Special (Garbage song)
|Single by Garbage|
|from the album Version 2.0|
|B-side||"13 x Forever"|
|Released||October 5, 1998
(See release history)
|Format||3" CD single
CD maxi, Cassette single
|Recorded||March 1997 - February 1998
|Genre||Alternative rock, power pop,|
|Label||Mushroom Records UK
Almo Sounds (North America)
|Garbage singles chronology|
"Special" is an alternative rock song written, performed and produced by Garbage, and was the third international single to be released from the band's platinum second album Version 2.0. "Special" gained much attention in the music press upon the 1998 release of Version 2.0, as it contained a vocal interpolation of a lyric taken from "Talk of The Town" by The Pretenders.
A moderate hit in the United Kingdom and Australia in October 1998, "Special" became a sleeper hit in the United States the following year. The song's success was marked by becoming nominated in the Best Rock Song and Best Rock Performance by a Duo or Group categories at the 2000 Grammy Awards, and winning a Wisconsin Area Music Industry award for Song of the Year and a Citation of Achievement from the BMI Pop Awards. The acclaimed sci-fi inspired music video for "Special" also received multiple nominations from music industry award panels; winning a D&AD Award, a MTV Video Music Award, and a VH1 Visionary Video award.
Composition and recording
Garbage began writing their second album, which would go under the working title of Sad Alcoholic Clowns, in March 1997 in the band's label-head Jerry Moss's Friday Harbor, Washington, vacation house. The group demoed and made rough outlines for new songs, of which "Special", was one of. When they felt they had made a good start, Garbage took the work they made in Washington back to their Madison, Wisconsin base at Smart Studios and begin fleshing out the ideas and rough sketches over the following year.
Garbage intended their second album to build upon the framework, music style and musical template laid down by their first release; to create a rapprochement between the "high-tech and low-down, the now sound and of golden memories" and wear musical references to the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s. Garbage recorded all of their work for the second album through a 48-track digital system digitally, direct to hard drives utilizing a 24bit Pro Tools rig.
Garbage employed touring bassist Daniel Shulman to perform electric bass on "Special", which he performed using a Fender Precision Bass run through an Ampeg SVT and then treated with "severe" equalization to achieve a Paul McCartney-esque Höfner sound to the part. The guitar solo intro (which returns at the end of both choruses) was performed on a 12-string Rickenbacker guitar. At the end of the first chorus, Garbage recorded a multi-tracked harmony vocal from Manson ("I can't think of any latter-day bands where a female is singing those sort of stacked '60's style vocals").
While experimenting with various phrasing over the outro to "Special", group vocalist Shirley Manson ad-libbed "We were the talk of the town" from the refrain of The Pretenders song "Talk of The Town". The band were keen to keep the lyric, and to circumvent any potential legal problems, Manson contacted Chrissie Hynde by telephone to ask for permission to use the lyric. Hynde agreed to let Garbage use the lyric without even hearing "Special" first (and did not ask for any credit or royalties); Manson felt that she should send Hynde a copy of the song just to be sure, but before she could do so, Hynde sent a fax to Smart Studios giving her written consent. Manson was reluctant to let people think that "Special" was simply a paean to Hynde; her lyrics concerned a friendship Manson had moved on from after her friend had let her down. Manson: "Ultimately it's about those feelings of betrayal you have for people when you set your sights too high and expect too much and how that can lead to disappointment in the end."
Garbage completed recording, producing and mixing of their second album in mid-February 1998, and the album was given the title Version 2.0. "Special" was tracklisted as the album's fifth song. Version 2.0 was released worldwide on May 11 of that year; despite a slow start, Version 2.0 went on to equal its predecessor, selling over four million copies and achieving platinum-certification in many territories, including United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Europe and Australia.
In advance of the UK release, Garbage promoted "Special" at the beginning of September with a live performance of the song on TFI Friday, a pre-record of both "Special" and "When I Grow Up" for Pepsi Chart Show, and also perform a three song set of "Special", "You Look So Fine" and "I Think I'm Paranoid" for broadcast on MTV Europe. Promotional discs and 12" remix packs were distributed across Europe from September 21 to clubs and DJs, which enabled the featured Brothers in Rhythm remixes to reach #6 on the pre-release industry Buzz Chart. "Special" is A-listed at Radio One and XFM and B-listed at Virgin, and also makes the playlists of 52 regional radio stations.
