Southeast Asian haze
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (April 2014) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)|
Southeast Asian haze is a fire-related large-scale air pollution problem that occurs regularly. These haze events have caused adverse health and economic impact on Brunei Darussalam, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, and to a lesser degree, the Philippines and Thailand. The problem flares up every dry season, in varying degrees. Transboundary haze in Southeast Asia has been recorded since 1972.
The haze is largely caused by illegal agricultural fires due to industrial-scale slash-and-burn practices in Indonesia, especially from the provinces of South Sumatra and Riau in Indonesia's Sumatra island, and Kalimantan on Indonesian Borneo. Burned land can be sold at a higher price illegally, and eventually used for activities including oil palm and pulpwood production. Burning is also cheaper and faster compared to cutting and clearing using excavators or other machines.
- 1 Causes
- 2 Effects
- 3 Proposed solutions
- 4 History
- 5 See also
- 6 References
A study published in 2005 concluded that there is no single dominant cause of fire in a particular site and there are wide differences in the causes of fires in different sites. The study identified the following direct and indirect causes of fire:
- Direct causes of fire
- Fire as a tool in land clearing
- Fire as a weapon in land tenure or land use disputes
- Accidental or escaped fires
- Fire connected with resource extraction
- Indirect causes of fire
- Land tenure and land use allocation conflicts and competition
- Forest degrading practices
- Economic incentives/disincentives
- Population growth and migration
- Inadequate fire fighting and management capacity
Fire as a tool in land clearing
Fire is the cheapest and fastest method to clear land in preparation for planting. Fire is used to clear the plant material left over from logging or old crops. Mechanically raking the plant material into long piles and letting them rot over time, is expensive and slow, and could harbour pests. Clearing land with machines and chemicals can cost up to US$200 per hectare while using fire costs US$5 per hectare.
After a peat swamp forest has been cleared and drained, the peat soil is still unsuitable for agriculture, because peat soil is nutrient-poor and acidic (pH 3 - 4). To make the soil suitable for agriculture, the pH has to be neutralised and nutrients added. Pests and plant diseases also have to be removed. One method is to use chemicals such as limestone to neutralise the acidity, as well as fertilisers and pesticides. This method costs about Rupiah 30 - 40 million per hectare. Alternatively, fire is used to clear the plant material left over from logging. The fire kills pests and the resulting ash serves to fertilise the soil and neutralise the acidity. This method costs Rupiah 2 million per hectare.
In Indonesia, the Basic Forestry Law grants the Ministry of Forestry authority over all land classified as forests. Approximately 49% of the nation (909,070 square kilometres) is covered by actual forest, although the government classifies 69% of the land area (1,331,270 square kilometres) as forest. The land rights of traditional communities that live on land classified as forest cannot be registered and are generally unrecognised by the state. Therefore, these communities do not really have the ability to enforce rules at the village level and exclude outsiders such as oil palm plantations, logging companies, residents of other villages, migrants, small-scale loggers or transmigrants. Competing claims in turn leads to land conflicts. As the number of new, external actors increases, so does the likelihood that fire will be used as a weapon.
Role of peat
A peatland is an area where organic material such as leaves and twigs had accumulated naturally under waterlogged conditions in the last 10,000 years. This layer of organic material, known as peat, can be up to 20m deep. Indonesia has 265,500 km2 of peatland, which comprises 13.9% of its land area. Malaysia also has significant peatland, at 26,685 km2, covering 8.1% of its land area.
Although originally a wetland ecosystem, much of the peatland in Southeast Asia have been drained for human activities such as agriculture, forestry and urban development. A report published in 2011 stated that more than 30% of peat swamp forests had been converted to agricultural land and a further 30% had been logged or degraded in the past 20 to 30 years. Excessive drainage in peat results in the top layer of peat drying out. Due to its high carbon content, dry peat is extremely susceptible to burning, especially during the dry season.
