Steamtown National Historic Site

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Steamtown National Historic Site
Steamtown Roundhouse.jpg
Five locomotives in the roundhouse
Map showing the location of Steamtown National Historic Site
Map showing the location of Steamtown National Historic Site
Map showing the location of Steamtown National Historic Site
Map showing the location of Steamtown National Historic Site
LocationScranton, Pennsylvania, USA
Coordinates41°24′26″N 75°40′17″W / 41.40733°N 75.67132°W / 41.40733; -75.67132Coordinates: 41°24′26″N 75°40′17″W / 41.40733°N 75.67132°W / 41.40733; -75.67132
Area62.48 acres (25.28 ha)
EstablishedOctober 30, 1986
Visitors106,309[1] (in 2005)
Governing bodyNational Park Service
WebsiteSteamtown National Historic Site

Steamtown National Historic Site (NHS) is a railroad museum and heritage railroad located on 62.48 acres (25.3 ha)[2] in downtown Scranton, Pennsylvania, at the site of the former Scranton yards of the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad (DL&W). The museum is built around a working turntable and a roundhouse that are largely replications of the original DL&W facilities; the roundhouse, for example, was reconstructed from remnants of a 1932 structure. The site also features several original outbuildings dated between 1899 and 1902. All the buildings on the site are listed with the National Register of Historic Places as part of the Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad Yard-Dickson Manufacturing Co. Site.[3][4]

Most of the steam locomotives and other railroad equipment at Steamtown NHS were originally collected by F. Nelson Blount, a millionaire seafood processor from New England. In 1964, Blount established a non-profit organization, the Steamtown Foundation, to operate Steamtown, U.S.A., a steam railroad museum and excursion business in Bellows Falls, Vermont. In 1984, the foundation moved Steamtown to Scranton, conceived of as urban redevelopment and funded in part by the city. But the museum failed to attract the expected 200,000 to 400,000 annual visitors, and within two years was facing bankruptcy.[5]

Overview of Steamtown NHS

In 1986, the U.S. House of Representatives, at the urging of Scranton native Representative Joseph M. McDade, approved $8 million to begin turning the museum into a National Historic Site.[6] The idea was derided by those who called the collection second-rate, the site's historical significance questionable, and the public funding no more than pork-barrel politics.[7][8] But proponents said the site and the collection were ideal representations of American industrial history.[9] By 1995, the National Park Service (NPS) had acquired Steamtown, USA, and improved its facilities at a total cost of $66 million.

Steamtown National Historic Site has since sold a few pieces from the Blount collection, and added a few others deemed of greater historical significance to the region. By 2008, low visitor attendance and the need of costly asbestos removal from many pieces of the collection were spurring discussion about privatizing Steamtown.[10]

Museum and collection[edit]

View of the turntable and museum / roundhouse

Steamtown NHS is located within a working railroad yard and incorporates the surviving elements of the 1902 DL&W Scranton roundhouse and locomotive repair shops. The visitor center, theater, technology and history museums are built in the style of and on the site of the missing portions of the original roundhouse, giving an impression of what the original circular structure was like.[11][12]

The museum has exhibits about the history and technology of steam railroads in the United States and specifically in Pennsylvania, particularly the DL&W; life on the railroad; and the business, labor, and governmental relationships between railroads.[11] The theater shows a short film throughout the day.[12]

Many locomotives and freight and passenger cars are on display. Some have open cabs and compartments that visitors can climb in and walk through, including a mail car, railroad executives' passenger car (with dining room and sleeping / lounge areas), a boxcar, two cabooses, and a recreated DL&W station with ticket window. A steam locomotive with cutaway sections helps visitors understand steam power. Part of one of the 1865 roundhouse inspection pits uncovered in archaeological excavations is also preserved in situ, under glass.[12]

Some of the rolling stock is historically connected to the site, including a DL&W steam engine and diesel, caboose, boxcar, a former World War II troop sleeper that the DL&W converted to maintenance of way service, and numerous passenger cars. Former Oneida & Western/Rahway Valley Railroad 2-8-0 engine #15 was overhauled by the DL&W. Other noteworthy pieces are the popular Union Pacific Big Boy #4012, Canadian Pacific Railway (CP Rail) #2929 (a rare Jubilee 4-4-4), Nickel Plate Road (NKP) S-2 #759, and Reading Company (RDG) T-1 #2124.[12]

Engines NKP #759, CN #47, New Haven Trap Rock Co. #43, and Rahway Valley #15 have operated at Steamtown, but not since the move to Pennsylvania.[12]

Locomotive roster[edit]

Operating units[edit]

Number Images Heritage Type Builder Status Notes
26 Baldwin Locomotive (107600721).jpg Baldwin Locomotive Works 0-6-0 Baldwin, 1929 Operational Operated in excursion service from the 1990s to 1999. Returned to steam in December 2015. Runs excursion trains on the Scranton Limited.[13][14]
514 514 passing platform.jpg Nickel Plate Road GP-9 Electro-Motive Division, 1958 Operational Operates excursion trains from Scranton.[14]
506/504 Lackawanna 663 & 664 (6125343033).jpg Bangor and Aroostook Railroad EMD F3 Electro-Motive Division, 1948 Operational Repainted as Lackawanna 663 and 664. Operates excursion trains from Scranton.[14]