"Special" was released by Mushroom Records UK in the UK on October 5 on three formats. The cassette single and first CD single contains B-side "13 × Forever"; the CD also includes a Brothers in Rhythm remix. The second CD single includes a newly recorded acoustic version of Version 2.0 album track "Medication" and a club remix of "Push It" by New York club DJ Victor Calderone. On October 12, "Special" charts at #15 in the UK Singles Chart. A week after the initial single release, Mushroom issued "Special" in a collectable 3" CD single format in blister pack packaging, featuring both B-sides and the Brothers in Rhythm remix of "Special". The 3-inch CD format was deleted after one week on sale. The same week, Version 2.0 is certified platinum by the BPI for shipping over 300,000 units in the United Kingdom. Top Of The Pops broadcast the band's earlier pre-record of "Special" to mark its chart position.
Across in Europe, BMG issued "Special" on CD maxi and CD single formats in various territories from October 5. Festival Mushroom, having absorbed and folded White Records as part of a recent merger of Festival Records and Mushroom Records, released "Special" on a single CD maxi format collecting together the five tracks from the commercial UK release on October 26. "Special" peaks at #54 on the ARIA charts.
Unlike Garbage's previous single, "I Think I'm Paranoid", the release of "Special" throughout Europe occurs when Garbage are not performing locally, the band having launched the three-month-long North American fall leg of their Version 2.0 tour in Denver, Colorado on September 15. As the tour progresses, "Special" was added to Modern Rock radio stations across North America on October 12, while remixes produced by Rickidy Raw are serviced to Urban radio. "Special" debuts on the Hot Modern Rock Tracks chart at #40 on October 31. Garbage performed "Special" on Late Show with David Letterman on October 29, and the following day promoted the single on The Howard Stern Show, (but perform their 1997 Modern Rock #1 hit #1 Crush instead of "Special"). As the tour reaches Canada, Garbage perform an extended set of tracks, including "Special" for a MusiquePlus televised performance filmed in Montreal on November 14, before returning to the US to wraps up the run of headline dates on November 28 in Green Bay. The following day, Garbage immediately set out to promote Version 2.0 and "Special" on a month-long radio show circuit starting at Madison's WMAD for Modern Rock Live and on for a further twelve US radio shows; Garbage also perform "Special" live on The Tonight Show on December 11. December 20 marks the final radio show in Detroit. Imports of "Special" from Europe make enough dance club playlists by the end of 1998 that the song is certified the #3 "Hot Dance Breakout" by Billboard on December 25: "Special" makes a debut on the January 6, 1999 Hot Dance Club Play chart at #44.
On January 4, 1999, "Special" was serviced to Top 40 radio stations in a new alternate mix for airplay. This second push of "Special" dovetailed with the announcement of nominations for the 41st Grammy Awards on January 6; Version 2.0 is nominated for both Album of the Year and Best Rock Album. On January 26, "Special" is declared "#1 Most Added" track at Top 40 radio with 53 adds, beating out Whitney Houston's "It's Not Right but It's Okay". "Special" peaks on Modern Rock at #11 on January 30 (in its 14th week on the chart).
Garbage returned from a sold-out European arena tour (where during a gap in dates they performed both "Special" and "The Trick Is to Keep Breathing" acoustically on French TV show Nulle Part Ailleurs) to spend two months supporting Alanis Morissette on her North American Junkie arena tour from February 16 in Cincinnati, Ohio. On February 20, "Special" registers on the Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles chart at #13, and, as mainstream airplay for the single increases, climbs to #1 in that chart over the next five weeks.
On March 6, "Special" peaked at #10 on its ninth week on the Hot Dance Club Play chart) and also debuts at #35 on the Hot Adult Top 40 chart. The following week, "Special" debuted at #40 on the Top 40 Mainstream chart. On March 20, during a break in the Junkie tour, Garbage perform both "Special" and "When I Grow Up" as that week's musical guests on entertainment show Saturday Night Live. March 27 sees "Special" debut on both the Billboard Hot 100 chart (at #88) and the Hot 100 Airplay chart (at #71). Garbage continue to promote the single on talk shows Charlie Rose and The Late Late Show, and return to The Tonight Show to perform "Special" for a second time on April 2. The Junkie tour ends on April 7 in Los Angeles; the following week "Special" makes its final appearance on one chart (Hot Dance Club Play, at #43, its fourteenth week) and its first on another (Top 40 Tracks, at #39). "Special" registers its last charting on the Modern Rock rankings at #35 on April 24, having enjoyed a twenty-six week chart run (however, a week later, "When I Grow Up" debuts on the Modern Rock chart).