Studies have shown that peat fires are a major contributor to the haze. In 2009, around 40% of all fires in Peninsular Malaysia, Borneo, Sumatra and Java were detected in peatlands, even though they cover only 10% of the land area studied. The concentration of sulphur in rain falling over Singapore in 1997 correlated closely with the PM2.5 concentration, which can be attributed to the strong sulphur emission from peat fires.
Haze related damages can be attributed to two sources: the haze causing fire and the haze itself. Each of the two factors can create significant disruption to people's daily lives and affect people's health. As a whole the recurring haze incidents affected regional economy and generated contention between governments of nations affected.
The haze causing fire can cause a multitude of damages that are local as well as transboundary. These include loss of direct and indirect forest benefits, timber, agricultural products and biodiversity. The fires also incur significant firefighting costs and carbon release to the atmosphere.
Some of the more direct damages caused by haze include damage to people's short term health and regional tourism during haze period. The haze also leads to industrial production losses, airline and airport losses, fishing decline, and incurs costs on cloud seeding. In addition, severe haze weather can lead to long-term health damages, reduced crop productivity, aesthetic value of reduced visibility, avertive expenditures, accidents, loss of life, evacuations, and loss of confidence by foreign investors.
Health effects of haze
The health effects of haze are mainly caused by the irritant effects of fine dust particles on the nose, throat, airways, skin and eyes. The health effects of haze will depend on its severity as measured by the Pollutants Standards Index (PSI). There is also individual variation regarding the ability to tolerate air pollution. Most people would at most experience sneezing, running nose, eye irritation, dry throat and dry cough from the pollutants. They are mild and pose no danger to the health of the general population.
However, persons with medical problems like asthma, chronic lung disease, chronic sinusitis and allergic skin conditions are likely to be more affected by the haze and they may experience more severe symptoms. Children and the elderly in general are more likely to be affected. For some, symptoms may worsen with physical activities.
The below solutions are proposed by Dennis et al. to mitigate the direct and indirect causes of fires which result in haze.
Reduce the use of fire as a tool in land clearing
Indonesian law prohibits the use of fire to clear land for any agriculture but weak enforcement is a major issue. Many companies have also claimed that zero burning is impractical and uncompetitive given the lack of meaningful penalties for illegal burning.
Resolve problems relating to land-use allocations and tenure
Research shows that the most common cause of fire was related to competition and conflict about land tenure and land allocation. Land-use allocation decisions made by central government agencies often overlap with the concession boundaries of local jurisdictions and indigenous communities’ territories. Regional reforms are needed to resolve the resource conflicts and they offer opportunities for the regional government to reconcile decisions with those of local and customary institutions. Regional reforms should also ensure that land and resource allocations and decisions at all levels are compatible with physical site characteristics, prominently taking fire risks into account. However, Indonesia’s legacy of inaccurate maps, overlapping boundaries, and a lack of technical expertise at the Provincial and District levels will make this a difficult task.
Reduce forest degrading practices
Policies to improve land management and measures to restore ecological integrity to degraded natural forests are extremely important to reduce the incidence of repeated fires. Promoting community involvement in such rehabilitation efforts is critical for their success in reducing fire risks.
Build institutional capacity to prevent and suppress fires
The fires in Kalimantan and Sumatra highlight the need to develop fire management systems that address concerns of specific areas. Sufficient resources must be made available to improve fire management in regions that need them, while recognising the diverse needs of different regions and the people within them.
Technology such as remote sensing, digital mapping, and instantaneous communications can help to predict, detect, and respond to potential fire crises. However, such technology should be broadly accessible, widely used, and transparently controlled before they can be effective in improving fire management in remote regions.
Implement economic disincentives and incentives
In addition to effective criminal and monetary penalties for illegal burning and liability for fire damage, some policy analysts believe in the potential for economic policy reforms and market-based incentives. A combination of eco-labeling and international trade restrictions could reduce markets for commodities that posed high-fire risks in their production. The government could also provide fiscal advantages to support companies’ investments in fire management.
