Talk:Maalbeek/Maelbeek metro station
|WikiProject Trains / Stations / Rapid transit||(Rated Start-class, Low-importance)|
Bilingual name of the station
For some unknown reason, this station and Arts-Loi/Kunst-Wet station are the only ones of the Brussels metro where the Dutch names are written before the French ones. As a reminder, Maelbeek metro station is now (unfortunately!) famous because of Brussels terrorist attacks, and Arts-Loi is the most frequented station of the network: those two stations are therefore the most "famous" stations of the Brussels metro network.
Surprisingly, the changes in the names happened a few days ago, both made by one user. The same user edited the 2016 Brussels bombings article to make sure only the Dutch name "Maalbeek" appears in the article.
Is there any discussion somewhere about the name convention for the Brussels metro station names? As for all the other station the "French name/Dutch name" convention is used, shouldn't we standardize it that way? MisterQ (talk) 17:55, 26 March 2016 (UTC)
This is a serious matter -- even more serious in the case of the cited 2016 Brussels Bombings article. I had noticed it also, first there, then here. I consider it an act of vandalism, and because committed during the week of the 2016 Brussels bombings, an especially disgraceful one; but those are opinions. More objectively speaking, the editing of text to reflect only Dutch-language names violates the principal of Neutral Point of View. In Belgian contexts, favoring either Dutch or French names (when both names are officially valid, as here) is always most likely to be a political act. By consulting the Brussels transit map on the STIB/MIVB (Brussels transit authority) website one finds -- officially? -- "Maalbeek/Maelbeek and "Arts-Loi/Kunst-Wet". Apparently there is a long-standing policy of alternating the French/Dutch order of station names on the metro system maps (and, I think, on signage). — Preceding unsigned comment added by 184.108.40.206 (talk) 16:27, 27 March 2016 (UTC)
- Indeed, STIB-MIVB has an official order. Also: both names are Dutch. The French use the pre-1949 Dutch spelling, nothing French about it. The name of the stream is also called Maalbeek BTW. So that's the common spelling on Wikipedia. As for Arts-Loi/Kunst-Wet: I tried to change it from 'Arts-Loi' to 'Arts-Loi/Kunst-Wet' (official MIVB order) but that page was blocked, that's why the reversed combination is used for that page.--Wester (talk) 21:31, 31 March 2016 (UTC)