Supreme Court of Puerto Rico
|Supreme Court of Puerto Rico|
|Established||1900 (116 years ago)|
|Country||Puerto Rico United States|
|Location||San Juan, Puerto Rico|
|Composition method||Appointed by the Governor of Puerto Rico with the advice and consent of the Senate|
|Authorized by||Constitution of Puerto Rico|
|Decisions are appealed to||Supreme Court of the United States|
|Judge term length||Justices serve until they reach 70 years of age|
|Number of positions||9|
|Currently||Liana Fiol Matta|
|Since||April 11, 2014|
The Supreme Court of Puerto Rico —Spanish: Tribunal Supremo de Puerto Rico (TSPR)— is the highest court of Puerto Rico, having judicial authority to interpret and decide questions of Puerto Rican law. The Court is analogous to one of the state supreme courts of the states of the United States; being the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico the highest state court and the court of last resort in Puerto Rico. Article V of the Constitution of Puerto Rico vests the judicial power in the Supreme Court—which by its nature forms the judicial branch of the government of Puerto Rico. The Supreme Court holds its sessions in San Juan.
Structure and powers
The Supreme Court of Puerto Rico was established by the Foraker Act in 1900 and maintained in the 1952 Constitution of Puerto Rico. It is the only appellate court required by the Constitution. All other courts are created by the Legislative Assembly of Puerto Rico. However, since Puerto Rico is under United States sovereignty, there is also a Federal District Court for the island.
The justices (currently nine) are appointed by the Governor of Puerto Rico and confirmed by majority vote by the Senate. One of these nine justices serves as Chief Justice; the remaining members are designated Associate Justices. Unlike the Supreme Court of the United States, the justices of the Puerto Rico Supreme Court do not serve for life, as the Puerto Rico Constitution requires that all judges must retire upon reaching age 70.
Although the Constitution of Puerto Rico provides for the Court to be composed of five justices, it also contains a provision that the number may be altered, though only by petition of the Court itself. This provision has been used four times in Court history. Immediately after the Constitution's ratification, the Court asked for two additional judges. During the early 1960s, the Court once again petitioned for the addition of two more judges, arguing that there was a case backlog on its docket. Subsequently, during the 1970s the Court asked for its number to be reduced back to seven members, arguing that the backlog had been attended to. Finally, in 2010 a 4–3 majority of the justices petitioned the Legislative Assembly to once again increase the Court's membership to 9. This decision has generated controversy since it is the first time that such a request has been done without unanimity from the justices.
The jurisdiction of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico is defined by the Constitution and the laws of Puerto Rico. In general, the jurisdictional structure parallels that of the state Supreme Courts in the continental United States. The Supreme Court of Puerto Rico has concurrent jurisdiction with federal courts to interpret federal laws, unless the Supremacy Clause requires otherwise. Judgments that stand on federal law grounds may be reviewed by the United States Supreme Court, unless an adequate and independent ground for the decision based in Puerto Rico commonwealth law is also present. The Court has the power of judicial review and its decision are considered binding precedent within the jurisdiction of Puerto Rico. The Supreme Court of Puerto Rico also regulates the practice of law in Puerto Rico.
The term of the Puerto Rico Supreme Court begins on the first Monday of October and ends in the last week of June of the following year. However, during the recess months of July through September, an alternating panel of three justices are allowed to hear cases and their decisions are considered binding precedent. However, in order for any law passed by the Legislative Assembly to be declared unconstitutional, it requires the votes of a majority of the total membership of the Court, therefore, a three-justice panel may not hear constitutional challenges to laws passed by the Legislature.
The justices decide whether or not to hear oral arguments for the case. If the case is controversial or carries high public interest, an oral argument may be scheduled, although oral arguments were rare under Chief Justice Hernández Denton. When oral argument occurs, each side has twenty-five minutes to state its respective claims and five minutes for rebuttal. After the sides have ended their argument, each justice has ten minutes (in order of seniority) to ask questions to each side. Justices may decide to yield the balance of their time to one of their colleagues.
Because several Federal judges have voluntarily withdrawn from the Puerto Rico Bar Association and was converted by statute into a voluntary membership organization, the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico maintains the official bar records of Puerto Rico licensed attorneys.
The Chief Justice is the presiding officer of the Supreme Court, and amongst its functions it directs the administration of the different courts, chairs the Constitutional Redistricting Board which revises Puerto Rico's senatorial and representative districts after every decennial census, and presides at the impeachment trial of the Governor of Puerto Rico.