"Special" continues to ride high in the mainstream charts throughout May 1999; peaking at #16 on the May 8 Hot Adult Top 40 (in its tenth week on that chart); and peaking for three weeks from the same date at #18 on the Top 40 Mainstream chart. "Special" peaks at #22 on Top 40 Tracks chart seven days later. The week of May 22 sees "Special" reach its highest position on both the Hot 100 (at #52, in its ninth week of thirteen) and on the Hot 100 Airplay (at #42, and in its eighth of ten). "Special" ends its chart runs on both the Hot 100 Airplay and Top 40 Tracks on June 5; on both the Hot 100 and Top 40 Mainstream on June 19; and after twenty two weeks on Hot Adult Top 40 Tracks on July 31.
The promotional video for "Special" was filmed over a four-day shoot in London at the end of August 1998 by director Dawn Shadforth for Black Dog/RSA Films. Shadforth came to Garbage's attention when they viewed her clip for "Beat Goes On" by electronica group All Seeing I. Her innovative storyboard treatment for "Special" highly impressed the band - her concept was not an obvious idea for a song like "Special".
Her concept for "Special" featured the members of Garbage in a dogfight in the skies of an alien world. Before production of the video commenced, Shadforth fashioned four study models of the fighter planes to enable her to plan in advance the shots and edits she needed to tell the storyline. The planes were designed by graphic artists who had worked on visual effects for Lost In Space and Star Wars Episode I: The Phantom Menace. Each band member was given a personalized plane design, emblazoned with imagery inspired by manga and sci-fi art; while each filmed their parts in a cabin set built upon a gimbal to give realism to the shots. Stylist William Baker, who worked on the video, said "Dawn wanted to present Shirley Manson as a space-age fighter pilot, with shots showing her sexily manipulating the controls of her craft". Shadforth later used techniques she used on the "Special" video in her 2001 music video for Kylie Minogue's "Can't Get You Out of My Head".
Throughout 1999, the "Special" music video received a number of nominations from industry panels. In April, Garbage were the leading nominee for the MVPA Music Video Awards industry event, with six nominations shared between the videos for "Special" and "Push It". "Special" was nominated for Best Special Effects (to SFX UK). In September, the "Special" video was nominated for Best Art Direction and won the award for Best Special Effects at the MTV Video Music Awards (given to effects team Shawn Broughton and Stuart Gordon of Digital Domain). In December, the "Special" video won the Visionary Video award at the VH1 Fashion Awards. The "Special" video also won a 'silver' Design and Art Direction award for Best Direction in Pop Promo Video and was nominated for a CAD (Creative and Design) Award for Best Special Effects (to Paul Simpson, Stuart Gordon, and Sean Broughton).
The "Special" music video began airing across Europe in mid-September 1998 and premiered on North American music stations on December 6, 1998. A remastered version of the full-length video was included on Garbage's 2007 greatest hits DVD Absolute Garbage, and the original shorter edit made available as a digital download via online music services later the same year. The full length video was made available to North American online music stores in 2010.
|Track title||Length||Remixer/Producer||Commercial release|
|"Special (Pop mix)"||3:35||Garbage||No|
|"Special (Brothers In Rhythm Club mix (Radio edit))"||4:11||Brothers in Rhythm||No|
|"Special (Brothers In Rhythm Club mix)"||7:24||Yes|
|"Special (Brothers In Rhythm Club mix)" 12" mix||9:58||No|
|"Special (Brothers In Rhythm Club mix (Instrumental))"||10:00||No|
|"Special (Rickidy Raw R+B remix)"||3:25||Rickidy Raw||Yes|
|"Special (Rickidy Raw Late Night mix)"||3:58||No|
For the initial release of "Special", Brothers in Rhythm's remix was included. Several early press releases for the single also included a remix by Nellee Hooper, but this version remains unreleased. Rickidy Raw's remixes were commissioned to service to North American urban radio stations, and his "R + B remix" saw a commercial release in the UK on formats of "When I Grow Up" and in Europe on "The Trick Is to Keep Breathing"
In 2007, Brothers in Rhythm's remix was remastered and included on the Absolute Garbage bonus disc Garbage Mixes.