Inoperable units[edit]

Number Images Heritage Type Builder Status Notes
1 -1 Brook Scanlon at Bellowsfalls.jpg Brooks-Scanlon Corporation 2-6-2 Baldwin, 1914 Display [15]
1 -1 MRL Co Shay at Bellows Falls VT.jpg Meadow River Lumber Company Class B Shay Lima, 1910 Display, awaiting possible cosmetic restoration Damaged by building collapse in 1983.[16]
2 Bullard Co. 0-4-0T at Bellows Falls.jpg Bullard Company 0-4-0T H.K. Porter, 1937 Undergoing cosmetic restoration Smallest locomotive in the collection.[17]
3 E.J. Lavino and Company 3.PNG E.J. Lavino and Company 0-6-0T ALCO, 1927 Display [18]
7 Shs2b1.jpg Berlin Mills Railway 2-4-2T Vulcan Iron Works, 1911 Display [19]
8 Steamtown NHS-27527-4.jpg Spang, Chalfant & Co. 0-6-0 Baldwin, 1923 Sectioned display Formerly operated on the Penn View Mountain Tourist Railroad from 1964 to 1966.[20]
15 EM DSC 0830 (2733451900).jpg Rahway Valley Railroad 2-8-0 Baldwin, 1916 Display Originally built for the Oneida and Western Railroad as 20, operated in Vermont.[21]
43 EM DSC 0855 (2732591103).jpg New Haven Trap Rock Company 0-4-0T Vulcan Iron Works, 1919 Display
44 Nickel Plate -44 P6230489.jpg Nickel Plate Road 4-6-0 Brooks Locomotive Works, 1905 Display, awaiting possible cosmetic restoration Oldest surviving Nickel Plate Road locomotive.
47 Canadian National steam locomotive 47 4-6-4T at Steamtown National Historic Site 11-Nov-2011 right.jpg Canadian National Railway 4-6-4T Montreal Locomotive Works, 1914 Display, awaiting possible cosmetic restoration The first steam locomotive to pull excursion runs at Steamtown, prior to the move from Vermont.[22]
132 Wabash Railroad SW-8 Electro-Motive Division, 1953 Display Painted as Lackawanna No. 500.
210 Hugh llewelyn 210 (5978463997).jpg Norwood & St. Lawrence Railroad 2-6-0 ALCO, 1923 Display
519 Hugh llewelyn 519 (5960505783).jpg Maine Central Railroad 2-8-0 ALCO, 1913 Display, awaiting possible cosmetic restoration
565 EM DSC 0864 (2733433834).jpg Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad 2-6-0 ALCO, 1908 Display Only DL&W locomotive in the collection.
759 NKP 759 at Steamtown-2015.JPG Nickel Plate Road 2-8-4 Lima, 1944 Display Operated in excursion service between 1968 and 1973.[23][24]
790 Steamtown,Scranton,PA (201034069).jpg Illinois Central Railroad 2-8-0 ALCO, 1903 Display Oldest locomotive in the collection.[25][26]
1901 Atlantic Coast Line Railroad SW-1 Electro-Motive Division, 1939 Undergoing overhaul
1923 Hugh llewelyn 1923 (5958785236).jpg Lowville and Beaver River Railroad 2-8-0 ALCO, 1920 Display Built for Compañía Azucarera Central Reforma of Cuba as No. 8 but never delivered.
2124 EM DSC 0827 (2732535879).jpg Reading Company 4-8-4 Reading Shops, 1947 Display Built from Reading I-10sa class 2-8-0 2044[27]
2317 Canadian Pacific 2317.jpg Canadian Pacific Railway 4-6-2 Montreal Locomotive Works, 1923 Displsy Sold to Nelson Blount for Steamtown U.S.A. in November 1965. Operated in excursion service from 1978 to 2010.[28] Stored inside the shops on display.[28][14]
2505 Delaware, Lackawanna and Western Railroad Electric Multiple Unit Pullman, 1930 Display Only piece of electric equipment in the collection.
2929 Canadian Pacific 2929.jpg Canadian Pacific Railway 4-4-4 Canadian Locomotive Company, 1936 Display, awaiting possible cosmetic restoration Only streamlined steam locomotive in the collection.
3254 Steamtown NHS Train.JPG Canadian National Railway 2-8-2 Canadian Locomotive Company, 1917 Display Operated in excursion service from 1987 to 2012.[29] On static display inside the shops.[29][14]
3377 Hugh llewelyn 3377 (5958224719).jpg Canadian National Railway 2-8-2 Canadian Locomotive Company, 1919 Display, awaiting possible restoration Previously used as a spare parts provider for No. 3254. Currently on static display, awaiting for a possible restoration.[30]
3713 BostonMaine3713.jpg Boston and Maine Railroad 4-6-2 Lima, 1934 Undergoing restoration Named the "Constitution".[14]
4012 Union Pacific Big Boy 4012 May 10th, 2021.jpg Union Pacific Railroad 4-8-8-4 ALCO, 1941 Display Largest locomotive in the collection.[31][21]
6039 EM DSC 0825 (2733347630).jpg Grand Trunk Western Railroad 4-8-2 Baldwin, 1925 Display Only 4-8-2 "Mountain" type in the collection.[32]
6816 Public Service Electric and Gas Co. 0-6-0F H.K. Porter, 1923 Display Only fireless locomotive in the collection.

