Susanna Montgomery, Countess of Eglinton

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
The Countess of Eglinton
Susanna Montgomery nee Kennedy.JPG
Lady Eglinton
Tenure 1709 - 1729
Born (1690-01-01)1 January 1690
Culzean Castle
Died 18 March 1780(1780-03-18) (aged 90)
Auchans Castle
Burial Kilwinning
Spouse Alexander Montgomerie, 9th Earl of Eglinton
James, Lord Montgomerie
Alexander, 10th Earl of Eglinton
Archibald, 11th Earl of Eglinton
Lady Elizabeth Montgomerie
Lady Helen Montgomerie
Lady Susan Montgomerie
Lady Margaret Montgomerie
Lady Christian Montgomerie
Lady Charlotte Montgomerie
Lady Grace Montgomerie
Lady Frances Montgomerie
Full name
Susanna Kennedy
House Clan Kennedy
Father Sir Archibald Kennedy, 1st Bt.
Mother Hon. Elizabeth Leslie

Susanna Montgomery, Countess of Eglinton (1690 – 18 March 1780) was the third wife of Alexander Montgomerie, 9th Earl of Eglinton. Born in 1690, she died at Auchans on 18 March 1780 at the age of 90.[1] She had been a widow for nearly 51 years.[2] The surname of the family is often rendered as Montgomerie and she signed herself as S. Eglintoune.[3]


Born at Culzean Castle, Lady Eglinton was the daughter of Sir Archibald Kennedy, 1st Bt. of Culzean and the Hon. Elizabeth Leslie, daughter of David Leslie, 1st Lord Newark.

Personal qualities, marriage and anecdotes[edit]

Susanna Montgomery, Countess of Eglinton.
Alexander Montgomery, 9th Earl of Eglinton.

Lady Eglinton was celebrated for her beauty, and for her patronage of the Scottish poets and writers of her day. Her interest in literature was seen by her contemporaries to be distinctly odd for one of her station.[4] Sir William Fraser, the Scottish historian, said that to her loveliness were added the more valuable attractions of genius and great accomplishment. She was exceptional in her knowledge of art, music, literature, science, philosophy and history; additionally she spoke Italian, French and German.[5]

Fullarton suggests that Susanna's personality owed much to her maternal grandfather, General David Leslie, later Lord Newark. He was second in command at the Battle of Marston moor and in command at the Battle of Philiphaugh; on the winning side at both encounters.[6]

She was beautiful and at 6 foot, unusually tall for those times.[7] It is stated that, on her arrival with her father in Edinburgh around the time of the Union (1702), she was surrounded by wooers. One of these, Sir John Clerk, baronet, of Pennycuik, was deemed likeliest to succeed, but was unsuccessful.

She instead married the 9th Earl. When Susanna's father consulted him as to the propriety of the match the earl, whose second countess was then alive but in a long-continued state of ill health, purportedly replied Bide awee, Sir Archie, my wife’s very sickly. Soon afterwards his second wife died of natural causes and he married again, this being to his third countess. Susanna did not immediately accept, but the earl eventually won through in spite of numerous rivals. She was married for 20 years and a widow at the age of 40, living for another 51 years.[8] She brought to the family a way of walking in a stately fashion which became known as 'the Eglinton air'.[9]

One story relates that she had long been destined to marry the 9th Earl, for one day whilst out walking at Culzean, a hawk belonging to the Earl landed on her shoulder when she called to it and those observing saw it as a clear omen once the silver bells around its neck were seen to carry the name of the earl.[10][11]

A roundelay entitled The Lovely Eglintoune became well known throughout Scotland, being composed by Hamilton of Bangour.[5]

The Gentle Shepherd, first published in 1725, was dedicated to her by Allan Ramsay and Hamilton of Bangour wrote flattering verse to Susanna, Lady Eglinton and her daughters.[4] Ramsay referred to her penetration, superior wit and sound judgement ........ accompanied with the diviner charms of goodness and equality of mind.[4] Samuel Boyse dedicated a volume of poems to her. Several other publications of the period were inscribed to her, and to her Ramsay also dedicated the music of his first book of songs. At a later period he presented to the countess the original manuscript of his great pastoral poem, which she afterwards gave to James Boswell, and it was for many years preserved in the library at Auchinleck House, along with the presentation letter of the poet.[12]

The Gentle Shepherd

Paraphrased by Hamilton of Bangour.

