|This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the Equale article.
This is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject.
|This article is of interest to the following WikiProjects:|
Quotation from Glöggl
I removed from the article an extended quote from Franz Xaver Glöggl, with the edit summary "we can't host this here, as we don't know for sure that the translation is out of copyright (as the underlying German text from 1828 indubitably is)". That was far from clear. What I meant to say was something like "we can't host this here without attribution to the author of the translation, as we don't know for sure that it is out of copyright (as the underlying German text from 1828 indubitably is)". I'm sorry about that. Properly quoted and attributed content can be added in Wikipedia, and I didn't mean to imply otherwise. I'm sorry about that.
HLHJ has suggested that the quote could be added back, with his/her own translation of the German text. I've no strong objection to that, but can't help thinking that the quote serves little purpose, and would be better used as a source for a sentence or two on the function of the equale in funeral rites in Linz. Justlettersandnumbers (talk) 21:32, 1 January 2017 (UTC)
- I found Justlettersandnumbers entirely clear, and also entirely correct. It was remarkably stupid of me not to think of the copyright on the translation; all apologies due are due from me. Still somewhat stupidly, I posted the original text on Justlettersandnumbers' talk page instead of here; just so anyone reading this knows what we are talking about, here is the quote with my no doubt lousy translation:
In der ersten Klasse wird bei Ankunft der Geistlichkeit durch eine kurze Trauermusik (Equal) mit Posaunen oder andern Blasinstrumented das Zeichen zur geistlichen Trauerhandlung fuer die Anwesenden gegeben, nach deren Vollendung sich der Leichenzug in bewegung sesset, welches wieder mittelst der blasenden Trauermusik angezeigt wird, mit welcher dann waerend des Zuges die Gesangmusik, die ein drei- oder vierstimmiges Misserere singet, abwechselt bis zum Eingange der Kirche oder Grabstaette, wo der Einsegnung der Vers.: Requiem aeternam, gesungen wird. Nach erfolgter Einsegnung und dem allgemeinem Gebet wird eine Trauer-Motette gesungen.(source, in blackletter, here: pp.20-21 page, record)
For first-class funerals, the arrival of the clergy will be announced by a short mourning-music (Equale) played on trombones or other wind instruments. This will mark the beginning of the funeral service. After this, the funeral procession will set out, again suitably announced by mourning music on wind instruments. During the procession, this shall be played alternately with a three- or four-voice choral Misserere until arrival at the entrance of the church or graveyard, where the benediction of the Requiem aeternam is sung. After the benediction and common prayer, a mourning motet is sung.
- There's a rather better PD description of Moravian funeral rites from a magazine:
"The cheerful, hopeful piety of the Moravian people is manifest in their burial customs. When a member of the church dies, it is announced by the tender strains of the trombone choir from the belfry of the church. While the funeral service is being held in the church, the body of the deceased lies in the Corpse House at the rear of the church. After the service, the coffin is placed on a bier and covered with a white cloth, as it is borne to the cemetery. At the grave a beautiful responsive service, participated in by the minister and the people, and with trombone accompaniment, is rendered. Amid the tall trees of the graveyard and surrounded by the graves of the departed, it is said to be a very beautiful and impressive service."
- -1899 Church Review
- I don't know exactly what the cultural relationship between Moravian and Austrian rites is, but I think they both involve aequales. I don't feel strongly about the inclusion of quotes; I'll go along with what others think best. HLHJ (talk) 05:31, 15 January 2017 (UTC)
- This (and what is below) is interesting stuff, HLHJ, and may well be relevant here. The problem I see is finding sources that confirm the connection between your research and this little-known "micro-genre" (it seems quite possible that the genre was actually invented by Glöggl – I don't know where I read that, nor do I remember why I didn't add it to the short page I wrote about him, but probably because it wasn't reliably sourced). What I think we probably wouldn't want to do is add info that has some tangential bearing on the topic, but isn't actually linked to it in any reliable source – because that runs the risk of straying into the territory of original research. But do please proceed as you think fit. I happen to believe that in an encyclopaedia, as in architecture, "less is more", but I wouldn't want that belief to prevent others from adding relevant stuff. Best regards, Justlettersandnumbers (talk) 21:40, 15 January 2017 (UTC)
With reference to this edit, I entirely agree that the 1500s are pretty irrelevant to aequales. But Luther's bible translation was in current use in the 1700s and 1800s; indeed, it's still in use in Germany to this day. People playing aequales would have thought of the trombone as the instrument that would raise the dead at the last judgment. They'd think of it as the instrument which accompanied the giving of the Ten Commandments in Exodus 20:18 and the unbearable voice of God in Hebrews 12:19. The trombone topples the walls of Jericho. And so on. Maybe there's a more concise way to convey this emotional background? HLHJ (talk) 05:31, 15 January 2017 (UTC)