Former units[edit]

Number Images Heritage Type Builder Notes
2816 CPR 2816 Locomotive.JPG Canadian Pacific Railway Steam Canadian Locomotive Company Sold to CP Rail where it operates in excursion service.[33]
1293 CP 1293.jpg Canadian Pacific Railway Steam Canadian Locomotive Company Sold to Jerry Joe Jacobson to operate on the Ohio Central Railroad. Now on static display at the Age of Steam Roundhouse, awaiting its 1,472-day inspection and rebuild.[34]
1278 Canadian Pacific Railway Steam Canadian Locomotive Company Traded to Gettysburg Railroad for Canadian National 3254.[34] Now on static display at the Age of Steam Roundhouse.[34]
1246 Hugh llewelyn 1246 (5957249733).jpg Canadian Pacific Railway Steam Montreal Locomotive Works The only G5 locomotive to operate in Scranton, it was sold at an auction in 1988 to the Valley Railroad in Connecticut. Now on display at the Railroad Museum of New England.[35]
1098 Hugh llewelyn 1098 (5957808910).jpg Canadian Pacific Railway Steam Canadian Locomotive Company It was sold in 1987 to George Hart to operate for his Rail Tours Inc.. It is on static display at the Reading Blue Mountain and Northern Railroad as 225.
1218 N&W 1218 Brocton, OH on August 6, 1988 (22541514277).jpg Norfolk and Western Railway Steam Norfolk and Western’s Roanoke Shops Traded to the Norfolk Southern Railway in exchange for NKP 514 and Wabash 132 to operate in mainline excursion service from 1987 to 1991. Now on static display at the Virginia Museum of Transportation in Roanoke, Virginia.
1395 Steam Engine on Static display (49756952866).jpg Canadian National Railway Steam Montreal Locomotive Works It was sold at an auction in 1988 to the Coopersville and Marne Railway in Coopersville, Michigan. It is currently stored, awaiting a cosmetic restoration.[36]
1551 Ohio central (3856632481).jpg Canadian National Railway Steam Montreal Locomotive Works It was traded to Jerry Joe Jacobson in exchange for Baldwin Locomotive Works 26, and it became the very first steam locomotive to pull trains on the Ohio Central Railroad System. It now resides at the Age of Steam Roundhouse.[37]
5288 Montreal Loco Works 4-6-2 5288, Tennessee Valley Railroad, April 2013 CNV00050 (10319176335).jpg Canadian National Railway Steam Montreal Locomotive Works It was purchased by the Tennessee Valley Railroad Museum in Chattanooga, Tennessee in 2001 to loosely represent a Southern Railway Ps-4 class while on static display.
1361 PRR K4 4-6-2 1361 on display at Horseshoe Curve, PA on February 23, 1969 (25145573673).jpg Pennsylvania Railroad Steam Altoona Works Moved to Scranton in 1996 for a complete restoration in partnership with University of Scranton, and the Railroaders Memorial Museum. However after several years of work, the plan was cancelled in April 2010 and the engine was moved back to Altoona in 2013.[38][39][40]

Several engines not part of the collection have visited the Scranton site: NYS&W #142, BM&R #425(now Reading Blue Mountain and Northern 425), Lowville & Beaver River Shay #8, former RDG T-1 #2102 (restored and operable by Reading Blue Mountain and Northern), Milwaukee Road 261, PRR 1361 and NKP 765.[12] "Peppersass" No.1 from Mount Washington Cog Railway visited the Steamtown Scranton site during Railfest 2016, and revisited again during March 11 to 13, 2019.

Demonstrations, tours, and excursions[edit]

A Steamtown excursion crosses Tunkhannock Viaduct.

Steamtown NHS offers a variety of demonstrations, tours, and excursions that demonstrate how railroads functioned in the age of steam. Park rangers give guided tours of the locomotive shop, where one can see work being done on the steam engines in the original roundhouse area; the Union Pacific Big Boy locomotive on display; and demonstrations of the turntable on a regular basis. They also give talks on the history of Steamtown. The Scranton yard occupies about 40 acres (16 ha).

