Talk:Paul W Draper

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  (Redirected from Talk:Paul W. Draper)
Jump to: navigation, search
WikiProject Biography (Rated Stub-class)
WikiProject icon This article is within the scope of WikiProject Biography, a collaborative effort to create, develop and organize Wikipedia's articles about people. All interested editors are invited to join the project and contribute to the discussion. For instructions on how to use this banner, please refer to the documentation.
Stub-Class article Stub  This article has been rated as Stub-Class on the project's quality scale.
Note icon
This article has been automatically rated by a bot or other tool as Stub-Class because it uses a stub template. Please ensure the assessment is correct before removing the |auto= parameter.
Articles for deletion


This article was nominated for deletion on December 17, 2005. The result of the discussion was no consensus. An archived record of this discussion can be found here.

BLP edit, sourcing concerns[edit]

This article is currently under discussion at the Biographies of living persons noticeboard. Content in living persons' biographies must be adequately supported by reliable sources and give due weight facts as indicated in those sources. Primary sources can be cited for basic biographical information, however those touching on notability or significant accomplishments should be supported by coverage in independent third-party sources. I've performed a cleanup to address the following problems:

  1. Arbitrary capitalization and other WP:MOS
  2. Add cites to biographical content
  3. Remove cites to the subject's self-publications; remove excess external links (once is enough)
  4. Remove unsupported claims about third parties including David Copperfield (WP:BLPSPS/WP:RS)
  5. "Frequent performer in..." — remove list as entirely unsupported, likely insignificant (many, many performers out there)
  6. Conferences, lectures, etc.; statements like, "Early in Draper's career he gave lectures at national and international academic conferences in the field of anthropology." — unsupported, likely one of many speakers and attendees, encyclopedically insignificant.
  7. Remove upcoming project "Mr. Clown" (WP:CRYSTAL)
  8. Professional memberships, charities — insignificant, unsupported.
  9. Minister — names of persons of no significance, entirely unsupported, entire topic is most probably insignificant: many in Nevada can marry people.
  10. Remove trivial TV appearances: all appear unsupported and probably insignificant. Note appearing on a TV show does not cause Draper to WP:INHERIT any noteworthiness in particular. See also WP:NOTNEWSPAPER and WP:FART for reasons that news mentions are not inherently noteworthy, and do not necessarily support biographically encyclopedic content.
  11. Remove awards, all of which were unsupported/unverifiable:
    1. Of questionable significance, regional awards by private associations: Irene Ryan Acting Award; Pacific Coast Association of Magicians and Rocky Mountain Emmy Awards — unsupported/unverifiable
    2. Of ostensibly no significance: Awards of Volunteer Award 2003 for the National Conference of Community and Justice; Houdini Award; bests and runner ups in city-wide 48hr Film Festivals; American College Theater Association award; finalist in National Forensic League Competition — unsupported/unverifiable
  12. Remove collection of media coverage and publications that are of little to no biographical significance (see WP:NOTNEWSPAPER, WP:RESUME, and WP:FART); de-puff claim that the subject was "featured" — at least half feature another topic entirely:
    1. As a cultural anthropologist: Draper talking about the Sony Executive Kazuo Hirai announcing the re-launch of the PlayStation Network, Draper talking about cosplay, Draper's comments as a consultant, on a commercial website — very little of this is substantially about Draper
    2. As a magician: Bloggy advert for a $10 show — not particularly reliable, too commercial
    3. Other: Draper talking about Googling himself; Draper talking about "Sin City still live up to its reputation as America's most extravagant party town"

The content I removed may, of course, be replaced with reliable third-party sources that support not only the content, but also its significance. Below are some links that might lead to such coverage:

Happy editing! JFHJr () 21:31, 7 July 2012 (UTC)

Planned Revisions[edit]

I will be working with Paul Draper to revise this page, and will take into consideration all comments and edits noted above. Almoustine (talk) 02:59, 23 May 2014 (UTC)

You need to read WP:COI - almost certainly best to suggest changes here for other editors to implement. I've left more links on your talk page. Dougweller (talk) 10:34, 23 May 2014 (UTC)

Further requested revisions.

Noting the hard work put into this page by those editors watching, I decided to ask for guidance in respect of some suggested edits to Mr Draper's page.

The suggested edits as follows and I value guidance in respect of each.

Keynote speaker for a neonatal convention.

My question: is the a noteworthy enough event in order to justify editing it into the article?

Mr Draper is consultant cultural anthropologist for the Utah Herald.

Does this warrant inclusion on the page about Mr Draper or on the page of the Utah Herald?

Is the following press article worthy of addition in the references section?

Mr Draper is a consultant for CBS I think that this is a clearly worthy reference, but don't want to ruffle any feathers. Please advise.

Likewise Deseret News, as follows:

Ditto Park City Record:

Ditto Parade Magazine:

Mr Draper is a credited advisor for the following publication. May I include it in the published references section?

Is this Yale press release worthy of including in the references section?

I felt most comfortable of all when considering suggestion Mr Draper's appearance on the Hallmark Channel, here talking about his experience of the first 10 shows in that series.

Would be very happy to receive advice about any of the above.

Thanks — Preceding comment added by HKgamer (talk) 11:15, 2 December 2014 (UTC) (talkcontribs) 04:15, 1 December 2014 (UTC)