Oh Eglintoun! thy happy breast,
Calm and serene enjoys the heavenly guest;
From the tumultuous rule of passions freed,
Pure in thy thought, and spotless in thy deed;
In virtues rich, in goodness unconfin'd,
Thou shin'st a fair example to thy kind.

She briefly attended the court of King George II in 1730[14] and had caught the eye of the Queen, Caroline of Ansbach.[15] King George II described her as the most beautiful woman in my dominions.[16] Susanna's special entertainments were magnificent and it was said that they were seldom if ever equalled in any private mansion.[5][17] She refused to attend the procession at the coronation of King George III in 1760 because of her Jacobite sympathies.[18]

Lady Susanna in her 80s

Susanna retained her figure and complexion until her death, supposedly because she never used paint or cosmetics and daily washed her face with sow's milk and drank it, recommending this treatment to others.[2] Her eyes colour however went from the blue of forget-me-not to the light blue of speedwells.[19] She once said to her daughter, Lady Bettie - What would you give to be as pretty as I am? To which Lady Bettie replied - Not half as much as you would give to be as young as I am.[17] Cummell in her lifetime recorded that her complexion was like rhododendron and rose flowers dipped in milk.[20] her daughter Helen once commented Who can surpass Mama? She has not aged a day in fourty years. It was believed that Susanna had discovered the secret of eternal youth, showing no signs of her beauty lessening even at the age of sixty.[5]

When she and her daughters were in Edinburgh the caddies at the Cross were said to be dumbfounded by their beauty as they stepped from their Sedan chairs.[9]

Paterson records that Susanna Countess of Eglintoun was amiable, accomplished and beautiful. A portrait of her ladyship when young was in the possession of the late Mr Sharpe. He had also a miniature of her in her 81st year, when she was a fine looking, stout old lady.[21] Her blue eyes grew lighter in colour as she advanced in years.[22] Her portrait still hangs in Culzean Castle.[7]

Dr. Robert Chambers recorded that In her bed-rooms was hung a portrait of her sovereign de jure (in principle), the ill-starred Charles Edward, so situated as to be the first object which met her sight on awaking in the morning.[23] Her husband had been a covert Jacobite.[10]

A full-length portrait (97" by 53") of Susanna as Countess in her robes was painted by Allan Ramsay and was sold at the 1925 auction of the contents of Eglinton Castle. Allan was the eldest son of Allan Ramsay the poet who had dedicated 'The Gentle Shepherd' to Susanna.[24] This painting now hangs in Culzean Castle.

Robert Campbell (Cummell) records that Quintin Crawfurd was Lady Susanna's factor.[25]

Involvement in industry[edit]

The Montgomerie family owned a number of coal mines or pits and Susanna was involved in the general supervision of miners on the estate as shown by her correspondence and the fact that she intervened in the 1749 - 50 labour unrest.[26] The miners at this time claimed that they were forced to work a 14-hour day, six days a week in order to earn a living wage.[27][28]

Susanna summoned the miners to Eglinton Castle to try and sort things out, as a result of which several of the miners signed a 'disclamation' which they later tried to repudiate. The lawyer who dealt with the case stated that it is probable a Lady of great Beauty of Address might prevail with some of the old Coalziers to sign any paper.[29]

She was very industrious and even established a distillery, later a brewery at the family's Burgh and Regality of Montgomeryston inside the walls of Cromwell's old Citadel fort at Ayr to increase her income. It seems to have been only moderately successful.[4][30]

Offspring and step children[edit]

She had three sons:

  • James, Lord Montgomerie, who died young;
  • Alexander, 10th Earl of Eglinton.
  • Archibald, 11th Earl of Eglinton.

And eight daughters, who were all married but one.

  • Lady Elizabeth married Sir John Cunningham of Caprington;
  • Lady Helen married Francis Stuart of Pittendriech in 1745;
  • Lady Susan married John Renton of Lamberton;
  • Lady Margaret married Sir Alexander MacDonald in 1739;
  • Lady Christian married James Moray of Abercairny;
  • Lady Grace married Cornet Byrne, a debaucher and gambler,[5] in 1751 and died in the same year;
  • Lady Frances died unmarried.[31]
  • Lady Charlotte, who died suddenly of fever after having previously lost the use of her limbs.
  • Lady Eleanor, who was frequently unwell and a special trip to the 'waters' at Bath did not cure her.
  • Lady Susanna, who died of scurvy.