Several working locomotives take visitors on short excursions through the Scranton yard in the spring, summer, and fall. Most rides are on passenger coaches, but there are also caboose and handcar rides offered. These rides are included in the admission, although reservations may be required. Longer excursions are scheduled with separate tickets. These include a ride on a Pullman coach and longer trips to various nearby towns, including the Lackawanna River valley and Carbondale, Tobyhanna and Moscow, Pennsylvania. On rare occasions, excursions are run to the Delaware Water Gap, Cresco, Pennsylvania, East Stroudsburg and Gouldsboro, Pennsylvania(stations are not listed in order of the line). Until 2012, Steamtown hosted RailCamp, a program put on by the National Railway Historical Society to educate future railroad employees and fans of the industry about railroad operation and preservation.[41]


New England roots[edit]

F. Nelson Blount, the heir to the largest seafood processor in the United States, was an avid railroad enthusiast. When he was 17, he wrote a book on steam power; later, he amassed one of the largest collections of vintage steam locomotives in the United States. By 1964, part of his collection — 25 steam locomotives from the United States and Canada, 10 other locomotives, and 25 pieces of rolling stock — was housed at North Walpole, New Hampshire.[42] The Monadnock, Steamtown & Northern Railroad, as the enterprise was then called,[43] ran excursions between Keene and Westmoreland, New Hampshire.[42]

After failing in 1962 to convince the State of New Hampshire to take over control of the bulk of the collection,[44] Blount established the "Steamtown Foundation for the Preservation of Steam and Railroad Americana" to operate Steamtown, USA in 1964. The non-profit, charitable, educational organization was to have nine un-salaried directors, including the five incorporators: Blount, former New Hampshire governor Lane Dwinell; Emile Bussiere; Robert L. Mallat Jr., mayor of Keene; and Bellows Falls Municipal Judge Thomas P. Salmon, who later became governor of Vermont. The president of the Campbell Soup Company, William B. Murphy, who had also served as National Chairman of Radio Free Europe, and the vice president of Blount Seafood, Fredrick Richardson, were among the other directors. The first order of business for the Steamtown Foundation was to acquire the Blount collection at North Walpole, and move it to property once owned by the Rutland Railroad, in Bellows Falls, Vermont.[42]

Blount was killed on August 31, 1967, when his private airplane hit a tree during an emergency landing, in Marlborough, New Hampshire.[45] By that time, a good deal of Blount's collection was controlled by the Steamtown Foundation and had been moved to Bellows Falls. One of Blount's corporations, the Green Mountain Railroad (GMRC), controlled the tracks that lay between Walpole, Bellows Falls and Chester, Vermont, which Steamtown was to use for its excursions. When Blount died, most of the controlling stock of the GMRC was transferred to the president of the railroad, Robert Adams.[46] By 1976, the relationship between Steamtown and GMRC was strained as the two organizations fought over maintenance of the tracks, which were owned by the state of Vermont.[47] In addition, the steam excursions that Steamtown sponsored violated Vermont's pollution regulations, but the railroad was able to operate for several years under waivers issued by the state.[48][49] By 1978, the Steamtown Foundation had begun scouting for a new location for Steamtown, USA.[50]

In 1980, Ray Holland, the Chairman of the Board of Steamtown Foundation, resigned after accusing the board of incompetence. His resignation was followed by that of Robert Barbera, a long-time director of the board.[51] In the year that followed, Steamtown did not run excursions. Don Ball Jr., had taken over direction of Steamtown by this time and discovered that the excursion train did not meet federal safety guidelines. In 1981, despite its vast holdings of vintage railroad stock, Steamtown had only 17,000 visitors, while Connecticut's Essex Valley Railroad, which ran two small engines, had 139,000 visitors.[52] Even in its best year, 1973, the Vermont location had attracted only 65,000 visitors.[53]

When questions about Steamtown, USA in New England are posed, the official response of the National Park Service is:

Steamtown National Historic Site was created in 1986 to preserve the history of steam railroading in America, concentrating on the era 1850 through 1950. This is the mission of the park. The park was not created to preserve the history of Steamtown USA. Our site does touch on the history of railroad preservation, specifically in our History Museum. The work of F. Nelson Blount, creator of the former Steamtown USA, and other pioneers of the steam preservation movement, is a part (albeit a small part) of the story Steamtown NHS has been charged with preserving.[54]

Move to Scranton[edit]

Self-syndicated newspaper columnist Michael McManus once said that his goal in writing his weekly column was "to suggest answers to problems of the old industrial states."[55] In March 1982 a substantial article by McManus appeared in the Bangor Daily News. In the article, McManus proposed several reasons why a city, like Chicago, Pittsburgh, or Scranton, might benefit from a tourist attraction like Steamtown. McManus went on to explain why the business was failing in Vermont: past failed management, an isolated location and the lack of signs on Interstate 91, which the state opposed.[52] Moreover, the roof of the largest storage shed on the property had collapsed under heavy snow the previous winter, damaging several pieces of equipment.[52] Among the injured were CP Rail No. 1293, which had served on Vermont's "Bicentennial Train" and on the movie Terror Train (1979),[56] and the Meadow River Lumber Company No. 1 Shay.[57]

Asked by McManus to describe the value of the Steamtown collection, Jim Boyd, editor of Railfan & Railroad magazine, said, "Everything there is no longer obtainable anywhere, whether it is the "Big Boy" [Union Pacific No. 4012] or the Rahway Valley No. 15, a nice-sized locomotive any museum would give a right arm for. Most of the other large collections do not have any serviceable equipment."[52] McManus added "What is at stake is more than tourism and jobs. It is a significant part of America's past before the welder's torch is turned on the likes of the 1877 'Prince of Liege', the rare Union Pacific diamond stack, etc. The steel alone is worth $3 million."[52]

