|Part of a series on|
A suicide bag, also known as an exit bag or hood, is a euthanasia device consisting of a large plastic bag with a drawcord used to commit suicide through inert gas asphyxiation. It is usually used in conjunction with a flow of an inert gas like helium or nitrogen, which prevents the panic, sense of suffocation and struggling before unconsciousness, known as the hypercapnic alarm response :45 caused by the presence of high carbon dioxide concentrations in the blood. This method also makes the direct cause of death difficult to trace if the bag and gas canister are removed before the death is reported.
Suicide bags were first used during the 1990s. The method was mainly developed in North America.
Self-administered and assisted suicides by asphyxiation using a plastic bag with helium were first recorded in the 1990s. Since the 2000s, guides have spread on the internet, in print and on video and the frequency of suicides by this method has increased.
In the book Final Exit by Derek Humphry, a suicide bag was described as a large plastic bag with an adjustable velcro strip around the neck. Its use with inert gases was mentioned in the Supplement to Final Exit in 2000.
The pro-euthanasia group Exit Australia distributed a manufactured version of the bag in Australia in 2002, alarming government officials and pro-life groups. The Australian chapter of Right to Life expressed concern that they would be used by vulnerable people.
In 2007, The Vancouver Sun cited Russel Ogden, Canadian criminologist and right-to-die advocate, who said that the combination of a suicide bag and helium was "a method of choice" within the right-to-die movement for people who are terminally ill and that its promotion does not appear to cause an increase in the number of suicides. However, he said that he has no way of knowing if the method was being used by people with terminal illness or by people who are mentally ill.
In 2008, Ludwig Minelli, founder of Dignitas, filmed four people committing suicide by helium inhalation. Subsequent to this, the method "has been winning supporters both in the USA and in Europe as a reliable, rapid and painless way to die".
In 2009, Philip Nitschke, founder of voluntary euthanasia organisation Exit International, wrote in a member newsletter that nitrogen has a lower risk of an adverse reaction by the body than helium and is also more available than helium in Australia and New Zealand. Nitschke's organisation sells suicide kits that contain nitrogen tanks and regulators. He promotes the use of nitrogen and suicide bags with lectures and films, such as Doing it with Betty – in which an elderly woman describes how to make a plastic 'exit' bag, and with published materials such as workshop handbooks. Nitschke calls the suicide bag death a "hypoxic death", and likens it to pneumonia, the "old person's friend", where hypoxia occurs because pneumonic inflammation stops the lungs extracting sufficient oxygen from the air, and "a peaceful death often results".
In 2015 author and right-to-die advocate Derek Humphry reported that Worthington Industries, the world's largest manufacturer of disposable helium cylinders, had announced that their helium cylinders will guarantee only 80% helium, with up to 20% air, making them inappropriate for use with a suicide bag in Humphry's opinion.
Dutch psychiatrist Boudewijn Chabot, in his 2015 book Dignified Dying, calls the suicide bag with inert gas method "rapid, painless and safe".
It is not illegal to own a suicide bag in any jurisdiction.
Selling suicide bags is prohibited in some places. In 2011, the FBI raided a small mail-order business in California, which shut down afterwards. In July 2011, this raid caused Oregon to be the first US state to pass legislation prohibiting the sale of kits containing suicide bags or hoods.
Canadian right-to-die advocates stopped shipping suicide bags to Australia in 2001, when the Australian government announced that it would review their importation. In 2002, the Queensland Police in Australia said that suicide bags did not violate any laws at that time, and the Australian federal government said it would look into banning them. Exit Australia gave them away to members upon request; they put warning labels on them, called them "exit bags", and included no instructions for use to circumvent Australian laws against assisting suicide.
A hypoxic, carbon dioxide free metabolically inert gas is provided for inhalation by confining the gas supply and the head in an impermeable bag which prevents contamination with oxygen from the surrounding air, minimising the amount of gas required. (The same effect could be reached by flooding any enclosed space with the gas, but much more gas would be needed, and this would be hazardous to a third party entering the space, an effect which is well known as a cause of industrial fatalities.)
