nature of the designs and was never completed. A fence was put up to keep people off the entry stairs because they were in very poor condition in 2008. In March 2014, an attempt to raise $5.5 million was attempted by the Riverside Park Conservancy following a $1.5 million survey done by the park system. The monument currently has many coatings of anti-graffiti paint. The ornamental bronze doorway has been damaged by vandals. At some point the richly sculptured bronze flagpole base, which featured ship forms, wreaths and other elements, was removed. The park system noted, "the monument is awaiting funding to repair loosened joints, chipped stone, and the damage generally wrought by time if not vandalism."
The monument was intended ro stand at the center of a complex sequence of balustraded formal paved terraces and stairs that would have rationalized the steep natural slopes to north and west, but were eliminated in the execurion.[note 2] Its siting at a curve in Riverside Drive makes it visible from a distance, a desirable feature for a monument in the City Beautiful movement, of which this Beaux-Arts monument is a prime example. Originally, there was a planned stairway to the river and a battlemented wall to the south but these were never built. It appears that the area south of the plaza was simply paved, or perhaps treated with pebbles. On the south side of the monument are two mounted cannons. On the west side of the memorial, the back steps to the terraces offer views of the Hudson River.
The monument measures approximately 29 meters tall. The initial design called for the monument to be crowned with a statue of Peace "of heroic size" but this was not done.
The sculptured bronze door at the base of the monument, now kept locked, was originally open to visitors. Currently, the interior is open one day annually at Openhousenewyork. The interior is entirely revetted with the same veined white marble used on the exterior. The interior is in two stages, with six niches in the lower stage, corresponding to the exterior basement, and an upper stage of tall Corinthian pilasters flanking plain panels; above is a ribbed interior dome with a central lantern. The mosaic on the floor is a star centered on a bronze relief medallion of the US arms, with crossed oak and laurel sprays.
The exterior colonnade carries an entablature adorned with a full frieze containing the inscriptions "To the memory of the Brave Soldiers and Sailors Who Saved the Union," A cresting of eagles alternating with cartouches surmounts the cornice. The monument terminates in a low conical roof crowned by a richly decorated marble finial.
The Riverside Park Conservancy maintains the plantings in the area surrounding the monument.
Parades and celebrations
Many huge Memorial Day celebrations have been centered on this monument. The number of people and interest in the Memorial Day celebrations at this monument has varied greatly and at times has been very significant. On Memorial Day 1907, 16,000 men marched in a GAR Parade. However, in 1910, in a celebration headed by President Taft, only 1,500 showed up. In 1911, 20,000 men and 150 organizations took part in the Memorial Day parade. Then in 1914, 9,000 men were noted in the New York Times article, in a parade from 72nd street to the monument. In 1922, the Memorial Day parade attracted 14,000 participants. The numbers dwindled down and in the 1990s attracted only a few dozen people. After the September 11 attacks, the numbers grew.
In addition to annual Memorial Day celebrations, the monument has been used in the scenes and as a backdrop of movies such as The Odd Couple, Godspell and Parting Glances as well as a backdrop to TV shows Law & Order and Sex and the City. In the mid 1980s the West Side Arts Coalition provided midsummer dance programs on the steps of the monument at 89th street. Since 2004, the monument has also served as the home of the Hudson Warehouse theatre company. They perform Shakespeare performances on the back steps of the monument in the summer months. It was also known as a "gay cruising area" in the 60's.
- Its full title appears on a bronze plaque on the rear wall.
- The paved plaza that leads to it was renovated in 1937 and again in 2008; three bronze cannon, each weighing 8508 pounds, are inscribed with their weight, the maker's initials (S.C.L. S. McM. & CO) and the date 1865.
- Guide to New York City Landmarks - Andrew S. Dolkart - Google Books. Books.google.com. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "Riverside Park Conservancy". Riversideparkfund.org. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "THE 71ST TO CHOOSE A COLONEL - Major Bates, It Is Believed, Will Be the First Candidate. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1899-11-01. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "WOMAN ACCUSES POLICEMAN. - Mrs. Wise of Brooklyn Says Cashman Insulted Her on the Street. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1900-09-21. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "Queries and Answers - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1910-07-10. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- T. Nelson, The Commercial Granites of New England, USGS Bulletin 738, 1923:101.