In June 1983, McManus wrote about Steamtown again, this time announcing that Scranton had taken his suggestion. He said that Springfield, Massachusetts, and Willimantic, Connecticut, had also vied for the collection. "But on May 24, Scranton signed a contract to get it, pledging to raise $2 million to cover the cost of moving 40 ancient steam engines and 60 cars, few of which are operable, and to create a museum."[55] On October 23, 1983, Steamtown sponsored its last Vermont excursion, using Canadian Pacific 1246 to pull a "dozen or so cars" on a 100-mile (160 km) round trip from Riverside station to Ludlow, Vermont,[58] and Scranton began raising money for the move.

When Scranton agreed to take on Steamtown, it was estimated that the museum and excursion business would attract 200,000 to 400,000 visitors to the city every year.[59] In anticipation of this economic boon, the city and a private developer spent $13 million to renovate the DL&W station and transform it into a Hilton hotel, at a time when the unemployment rate in the city was 13 percent.[60] Only 60,000 visitors showed up at Steamtown in 1987, and the 1988 excursions were canceled. After only three years, it was $2.2 million in debt[61] and facing bankruptcy.[62] Part of the problem was the cost of restoration of the new property and the deteriorating equipment. In addition, while the tourists in Vermont had enjoyed the sights of cornfields, farms, covered bridges, a waterfall and a gorge on a Steamtown excursion,[63] the Scranton trip to Moscow, Pennsylvania, cut through one of the nation's largest junkyards,[64] an eyesore described by Ralph Nader as "the eighth wonder of the world".[64]


In 1986, the U.S. House of Representatives, under the urging of Scranton native Representative Joseph M. McDade,[62] voted to approve the spending of $8 million to study the collection and to begin the process of making it a National Historic Site (NHS).[6] The National Park Service (NPS) consequently conducted historical research on the Steamtown Foundation's equipment in 1987 and 1988. This research was used for a Scope of Collections Statement for Steamtown NHS and was published in 1991 under the title Steamtown Special History Study. Aside from providing concise histories of the equipment, the report also made recommendations as to whether or not each piece belonged in the now government-funded collection.[65] Historical significance to the United States was a criterion of the recommendations. Many of the pieces of equipment that did not meet the report's recommendations were sold or traded for pieces that had historical significance to the region.[66]

The adoption of Steamtown as a federal endeavor caused controversy. On November 23, 1991, an article in The New York Times said, "The provision for the park was inserted into a huge appropriations bill at a late-night meeting near the end of the legislative session in October 1986. Congressional authorizing committees, which are charged with setting policy and reviewing such proposals, were bypassed, and the Park Service did not conduct its customary two-year review of proposed new parks."[7] The article noted that "a number of historians and museum curators around the nation call Steamtown a second-rate collection of trains on a third-rate site. They say that while such historic recreations have a place, the Federal Government should not be financing them simply because influential members of Congress want them for their districts."[7] It said that James M. Ridenour, director of the Park Service, said that Steamtown was among other projects that the agency neither needed nor wanted, adding that the same collection was rejected by them when it was still in Vermont because it "lacked historic importance".[7] Aside from the $73 million that had at that point been proposed for the development of the project, there would also be a projected annual operation cost of $6.5 million. A December 17, 1991, editorial reported that the development appropriation had been capped at $53 million, and said the Steamtown project had siphoned resources "from the Park Service's worthier, maintenance-starved projects."[67]

William W. Scranton, former governor of Pennsylvania and descendant of the founders of Scranton, along with J. A. Panuska, president of the University of Scranton, responded to the Times' coverage with a letter to the editor. Published on January 8, 1992, the letter argued that the statement, first made by a former Smithsonian curator, that "Steamtown was a second-rate collection on a third-rate site," was unfounded.[9] Scranton and Panuska wrote, "The collection of 29 steam engines and 82 other railroad cars and equipment is the third largest in the country, the only one available for commemorating the industrialization of America in a historic setting."[9] They said that the 19th-century American Industrial Revolution was under-represented in the National Parks system[9] and further said that

Scranton is the only city in the Eastern United States with the vestiges of the era of industrialization (1840-1920) in plain sight, 40 acres in the middle of downtown, with car shops, locomotive shops, roundhouse, turntable, grand passenger station, a working yard, iron furnaces, passenger excursions — the whole works and a restored coal mine nearby. There is no other site like it. This city [Scranton] was founded because of its iron ore and its ability to produce rails (previously imported from England), followed by its graduation to a coal and steel economy. It is a graphic demonstration of the industrial period of our country, an excellent site for Americans to learn about their history.[9]