Inhalation of oxygen deficient or oxygen free gas not only fails to replenish oxygen used in normal metabolism, but causes the blood passing through the capillaries of the gas exchange regions of the lungs to lose residual oxygen in relation to the concentration difference between the oxygen in the alveolar air and in the blood in the alveolar capillaries. This causes a far quicker drop in blood oxygen level than holding the breath. The deoxygenated blood then passes through the systemic circulation to the vital organs, including the brain, and rapidly lowers oxygen concentrations below the level required to sustain consciousness, and when it is insufficient to keep the heart functioning, cardiac arrest will occur. For the most people, an alveolar oxygen tension of less than 30 millimetres of mercury (40 mbar) or 4% by volume at atmospheric pressure is not sufficient to support consciousness.
The urge to breathe in normal humans is mainly controlled by blood carbon dioxide concentration and the acidity that it causes. A rise in carbon dioxide concentration caused by the inability to inhale fresh gas will cause a strong reflex to breathe, accompanied by increasing distress as the level rises, culminating in panic and desperate struggle for air. This effect will remain if the person is free to breathe but the available air has a high carbon dioxide content. If the supplied breathing gas is free of carbon dioxide, the blood carbon dioxide levels will remain low while breathing occurs, and there will be no distress or urge to increase breathing rate, as the sensitivity in normal people to blood oxygen level as a breathing stimulus is very low.
The effect of contamination of the inert gas by air or other source of oxygen is to reduce the effects of oxygen loss and the person exposed may feel weak, tired and confused, but without a strong urge to breathe or the associated respiratory distress. The efficiency of the system for euthanasia requires minimising contamination by oxygen and carbon dioxide. Small amounts of oxygen will not affect the end result, but may extend the time taken.
Short term physiological effects and hazards of the gases used
Helium and nitrogen are non toxic and can be breathed with no ill effects over short or long term when oxygen levels are sufficient, and present no health risk to third parties except asphyxiation. The danger lies in that they are undetectable by human senses, and the first warning of their presence in asphyxiant concentrations may be loss of consciousness. Lower concentrations may cause confusion and weakness. Use of a suicide bag in a well ventilated room using either of these gases is unlikely to pose a hazard for other people, and there is no fire hazard.
Propane, butane and natural gas are to varying degrees narcotic, and are a serious fire and explosion hazard, depending on concentration of the gas and of oxygen. They are usually supplied with strong-smelling additives to provide a warning. These additives may be toxic in large doses, but the concentrations which are needed to indicate the presence of the gas are not dangerous over short terms. The unpleasant smell may be a deterrent to more widespread use as a euthanasia agent, but the primary purpose is a warning of fire hazard.
Propane has low toxicity since it is not readily absorbed and is not biologically active. It is heavier than air and may accumulate in low places, particularly if they are poorly ventilated. Butane is similar to propane, and heavier, and has narcotic effects in large doses. Natural gas is lighter than air and disperses quickly in a well ventilated area.
Medical and scientific research
Suicide bags have been used with gases other than inert gases, with varying outcomes. Examples of other gases used are propane-butane, which has narcotic effects, and is commonly adulterated with strong smelling additives to warn of gas leaks, and natural gas.
Suicides using a suicide bag and an inert gas produce no characteristic post-mortem macroscopic or microscopic findings. Forensic death investigations of cause and manner of death may be very difficult when people commit suicide in this manner, especially if the apparatus (such as the bag, tank, or tube) is removed by someone after the death. Petechiae, which are often considered a marker of asphyxia, are present in only a small minority of cases (3%). Frost reported that of the two cases he studied that featured death from inert gas asphyxiation using a suicide bag, one had "bilateral eyelid petechiae and large amounts of gastric content in the airways and that these findings challenge the assumption that death by this method is painless and without air hunger, as asserted in Final Exit." A review study by Ely and Hirsch (2000) concludes that conjunctival and facial petechiae are the product of purely mechanical vascular phenomena, unrelated to asphyxia or hypoxia, and do not occur unless ligatures were also found around the neck. The authors wrote,
Unless the bag is fastened around the neck by a ligature with sufficient tension to obstruct venous return from the face, in our experience, such persons never have facial or conjunctival petechiae. Persons with tight fastenings around the neck are recognizable instantly by their facial plethora of numerous petechiae. We are aware that some observers may have seen an occasional petechia in rare instances of plastic bag suicide. However, we have not seen detailed descriptions of such observations that permit another person to evaluate the variables that might have produced an isolated petechia in a rare victim. Conversely, in New York City, an average of approximately 15 persons per year accomplish suicide by plastic bag, and we never have observed petechiae in a person who did not tightly fasten the bag around his/her neck— Ely SF, Hirsch CS, "Asphyxial deaths and petechiae: a review". J. Forensic Sci, (2000)
There are also documented cases of suicide attempts using the suicide bag that failed. A case report study in 2015 discussed the risks associated with failed attempts using this method. The authors wrote, "If the process is interrupted by someone, there is no gas or the tube slips out of the bag, there is a high risk of severe hypoxia of the central nervous system" (in survivors). Brain cells are very sensitive to reduced oxygen levels. Once deprived of oxygen they will begin to die off within five minutes. If hypoxia results in coma, the length of unconsciousness is often indicative of long-term damage. In some cases coma can give the brain an opportunity to heal and regenerate, but, in general, the longer a coma, the greater the likelihood that the person will remain in a vegetative state until death.