"Special" end-of-year poll results:
- 42 in WHFS's "Top 99.1 Songs of 1998"
- 51 in WFNX's "Top 101.7 of 1998"
- 64 in KROQ's "Top 106.7 of 1998"
- 65 in Live 105's "Top 105.3 of 1998"
- 89 in Triple J's "Hottest 100 of 1998"
- 102 in Radio & Records "Top 103 of 1998"
- 11 in KROQ's "Top 106.7 of 1999"
- 16 in 89X's "Top 89 Songs of 1999"
- 36 in Radio & Records "Top 103 of 1998"
- 37 in Live 105's "Top 105.3 of 1999"
- 51 in WHFS's "Top 99.1 Songs of 1999"
- 54 in Q101's "Top 101 of 1999"
- 57 in WFNX's "Top 99 of 1999"
- 66 in The End's "Top 107 of 1999"
Credits and personnel
Brothers In Rhythm remixes
Rickidy Raw remixes
|Release Date||Territory||Record Label||Format(s)|
|September 21, 1998||United Kingdom||Mushroom Records UK||Airplay|
|October 5, 1998||2×CD single set, cassette single|
|Europe||BMG||CD maxi, CD single|
|October 12, 1998||United Kingdom||Mushroom Records UK||3" CD single|
|United States||Almo Sounds||Airplay: Modern Rock|
|October 28, 1998||Australia||Mushroom Records||CD maxi|
|January 4, 1999||United States||Almo Sounds||Airplay: CHR/Top 40|
|Australia Singles Chart (ARIA)||54|
|Canada Top 100 Singles (RPM)||62|
|Canada Alternative 30 (RPM)||24|
|Europe Top 50 Airplay (Music & Media)||38|
|Spain Top 40 Airplay Chart (AFYVE)||25|
|Scotland (Official Charts Company)||8|
|United Kingdom Singles Chart (CIN)||15|
|United Kingdom Airplay Chart (CIN)||19|
|Canada Top 100 Singles (RPM)||42 (RE)|
|U.S. Billboard Hot 100||52|
|U.S. Billboard Hot 100 Airplay||42|
|U.S. Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles (Billboard)[A]||101|
|U.S. Hot Modern Rock Tracks (Billboard)||11|
|U.S. Hot Dance Music/Club Play (Billboard)||10|
|U.S. Adult Top 40 (Billboard)||16|
|U.S. Top 40 Mainstream (Billboard)||18|
|U.S. Top 40 Tracks (Billboard)||22|
^ A Bubbling Under Hot 100 Singles lists the top twenty-five singles which had not, at the time of publishing, charted on the Hot 100 chart. "Special" technically topped this chart.
- Hogwood, Ben (23 July 2007). "Garbage – Absolute Garbage – Greatest Hits". Retrieved 21 October 2014.
strong supporting cast of the power pop trio Push It, Special and When I Grow Up
- "Garbage - Special". Billboard.com. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- "42nd Annual Grammy Awards nominations". dIGITALhIT.com. Retrieved 2009-02-19.
- "Garbage". RockontheNet.com. Retrieved 2006-09-20.
- "Rob Thomas, Eagle-Eye Cherry Receive BMI Awards". MTV.
- "Realise Studio: Awards". RealiseStudio.com.
- "New Best Of Album". Garbage.com. Retrieved 2009-02-19.
- "Garbage Experiment With New Sounds For Next Album". Addicted to Noise (archived at Garbage.net). Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- "Almo/Mushroom's Garbage Puts Cyber Spin on Classic Pop Spirit". Billboard magazine (reproduced on Cafemomo.com). Archived from the original on November 22, 2001. Retrieved 2010-10-29.
- "Talking Tech and Trash with Garbage", Musician magazine, October 1998 issue
- Murphy, Peter S. (May 13, 1998). "Modern Life is Rubbish". Archived from the original on December 8, 2000. Retrieved 2011-07-20.
- Garbage: Special Effects, published by Melody Maker, October 11, 1998 issue
- Beautifulgarbage press release. Retrieved 2010-10-29
- "Garbage 1998 Setlists". Garbagebase.com. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- "beautifulgarbage promotional history press release" Retrieved 2009-02-19
- ""Special" release discography". The Garbage Discography site. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- "Garbage Record Acoustic B-Side For Next Single". GarbageDiscoBox.com (originally published on VH1.com). Retrieved 2007-11-07.
- "TOP 40 OFFICIAL UK SINGLES ARCHIVE (17th October 1998)". The Official Charts Company.
