Soviet westward offensive of 1918–19

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Soviet westward offensives of 1918–1919
Part of Russian Civil War, Polish-Soviet War, Estonian War of Independence, Latvian War of Independence, Lithuanian Wars of Independence, and Ukrainian War of Independence
Date November 18, 1918 – March, 1919
Location Belarus, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania,
Poland, Russia, Ukraine
Result Soviet defeat
Belligerents
Belarus Belarus
 Estonia
 Latvia
Lithuania Lithuania
Poland Poland
Romania Romania
Russia White Movement
Ukraine Ukraine
 United Kingdom
German Empire Ober Ost
Finnish volunteers
 Russian SFSR
Commanders and leaders
Estonia Johan Laidoner
Flag of Poland.svg Józef Piłsudski
Flag of the German Empire.svg Max Hoffmann
Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic Jukums Vācietis
Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic Dmitry Nikolayevich Nadyozhny
Strength
Estonia: 19,000[1]
Poland: ?
285,000

The Soviet westward offensive of 1918–1919 was part of the general move of the Russian Soviet Federated Socialist Republic into areas abandoned by the Ober Ost garrisons that were being withdrawn to Germany following that country's defeat in World War I. The initially successful offensive against Estonia ignited the Estonian War of Independence which ended with the Soviet recognition of Estonia. The war against Latvia and Lithuania was more successful and the Latvian Socialist Soviet Republic and Lithuanian Soviet Socialist Republics were established. In Belarus the Belarusian People's Republic was conquered and the Socialist Soviet Republic of Byelorussia proclaimed.

The campaign eventually bogged down and led to the Estonian Pskov Offensive, the White Russian Petrograd Offensives, Lithuanian–Soviet War, Latvian War of Independence, continuation of the Ukrainian–Soviet War and start of the Polish-Soviet War.

Soviet war aims[edit]

The newly formed Red Army was growing in personnel, and Vladimir Lenin could gather enough strength to replace withdrawing Western curtain forces ("Западная завеса") by solid military and re-take the lands lost by Russia in 1917 by simply following the withdrawing German army. Upon receiving the news about the German Revolution, on November 13, 1918, the Soviet government annulled the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk and issued orders to the Red Army to move in the direction of Belarus, Ukraine and the Baltic States in order to establish Soviet governments there. The move of the newly created (on November 16) Western Army that started at night of November 17, 1918, in the operational vacuum created by the withdrawing German Imperial army, in the geneal direction of Belarus, Ukraine and Poland (parts of the latter within the Imperial Russia were referred to as "Privislinsky Krai" ), according to N. Davies, was code-named Target-Vistula.

The offensive in the Vistula River direction by the newly created Western Army had the aim of establishing similar Soviet governments in Belarus, Ukraine and Poland and to drive as far west as possible in order to join up with the German Revolution and to ignite the World revolution.

Background[edit]

After signing the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, Bolshevik Russia lost the European lands it annexed in the 18th and 19th centuries. Most of today's Poland, Belarus, Ukraine and the Baltic States were granted to the government of Germany, which in turn decided to grant these states limited independence as buffer states. However, the German defeat on the Western Front and the internal dissolution of Austria-Hungary made the plans for creation of Mitteleuropa obsolete.

In November and December the German army started a retreat westwards. Demoralised officers and mutinous soldiers abandoned their garrisons en masse and returned home. The areas abandoned by the Central Powers became a field of conflict between local puppet governments created by Germany as part of its plans, local nationalist governments that sprung up after the withdrawal of the Germans, Poland, and the Bolsheviks wanting to incorporate these areas into Bolshevik Russia. Belarusian, Estonian, Latvian, Lithuanian, Ukrainian and even Cossack national governments were formed. Internal power struggles prevented any of the governments in Belarus from gaining lasting power. In Ukraine the situation was even more complex, with an ongoing conflict between Makhno's anarchists, communists, the White Movement, various governments of Ukraine and the reborn Polish Army. The entire region abandoned by the German forces became a gigantic free-for-all theatre, where dozens of factions competed for power.