Russel Ogden (2002) said that the existence of "how-to" literature involving the suicide bag has been "shown to influence the choice of suicide method but not the overall suicide rate, and that an emerging counterculture of death providers, operating outside of the traditional medicolegal framework of health care, was placing assisted death outside the normative gaze of medicine". In 2010, Ogden and colleagues observed four cases of assisted suicide with helium delivered by face mask. The authors stated that a hood method might be able to play a role in "demedicalising assisted suicide". Ogden views a bag and inert gas as "the quickest way to go; used properly, you're unconscious after the second breath and dead in about 10 minutes".
Clinical psychologist Phillip Kleespies said that Ogden's work calls attention to some of the risks associated with covert assisted suicide using unregulated methods like the suicide bag with inert gas. He does not dispute that the method is "swift, highly lethal and painless", as claimed by Ogden and other right-to-die proponents. However Kleespies feels it is an undignified, impersonal and "hurried" manner of death, which may be used by people who have not had the opportunity for appropriate counseling and that this is largely a result of more dignified methods being made illegal. He concludes by expressing the hope that with improved and more appropriate care during the dying phase of life, there will be less perceived need for these methods of self-deliverance.
A study poses the dilemma for medical ethicists and the general public who "may also want to carefully weigh the unintended adverse consequences of widely disseminated suicide methods likely to appeal to some depressed persons (irrespective of their physical health status or age) against the putative benefits associated with making these methods more widely known and available".
Characteristics of users
Promoters of this suicide method recommend it to terminally ill patients. However, across the world, most people who use suicide bags are physically healthy. Instead of having incurable cancer or other life-threatening physical diseases, most of the users have psychiatric disorders or substance abuse problems that might possibly be addressed through medical and psychological treatment. The demographics of its users varies; in one survey, the method had been used mostly by middle-aged adults in failing health, who were attracted to the relative nonviolence of the method.
This suicide method is also typically used by younger or middle-aged adults, rather than by older adults. In the US, it is more commonly chosen by non-Hispanic white males than by women or people of other races.
- Williams, Martin (2016-03-30). "Scots assisted death and abortion pioneer dies, aged 89". The Herald. Retrieved 2016-04-18.
- Ogden RD, Hassan S (2011). "Suicide by oxygen deprivation with helium: a preliminary study of British Columbia coroner investigations". Death Studies. 35 (4): 338–64. doi:10.1080/07481187.2010.518513. PMID 24501824.
- Nitschke, Philip; Stewart, Fiona (2016). "Hypoxic Death and the Exit bag". The Peaceful Pill Handbook. Exit International US Limited. ISBN 9780975833919.
- Schön CA, Ketterer T (December 2007). "Asphyxial suicide by inhalation of helium inside a plastic bag". The American Journal of Forensic Medicine and Pathology. 28 (4): 364–7. doi:10.1097/PAF.0b013e31815b4c69. PMID 18043029.
- Auwaerter V, Perdekamp MG, Kempf J, Schmidt U, Weinmann W, Pollak S (August 2007). "Toxicological analysis after asphyxial suicide with helium and a plastic bag". Forensic Sci. Int. 170 (2&ndash, 3): 139–41. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2007.03.027. PMID 17628370.(subscription required)
- Ogden RD, Wooten RH (September 2002). "Asphyxial suicide with helium and a plastic bag" (PDF). Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 23 (3): 234–7. doi:10.1097/00000433-200209000-00005. PMID 12198347.