- 1900–1909: José Severo Quiñones
- 1909–1922: José Hernández Santiago
- 1922–1943: Emilio del Toro Cuebas
- 1944–1948: Martín Travieso Nieva
- 1948–1951: Angel de Jesús Sánchez
- 1951–1952: Roberto Todd Borrás
- 1953–1957: A. Cecil Snyder
- 1957–1957: Jaime Sifre Dávila
- 1957–1972: Luis Negrón Fernández
- 1973–1974: Pedro Pérez Pimentel
- 1974–1985: José Trías Monge
- 1985–1992: Víctor Pons Núñez
- 1992–2003: José Andréu García
- 2003–2004: Miriam Naveira Merly
- 2004–2014: Federico Hernández Denton
- 2014–present: Liana Fiol Matta
During much of the 20th century, the court system in Puerto Rico had consisted of Municipal Courts, District Courts, and the Supreme Court. Cases could be appealed from Municipal Courts to commonwealth District Courts. From the commonwealth District Courts cases were then appealed to the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Supreme Court. Municipal and District courts have existed in Puerto Rico since at least the 19th century. When the United States invaded the island, it set to reorganize the judicial system. The U.S. military regime in Puerto Rico promulgated Order 118 of 1899, by which the system of Criminal Courts and Courts of First Instance and Investigation were replaced by five district courts in San Juan, Ponce, Mayaguez, Arecibo and Humacao.
Appointments to the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico have traditionally been a politicized and often controversial process. The Governor of Puerto Rico usually appoints someone who is affiliated with his own political party. For example, during his sixteen years as Governor, Luis Muñoz Marín appointed only one statehooder, Rafael Hernández Matos to the court, despite the fact that statehooders represented the largest political minority in Puerto Rico. During the four years of divided partisan control of government between 2005 and 2009, when the governorship was occupied by commonwealther Aníbal Acevedo Vilá and the Senate presidency was held by statehooder Kenneth McClintock, despite the 2005 retirement of Associate Justice Baltasar Corrada del Rio, the death of Associate Justice Jaime Fuster in 2007 and the 2008 retirement of Associate Justice Francisco Rebollo, no appointments were made. For over half a century, the Court has been dominated by justices affiliated with the Popular Democratic Party, until February 2009 when, due to the accumulation of unfilled vacancies, pro-statehood Governor Luis Fortuño was able to fill three vacancies. Added to one Justice already on the Court, appointed by another pro-statehood Governor, the justices appointed by statehooders became a majority in the Court. Four women have been appointed justices since 1952; one of them, Miriam Naveira, was Chief Justice for a period of one year. Only one black, Justice Erick Kolthoff, has served in the Court. He is also the Court's only Protestant.
The current Chief Justice, Liana Fiol Matta, appointed by Gov. Alejandro García Padilla, is the second woman to hold the post, succeeding Federico Hernández Denton, who was appointed in 2004 by Governor Sila Calderón. Previously, he served as an Associate Justice from 1985 to 2004. In this capacity, Chief Justice Hernández Denton has sworn in Governors Aníbal Acevedo Vilá and Luis Fortuño. Chief Justice Fiool-Matta is also the administrator of the Judicial Branch of Puerto Rico.
With the arrival of Associate Justice Oronoz, the four female justices constitute the largest number of women in history to serve on the Court simultaneously.
Of the eight current Associate Justices, five have served on the Puerto Rico Court of Appeals. Justice Anabelle Rodríguez served as Solicitor General and Attorney General of Puerto Rico, Justice Kolthoff served as a Superior Court Judge and Justice Estrella served as legal advisor to the president of the Puerto Rico Senate.
|Name||Rank||Age||Years until mandatory retirement||Appointed by||Year appointed|
|Anabelle Rodríguez||Associate Justice||66||4 years||Sila María Calderón||2004|
|Edgardo Rivera Garcia||Associate Justice||61||9 years||Luis Fortuño||2010|
|Erick Kolthoff Caraballo||Associate Justice||55||15 years||Luis Fortuño||2009|
|Liana Fiol Matta||Chief Justice||70||0 years||Sila María Calderón||2004|
|Luis Estrella Martínez||Associate Justice||45||25 years||Luis Fortuño||2011|
|Mildred Pabón Charneco||Associate Justice||59||11 years||Luis Fortuño||2009|
|Rafael Martínez Torres||Associate Justice||57||13 years||Luis Fortuño||2009|
|Roberto Feliberti Cintrón||Associate Justice||53||17 years||Luis Fortuño||2011|
|Maite Oronoz Rodríguez||Associate Justice||40||30 years||Alejandro Garcia Padilla||2014|
|This section does not cite any sources. (December 2014)|
The realignment on the court has led to several significant court decisions. In Suarez Caceres vs CEE, the court overruled a previous court decision that required that a "None of the Above" option be included in political status plebiscites. That option obtained an absolute majority of votes in the 1998 political status plebiscite.
