Talk:Matt Gonzalez/Archive 4
|This is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page.|
- 1 Proposed Matt Gonzalez Article
- 1.1 Untitled
- 1.2 Matt Gonzalez
- 1.2.1 Childhood and youth
- 1.2.2 Education
- 1.2.3 San Francisco Public Defender's Office (1990–2000)
- 1.2.4 San Francisco Board of Supervisors (2001–2005)
- 1.2.5 2003 San Francisco Mayoral Election
- 1.2.6 "Floppy-haired, slump-shouldered champion of the counterculture"
- 1.2.7 Retirement from public life (2005)
- 1.2.8 External links
- 1.2.9 External links to articles written by Gonazlez
- 1.2.10 External links to audio and video recordings of Gonzalez
- 1.2.11 Further reading
- 2 Comparing the main and proposed articles
Proposed Matt Gonzalez Article
As regards the Clean Up notice, the sprawling, poorly written article on the Article page is filled with factual errors and is weighed down with POVs, editorializing, unneeded detail, too many footnotes, and numerous grammatical errors. Judging by the paltry number of edits to the article, we can assume nobody reads past the first paragraph or two. The article is not objective or balanced (much of the material is copied verbatum from Gonzalez campaign Web sites and the SF Bay Guardian). As the Wikipedia tag notes at the top of the article's edit page, This page is 38 kilobytes long. This may be longer than is preferable. That tells you right away that the article needs editing.
I propose using the following article instead. It is objective and paints a thorough, concise, accurate picture of the former supervisor and mayoral candidate. I request that if you have comments about this article, you put them below the article, not between paragraphs. Thank you. Griot 21:07, 28 November 2005 (UTC)Griot
Matt Gonzalez is a leading member of the Green Party. From 2001 to 2005, he served on the Board of Supervisors in San Francisco, California, and was president of the board from 2003 to 2005. He narrowly lost the 2003 San Francisco mayoral election. Gonzalez now heads the law firm Gonzalez & Leigh (pronounced LAY) in San Francisco.
Childhood and youth
Matthew Eduardo Gonzalez was born June 4, 1965 in the border town of McAllen, Texas, in the Rio Grande Valley, but spent his first five years in San Juan, Puerto Rico. His father was a division chief for the international tobacco company Brown & Williamson. Besides San Juan, job transfers took the Gonzalezes to New Orleans, Maryland, and Kentucky, before the family returned to McAllen when Gonzalez was eleven years old. "Eddie" as he was called in his youth was an Eagle Scout and president of his senior class. He discovered his talent for debating at Memorial High School, from which he graduated in 1983. 
Gonzalez said about his childhood in South Texas: "The Mexican-American–Latino–Chicano culture in California is different than my experience in Texas. I grew up in a town that is majority Mexican and Mexican-American. In McAllen, we didn't refer to ourselves as Latinos or Chicanos. We referred to ourselves as Mexican. There's a different feel in that border area." 
Gonzalez's interest in politics, El Universal suggested, was hereditary.  From 1981 to 1983, Enfrían Martínez Rendón, his godfather and maternal uncle, was mayor of Reynosa, an industrial city across the border from McAllen in the northern Mexican state of Tamaulipas.   Oralia, his mother, was born in Mexico; his father Mateo was born in the United States.
In 1987, Gonzalez earned a B.A. from Columbia University in political theory and comparative literature. He was captain of Columbia's debating team; he developed a taste for modern art in New York City's many art museums and galleries. "I see myself as a product of affirmative action..." he said in an interview. "It's something when your first museum experience is going the Metropolitan or the Whitney or the Guggenheim." 
Gonzalez earned a law degree from Stanford Law School in 1990. He was an editor of the Stanford Law Review and member of the Stanford Environmental Law Journal. He helped Paul Brest, the Dean, revise a constitutional law casebook (his contributions to this textbook had to do with gender discrimination and no-religious-test-clause issues). Gonzalez also worked for the California Appellate Project, a state-funded non-profit law firm that represents indigent people in death-penalty and other criminal appeals.