- Malbranque S, Mauillon D, Turcant A, Rouge-Maillart C, Mangin P, Varlet V (25 Apr 2016), "Quantification of fatal helium exposure following self-administration", International Journal of Legal Medicine, 130 (6): 1535–1539, doi:10.1007/s00414-016-1364-x, PMID 27113477
- Ogden, RD. (June 2010). "Observation of two suicides by helium inhalation in a prefilled environment". Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 31 (2): 156–61. doi:10.1097/PAF.0b013e3181d749d7. PMID 20216304.
- Hofsess, John (2016-03-04). "By the time you read this, I'll be dead". Toronto Life. Retrieved 2016-05-19.
- Humphry, Derek (1992). Final Exit: the Practicalities of Self-Deliverance and Assisted Suicide for the Dying. New York: Delta Trade Paperback. ISBN 978-0-385-33653-6.
- Humphry, Derek (2002). Final Exit: the Practicalities of Self-Deliverance and Assisted Suicide for the Dying (3rd edition). New York: Delta Trade Paperback. ISBN 978-0-385-33653-6.
- Humphry, Derek (2000), Supplement to Final Exit, Norris Lane Press and ERGO
- Roberts, Greg (2002-08-21). "Nitschke skirts law with suicide bag". The Age. Retrieved 2016-05-11.
- "Outrage over suicide bag giveaway". www.smh.com.au. 2002-07-09. Retrieved 2008-12-19.
- Cribb, Robert (26 Dec 2012), "Death's midwife helps terminally ill Canadians end their lives", The Toronto Star
- "Helium in an "exit bag" new choice for suicide". www.canada.com. Archived from the original on 2009-11-09. Retrieved 2008-12-19.
- Smędra A, Szustowski S, Jurczyk AP, Klemm J, Szram S, Berent J (2015). "Suicidal asphyxiation by using helium - two case reports". Arch Med Sadowej Kryminol. 65 (1): 37–46. PMID 26007160.
- "The Nitrogen Alternative" (PDF). Exit International. January 2009. Retrieved 2011-07-28.
- Rice, Steve (16 Aug 2012), "Philip Nitschke says Exit International has seen a surge in demand for help to die peacefully", Herald Sun
- "Dr Death attempts to dodge film law". stuff.co.nz. 2011. Retrieved 25 July 2011.
- de Bruxelles, Simon (May 6, 2009). "'Dr Death' Paul Nitschke reveals secrets of a peaceful exit". The Times TimesOnline. London: News International. ISSN 0140-0460. Retrieved 25 July 2011.
- Connell, Tim (2011). "Dr Death ignites right to die debate". Great Lakes Advocate. Archived from the original on 21 August 2011. Retrieved 24 July 2011.
- Humphry, Derek (2015-04-24). "Warning on diluted helium tanks". Assisted Dying Blog. Derek Humphry. Retrieved 2016-04-17.
- Chabot, Boudewijn (2015). Dignified Dying. Lulu.com. p. 63. ISBN 9789081619462. Retrieved 2016-05-20.
- Marosi, Richard (May 30, 2011). "Suicide kits: Woman selling 'suicide kits' reignites right-to-die debate". Los Angeles Times. Los Angeles: Tribune Co. ISSN 0458-3035. Retrieved 27 July 2011.
- Federal agents raid California suicide kit seller Yahoo News.
- Ertelt, Steven (2011). "Oregon Governor Signs Bill Banning Sale of Suicide Kits". lifenews.com. Retrieved 27 July 2011.
- "Inert Gas Risks - Oxygen Deficiency". BOC. Retrieved 5 March 2018.
- "Lack of oxygen in confined spaces". Health and Safety Executive. Retrieved 5 March 2018.
- "Asphyxiation hazards in welding and allied processes" (PDF). Health and Safety Executive. Retrieved 5 March 2018.
- Paul W. Fisher. "2 - High Altitude Respiratory Physiology". USAF Flight Surgeon's Guide. USAF School of Aerospace Medicine. Archived from the original on 16 March 2007. Retrieved 5 March 2015.
