Speech sound disorder
|This article needs additional citations for verification. (December 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)|
Speech sound disorders are speech disorders in which some speech sounds (called phonemes) in a child's (or, sometimes, an adult's) language are either not produced, not produced correctly, or are not used correctly. The term protracted phonological development is sometimes preferred when describing children's speech to emphasize the continuing development while acknowledging the delay.
Errors produced by children with speech sound disorders are typically classified into four categories:
- Omissions: Certain sounds are not produced — entire syllables or classes of sounds may be deleted; e.g., fi' for fish or 'at for cat.
- Additions (or Epentheses/Commissions): an extra sound or sounds are added to the intended word; e.g. puh-lane for plane.
- Distortions: Sounds are changed slightly so that the intended sound may be recognized but sounds "wrong," or may not sound like any sound in the language.
- Substitutions: One or more sounds are substituted for another; e.g., wabbit for rabbit or tow for cow.
Sometimes, even for experts, telling exactly which type has been made is not obvious — some distorted forms of /r/ may be mistaken for /w/ by a casual observer, yet may not actually be either sound but somewhere in between. Further, children with severe speech sound disorders may be difficult to understand, making it hard to tell what word was actually intended and thus what is actually wrong with it. Some terms can be used to describe more than one of the above categories, such as lisp, which is often the replacement of /s/ with /th/ (a substitution), but can be a distortion, producing /s/ just behind the teeth resulting in a sound somewhere between /s/ and /th/.
There are three different levels of classification when determining the magnitude and type of an error that is produced:
- Sounds the patient can produce
- A: Phonemic- can be produced easily; used meaningfully and contrastively
- B: Phonetic- produced only upon request; not used consistently, meaningfully, or contrastively; not used in connected speech
- Stimulable sounds
- A: Easily stimulable
- B: Stimulable after demonstration and probing (i.e. with a tongue depressor)
- Cannot produce the sound
- A: Cannot be produced voluntarily
- B: No production ever observed
Note that omissions do not mean the sound cannot be produced, and some sounds may be produced more easily or frequently when appearing with certain other sounds: someone might be able to say "s" and "t" separately, but not "st," or may be able to produce a sound at the beginning of a word but not at the end. The magnitude of the problem will often vary between different sounds from the same speaker.
Speech sound disorders may be subdivided into two primary types, articulation disorders (also called phonetic disorders) and phonemic disorders (also called phonological disorders). However, some may have a mixed disorder in which both articulation and phonological problems exist. Though speech sound disorders are associated with childhood, some residual errors may persist into adulthood.
Articulation disorders (also called phonetic disorders, or simply "artic disorders" for short) are based on difficulty learning to physically produce the intended phonemes. Articulation disorders have to do with the main articulators which are the lips, teeth, alveolar ridge, hard palate, velum, glottis, and the tongue. If the disorder has anything to do with any of these articulators, then it is an articulation disorder. There are usually fewer errors than with a phonemic disorder, and distortions are more likely (though any omissions, additions, and substitutions may also be present). They are often treated by teaching the child how to physically produce the sound and having them practice its production until it (hopefully) becomes natural. Articulation disorders should not be confused with motor speech disorders, such as dysarthria (in which there is actual paralysis of the speech musculature) or developmental verbal dyspraxia (in which motor planning is severely impaired).
In a phonemic disorder (also called a phonological disorders) the child is having trouble learning the sound system of the language, failing to recognize which sound-contrasts also contrast meaning. For example, the sounds /k/ and /t/ may not be recognized as having different meanings, so "call" and "tall" might be treated as homophones, both being pronounced as "tall." This is called phoneme collapse, and in some cases many sounds may all be represented by one — e.g., /d/ might replace /t/, /k/, and /g/. As a result, the number of error sounds is often (though not always) greater than with articulation disorders and substitutions are usually the most common error. Phonemic disorders are often treated using minimal pairs (two words that differ by only one sound) to draw the child's attention to the difference and its effect on communication.
Some children with phonemic disorders may seem to be able to hear phoneme distinctions in the speech of others but not their own. This is called the fis phenomenon based on scenario in which a speech pathologist will say, "Did you say 'fis,' don't you mean 'fish'?" To which the child responds, "No, I didn't say 'fis,' I said 'fis'." In some cases, the sounds produced by the child are actually acoustically different, but not significantly enough for others to distinguish - ironically, because those sounds are not phonemically unique to speakers of the language.
Though phonemic disorders are often considered language disorders in that it is the language system that is affected, they are also speech sound disorders in that the errors relate to use of phonemes. This makes them different from Specific Language Impairment (SLI), which is primarily a disorder of the syntax (grammar) and usage of language rather than the sound system. However, the two can coexist, affecting the same person.
