Tennessee Supreme Court
|Tennessee Supreme Court|
|Country||Tennessee, United States|
|Location||Knoxville, Nashville, and Jackson|
|Composition method||Executive selection plus
see Tennessee Plan
|Authorized by||Tennessee Constitution|
|Decisions are appealed to||Supreme Court of the United States|
|Number of positions||5|
|Currently||Jeffrey S. Bivins|
The Tennessee State Constitution, adopted in 1870, calls for five justices, no more than two of whom may come from any one of the state's three Grand Divisions (East Tennessee, Middle Tennessee, and West Tennessee) in order to prevent regional bias. For the same purpose, the court is required to convene alternately in Knoxville, Nashville, and Jackson. In recent years this provision has been regarded as permissive rather than restrictive, and the court has also met in other cities throughout the state as part of a legal education project for high school students.
The justices serve eight-year terms and can succeed themselves. The office of chief justice rotates among the justices. Justices are required to recuse themselves in cases in which they may have a personal interest; the whole court once had to step aside and a case be heard by a special court appointed by the governor, this occurring when the court itself became the subject of litigation, as described below.
The Tennessee Supreme Court has no original jurisdiction. Other than in cases of worker's compensation, which have traditionally been appealed directly to it from the trial court, it hears only appeals of civil cases which have been heard by the Court of Appeals, and of criminal cases that have been heard by the Court of Criminal Appeals. The Tennessee Supreme Court was created through the Constitutional Convention of 1834 and replaced the Tennessee Court of Errors and Appeals.
The method by which Tennessee's supreme court justices are selected has changed significantly over the years.
Originally, each justice was elected by the Tennessee General Assembly for life.
An 1853 amendment to the state constitution set judicial terms of office to eight years (even with changes in the election process, the tenure has remained the same ever since) and provided that all judges (including supreme court justices) would be elected by the people. Under this arrangement, a justice could enter office either through gubernatorial appointment (to fill a vacancy) or by winning a partisan election. Either way, the justice would have to stand for reelection during the next general state election.
In 1971, a statute modified this process at the appellate level. Under a modified version of the Missouri Plan, appellate judges (including supreme court justices) would be subjected only to a "Yes/No" retention vote rather than to any challenge from an electoral opponent. Thus it became impossible to become an appellate judge without being appointed by the governor.
The revised statute was subject to litigation. In the case of Higgins v. Dunn (1973), the Court held that the retention elections were constitutional, as the constitution specified only that judges must be elected, without precisely defining what kinds of elections the General Assembly must enact for that purpose. Justice Allison Humphries, in his dissent, opined that the supreme court justices approving the constitutionality of the Modified Missouri Plan had, "like Esau, sold their soul for a mess of pottage" and had made the judicial branch subordinate to the legislative branch.
Partially as a result of that decision, the statute was revised in 1974 to remove Tennessee Supreme Court justices from the plan, yet a 1994 revision to what was now called the "Tennessee Plan" extended it once again to supreme court justices.
The case of DeLaney v. Thompson challenged the statute once more, in 1998. The plaintiffs argued that the process was not an "election" in the sense envisioned by the authors of the state constitution, and that the court in Higgins v. Dunn had been incompetent to render a decision because of its interest in the outcome of the case. DeLaney v. Thompson was appealed to the Tennessee Supreme Court, which, if it had not recused itself in the case of Higgins v. Dunn, recused itself altogether and entirely now. The Governor appointed five temporary replacements to hear this case. That body declined to rule on the constitutionality of the Tennessee Plan, but rather remanded the case on a technicality.
In 2014, Tennessee voters approved an amendment to the Tennessee Constitution which codified the Tennessee Plan while adding to it a provision that gubernatorial appointments must be confirmed by the General Assembly.
Only one member of the Tennessee Supreme Court has ever been removed under the Tennessee Plan. Former Justice Penny White was removed in 1996 in a campaign reminiscent of that used a few years earlier in California to remove former Chief Justice Rose Bird, and for largely the same reason: a putative opposition to the death penalty.
As of 2016, the justices of the Tennessee Supreme Court are:
|Appointed By||Beginning of Active Service|
|Cornelia A. Clark||September 15, 1950||Franklin, Tennessee||Middle||Phil Bredesen||September 19, 2005|
|Sharon Gail Lee||December 8, 1953||Knoxville, Tennessee||East||Phil Bredesen||September 29, 2009|
|Jeffrey S. Bivins||August 31, 1960||Kingsport, Tennessee||Middle||Bill Haslam||July 16, 2014|
|Holly M. Kirby||July 9, 1957||Memphis, Tennessee||West||Bill Haslam||September 1, 2014|
|Roger A. Page||October 7, 1955||Medina, Tennessee||West||Bill Haslam||February 22, 2016|
- Office of the Attorney General and Reporter, State of Tennessee website, accessed August 15, 2009
- Workman, Dale. "The Courts of Tennessee". Knoxville Bar Association. Retrieved 1 May 2015.
- See Tennessee Code, Annotated article 67.
- Robert L. Delaney vs. Brook Thompson, 01S01-9808-CH-00144 (Tenn. 1998).
- Locker, Richard (November 5, 2014). "Tenn. voters approve all four constitutional amendments date". Knoxville News Sentinel. Retrieved January 29, 2016.
- Judicial Selection in the States: Tennessee (accessed September 9, 2014)
- Supreme Court Information and Biographies (accessed September 9, 2014)
- Supreme Court in the Tennessee Blue Book (pdf) (accessed September 9, 2014)