Phoebe Snow advertisement for the DL&W

The site they were referring to had mostly belonged to the DL&W, which joined the Erie Railroad in 1960 to form the Erie Lackawanna Railway. The site eventually passed to Conrail, and was purchased by the city of Scranton as the site for Steamtown, USA. The site included 13 buildings built between 1865 and 1937 that were listed on the National Register of Historic Places.[3] Wrote Linda Greenhouse of The New York Times, "Scranton was once served by five railroads, an almost unthinkable luxury for a city of just over 80,000 people. The passenger trains stopped decades ago, but one memory remains: the Lackawanna's elegant station, just up the street from Steamtown, completed in 1908 and converted into a hotel through a public-private partnership in 1983."[68]

In April 1992, Newsweek printed an excerpt from a soon-to-be-published book about pork-barrel politics called Adventures in Porkland. It said of Representative McDade's leadership in securing funds for Steamtown:

McDade has achieved the dream of most pork-barrel congressmen, a living memorial, indeed two: the University of Scranton's new Joseph M. McDade Center for Technology and Applied Research, and the county's McDade Park, with its Anthracite Coal Museum. But the congressman's crowning achievement is a historic theme park called Steamtown.[8]

The article also repeated the charge that the collection was second-rate. It went on to say that at the site there was little evidence of the $40 million that had been spent to date; that several of the pieces were from the 1940s and 1950s, not the 19th century, which was the time period that was supposedly being preserved; that some of the better pieces of equipment were Canadian, not U.S.; that other museums, already in existence, were already fulfilling the historical mission of Steamtown; and that other NPS projects like Yosemite and Yellowstone were in desperate need of funding.[8] Nevertheless, in February 1992, the House of Representatives voted against dropping the project from the NPS and, instead voted to add an additional $14 million to its funding.[69]

By 1994, one of the earlier skeptics of the Steamtown project, Railfan & Railroad magazine associate editor Mike DelVecchio, who had visited the site, had changed sides in the debate saying, "When it is finished, Steamtown will be the only place in America that can recreate the experience of mainline steam railroading."[5] The director of Steamtown, Roger G. Kennedy, said, "those who concentrated on the pork-barrel politics of the development of the park were ignorant of the history."[5] Len Barcousky, writing for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, described that history saying: "It was steam locomotives that unified the nation in the century between 1850 and 1950. Maintained in giant roundhouses in a hundred cities like Scranton, the smoke-belching engines carried the people and the goods that made possible the Industrial Revolution."[5]

Operation as an NHS[edit]

By 1995, Steamtown had been acquired and developed by the NPS at a total cost of $66 million.[61][62] In June 1995, the newest National Historic Site was ready for its grand opening. Michigan's only surviving steam locomotive, no. 1225, was to arrive on July 1 for the occasion.[70] Less than two weeks after the museum opened, two teen-aged boys were killed when they were struck by Steamtown's Canadian Pacific 2317, which was pulling a train with 575 passengers on an excursion trip to Moscow, Pennsylvania. The boys were hit while trying to remove their all-terrain vehicle which had gotten stuck on the tracks.[71] Two years later, the parents of the boys would file a lawsuit for $48 million.[72] In November 1995, The New York Times printed a favorable review written by Supreme Court correspondent Linda Greenhouse, who had visited the site with her husband and daughter. Wrote Greenhouse, "The pleasure of the park is to see trains not only as one might see them in a museum but to see them in motion. Steamtown is a dynamic museum, with locomotives moving regularly from the yard into the park's architectural centerpiece, the roundhouse".[68] Visitor attendance in its first year was 212,000.

By 2008, the federal government had spent a total of $176 million on Steamtown, which had an annual operating cost of $5.2 million. Visitor attendance had declined since its opening year to 61,178 in 2006. Many of the locomotives and passenger cars contained asbestos,[10] a carcinogen.[73] The federal government pledged $1.5 million for its removal, to be disbursed in 2011, and more money for restoration of the equipment, providing the money was matched by non-federal funds.[10]

From October 1 through 16, 2013, Steamtown was closed, along with the rest of the National Park system, as part of the United States federal government shutdown of 2013.[74]

