Occupation - Disagreement about the reliability of historical accounts
According to tradition, Sophroniscus was by trade a stonemason or sculptor. Plato scholars Thomas Brickhouse and Nicholas Smith question the authenticity of that tradition, mainly on the grounds that the earliest extant sources of the story are comparatively late and that it is unmentioned by more reliable sources such as Plato, Xenophon, Aristophanes, or Aristotle. According to John Burnet, the earliest extant mention of Socrates as a statuary or stonemason is in Timon of Philius  (c.325 - 235 BC ) as quoted by Diogenes Laertius 2.19. Burnet claims that Timon "is a very unsafe authority for anything", and that the attribution "appears to have arisen from an almost certainly false interpretation of [Socrates'] references to Daedalus as the ancestor of his family" (in Plato's Euthyphro 11c, 15b). Burnet points out that Daedalus had nothing to do with stone-cutting or marble sculpture; his media were instead metal and wood. Burnet furthermore argues that Xenophon and Plato would at some point have explicitly mentioned Socrates' background in stone-craftsmanship, if it were real, since both writers so often make Socrates mention craftsmen. Another early source of the claim that Socrates was a stone-worker is Duris of Samos (c.340-260 BC ), who described Socrates as a slave. According to Eduard Zeller, Duris seems to have confused Socrates with Phaedo of Elis.
In direct contradiction to Plato's Crito 50d-e, one scholar of ancient Greek music has claimed that "Socrates received no training in mousikē in boyhood...", based on the assumption that "[h]is father, a stonemason, was typical of a class that did not receive a training in mousikē."
According to Plato (in the dialogue Laches), Sophroniscus was a close friend of Lysimachus, son of the illustrious Aristides the Just, which (presumably) allowed Socrates to become familiar with members of the circle of Pericles. (Since Plato has Lysimachus refer to Sophroniscus in the past tense, and since the dialogue's dramatic date is not long after the battle of Delium, we may safely infer that Sophroniscus was dead by 424.) The fact that one of Socrates' sons — but not his eldest son Lamprocles — was named after Sophroniscus suggests that Sophroniscus was the less illustrious of the two grandfathers (John Burnet 1911, Plato: Phaedo, p. 12); the father of Socrates' wife, Xanthippe, was named Lamprocles and had a more impressive pedigree than Sophroniscus. All this suggests that Socrates' inherited social status was in fact much higher than is traditionally recognized.
- V Tejera - Rewriting the History of Ancient Greek Philosophy (p.105) Greenwood Publishing Group, 1 Jan 1997 [Retrieved 2015-3-23] (ed. this source indicated the source <Euthydemus>)
- Plato translated by B Jowett - Euthydemus (in) The Complete Works of Plato published by e-artnow, 2013 ISBN 8074849678 [Retrieved 2015-3-23] (ed. no page number shown in text to provide detail)
- Plato translated by B Jowett - The Works of Plato: Charmides, Lysis, Other Dialogues and the Laws (p.260) published by Cosimo, Inc., 2010 ISBN 1616403152 (Length 492 pages) [Retrieved 2015-3-24]
- TC. Brickhouse, ND. Smith - Socrates on Trial (p.30) Oxford University Press, 1990 ISBN 0198239386 [Retrieved 2015-3-23]
- Greek Thought: A Guide to Classical Knowledge (p.746) (edited by J Brunschwig (Professor of the History of Ancient Philosophy, Emeritus, at the University of Paris during 2000), GER Lloyd, P Pellegrin) Harvard University Press, 2000 ISBN 067400261X [Retrieved 2015-3-23]
- p. 58, W. K. C. Guthrie, Socrates, Cambridge University Press, 1971.
- p. 17, The Philosophy of Socrates, Westview Press, 2000.
- Encyclopaedia of Religion and Ethics, s.v., "Socrates", 1919.
- R.Bett - The Emotions in Hellenistic Philosophy ( edited by J. Sihvola, T. Engberg-Pedersen) Springer Science & Business Media, 31 Oct 1998 ISBN 0792353188 [Retrieved 2015-3-23]
- p. 50, Plato's Euthyphro, Apology of Socrates, and Crito, Oxford University Press, 1924. Burnet cites Plato's Apology 22c9ff. and Xenophon's Memorabilia 3.10.6 as passages where the writers could not have avoided mentioning Socrates' own experience with craftsmanship if he really had any.
- FW Walbank - The Cambridge Ancient History (p.3) (edited by FW Walbank, FW Walbank, AE Astin) Cambridge University Press, 6 Sep 1984 ISBN 052123445X [Retrieved 2015-3-23]
- Cited in Diogenes Laertius 2.19.
- Zeller, Socrates and the Socratic Schools, trans. O.J. Reichel (London 1877), 2nd edition, p. 60 n. 1.
- p. 142, Warren Anderson, Music and Musicians in Ancient Greece, Cornell University Press, 1994. Education in music and gymanastics was in Socrates' time, "probably confined to the aristocratic strata...", according to the Oxford Classical Dictionary, 3rd edition, s.v., "education, Greek".
- p. 235, Debra Nails, The People of Plato, Hackett, 2002.