- "New York Architecture Images- Soldiers and Sailors' Monument". Nyc-architecture.com. 2002-10-13. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "SOLDIERS' SHAFT DAMAGED. - Veterans Ask for Funds to Repair Army and Navy Memorial. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1907-03-27. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- Popular Science - Google Books. Books.google.com. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- KELLY CROW (2002-04-21). "NEIGHBORHOOD REPORT: RESTORATION; Spit and Polish For an Old Soldier - New York Times". Nytimes.com. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- Kugel, Seth (2005-07-10). "Seeking a Little Respect for a Long-Suffering Monument". The New York Times.
- Kugel, Seth (2005-07-10). "Seeking a Little Respect for a Long-Suffering Monument". The New York Times.
- Mindlin, Alex (2007-01-14). "Uninviting or Idyllic? A Redesign Airs Old Disputes". The New York Times.
- Manhattan CB7 meeting notes, nyc.gov (January 2, 2008)
- "$5.5M Renovation Sought for Riverside Park Civil War Monument". DNAinfo New York.
- "Riverside Park". nycgovparks.org.
- Riverside Park Highlights - Soldiers’ and Sailors’ Monument : NYC Parks. Nycgovparks.org (2004-11-13). Retrieved on 2013-09-07.
- "» Getting To Know Riverside Park: The Soldiers’ & Sailors’ Monument". Myupperwest.com. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "THE SOLDIERS' MONUMENT - It May Not Be Erected on the Proposed Site on the Plaza. SCULPTURE SOCIETY'S VIEW It Opposes the Erection of Any Memorial at This Approach to Central Park, and Its President Will Not Give His Consent. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1897-11-24. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "16,000 MEN MARCH IN G.A.R. PARADE - Soldiers and Sailors and the Veterans of Three Wars Applauded. WARSHIPS BOOM SALUTES Men Who Fought In the Civil War Are Growing Few - They Were the Real Attraction of the Day. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1907-05-31. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "TAFT COMING HERE FOR MEMORIAL DAY - Parade of Regulars, Guardsmen, and War Veterans Will Pass in Review Before Him. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1910-05-29. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "BIG PARADE PLANNED FOR MEMORIAL DAY - Military and Civic Organizations Will Have 20,000 Men in Line with Grand Army. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1911-05-28. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "MEMORIAL PARADE AT THE RIVER SIDE - Army of 9,000 to March from 72d Street to the Soldiers and Sailors' Monument. 700 G.A.R. VETERANS IN VAN The Cruiser Tennessee to Fire Salutes In the Hudson - Other Celebrations of the Day. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1914-05-29. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- "WHOLE CITY TO PAY HONOR TO WAR DEAD - Ceremonies Planned Today for Every Part of New York, with Fair Weather Predicted. AGED VETERANS TO MARCH 400 Civil War Survivors to Lead a Parade of Ex-Fighters Up Riverside Drive at 9 A.M. Bronx to Honor 950 Fallen. - View Article - NYTimes.com". New York Times. 1922-05-30. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- Haberman, Clyde (2011-05-31). "The Day: Renewed Respect for the Military - NYTimes.com". Cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com. Retrieved 2013-05-27.
- The Odd Couple Film Locations. On the set of New York.com. Retrieved on 2013-09-07.
- Dougherty, Philip H.. (1985-07-19) NEW YORK DAY BY DAY - Participatory Dances. NYTimes.com. Retrieved on 2013-09-07.
- The Hudson Warehouse, www.hudsonwarehouse.net.
- The Brutal Attacks on Gay Men in the Ramble - New York Magazine. Nymag.com (1978-07-24). Retrieved on 2013-09-07.
- George Chauncey, Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World, p. 182.
- New York Architecture: Soldiers' and Sailors' Monument
- Michael Minn: 89th St Soldiers and Sailors Monument
- Riverside Park Fund