To them their handsome mother transmitted a nobleness of mien, distinguished at the period as the "Eglinton air."[12] She had seven step children through the earl's two previous marriages.[7]

Two of her sons had smallpox and one had scarlet fever. Apart from Charlotte all her daughters lived long enough to marry and have children, however Susanna, the mother, outlived them all.[24]

Lady Margaret MacDonald helped Flora MacDonald in her efforts to save Bonnie Prince Charlie whilst her husband was off fighting the Jacobites.[32]

The death of her son Alexander, 10th Earl of Eglinton[edit]

A panel from the coach in which the 10th Earl travelled during the Mungo Campbell incident.
the outside facing side of the panel from the coach in which the 10th Earl travelled during the Mungo Campbell incident.

On 24 October 1769, near Ardrossan, travelling in his carriage and four servants following him, Alexander met two men, one of whom was Mungo Campbell, an officer of excise at Saltcoats, and son of a Provost of Ayr, one of twenty-four children.[33] Alexander, as Mungo had previously been caught shooting game on his estates, asked Mungo to hand over the gun he was carrying, which he refused, saying that he would rather die. The earl then ordered his fowling-piece, which was not loaded, to be brought from the carriage and in the scuffle that ensued, Mungo fired at Lord Eglinton, who was mortally wounded in the bowels, and died ten hours later at about one o’clock the following morning, at Eglinton Castle, where he had been taken in his carriage.[34] The preserved door pannel (sic) contradicts the stated course of events by stating that the Earl was instantly shot upon leaving his carriage.

A contemporary newspaper report first recorded the incident as actually being a duel over a woman in which the Earl had been worsted. Indeed, when in London (from 1760 to 1763 at the least) he stayed in Queen Street, Mayfair and according to Boswell, he kept a mistress, a Ms. or Mrs. Brown, who, in 1763, "had lived with him seven or eight years".[35]

Mungo Campbell hanged himself and thereby cheated the hangman. He left the following note -

"Farewell, vain world, I've had enough of thee,
And now am careless what thou say'st of me,
Thy smiles I court not, nor thy frowns I fear,
My cares are past, my heart lies easy here,
What faults they find in me take care to shun,
And look at home, enough is to be done".[36]

Susanna never quite recovered from the sight of her dying son being carried into Eglinton Castle and wrote I shall endeavour to bear my suffering with as little trouble to my fellow creatures as possible.[37] Millar records that after the murder, by Mungo Campbell, of her son Alexander, tenth Earl of Eglintoun, in 1769, she retired from the position which she held in society.[38] She had insisted that the Earl was always referred to as Lord Eglinton as a youth and he had formally led her down to dinner every night.[18] The murderer was tried before the high court of justiciary at Edinburgh, and condemned to death, but prevented a public execution by hanging himself in prison.

The Countess Susanna would have been further devastated by the attitude of many of the estate tenants who had more sympathy for Mungo Campbell than for the earl, and saw his death as a punishment imposed by heaven, due to the misimprovements of his life and the still more irritating improvement of his estates, his changes of old customs, his interference with old tenants.[39][40] Mungo himself was also well liked in all the places that he had resided as an Excise officer, namely Stewarton, Saltcoats and Irvine.[41]

Wilson records that "This sad affair , which took place on the grounds between Saltcoats and Ardrossan, was long the topic of discourse in town and country, .."[42]

Dying unmarried, the earl was succeeded by his brother, Archibald.[12] The carriage door, inscribed with the details of the tragedy, was retained by the Montgomerie family until the great sale of Eglinton Castle's contents in the 1920s.[43] The incident was written into a novel by John Galt, the well known story of fictitious Ayrshire village life, Annals of the Parish.[44]


Susanna was a prolific letter writer if the sixty-four letters that have survived are any indication. She wrote in particular to her daughters, step children, Lord Milton (the family Guardian appointed by her deceased husband), Andrew Fletcher of Salton and the Lord Justice Clerk.[45]

Dower Houses[edit]

Eglintoune castle as it was during Susanna's lifetime
Kilmaurs Place.

It was traditional and practical for a dowager to move out of the family seat and dwell within a dower house. Susanna as dowager countess seems to have first moved to Kilmaurs Place in Kilmaurs, East Ayrshire and later moved to Auchans near Dundonald. Letters from 1751 to 1762 are recorded as being written at Kilmars (sic) and from 1765 they are recorded as being written at Auchans. In 1762 she writes in a letter to her son-in-law James Moray of Abercairney that her son (the tenth Earl) has given her Auchans House and that she was about to repair it.[46] When her second son, Archibald (the 11th Earl) was married in 1772, she took up her residence permanently at Auchans,[38] where she lived for eight years.[19]

Auchans House views[edit]

Meeting with Samuel Johnson and James Boswell[edit]

James Boswell of Auchinleck.
Samuel Johnson by Joshua Reynolds.