The Bolsheviks were also implementing a new strategy, "Revolution from abroad" (Revolutsiya izvne—literally, "revolution from the outside"), based on an assumption that revolutionary masses desire revolution but are unable to carry it out without help from more organized and advanced Bolsheviks. Hence, as Leon Trotsky remarked, the revolution should be "brought on bayonets" (of the Red Army), as "through Kiev leads the straight route for uniting with Austro-Hungarian revolution, just as through Pskov and Vilnius goes the way for uniting with German revolution. Offensive on all fronts! Offensive on the west front, offensive on the south front, offensive on the all revolutionary fronts!". The concept was developed in 1918 but officially published under that name first in 1920 (Wojennaja Mysl i Riewolucija, 3/1920, Mikhail Tukhachevsky.[2]

Territories occupied by Germany during 1918
Estonian and Soviet operations in Estonia and Latvia, 1918–19
Soviet operations in Southeast Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and Belorussia in 1918–19
Latvian, Lithuanian and Polish counterattacks
Polish-Ukrainian front and Polish-Soviet front as forming in February 1919

Offensives[edit]

Estonian direction[edit]

The Gdov and Yamburg Detachments of the 7th Red Army attacked the German Infanterie-Regiment Nr. 405 defending the city of Narva on 22 November 1918. The 6th Red Division captured the railway junction of Tapa from the freshly formed Estonian 4th and 5th Regiments on Christmas Eve and advanced to 34 km (21 mi) from the capital Tallinn. The local Bolsheviks declared the Estonian Workers' Commune in Narva. In south Estonia the 49th Red Latvian Rifle Regiment took the railway junction of Valga on 17 December and the city of Tartu on December 24. The Estonian Army stopped the 7th Red Army's advance along the entire front on 2–5 January. Two days later Estonian forces began the counteroffensive to expel the Soviet forces from Estonia. A Finnish volunteer marine brigade landed in the rear of the 6th Red Division, and the 1st Estonian Division captured Narva on 18 January.

Subsequently, the northeastern front stabilized along the Narva River. In South Estonia the Estonian commando-type Tartumaa Partisan Battalion drove the Red Latvian rifle regiments out of Valga on 31 January. The 7th Red Army was temporally forced out of the boundaries of Estonia. On 16 February the Red army started a counteroffensive to recapture Estonia. The newly formed Estonian Red Army gained the Setomaa, Vastseliina and Räpina Parishes by 15 March. The Estonian 2nd Division counterattacked and regained Petseri by 28 March. Similar combat took place between the Estonian Army and the Northern Group of the Latvian Red Army along the AinažiStrenčiAlūksne front stabilized in northern Latvia. In the positions along the Narva River, the Estonian 1st Division repelled 7th Red Army attacks.[3]

Polish direction[edit]

On January 5, 1919, the Red Army entered Minsk almost unopposed, putting an end to the short-lived Belarusian People's Republic. At the same time \Polish and Belarusian self-defence units sprung up across western Belarus. Ill-equipped and composed mostly of local recruits, they were determined to defend their homes from what the newspapers described as a Red Menace. Similar Bolshevik groups were operating in the sector and a series of skirmishes ensued. The Polish-Soviet struggle over Vilna in the first week of 1919 was a sign of things to come, as the Polish militia was forced to withdraw after the first organised units of the Soviet Western Army entered the city. In response, the Polish Army started sending units eastwards to help the self-defence, while the Soviets did the same but in the opposite direction. Open conflict seemed inevitable.

On January 12 Soviet High Command declared the goal of its "Target Vistula" operation: deep scouting towards the Neman River. On February 12 that goal was updated to the Bug river.(Davies, p. 12) On that day Jukums Vācietis ordered the new Western Command to carry out a "reconnaissance in depth" as far as Tilsit, Brest-Litovsk, Kowel and Rowne. He also ordered the securing of main railway junctions, including those in Wilno, Lida, Baranowicze and Luninets.(Davies, p. 39)

Among the aims of the Bolsheviks was to drive through eastern and central Europe and support the Revolutions in Germany and Austria-Hungary.(Davies, p. 29) The Bolshevik Russian forces did not anticipate serious opposition on the way and saw the states of Poland, Belarus and Lithuania as mere ephemerides, unable do defend their own temporary borders. However, it is unlikely that the Soviets really expected to reach the Vistula. The military orders were full of propaganda. The main goal of the operation was likely to see how much territory could be opportunistically grabbed in the chaotic governmental flux caused by the after-effects of WW I in Europe's east before any serious independent governing authorities arose. (Davies, p. 12 and p. 13)

Finally, the first Polish-Soviet clashes happened in the area of the towns of Bereza Kartuska (February 14) and Mosty,[disambiguation needed] where both armies clashed in a series of skirmishes. The Bolshevik offensive came to a halt by late February and it became apparent that the Red Army would not break through the Polish lines by half-hearted attacks. Both the Soviet offensive and the Polish counterattack started at the same time, which resulted in an increasing number of troops being brought to the area. In April the Bolsheviks captured Grodno and Wilno, but were soon pushed out by the Polish counteroffensive.