San Francisco Public Defender's Office (1990–2000)
For ten years beginning in 1990, Gonzalez worked at the Public Defender's office in San Francisco as a trial lawyer. He earned a reputation for being fiercely loyal to this clients. "Most public defenders are devoted to their work," colleague (now Public Defender) Jeff Adachi said about Gonzalez. "But we don't give clients our home phone numbers or let them know where we live. Matt would bring clients home with him." 
Defending a client in a minor marijuana-related offense, an angry Gonzalez told the deputy district attorney handling the case that he would run for district attorney if his client were sent to jail on a felony conviction rather than allowed to plead guilty to a misdemeanor charge.  In 1999, Gonzalez ran for district attorney against incumbent Terence Hallinan. Although he came in third in the election with just 11 percent of the vote, he earned the endorsement of many Democratic clubs, and his campaign for district attorney raised his profile in San Francisco. 
San Francisco Board of Supervisors (2001–2005)
In 2000, a system of electing supervisors by district rather than citywide took effect. At the urging of Supervisor Tom Ammiano, Gonzalez moved his residence from the Mission District (in District 9) to Hayes Valley, and ran for supervisor in newly made District 5 (besides Hayes Valley, District 5 comprises the Haight-Ashbury, the Western Addition, Alamo Square, and the easternmost part of the Sunset District). Between the general election and the run-off election in which he defeated school-board member Juanita Owens, Gonzalez left the Democratic Party and joined the Green Party. Gonzalez became the first Green Party member ever elected in San Francisco (although the first according to some sources, namely the San Francisco Green Party, was school-board member Mark Sanchez ).
Conversion to the Green Party
Gonzalez's conversion to the Green Party occurred at the spur of the moment, without aforethought, in what he called "a political or moral epiphany." Gonzalez was attending a rally at the offices of KRON-TV in San Francisco to protest the absence of Green Party senatoral candidate Medea Benjamin at a debate between Senator Dianne Feinstein, a Democrat, and her Republican challenger Tom Campbell. Gonzalez described his conversion to the San Francisco Bay Guardian:
- I wasn't anticipating anything. I certainly wasn't expecting any kind of political or moral epiphany.
- But as the event wore on, what was at stake became disturbingly obvious to me: a thoughtful, intelligent, and honest progressive candidate for senator was being excluded from the opportunity to reach voters and win electoral support.
- I couldn't help thinking of how most of my support in last year's district attorney's race came as a result of being allowed into televised debates with my better-known opponents and how that support has eventually led to my being the frontrunner in the District 5 supervisorial race.
- The more I thought about it, the more I knew I wasn't OK with it. I didn't want to be a member of a party that was urging the exclusion of a candidate solely on the grounds that the candidate didn't have enough support, when it's precisely television coverage that could win that candidate public acceptance. 
In the run-off election, Gonzalez's opponent, Juanita Owens, tried to take advantage of his Green Party affiliation and capitalize on many Democrats' ill feelngs toward the Green Party in the wake of the acrimonious 2000 presidential election , but Gonzalez won the run-off election. Like all municipal elections in San Francisco, elections for supervisor are nonpartisan, but some Greens saw the election of their candidate as a significant achievement because, for the first time, a Green Party member had been elected to an important position in a major U.S. city.
Term on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors
Midway through Gonzalez's four-year term on the San Francisco Board of Supervisors, his colleagues elected him to a two-year term as Board President. From this powerful position, he was able to push his legislative agenda. Gonzalez told the San Francisco Call about his term on the Board: "I'd rather think of the minimum wage and IRV (instant run-off voting) and the chain store legislation as my legacy." 
Gonzalez's crafted these ballot propositions that won election in San Francisco:
- Minimum Wage (Proposition L in 2003): A city ordinance that raised the minimum wage in San Francisco to $8.50 an hour (or $7.75 for nonprofit groups and companies with fewer than 10 employees). The ordinance gave San Francisco one of the highest minimum wages in the United States. 