In 1773 James Boswell and Samuel Johnson visited Lady Susanna, now the Dowager Countess, at her home, Auchans, near Dundonald.[1] Her son Alexander already knew Johnson and had passed on much information about him to his mother.[47] She knew that Johnson wished to live a long life and became sulky if death was mentioned. She tactfully embraced Johnson upon his departure and commented that as she was old enough to be his mother, she would adopt him as her son; Johnson was delighted.[15][48] Auchans is now Old Auchans and stands as a substantial ruin in 2009.

Lady Susanna is also remembered for taming a number of rats at Auchans to come for food at her table when she tapped on the oak wall panel and opened a small door.[49] These ten or twelve rats would leave when instructed to; she commented that she valued the gratitude they showed, something she had rarely received from humans.[30]

Johnson, in a letter to Mrs Thrale, described Susanna as a lady who for many years gave the laws of elegance to Scotland. She is in full vigour of mind, and not much impaired in form. She is only eighty-three. She was remarking that her marriage was in the year eight; and I told her my birth was in the year nine. 'Then,' says she, 'I am just old enough to be your mother, and I will take you for my son.' She called Boswell the boy. 'Yes, Madam.' said I, 'we will send him to school.' 'He is already,' said she, 'in a good school;' and expressed her hope of his improvement. At last night came, and I was sorry to leave her.[23]

Johnson also wrote that Her figure is majestic, her manner high bred, her reading extensive and her conversation elegant. She has been the admiration of the gay circles of life.[17]


A Lady Susanna Montgomerie was the daughter of General Archibald Montgomerie, 11th Earl of Eglinton and Frances Twysden. She died on 16 November 1805, unmarried.[50]

Archibald William Alexander Montgomerie, 17th Earl of Eglinton and Winton named his first child for Susanna; Lady Susanna Montgomerie was born 19 October 1941 and became Lady Susanna Crawfurd, having married Mr David Dundas Crawford.[51]


Memorial to John Dunlop.

Around 1708 the elderly Sir John Eldon laid siege to Culzean Castle in a passionate and fruitless act known to locals as Susanna and the Elder.[5]

John Dunlop Esq. of Whitmuir Hall near Selkirk, who lived to sixty one years of age, was the onetime Factor to Susanna Montgomery at Auchans Castle. He may have lived at the now ruined Old Auchans and was held in high regard by William Aiton.