- "Propane". The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). 2017-11-17. Retrieved 2016-05-12.
Propane is a simple asphyxiant and does not present an IDLH hazard at concentrations below its lower explosive limit (LEL). The chosen IDLH is based on the LEL of 21,000 ppm rounded down to 20,000 ppm.(2% by volume)
- "Safety Alert: Suicide Bags" (PDF). Trenton, NJ: New Jersey Department of Community Affairs, Division of Fire safety, Office of the State Fire Marshall. August 2012. Retrieved 5 March 2018.
- Raymond D. Harbison, Marie M. Bourgeois, Giffe T. Johnson (2015). Hamilton and Hardy's Industrial Toxicology (6, reprint ed.). John Wiley & Sons. ISBN 9781118834213.
- Oosting R, van der Hulst R, Peschier L, Verschraagen M (2015). "Toxicological findings in three cases of suicidal asphyxiation with helium". Forensic Sci. Int. 256: 38–41. doi:10.1016/j.forsciint.2015.06.028. PMID 26298854.
- Gunnell D, Coope C, Fearn V, Wells C, Chang SS, Hawton K, Kapur N (2015). "Suicide by gases in England and Wales 2001-2011: evidence of the emergence of new methods of suicide". Journal of Affective Disorders. 170: 190–5. doi:10.1016/j.jad.2014.08.055. PMID 25254616.
- Zivković, V.; Juković, F.; Nikolić, S. (2010). "[Suicidal asphyxiation by propane-butane mixture inside a plastic bag: case report]". Srp Arh Celok Lek. 138 (5&ndash, 6): 376–8. doi:10.2298/sarh1006376z. PMID 20607988.
- Brick, John (2004). "Online Facts: Inhalants" (PDF). Rutgers New Brunswick/Piscataway Campus Center of Alcohol Studies. Retrieved 3 March 2018.
- Maryam A, Elham B (2010). "Deaths involving natural gas inhalation". Toxicol Ind Health. 26 (6): 345–7. doi:10.1177/0748233710369122. PMID 20430818.
- Haddix TL, Harruff RC, Reay DT, Haglund WD (1996). "Asphyxial suicides using plastic bags". Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 17 (4): 308–11. doi:10.1097/00000433-199612000-00006. PMID 8947355.
- Frost, Joachim (2013), "Death by self-inflicted asphyxia with helium – First case reports from Norway and review of the literature" (PDF), Scandinavian Journal of Forensic Science, 19 (2): 52–54, doi:10.2478/sjfs-2013-0010
- Ely SF, Hirsch CS (2000). "Asphyxial deaths and petechiae: a review" (PDF). J. Forensic Sci. 45 (6): 1274–7. PMID 11110181.
- Richmond, T. S. (May 1997). "Cerebral Resuscitation after Global Brain Ischemia", AACN Clinical Issues 8 (2). Retrieved on 2007-04-13. Free full text Archived September 27, 2007, at the Wayback Machine.
- Phillips, Helen (2006-07-03). "'Rewired brain' revives patient after 19 years". New Scientist. Retrieved 2007-04-13.
- National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke (2007-02-08). "Cerebral Hypoxia Information Page". U.S. National Institutes of Health. Retrieved 2007-04-13.
- Ogden, RD.; Hamilton, WK.; Whitcher, C. (Mar 2010). "Assisted suicide by oxygen deprivation with helium at a Swiss right-to-die organisation". J Med Ethics. 36 (3): 174–9. doi:10.1136/jme.2009.032490. PMID 20211999.
- Martindale, Diane (2005-06-01). "Culture of Death". Scientific American. Retrieved 2016-05-11.
- Kleespies, PM (2010), "Psychological and ethical considerations concerning the debreather and assisted suicide: a commentary on Ogden", Death Studies, 34 (4): 318–24, doi:10.1080/07481181003613859, PMID 24479189
- Howard MO, Hall MT, Edwards JD, Vaughn MG, Perron BE, Winecker RE (2011). "Suicide by asphyxiation due to helium inhalation" (PDF). Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 32 (1): 61–70. doi:10.1097/paf.0b013e3181ed7a2d. PMID 21394956.