- Instant Runoff Voting (Proposition A in 2002): A charter amendment changing the election laws to allow for instant run-off (IRV) elections in San Francisco. IRV reduces the expense of run-off elections and is believed by its supporters to promote third-party candidates. San Francisco became the first city in the nation to implement IRV. 
- Supervisors' Salaries (Propositoin J in 2002): A charter amendment re-classifying the eleven San Francisco supervisors from part-time to full-time status and setting their salaries by the Civil Service Commission at $112,000 (previously the supervisors' salaries were $38,000) 
Gonzalez also wrote and pushed to pass this legislation:
- A law subjecting illegal mother-in-law apartments to rent control.
- "Tripwire" legislation requiring the city to notify residents when a big-box retail outlet or chain store applies for a business permit in their neighborhood. The legislation was aimed at Starbucks and Walgreens, which had been displacing independent retailers, and was meant to halt gentrification.
Gonzalez opposed the sale of the naming rights to Candlestick Park (he tried but failed to qualify a ballot proposition to rename the ballpark "Mays Field at SBC Park"). He prohibited the San Francisco Zoo from keeping elephants after concerns were raised about their health , and he changed the term "pet owner" to "pet guardian" in city regulations.  He supported transgender health benefits for city employees  and the acceptance of Matrícula Consular ID cards for immigrant workers from Mexico.  He sponsored a resolution calling on San Francisco to develop a means of generating electrical power from tides. 
Gonzalez also authored these ballot initiatives that were voted down at the polls:
- Energy Self Sufficiency (Proposition D in 2002): A charter amendment requiring San Francisco to acquire its own municipally owned and operated public utility system. The inititative would have required the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission to secure electrical supplies for all the city's power customers and to possibly buy out PG&E's local distribution system. 
- Noncitizen Voting in School Board Elections (Proposition F in 2004): A charter amendment giving non-citizen parents and guardians of schoolchildren the right to vote in local school board elections. 
2003 San Francisco Mayoral Election
In 2003, Gonzalez entered the race for mayor of San Francisco only 24 hours before the filing deadline. The race pitted Gonzalez against Gavin Newsom, a millionaire businessman and ally of then-Mayor Willie Brown. Like Gonzalez, Newsom was a member of the Board of Supervisors. Both candidates were not yet forty years old.
The Gonzalez campaign benifited from anger against Mayor Brown, whose policies, many believed, encouraged gentrification in the City and who was thought to practice corrupt machine-style politics. Gonzalez presented himself as the candidate with the most personal integrity. "They're scared, not of a Green being elected mayor," Gonzalez said, "but of an honest person being elected mayor." 
To many voters, Gonzalez personified San Francisco's traditional blue-collar, liberal values (although some observers pointed out that Gonzalez came from a privileged background and went to an Ivy League university, whereas his opponent was raised by a single mother in relatively humble circumstances).  Perhaps because he entered the race so late, Gonzalez's positions on the issues were not as well-thought-out as Newsom's. For example, Newsom's "Care Not Cash" initiative (Measure N in 2002),  passed by the voters, called for specific policies for addressing San Francisco's notorious homeless problem, but Gonzalez's ideas for addressing this problem, some voters thought, were vague. 
Still, Gonzalez's charismatic appeal was undeniable, and many volunteers flocked to his campaign. "He's the indie-rock Kennedy," one supporter said of Gonazlez.  Said Rich DeLeon, professor of political science at San Francisco State University, "The Gonzalez campaign was truly a mobilizing campaign. It really attracted young people who had not been involved — who were perhaps cynical and apathetic — into the active electorate." 