In 2021, Steamtown completed a two-year, $1.6 million restoration of its largest engine, Union Pacific Big Boy #4012.[75]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ "NPS Annual Recreation Visits Report". National Park Service. Retrieved November 4, 2013.
  2. ^ "The National Parks: Index 2009–2011 . Part 2". National Park Service. Retrieved 2011-08-26.
  3. ^ a b Kissel, Kelly P. From Train yard Spouts National Park. Ludingtone Daily News. May 19, 1992. Pg. 5, Accessed March 11, 2012.
  4. ^ "Steamtown National Historic Site". National Park Service. Retrieved March 11, 2012.
  5. ^ a b c d Barcousky, Len. Federal Train Park Steams Both Sides. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. July 3, 1994. Pg B1. Accessed July, 18, 2010.
  6. ^ a b House Approves Spending for Scranton Steamtown. The Pittsburgh Press, October 16, 1986. Accessed July 16, 2010
  7. ^ a b c d Hinds, Michael deCourcy As 'Steamtown' Grows, So Does Park Debate New York Times, November 23, 1991. Accessed July 16, 2010
  8. ^ a b c Kelly, Brian. A Tale of Piggery. Newsweek. April 13, 1992. Accessed July 18, 2010,
  9. ^ a b c d e At Scranton's Steamtown, At Scranton's Steamtown, Our Industrial Past Comes to Life New York Times. January 8, 1992. Accessed July 16, 2010
  10. ^ a b c "Scranton Site Out of Steam: Critics: Some say Steamtown National Historic Site would benefit from privatization". Associated Press via Times-Leader. September 15, 2008. Archived from the original on August 13, 2011. Retrieved July 24, 2010.
  11. ^ a b "Steamtown National Historic Site". National Park Service. Retrieved March 11, 2012.
  12. ^ a b c d e f "Steamtown". The National Park Service. Retrieved March 11, 2012.
  13. ^ "Baldwin Locomotive Works 26 - Steamtown National Historic Site (U.S. National Park Service)".
  14. ^ a b c d e f "Steamtown's Operating Locomotives - Steamtown National Historic Site (U.S. National Park Service)".
  15. ^ Chapell, Gordon. Steam Over Scranton: The Locomotives of Steamtown. Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives: Brooks-Scanlon Corporation No. 1 Archived October 6, 2011, at (Error: unknown archive URL)National Park Service. 1991. Accessed July 12, 2010
  16. ^ Chappell, Gordon. "Meadow River Lumber Company No. 1". Steam Over Scranton: Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives. National Park Service. Retrieved March 13, 2012.
  17. ^ "Steamtown NHS: Special History Study".
  18. ^ "E.J. Lavino and Company No. 3". Steam Over Scranton: Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives. National Park Service. Archived from the original on 1 June 2009. Retrieved March 13, 2012.
  19. ^ "Berlin Mills Railway No. 7". Steamtown. United States National Park Service. February 14, 2002. Archived from the original on November 6, 2013.
  20. ^ "Facebook". Archived from the original on 2022-02-26. Retrieved 2021-07-19.
  21. ^ a b "Steamtown's Locomotives and Cars". Steamtown National Historic Site. National Park Service. Retrieved March 13, 2012.
  22. ^ "Steamtown NHS: Special History Study".
  23. ^ Barris, Wes. "".
  24. ^ "Steamtown NHS: Special History Study". Archived from the original on 2002-12-01.
  25. ^ Chappell, Gordon. "Illinois Central Railroad No. 790". Steam Over Scranton: Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives. National Park Service. Retrieved March 15, 2012.
  26. ^ Edson, p. 38
  27. ^ Duley, Richard; Llanso, Steve. "Philadelphia & Reading 4-8-4 "Northern" Type Locomotives".
  28. ^ a b "Canadian Pacific 2317". Steamtown NHS. National Park Service. Archived from the original on September 19, 2016. Retrieved February 13, 2019.
  29. ^ a b "Steamtown National Historic Site - Canadian National 3254 (U.S. National Park Service)". Retrieved June 26, 2010.
  30. ^ Franz, Justin, Steamtown eyes the next restoration candidate, retrieved 2021-10-01
  31. ^ Chappell, Gordon. "Union Pacific No. 4012". Steam Over Scranton: Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives. National Park Service. Retrieved March 13, 2012.
  32. ^ "Steamtown National Historic Site, Scranton, Pennsylvania". Retrieved 2021-10-04.
  33. ^ "Canadian Pacific Railway No. 2816". National Park Service. Archived from the original on March 2, 2019. Retrieved March 2, 2019.
  34. ^ a b c "CP 1278 - Ex Canadian Pacific 4-8-2 No. 1278". Age of Steam Roundhouse. Age of Steam Roundhouse, LTD. Archived from the original on March 23, 2012. Retrieved March 12, 2012.
  35. ^ "Canadian Pacific 1246". Railroad Museum of New England. 2007-10-12. Retrieved July 17, 2020.
  36. ^ "Coopersville & Marne Railway -". Retrieved 2022-02-02.
  37. ^ "Canadian National 4-6-0 No. 1551 – Age of Steam Roundhouse". Retrieved 2022-02-02.
  38. ^ Kaufman, Dirk W (March 18, 2007). "Altoona awaits refurbished steam locomotive". Pittsburgh Tribune-Review. Retrieved July 27, 2013.
  39. ^ Kibler, William (April 14, 2010). "Official: Working K-4 plans derailed". Altoona Mirror. Retrieved July 27, 2013.
