Talk:Slice of life

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
WikiProject Theatre (Rated Start-class, High-importance)
WikiProject icon This article is part of WikiProject Theatre, a WikiProject dedicated to coverage of theatre on Wikipedia.
To participate: Feel free to edit the article attached to this page, join up at the project page, or contribute to the project discussion.
Start-Class article Start  This article has been rated as Start-Class on the project's quality scale.
 High  This article has been rated as High-importance on the project's importance scale.
 
Note icon
This article has been marked as needing immediate attention.

reword top[edit]

Top of Slice of life article says "For anime usage, see Slice of life story", but "Slice of life story" article has lots of NON-anime (Seinfeld, Of Mice and Men, James Joyce's Dubliners, etc). Change that "anime" to "fictional works"? --EarthFurst (talk) 21:45, 16 August 2009 (UTC)

Merger proposal[edit]

I propose that Slice of life story be merged into Slice of life. I think that the content in the "Slice of life story" article can easily be explained in the context of "Slice of life" as it's just a more focused section of that topic, and the "Slice of life" article is of a reasonable size in which the merging of "Slice of life story" will not cause any problems as far as article size or undue weight is concerned. In fact, I think it will help the "Slice of life" article become a better article and will help expand it into a more standard size. Please offer your Support or Oppose opinion below, and be sure to include your reasoning for your opinion as this is a discussion, not a vote. Thank you for your participation. ···日本穣? · 投稿 · Talk to Nihonjoe · Join WikiProject Japan! 23:25, 25 December 2010 (UTC)

Discussion[edit]

  • Support as nom. ···日本穣? · 投稿 · Talk to Nihonjoe · Join WikiProject Japan! 23:25, 25 December 2010 (UTC)
  • Oppose I feel that there is a significant difference between the cinematic and theatrical meaning of Slice of life and the format of a slice of life story. They are really two different things and there are more than enough sources out there to improve both of them to fairly hgih-quality articles. SilverserenC 01:28, 26 December 2010 (UTC)
  • Not merge for several reasons. A comparison reveals that, apart from the mention of the French phrase, the two pages are totally different. "Slice of life" has fully referenced research with correct categories. "Slice of life story", as noted, has numerous issues, a request for attention by an expert, no explanation of the anime usage, an original research tag from years ago and many citation notices. The discussion page notes more than a few contradictions, with several remarks indicating subjective interpretations or errors. As I previously noted, there's a reason that Beat Generation and beatnik have separate pages even though the two topics have an obvious intrinsic connection; if merged, the distinctions would be instantly blurred. What makes "beatnik" stand apart would then become allied with "Beat Generation" in such a way as to generate confusion. Such an alliance was the original problem with the "beatnik" page before it was given extensive revisions. I believe a similar confusion could result here from a merger. Any suggestion for a simple "clean-up" after such a merger will be inadequate, as the original problems of "slice of life story" will not go away. They might even increase. Pepso2 (talk) 16:56, 15 January 2011 (UTC)
  • Support There is a lot of overlap, at the very least. I think one is just the sub-category of the other. --Havermayer (talk) 06:03, 14 June 2011 (UTC)

Articles merged[edit]

I have decided to go ahead with the merger, discarding all unreferenced material except the claim of seasonality in anime slice-of-life. I have added a reference for the literary use of the term as a narrative technique. --IsaacAA (talk) 14:33, 8 July 2011 (UTC)

Misuse of the term in labeling Japanese media[edit]

I don't think I will ever feel arsed enough to write an article on this topic, so I don't have a citation to go against the one citation the article has so far pointing to the meaning of SoL in Japanese media, and it seems pretty deeply ingrained in Wikipedia, being used as a genre/category for anime, but still, here goes; a critique of the usage of the term:

The term SoL seems horribly misused while categorizing anime/manga. It obviously has nothing to do with the original literary meaning, but let's leave even that aside. It seems most often a show is categorized as SoL when it's a mix of something cute and a comedy. (The cute aspect, or rather "heartwarming" when in more concentrated form, would probably best be termed "iyashikei": http://chrome.dasaku.net/?p=501) But such a show could really be laying anywhere on the scale from pure iyashikei to pure comedy. Examples on the iyashikei side would be shows in the previously provided link like Café Alpha and Aria, as well as (in my opinion) Yama no Susume, Hidamari Sketch, Non Non Biyori, and Barakamon, though these partly sweep towards comedy already. The majority of iyashikei shows incorporate a good deal of comedy so as not to become boring, like K-On, Ichigo Mashimaro, Mitsudomoe, Kiniro Mosaic, Gochuumon wa Usagi desu ka?, A Channel, and Nichijou and Azumanga Daioh; in fact I've seen the last two called pure comedies despite their in part fairly heartwarming nature. Others can be prone to be labeled SoL when they're mostly or purely comedies, like Kitakubu Katsudō Kiroku, Nichibros, Joshiraku, Yuru Yuri, Kill Me Baby, and maybe even Milky Holmes.

It doesn't help that most anime fans would probably label for example Hyouka as a SoL, perhaps many of them Uchouten Kazoku as well, and some even Mushishi to a certain degree. Good recent examples of shows that are mostly drama/romance but are nevertheless also called SoL would be Nagi no Asukara and Glasslip. All these shows have iyashikei elements, and mostly no overarching plot, though they're not as lighthearted as all the previous examples, and notoriously don't do the "all girls main cast" thing, which should probably *not* be a criterion for determining the genre of a show.

So we use "SoL" for an awful lot of shows, which could be anything from a pure slapstick comedy that just happens to have an all-girls cast, to an atmospheric and heartwarming story with near to no actual comedy aspects, and a bunch of other stuff that brushes off the latter category and might just have a lot of drama. One never knows how much comedy, how much "chill out atmosphere", and how much drama to expect when hearing of a "SoL" series.

Now then I look at Wikipedia articles of various shows, it seems the term SoL is used mostly in overlap with what I would call iyashikei. At least anything with comedy aspects is clearly labeled as comedy aside from SoL, and non-comedy iyashikei shows like Café Alpha and Aria do have SoL listed under their genres, so at least Wikipedia is making a good logical categorization without conflating it with comedy, albeit using the wrong term. Still, the "Slice of Life" links on each of those pages lead one to this page which first explains the original and unrelated literary meaning(s) of the term, and then has some short and weakly cited remark on its usage in Japanese media, not even making it clear that it's primarily supposed to mean iyashikei, drawing a parallel to "teen melodrama" instead.

I would recommend Wikipedia to use the term iyashikei in place of SoL, and document the term SoL as a phenomenon of people applying a term to shows of a variety of genres, since it's unclear what it should mean as a genre. So far Wikipedia just uses SoL to mean iyashikei, which neither is fully conformant with the one given citation, nor reflects popular usage, nor makes sense as opposed to "iyashikei" which literally means "healing" and is thus a more adequate word to describe heartwarming atmospheric shows. If that terminological switch isn't possible, I would at least endorse clarifying the issue within this article, though that would probably boil down to admitting that Wikipedia chooses its own interpretation of the term "SoL" which would of course be unacceptable.

Maybe, if something on a talk page on Wikipedia can count as a source, given that I augment some of my above claims with citations, I can do part of the job myself, but it would be mostly pointless if we won't do a wholesale move from "Slice of Life" to "iyashikei", which requires cooperation. 2003:51:4A34:D592:213:E8FF:FEED:36FB (talk) 20:35, 3 October 2014 (UTC)

Thank you for your comments. You are obviously very passionate about this topic, so it is good to see someone taking an interest. I recommend creating an account so it is easier to interact with you and so you can keep a watchlist of topics which interest you.
As for "slice of life", yes, there are an awful lot of them which also fall under comedy, drama, and several other genres, and that's perfectly fine. If there are specific articles you think shouldn't have that category, I recommend discussing them specifically on those talk pages and then leaving a pointer to the discussion(s) here so interested parties can participate. Categories can be hard to determine sometimes, and people can be over-zealous in adding them to articles (I know I've likely gone overboard a few times). We welcome your help on this. ···日本穣? · 投稿 · Talk to Nihonjoe · Join WP Japan! 01:23, 4 October 2014 (UTC)

Currency?[edit]

Is this term still actively used? It seems to have fallen out of use around the early 1990s. Viriditas (talk) 09:24, 11 April 2015 (UTC)