Newsom outspent Gonzalez by $3 million. The national Democratic Party, fearful of losing one of its traditional liberal strongholds, San Francisco, to the upstart Green Party, dispatched Bill Clinton, Al Gore, Jesse Jackson, and Dianne Feinstein to campaign on Newsom's behalf. Nevertheless, Gonzalez lost the race by only 6 percentage points.  He received 10,000 more votes than his opponent on Election Day but lost when the absentee ballots were counted. Voter turnout was the highest for a mayoral election in 25 years (although, at 53 percent, turnout was well below the 2000 presidential election, when 67 percent of San Francisco voters went to the polls).  Had Gonzalez won the election — had he perhaps entered the race sooner, articulated his positions more thoroughly, or not faced organized opposition from the national Democratic Party — he would have become the first Green Party mayor of a major U.S. city.
"Floppy-haired, slump-shouldered champion of the counterculture"
"Gonzo" as he was affectionately called by his supporters was an unorthodox politician. Newspaper accounts from the San Francisco mayoral election noted that Gonzalez slept on the uncushioned slats of a futon frame because "it's more comfortable," didn't own a watch, and wore Dr Martens and baggy suits  (some of which were given him by former San Francisco mayor Art Agnos).  The "floppy-haired, slump-shouldered champion of the counterculture," as the Christian Science Monitor called him , never married or owned property. He gave away his 1967 Mercedes Benz sedan because, he said, he found it easier to get around on public transportation. 
Gonzalez hosted monthly art exhibits in his City Hall office. He was fond of playing chess and reading poetry. In 1997, at his own expense, he published a collection of poetry by Beat poet Jack Micheline called Sixty-Seven Poems for Downtrodden Saints. He served on the Board of Directors for Intersection for the Arts, a non-profit organization, and in 2004 taught a course called "Art & Politics" at the San Francisco Art Institute. He played bass guitar in a rock band (called John Heartfield after the German artist and anti-Nazi activist). Also in the band were his brother Chuck and his law partner Whitney Leigh. 
Gonzalez's critics considered him a stubborn and willful idealogue. He walked out of Mayor Willie Brown's State of the City address in 2002; he refused to meet with Brown during his first two years on the Board of Supervisors. When the Board put forth a resolution commending Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi, a San Franciscan, for being elected House Minority Whip and being the first woman to hold that position, Gonzalez was the only board member who voted against it. As a public defender, he was twice jailed for contempt of court and ordered arrested a third time (the contempt findings were overturned on appeal).
At an art exhibit in his City Hall office, graffiti artist Barry McGee spray-painted "Smash the State" on the wall.  In March 2002, Gonzalez stunned a Golden Gate Breakfast Club audience when he allegedly told them, "Really, I am a Marxist."  He had earlier written in regard to why he joined the Green Party, "I read The Communist Manifesto & liked it." 
Retirement from public life (2005)
In early 2005, Gonzalez, arguably the highest-ranking Green Party politician in the United States, abruptly announced that he would not seek re-election as supervisor and would return to practicing law. He explained his decision to the San Francisco Examiner:
- I like the whole idea of disengaging from politics for a while and looking at things from the outside. I think the world would be a better place if politicians returned to private life from time to time... Hey, you've got to follow your instincts, you know. That's how I got into politics in the first place, joined the Green Party, ran for the board presidency and later for mayor. What am I supposed to do now? Not listen to myself? 
He told the Golden Gate Xpress:
- What you’re hearing in terms of bitterness is just someone who is angry about the state of political matters, period. I hope I stay angry, because out of that comes a willingness to do things, like getting a minimum wage passed, or changing how elections are done, or fighting chain stores, or keep zoos from having elephants or whatever the hell the issue is. That doesn’t come because I’m happy with everything; that comes because you gotta be pissed-off. You get out there, you try and change it, you expend political capital to try and make it happen. 
Besides his work at Gonzalez & Leigh, the former supervisor keeps busy as a frequent contributor to the publications Mesh and SF Frontlines. A return to Texas may be in Gonzalez's future. "I’m not capable of saying I won’t go home," he told Columbia College Today. "Notwithstanding the political differences of Texas, I’ve always liked where I come from, so it's always been a natural thought that I would get back there." 
- Gonzalez & Leigh LLP, the Web site of Gonzalez's law firm.