In 1810 a John Crawfurd made a bogus claim to the titles and estates of the Crawfurds and Lindsays; to add some credibility he claimed that his forebear had been the eldest son and heir and had been forced to flee to Ireland after having murdered a man in a duel by firing before the signal. This duel he claimed had been over a matter of honour relating to the Lady Susanna Kennedy, with whom he was entirely smitten.[52]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ a b Love, Page 227.
  2. ^ a b Robertson, Page 104.
  3. ^ Fraser, Page 352
  4. ^ a b c d Cousins, Page 53
  5. ^ a b c d e f McEvoy, Page 311
  6. ^ Fullarton, Page 61
  7. ^ a b c Cousins, Page 50
  8. ^ Cousins, Page 51
  9. ^ a b Service, Page 109
  10. ^ a b Service, Page 45
  11. ^ Robertson, Page 95.
  12. ^ a b c The Scottish Nation - Eglinton
  13. ^ Dougall, Page 228
  14. ^ Fraser, Page 350
  15. ^ a b Robertson, Page 98.
  16. ^ McMichael, Page 170
  17. ^ a b c Cousins, Page 54
  18. ^ a b Service, Page 47
  19. ^ a b Service, Page 108
  20. ^ Service, Page 44
  21. ^ Google Images
  22. ^ Paterson, Page 501.
  23. ^ a b Hill, Page 269
  24. ^ a b Eglinton Archive, Eglinton Country Park
  25. ^ Service, Page 12
  26. ^ Duckham, Page 157
  27. ^ Duckham, Page 268
  28. ^ Whatley, Page 86
  29. ^ Duckham, Page 290
  30. ^ a b Robertson, Page 103.
  31. ^ Reilly, Page 26
  32. ^ Stewart, page 7
  33. ^ Robertson (1889), Page 324
  34. ^ Service, Page 100
  35. ^ James Accessed : 2010-07-22
  36. ^ Tarlton Law Library. Accessed : 2010-07-22
  37. ^ Cousins, Page 56
  38. ^ a b Millar, Page 14
  39. ^ McClure, Page 169
  40. ^ Aiton, Page 77
  41. ^ Fullarton, Page 169
  42. ^ Wilson, Page 95
  43. ^ Catalogue of the Superior Furnishings within Eglinton Castle. Dowell's Ltd. 1 December 1925
  44. ^ Cuthbertson, Page 155
  45. ^ Fraser, Pages 342 - 374
  46. ^ Fraser, Page 369
  47. ^ Paterson, Pages 433
  48. ^ Dougall, Page 227
  49. ^ Hill, Page 270
  50. ^ Lundy, Darryl. "UK and European peerage". The Peerage. [unreliable source]
  51. ^ Descendents of the 12th Earl of Eglinton
  52. ^ Lauchland, Page 73
  1. Aiton, William (1811). General View of The Agriculture of the County of Ayr; observations on the means of its improvement; drawn up for the consideration of the Board of Agriculture, and Internal Improvements, with Beautiful Engravings. Glasgow.
  2. Cousins, M. B. L. Elizabeth. Montgomeries of Eglinton. Ayr Division. Strathclyde Department of Education.
  3. Cuthbertson, David Cuningham (1945). Autumn in Kyle and the Charm of Cunninghame. London : Jenkins.
  4. Dougall, Charles S. (1911). The Burns Country. London : A & C Black.
  5. Dowell's Ltd (1925). Catalogue of the Superior Furnishings within Eglinton Castle. 1 December 1925.
  6. Duckham, Baron Frederick (1970). A History of the Scottish Coal Industry - Volume 1: 1700-1815. A Social and Industrial History. Newton Abbot : David & Charles. ISBN 0-7153-4886-8 / .
  7. Fraser, William (1859). Memorials of the Montgomeries Earls of Eglinton. Edinburgh.
  8. Fullarton, John (1864). Historical Memoirs of the family of Eglinton and Winton, together with relative notes and illustrations. Ardrossan : Arthur Guthrie.
  9. Hill, George Birkbeck (1890). Footsteps of Dr. Johnson (Scotland). London : Sampson Low, Marston, Searle and Rivington.
  10. Lauchland, John (2000). A History of Kilbirnie Auld Kirk. Pub. The Friends of the Auld Kirk Heritage Group.
  11. Love, Dane (2003), Ayrshire : Discovering a County. Ayr : Fort Publishing. ISBN 0-9544461-1-9.
  12. Millar, A. H. (1885). The Castles and Mansions of Ayrshire. Glasgow : Grimsay Press. ISBN 1-84530-019-X.
  13. McClure, David (2002). Ayrshire in the Age of Improvement. Ayrshire Monographs 27. Ayr Arch & Nat Hist Soc. ISBN 0-9542253-0-9.
  14. McEvoy, Edward (1976). The Astonishing Miss Kennedy. The Lady.
  15. McMichael, George (c. 1881 - 1890). Notes on the Way Through Ayrshire and the Land of Burn, Wallace, Henry the Minstrel, and Covenant Martyrs. Hugh Henry : Ayr.
  16. Paterson, James (1863–66). History of the Counties of Ayr and Wigton. V - II - Kyle. Edinburgh : J. Stillie.
  17. Reilly, Emilia Georgiana Susanna (1842). A Genealogical History of the family of Montgomery, comprising the lines of Eglinton and Braidstane in Scotland and Mount-Alexander and Grey-Abbey in Ireland. Privately published.
  18. Robertson, William (1889). Historical Tales and Legends of Ayrshire. London: Hamilton, Adams and Co.
  19. Robertson, William (1908). Ayrshire: Its History and Historic Families. Glasgow : Grimsay Press. ISBN 1-84530-026-2. V.2.
  20. Service, John (1913), The Memorables of Robin Cummell. Paisley : Alexander Gardner.
  21. Whatley, C. A. (1983). The Finest Place for a Lasting Colliery. Ayr. Arch. & Nat. Hist. Soc.
  22. Wilson, M. (1875). The Ayrshire Hermit. Kilmarnock : Alfred Chas. Jonas

External links[edit]