- 1997 Southeast Asian haze
- 1997 Indonesian forest fires
- 2005 Malaysian haze
- 2006 Southeast Asian haze
- 2009 Southeast Asian haze
- 2013 Southeast Asian haze
- 2015 Southeast Asian haze
- 2016 Southeast Asian haze (Affected Thailand & Indonesia in the earlier part of the year, affected Singapore at 26/8/2016, which 3 hr PSI peak at 215)
- "Regional Haze Action Plan". ASEAN.org. Haze Action Online. Retrieved 23 February 2014.
- "Why is South-East Asia's annual haze so hard to deal with?". The Economist. Retrieved 28 June 2014.
- Lee, Min Kok. "Haze in Singapore: A problem dating back 40 years". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 2 October 2015. Retrieved 3 October 2015.
- Soeriaatmadja, Wahyudi. "Minister blasts execs of firm that denied burning forest". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 13 October 2015. Retrieved 13 October 2015.
- "What causes South East Asia's haze?". BBC News. 16 September 2015. Archived from the original on 3 October 2015. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
- "Southeast Asia's haze: what's behind the annual outbreaks?". Agence France-Presse. 17 September 2015. Archived from the original on 27 September 2015. Retrieved 26 September 2015.
- Fogarty, David. "Lucrative illegal market for crop land a key cause of fires: Researcher". The Straits Times. Archived from the original on 28 September 2015. Retrieved 27 September 2015.
- Heil, A.; Goldammer, J. G. (1 August 2001). "Smoke-haze pollution: a review of the 1997 episode in Southeast Asia". Regional Environmental Change. 2 (1): 24–37. doi:10.1007/s101130100021.
- "Guide to the #haze in infographics". Retrieved 21 September 2015.
- Miettinen, Jukka; Shi, Chenghua; Liew, Soo Chin (17 June 2010). "Influence of peatland and land cover distribution on fire regimes in insular Southeast Asia". Regional Environmental Change. 11 (1): 191–201. doi:10.1007/s10113-010-0131-7.
- Dennis, Rona A. (August 2005). "Fire, People and Pixels: Linking Social Science and Remote Sensing to Understand Underlying Causes and Impacts of Fires in Indonesia". Human Ecology. 33 (4): 465–504. doi:10.1007/s10745-005-5156-z.
- Varkkey, Helena. "Patronage politics, plantation fires and transboundary haze". Environmental Hazards. 12 (3-4): 200–217. doi:10.1080/17477891.2012.759524.
- "Infographic (in Indonesian)". Tempo.co. Retrieved 17 May 2014.
- "Property Rights & Resource Governance, Indonesia" (PDF). USAID.
- Carder, Reuben. "Indonesian villagers think their land tenure is stronger than it actually is – study". CIFOR. Retrieved 15 May 2014.
- Colfer, Carol; Resosudarmo, Ida Aju Pradnja (2002). "Ten propositions to explain Kalimantan's fires" in Which way forward?. Washington, D.C.: Resources for the Future. p. 315. ISBN 1891853457.
- Joosten, Hans (2009). The Global Peatland CO2 Picture: peatland status and drainage related emissions in all countries of the world (PDF). Wetlands International.
- Peatlands in Southeast Asia: A Profile. ASEAN Secretariat and Global Environment Centre. 2011.
- "Two years of aerosol pollution monitoring in Singapore: a review". Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms. 150 (1-4): 457–464. 1999. doi:10.1016/S0168-583X(98)01053-2.
- edited by David Glover & Timothy Jessup (2006). Indonesia's fires and haze the cost of catastrophe (Reprint 2006 with update. ed.). Ottawa: International Development Research Centre. ISBN 1-55250-332-1.
- "Health Effects Of Haze". Ministry of Health Singapore. Retrieved 11 April 2014.