- Forever the Rebel with a Cause, Gonzalez Exits Left at City Hall, by Susan Herel. San Francisco Chronicle, January 3, 2005.
- Discussion with Matt Gonzalez on the 2003 San Francisco Mayoralty Campaign & US Politics Today. Left Curve Magazine, January 5, 2004 (roundtable discussion with Gonzalez, Peter Camejo, Jack Hirschman, and others).
- No Left Turn, by George Will. Washington Post, January 25, 2004.
- Newsom: "The Time for Change Is Here"; Tight Race; Strong Bid by Gonzalez Falls Short, by Rachel Gordon. San Francisco Chronicle, December 10, 2003.
- Matt Gonzalez for Mayor, the official Web site of the Gonzalez for Mayor campaign.
- Poets and Yogis: San Francisco Politics, by Mark Sappenfield. Christian Science Monitor, December 9, 2003.
- San Francisco's Greens vs. Democrats Grudge-Match, by Joan Walsh. Salon, December 9, 2003.
- Gonzalez: Giving Back in San Francisco after Childhood of Privilege, by Julian Guthrie. San Francisco Chronicle, December 7, 2003.
- S.F. Voters Need to Tune in to What's Real, by Joan Ryan. San Francisco Chronicle, December 7, 2003.
- The Gonzalez Insurrection, by Marshall Kilduff. San Francisco Chronicle, December 3, 2003.
- S.F. Mayor's Race: The Stretch Run, by Mark Simon and Rachel Gordon. San Francisco Chronicle, November 30, 2003.
- Gonzalez Thumbs His Nose at Voters, by Ken Garcia. San Francisco Chronicle, November, 24, 2003.
- The Party Crasher, by Joan Walsh. San Francisco Magazine, September, 2003.
- Matt Gonzalez Would Govern from the Left, by Rachel Gordon, San Francisco Chronicle, October 18, 2003.
- Greens to Revive Flower Power in San Francisco, by Oliver Poole. new.telegraph.uk, August 12, 2003.
- Who's Afraid of the Greens?, by Ross Mirkarimi. San Francisco Bay Guardian, December 6, 2000.
- Supervisor Candidate Turns Green: Gonzalez's Move Costs Him Democrats' Support by Edward Epstein. San Francisco Chronicle, November 18, 2000.
- Free Matt Gonzalez!, editorial. San Francisco Bay Guardian, January 26, 2000.
- Instant Runoff Voting - On the Move, North Bay Progressive. November, 2005.
- Sparing the Crips Founder, Issue 12, Mesh November, 2005.
- Debunking Ackerman's Numbers. SF Frontlines, November 2005.
- Giving Noncitizens Access to the Voting Booth. SF Frontlines, October, 2005.
- Howl! A Look at Allen Ginsberg's Howl! on the 50th Anniversary of Its Debut, Issue 11, Mesh September 2005.
- Where Is the Body? Understanding the Corpus Delicti Rule, Issue 10, Mesh July 2005.
- A New Era in San Francisco Politics?. San Francisco Bay View, June 29, 2005.
- Marla Ruzicka, 1976–2005, San Francisco Bay Guardian, April 20, 2005.
- Free Santos Reyes!, San Francisco Bay Guardian, March 22, 2005.
- Existential Warfare: Overwhelming our Opponents by Killing Ourselves, Issue 9, Mesh, March 2005.
- A New Era in Baseball, The Golden Gate -X-Press Online, February 28, 2005.
- Green & Red Apples SF Bay View, February 20, 2005.
- Boxers Rebellion: Understanding Self-Preservation Politics, Issue 8, Mesh January 2005.
- Ignoring Tired Pleas. Issue 7, Mesh, November, 2004.
- Why to Vote for Nader. SF Frontlines, October, 2004.
- In Another Era: The Socialist Circle of Eugene Debs, Issue 6, Mesh August 2004.