  40. ^ "RailPictures.Net Photo: PRR 1361 Pennsylvania Railroad Steam 4-6-2 at Rockhill, Pennsylvania by Dennis A. Livesey". Retrieved 12 September 2018.
  41. ^ "RailCamp". National Railway Historical Society. Archived from the original on 30 August 2018. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
  42. ^ a b c Sawyer, Mina Titus.Maine's 'Iron Horses' Head For Their Last Dramatic Round-up. Lewiston Evening Journal. February 1, 1964. Accessed July 12, 2010
  43. ^ Railroad That Go Nowhere Really Getting Somewhere, Reading Eagle, December 25, 1961. accessed July 13, 2010,
  44. ^ Steamtown Out of Steam. Nashua Telegraph, February 15, 1963. Pg. 2. Accessed on July 13, 2010
  45. ^ Millionaire Dies in Plane Crash. The Milwaukee Journal, September 1, 1967. Pg. 2. Accessed July 14, 2010
  46. ^ Jones, Robert C. (2006). Vermont Rail System: A Railroad Renaissance. Evergreen Press. ISBN 0-9667264-5-6.
  47. ^ Steamtown Seeks Increased Control Over Tracks. Lewiston Daily News. October 5, 1976. Pg. 10 Accessed July 14, 2010
  48. ^ Steam Railroad Gets Extension. Accessed March 11, 2012. Bangor Daily News. November 19, 1971. Pg. 5
  49. ^ Stewart, Colin. The Past is the Future. Beaver County Times. March 7, 1974. Pg. B15. Accessed July 14, 2010
  50. ^ Winn, Sherry. 'Steamtown USA' is Looking for a New Home. Sarasota Herald-Tribune, August 8, 1978. Accessed July 14, 2010,
  51. ^ Steamtown Chair Charges Incompetence. Nashua Telegraph. October 14, 1980. Pg 10. Accessed July 15, 2010
  52. ^ a b c d e McManus, Michael. How Would Your Community Like a Big Tourist Attraction? Bangor Daily News. March 29, 1982. Access date March 11, 2012
  53. ^ Steam Railroad Museum Moving Down Tracks. Star New, August 11, 1983, accessed July 16, 2010.
  54. ^ National Park Service, U.S. Department of Interior. Steamtown: Frequently Asked Questions. Updated February 20, 2010. Accessed July 24, 2010
  55. ^ a b McManus, Michael. Three Proposals That Didn't Die. Schenectady Gazette. June 14, 1983. Pg. 28. Accessed July 15, 2010
  56. ^ Chapell, Gordon. Steam Over Scranton: The Locomotives of Steamtown. Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives: Canadian Pacific Railways No. 1293National Park Service. 1991. Accessed July 13, 2010
  57. ^ Chapell, Gordon. Steam Over Scranton: The Locomotives of Steamtown. Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives: Meadow River Lumber Company No. 1National Park Service. 1991. Accessed July 13, 2010
  58. ^ Van Gelder, Lawrence. Steamtown's Autumn Outing is a Farewell. New York Times. September 25, 1983. Accessed on July 13, 2010
  59. ^ Rail Museum on Track to New Home. Reading Eagle. December 26, 1983. Pg. 6. Accessed July 16, 2010
  60. ^ Roddy, Michael. Scranton is Converting Railroad Station Into Hotel Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. January 7, 1983. Pg 3. Accessed July 16, 2010
  61. ^ a b Smith, John W.Rail Run out of Steam. Reading Eagle. January 28, 1988. Pg. 5. Accessed July 16, 2010
  62. ^ a b c Getting Burned by Steamtown Reading Eagle. July 2, 1995. Pg. A16 Accessed July 16, 2010
  63. ^ Rice, Bill. A Great Way to See and Hear a Lonesome Whistle Schenectady Gazette. September 3, 1977. Pg. 30 Accessed July 14, 2010
  64. ^ a b Flannery, Joseph X. The Junkyard on the Mountainside. Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.October 2, 1987. Pg. 9. Accessed July 16, 2010
  65. ^ Chapell, Gordon. Steam Over Scranton: The Locomotives of Steamtown. Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives: Introduction National Park Service. 1991. Accessed July 14, 2010
  66. ^ Chapell, Gordon. Steam Over Scranton: The Locomotives of Steamtown. Special History Study, American Steam Locomotives: Rahway Valley Railroad No. 15.[dead link] National Park Service. 1991. Accessed July 14, 2010
  67. ^ Topic of the Times; The Steamtown Steamroller. New York Times, December 17, 1991. Accessed July 16,
  68. ^ a b Greenhouse, Linda. "Pennsylvania Recalls the Century of Steam". New York Times. November 19, 1995. Accessed July 19, 2010
  69. ^ House Rejects Steamtown Proposal. Reading Eagle Tribune. February 6, 1992 Accessed July 18, 2010.
  70. ^ Grnak, Robert, Steam Locomotive 1225 to Gain National Exposure at Pennsylvania Activity. The Argus-Press. May 25, 1995 accessed July 18, 2010.
  71. ^ Steamtown Stunned By Rail Deaths. Reading Eagle Tribune. July 11, 1995. Accessed July 18, 2010.
  72. ^ Steamtown Faces Suit in Deaths. The Times Leader. July 12, 1997. Accessed July 24, 2010
  73. ^ Trouble on the Tracks at Steamtown NHS. Mesothelioma News. September 24, 2008. Accessed July 24, 2010
  74. ^ "Steamtown Shutdown". October 2013. Retrieved 5 May 2016.
  75. ^ says, Benjamin Deutschman. "Big Boy restoration at Steamtown complete, locomotive returns to public display". Trains. Retrieved 2022-01-09.

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]