Other disorders can deal with a variety of different ways to pronounce consonants. Some examples are glides and liquids. Glides occur when the articulatory posture changes gradually from consonant to vowel. Liquids can include /l/ and /.1/ .
Mixed speech sound disorders
In some cases phonetic and phonemic errors may coexist in the same person. In such case the primary focus is usually on the phonological component but articulation therapy may be needed as part of the process, since teaching a child how to use a sound is not practical if the child does not know how to produce it.
Even though most speech sound disorders can be successfully treated in childhood, and a few may even outgrow them on their own, errors may sometimes persist into adulthood rather than only being not age appropriate. Such persisting errors are referred to as "residual errors" and may remain for life.
Diagnosis and prognosis
In a typical 2-year-old child, about 50% of speech may be intelligible. A 4-year-old child's speech should be intelligible overall, and a 7-year-old should be able to clearly produce most words consistent with community norms for their age. Misarticulation of certain difficult sounds (l, r, s, z, th, ch, dzh, and zh) may be normal up to 8 years. Children with speech sound disorder have pronunciation difficulties inappropriate for their age, and the difficulties are not caused by hearing problems, congenital deformities, motor disorders or selective mutism.
- A. Persistent difficulty with speech sound production that interferes with speech intelligibility or prevents verbal communication of messages.
- B. The disturbance causes limitations in effective communication that interfere with social participation, academic achievement, or occupational performance, individually or in any combination.
- C. Onset of symptoms is in the early developmental period.
- D. The difficulties are not attributable to congenital or acquired conditions, such as cerebral palsy, cleft palate, deafness or hearing loss, traumatic brain injury, or other medical or neurological conditions.
For most children, the disorder is not lifelong and speech difficulties improve with time and speech-language treatment. Prognosis is poorer for children who also have a language disorder, as that may be indicative of a learning disorder.
Most speech sound disorders occur without a known cause. A child may not learn how to produce sounds correctly or may not learn the rules of speech sounds on his or her own. These children may have a problem with speech development, which does not always mean that they will simply outgrow it by themselves. Many children do develop speech sounds over time but those who do not often need the services of a Speech-Language Pathologist to learn correct speech sounds.[clarification needed]
Some speech sound errors can result from other syndromes or disorders such as:
- developmental disorders (e.g. autism)
- genetic disorders (e.g. Down syndrome)
- hearing loss, including temporary hearing loss, such as from ear infections
- cleft palate or other physical anomalies of the mouth
- neurological disorders (e.g. cerebral palsy)
- Accent (sociolinguistics)
- Developmental verbal dyspraxia
- KE family
- Infantile speech
- Speech and language pathology
- Treatment of Articulation Disorders in School Systems
- Fromkin, Victoria. (2000). "Phonology". Linguistics : an introduction to linguistic theory (Malden, Mass. ; Oxford, U.K.: Blackwell). ISBN 978-0-631-19711-9. OCLC 43577669. Missing or empty
- American Psychiatric Association, ed. (2013). "Speech Sound Disorder, 315.39 (F80.0)". Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition. American Psychiatric Publishing. pp. 44–45.
- Bauman-Wängler, Jacqueline Ann. (2004). Articulatory and phonological impairments : a clinical focus (2 ed.). Boston: Allyn and Bacon. ISBN 978-0-205-40248-9. OCLC 493612551.
- Secord, Wayne.; Boyce, Suzanne.; Donahue, JoAnn; Fox, Robert; Shine, Richard (2007). Eliciting sounds : techniques and strategies for clinician. Clifton Park, NY: Thomson Delmar Learning. ISBN 978-1-4018-9725-3. OCLC 77708677.
- Justice, Laura M. (2006). Communication sciences and disorders : an introduction. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Merrill Prentice Hall. ISBN 978-0-13-113518-5. OCLC 58563236.
- Shriberg, Lawrence D.; Kent, Raymond D. (2013). Clinical phonetics (4 ed.). Boston, MA: Pearson Education. ISBN 978-0-13-702106-2. OCLC 798389609.
- Bowen, C. (2009). Children's speech sound disorders. Oxford: Wiley-Blackwell
- Raz, M. (1992). How to Teach a Child to Say the "S" Sound in 15 Easy Lessons. GerstenWeitz Publishers ISBN 9780963542601
- Raz, M. (1996). How to Teach a Child to Say the "R" Sound in 15 Easy Lessons. GerstenWeitz Publishers ISBN 9780963542618
- Raz, M. (1999). How to Teach a Child to Say the "L" Sound in 15 Easy Lessons. GerstenWeitz Publishers ISBN 9780963542649