Romanian direction[edit]

In early 1918, Bessarabia, a former Russian province, united with Romania after two months of independence. The new Communist Russian Government did not accept the union and tried to retake the region by force. However, it all amounted to several sporadic attacks along the Dniester river. The Russians also attacked in order to support Communist Hungary, who also had a war with Romania. It was to no avail, as the region was successfully defended against Bolshevik attacks.[citation needed]

Aftermath[edit]

The Estonian and Polish armies proved to be far more difficult opponents than the Red Army had assumed. The Pskov Offensive of the Estonian Petseri Battle Group destroyed the Estonian Red Army, captured Pskov and expelled Soviet forces from the territory between Estonia and the Velikaya River on 25 May. The 7th and 15th Red Armies began a counteroffensive in Ingria and in the north of Pskov in July 1919, which regained most of the lost territories of Petrograd and the northern Pskov regions. With weapons provided by Britain and France and operational support by the Estonian Army and the Royal Navy, the White Russian Northwestern Army began the Offensive Operation "White Sword" on 28 September 1919 with the aim of capturing Petrograd. The Northwestern Army approached to within ten miles (16 km) of the city, but the 7th Red Army repulsed the White Russian troops, driving them back into Estonia.[3]

Although the orders for the Target-Vistula operation were never withdrawn, Russian plans were soon made obsolete by growing Polish resistance and eventually by the Polish counter-offensive in April. Unable to accomplish their objectives, the Red Army withdrew from their positions and started a reorganisation. The Polish-Soviet War had begun.

Analysis[edit]

The best known comprehensive historical analysis of the campaign against Poland was performed by Norman Davies in his book White Eagle, Red Star (1972). Davies mentioned the codename for this offensive: Target Vistula; however, it is not commonly used in historiography.[4]

Notes[edit]

  1. ^ Maide, J. (1933). "IV". Ülevaade Eesti Vabadussõjast 1918–1920. Tartu: Kaitseliidu kirjastus. OCLC 250435918. 
  2. ^ (Polish) Bohdan Urbankowski, Józef Piłsudski: marzyciel i strateg (Józef Piłsudski: Dreamer and Strategist), Wydawnictwo ALFA, Warsaw, 1997, ISBN 83-7001-914-5, p. 293
  3. ^ a b Estonian War of Independence 1918–1920. Jyri Kork (Ed.). Esto, Baltimore, 1988 (Reprint from Estonian War of Independence 1918–1920. Historical Committee for the War of Independence, Tallinn, 1938)
  4. ^ Norman Davies in his book claims that "Target Vistula" ("Цель – Висла" or similar) was the Soviet codename of the offensive. This term, however, is mostly absent in Polish and Soviet historiography of the period. In this association one may notice the title "An Expedition beyond Vistula" (Pokhod za Vislu) of Tukhachevsky's memoirs about his Polish campaign. Other translations of the offensive include Operation Vistula (from Polish Operacja Wisła). This name is used for example in Jan Pieszczachowicz (ed.). "Operacja Wisła". WIEM Encyklopedia (in Polish). VIII. Kraków: Fogra. ISBN 83-85719-68-7. Archived from the original on June 28, 2006.  or Andrzej Leszek Szczesniak, Wojna polsko-bolszewicka 1918–1920, THE SUMMIT TIMES, Vol. 9, Issue No. 28/2002. Please notice that the term "Operation Vistula" commonly refers to a totally different event.

References[edit]

  • Davies, Norman, White Eagle, Red Star: the Polish-Soviet War, 1919–20, Pimlico, 2003, ISBN 0-7126-0694-7. (First edition: St. Martin's Press, Inc., New York, 1972)