- Are You Ready for Bechtel Park? How about Halliburton Stadium, or Monsanto Field?, Issue 5, Mesh, June, 2004.
- Reigning in the Chains, Issue 4, Mesh, April, 2004.
- Until When?. Issue 3 Mesh, February, 2004.
- Concession Speech - San Francisco Mayor’s Race, San Francisco Call, May 10, 2005 (this speech was delivered on December 9, 2003).
- Multicultural America Reclaiming Cinco de Mayo. San Francisco Chronicle, May 5, 2003.
- Escaping the Ice Age. San Francisco Bay Guardian, June 19, 2002.
- CHOROSHO! An Auto/Biographical Sketch of Jack Hirschman (with Jack Hirschman). San Francisco Call, May 24, 2002.
- Let's Bellyache!. San Francisco Call, May 24, 2002.
- My Green Manifesto. Left Curve Magazine, February 14, 2002.
- Why I Turned Green. San Francisco Bay Guardian, November 15, 2000.
- Who Has a Dark Wallet?. San Francisco Bay Guardian, March 8, 2000.
- Community Voices: Interview with Matt Gonzalez, an audio podcast interview conducted by Janet Reilly. January 5, 2006.
- Matt Gonzalez Welcoming Speech, a speech at a Nader for President campaign rally. July 16, 2004.
- Matt Gonzalez: Passionate Politico, an audio interview conducted by The Very Rev. Alan Jones of Grace Cathedral and studio audience members in San Francisco. May 16, 2004. (Requires RealPlayer software.)
- Matt Gonzalez Editorial Board Interview, a video interview in 19 segments conducted in the offices of the San Francisco Chronicle by Chronicle editors during the 2003 mayoral election. December 4, 2003. (Requires QuickTime software.)
- Carlsson, Chris, ed. (2005) The Political Edge, City Lights Foundation Books: San Francisco, CA. ISBN: 1-93140-405-4.
- Walter, Nicole (2004) Go Matt Go! Hats Off Books: Tucson, AZ. ISBN: 1-58736-346-1.
==Necessity of Keeping Alternative ARticle Let's keep the alternative article, which is superior to the old one. I propose a vote in which we decide which one to keep. ~Griot
Comparing the main and proposed articles
The proposed article's editor believes it "paints a thorough, concise, accurate picture" while the main article does not. Yet, upon further examination, the proposed article doesn't meet the editor's own expectations. It seems reasonable enough to question how the proposed article does what its proponent says when the reasons for using it don't amount to anything more than an unsupported POV. The editor states:
- Main article is “sprawling” and is “38 kilobytes long.” Fact: the proposed article contains 2,472 words, not including subsections or citation references, and the main article has 2,098 words. As of today, the main article’s edit page states it is 31 kilobytes long, an acceptable length. Surely, the proposed article is "sprawling" given this reasoning.
- Main article has “too many footnotes.” Fact: as of today, the proposed article has 50 source citations (18 external, 26 external links to articles written by Gonzalez, 4 external audio links, and 2 further reading links). The main article contains 57 citations. It should be noted, the number of citations in the main article are the result of that editor’s NPOV claim and to demonstrate its content is supported by a number of verifiable, secondary sources. If the editor believes 57 citations are "too many" for an article being challenged for a point of view, seven fewer citations in an unchallenged article should be held to the same level of criticism.
- Main article is “poorly written...filled with factual errors...weighed down with POVs, editorializing, unneeded detail, too many footnotes, and numerous grammatical errors.” Fact: a POV the editor has not supported with specific examples.
- ”...(much of the material is copied verbatum from Gonzalez campaign Web sites and the SF Bay Guardian).” Fact: no examples are cited.
- "Eighty percent of the citations are to one place -- the SF Bay Guardian." Fact: let the article’s Works cited section show the SF Bay Guardian was cited a whopping 14 times, and San Francisco Chronicle cited 18 times. Combined, citations from both sources make up slightly more than half of the total number used - 32 of 57. Rasax 03:25, 14 April 2006 (UTC)