- "Certified Awards". BPI.co.uk. Retrieved 2007-11-07.
- "Garbage Fast Facts". Garbage.com. Archived from the original on April 8, 2000. Retrieved 2009-02-19.
- Garbage - Special. Billboard magazine, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2010-10-31.
- "10.29.98 Road Report Five For 98 - New York Media Blitz (or 2 days in hell)". Garbage.com. Retrieved 2009-02-19.
- Hot Dance Breakouts: Garbage - Special (Mushroom Import, #3). Billboard magazine, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- Hot Dance Club Play chart, issue January 6th, 1999). Billboard magazine, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- "Special / Garbage.". United States Copyright Office. January 4, 1999. Retrieved 2011-07-27.
SR0000263627; Special / Garbage; Almo Sound AMS5P-8070; 3 versions; © ℗ Almo Sounds, Inc.
- Hits magazine ("Special" trade ad) Retrieved 2009-02-19
- "Top Grammy nominations". The Register-Guard. Guard Publishing. January 6, 1999. Retrieved November 24, 2010.
- Hot Modern Rock Tracks chart, issue January 30th, 1999). Billboard magazine, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- "Garbage 1999 Setlists". Garbagebase.com. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- "Garbage > Charts & Awards". AllMusic. Retrieved April 23, 2008.
- Hot Dance Club Play chart, issue March 6th, 1999). Billboard magazine, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- Hot 100 chart, issue March 27th, 1999). Billboard magazine, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- Hot 100 Airplay chart, issue March 27th, 1999). Billboard magazine, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2010-11-24.
- Adult Top 40. Billboard, issue dated May 8, 1999, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2011-02-16.
- Billboard Hot 100. Billboard, issue dated May 22, 1999, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2011-02-13.
- Billboard Hot 100 Airplay. Billboard, issue dated May 22, 1999, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2011-02-16.
- Rock Is War!. Boston: Raygun. April 1, 1999. Archived from the original on February 12, 2011.
- "Mirrorball; Dawn Shadforth (part 2 of 3)". Blackwatch Production / Channel 4. Archived from the original on August 6, 2007. Retrieved 2011-07-21.
- William Baker, Kylie Minogue (2002). Kylie: La La La. Hodder & Staughton. ISBN 0-340-73439-6.
- "The Eye: Garbage, Busta, Squarepusher Among Nominees For Mvpa Awards". Billboard, reproduced on AllBusiness.com.
- "Nominees For the 8th Annual MVPA Awards". Music Video Production Association. Archived from the original on October 9, 1999. Retrieved 2011-08-20.
- "Ricky Martin, Lauryn Hill Dominate At MTV Video Music Awards". MTV. 10 September 199. Retrieved 31 January 2015. Check date values in:
- "VH1/Vogue dole out fashion awards". CNN. December 6, 1999. Retrieved 2011-07-20.
- "Special". United States Copyright Office. December 6, 1998. Retrieved 2011-07-27.
PA0000921459; Special; Videocassette; 3/4 in; Music video performed by Garbage; Almo Sounds, Inc.
- "Special by Garbage". iTunes UK Store. Retrieved 2011-07-21.
- "Special by Garbage". iTunes US Store. Retrieved 2011-07-21.
- "RPM 100 Hit Tracks". RPM 68 (11). December 7, 1998. Retrieved February 16, 2011.
- "RPM Alternative 30". RPM 68 (8). November 16, 1998. Retrieved February 16, 2011.
- Version 2.0: International Sales Report, internal document published by Mushroom Records UK distributed to shareholders and relevant stakeholders, published June 2001
- Sólo éxitos. Año a año. 1959-2002, by Fernando Salaverri, published by the Foundation Author of the General Society of Authors and Editores (SGAE), 2002
- "Official Scottish Singles Chart Top 100; 11 October 1998 - 17 October 1998". Official Charts Company. Retrieved 2015-02-22.
- Music Week, issue dated October 19, 1998
- "RPM 100 Hit Tracks". RPM 69 (7). June 7, 1999. Retrieved February 16, 2011.
- Hot Modern Rock Tracks. Billboard, issue dated January 30, 1999, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2011-02-16.
- Hot Dance Music/Club Play. Billboard, issue dated March 6, 1999, reproduced on Google Books. Retrieved 2011-02-16.
- Garbage official website
- "Special" music video
- "Special" lyrics
- "Special" release discography
- Full lyrics of this song at MetroLyrics