A 4–3 majority amended Rule 5 of the court's regulations to enable the most senior judge on the majority side of every case to determine the member of the Court that would write the majority opinion, which is the practice in the Supreme Court of the United States. Previously, the Chief Justice, even when on the minority side of a case, assigned the writing of the opinion of the Court.
Conflicts with the US Federal Court
From 1915 to 1961, decisions of the Puerto Rico Supreme Court could be appealed to the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. In earlier years, the First Circuit frequently reversed the Puerto Rico Supreme Court, sometimes attempting to impose its own interpretations of Puerto Rico's civil law legal norms despite the Boston-based court's unfamiliarity with Puerto Rico jurisprudence, until a series of opinions by United States Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes instructed that the Puerto Rico Supreme Court's interpretations were not to be overturned by the federal appeals court unless they were "manifestly wrong."
With the standard of review so limited, and especially after Puerto Rico attained Commonwealth status under the 1952 Constitution, the route for appeals was deemed anachronistic and was repealed in 1961 providing Puerto Rico with a judicial state-federal court structure equal to that of States.
Today, decisions of the Puerto Rico Supreme Court are as final as those of any state supreme court and are reviewable by the Supreme Court of the United States only pursuant to a writ of certiorari, when an important question of federal law is involved.
Conflicts between the Puerto Rico courts and the federal court do arise from time to time. According to the 1952 Constitution of Puerto Rico, the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court is only for laws of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico. However, on several[which?] occasions the U.S. District Court for the District of Puerto Rico has taken jurisdiction on cases having to do with Puerto Rican law.
2004 general election
A highly controversial instance occurred in November 2004, when the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico declared that all ballots should be counted during the Puerto Rican general election, 2004. The New Progressive Party brought the matter to the Federal Court and claimed that some of the ballots were applied. Federal Judge Daniel Dominguez took jurisdiction of the case, in a ruling that would effectively have nullified the decision of the Supreme Court. However, on December 15, 2004, the First Circuit Court reversed Dominguez's decision and found that questions on the electoral process of Puerto Rico are matters reserved for the Puerto Rico local court system, headed by the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico.
- List of Justices of the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico by court
- Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
- Puerto Rico Federal District Court
- Courts of the United States
- State court (United States)#Nomenclature
- Trial court
- Judiciary of Puerto Rico
- "Puerto Rico Basic Facts". Puerto Rico Government Development Bank. Paragraph 6. Retrieved December 30, 2012.
The highest court within the local jurisdiction is the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico.
- "Supreme Court Building in Puerto Rico". National Park Service. Paragraph 1. Retrieved December 30, 2012.
[ ... ]of the highest court of law on the island.
- Article III of the Constitution of Puerto Rico Section 4, Constitution of Puerto Rico (July 25, 1952). Retrieved on August 11, 2013.
- Article V of the Constitution of Puerto Rico Section 3, Constitution of Puerto Rico (July 25, 1952). Retrieved on August 11, 2013.
- Article III of the Constitution of Puerto Rico Section 21, Constitution of Puerto Rico (July 25, 1952). Retrieved on August 11, 2013.
- The People v. Casiano. Appeal from the District Court of Ponce. No. 7. Decided April 26, 1905. Report of Cases Adjudged in the Supreme Court of Puerto Rico. Coleccion de Sentencias y Soluciones Dictadas por el Tribunal. Volumen 8. (January 23 to June 17, 1905) Puerto Rico. Supreme Court, Antonio F. Castro, Rafael Hernandez-Usera, Raleigh F. Haydon, Pablo Berga y Ponce de León, Joaquín López. Pages 344–346 and others. Printed by the Bureau of Supplies, Printing, and Transportation. San Juan, Puerto Rico. Retrieved 1 December 2011.
- REGISTER OF PORTO RICO FOR 1903. Hon. Charles Hartzell, Secretary of Porto Rico. October, 1903. San Juan, Puerto Rico: Press of Lou 18 E. Tuzo and Company. 1903. (AUG 14 1944). Page 82. Retrieved 19 December 2011.
- El libro de Puerto Rico: Chapter IV: Government: The Judiciary - Its Importance and Influence, by Emilio del Toro Cuebas. E. Fernandez Garcia, editor. Francis W. Hoadley & Eugenio Astol, co-editors. San Juan, Puerto Rico: El Libro Azul Publishing Company. 1923. Page 181. Retrieved 20 July 2012.
- CONSEJO DE SALUD PLAYA DE PONCE v JOHNNY RULLAN, SECRETARY OF HEALTH OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF PUERTO RICO (PDF), The United States District Court for the District of Puerto Rico, retrieved 2010-01-15