The Banks of Green Willow
This is a short orchestral piece by George Butterworth, probably the most played of his three works for orchestra. It has certainly been his most recorded orchestral work.
Described by its composer as an "Idyll", and written in 1913, it is scored for a small orchestra consisting of two flutes, two oboes, two clarinets, two bassoons, two horns, one trumpet, harp and strings. It is thus a belated companion to the Two English Idylls of 1910-1911. All three pieces are founded on folk melodies Butterworth collected in Sussex in 1907, each has a similar "arch" shape, and each lasts between 4½ and 6 minutes.
Butterworth based The Banks of Green Willow on two folk song melodies that he noted in 1907 - "The Banks of Green Willow" (Child 24, Roud 172) and "Green Bushes" (Roud 1040, Laws P2). The first was noted from the singing of "Mr & Mrs Cranstone" of Billingshurst, though a few bars from the end (after the flute and harp have played Green Bushes) a solo violin muses on a variant of the tune, recorded by Butterworth in 1909, using a phonograph, from the singing of David Clements in Basingstoke Workhouse. Versions of the second tune were noted from at least ten different singers, though the tune as it appears in the Idyll is not any of them. Each use of each tune varies slightly, and it is likely that Butterworth created new variants based on features of all the various versions he collected. Green Bushes as it appears in the Idyll most closely resembles that sung by Ned Harding of Lower Beeding, Sussex, in June 1907. It is interesting that the composer also noted a version from Mr Cranstone, though it is not much like the one in the Idyll. Green Bushes was a common tune, and there are notable uses of it in works by Ralph Vaughan Williams (Folk Song Suite, Movement 2) and Percy Grainger (Passacaglia: Green Bushes and The Lost Lady Found).
A solo clarinet and strings create a pastoral scene with the title theme, followed by a short development and restatement of the tune. The mood becomes more sombre and agitated as a new theme (Butterworth's own, on horns) is introduced. An animated motif leads to the main climax, which is surprisingly passionate for such a short work, before the music subsides to introduce Green Bushes hesitantly on oboe. This is repeated gently on flute, accompanied by harp, and the piece ends tranquilly with snatches of the variant title theme on violin solo, horn and oboe.
As the composer said this piece is a "musical illustration to the ballad of the same name", it may be useful to realise that the folk ballad tells the tale of a farmer's daughter who falls in love with a young sea-captain, becomes pregnant and runs away with him to sea, having first stolen money from her parents. When her child is born on board ship, the labour is especially difficult and there is no "woman's help" available. Knowing she will die, she asks her lover to "bind a napkin round my head, then throw me overboard, both me and my baby" Her lover does this and watches as she "quivers" - presumably in her death-throes - and he sings a lament to "my true love, whom I once loved so dearly" and who shall be buried on "The Banks of Green Willow" (Butterworth's capitalisation). It is a shocking tale, even more so in other collected versions, where it is the man who decides to throw the girl and baby overboard rather than risk the shame of taking them home (Mr & Mrs Cranstone's text is a little more palatable).
The premiere of The Banks of Green Willow took place on 27 February 1914, when Adrian Boult conducted a combined orchestra of forty members of the Hallé and Liverpool orchestras in West Kirby. This was, in fact, the 24-year-old conductor’s first concert with a professional orchestra (he also gave the British premiere of Hugo Wolf's Italian Serenade at the same concert). The London premiere took place three weeks later, and seems to have been the last occasion Butterworth heard his own music.
- Maurice Miles/Philharmonia Orchestra (1946)
- Sir Adrian Boult/London Philharmonic Orchestra (1954)
- Sir Adrian Boult/London Philharmonic Orchestra (1969)
- Neville Dilkes/English Sinfonia (1971)
- Sir Adrian Boult/London Philharmonic Orchestra (1973)
- Sir Neville Marriner/Academy of St Martin in the Fields (1975)
- André Previn/ London Symphony Orchestra (1976)
- Norman Del Mar/Bournemouth Sinfonietta (1978)
- Jeffrey Tate/English Chamber Orchestra (1987)
- William Boughton/English String Orchestra (1988)
- Sir Charles Groves/English Chamber Orchestra (1989)
- Grant Llewellyn/Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra (1991)
- Kenneth Page/ Orchestra Da Camera (1996)
- Richard Hickox/London Symphony Orchestra (2000)
- Sir Mark Elder/Hallé Orchestra (2002)
- Christopher Warren-Green/ Royal Philharmonic Orchestra (2004)
There are many variant folk songs by the same name. A 2003 novel by the Irish writer Kevin Myers also has the title.
Piano solo, arranged by John Mitchell ([Thames Publishing, available from Music Sales as a special order edition
- arranged by Phillip Brookes (Pabmusic, 1972)
- arranged by Duncan Wilson
- Score published by Stainer & Bell, London, 1918
- Barlow, Michael, Whom The Gods Love, Toccata Press, London, 1997
- All songs that Butterworth collected are in the Vaughan Williams Memorial Library, Cecil Sharp House, London. The Cranstone song is manuscript no.GB/6b/26.
- EFDSS cylinders no.97 & 104
- Manuscript no.GB/6a/80. Vaughan Williams Memorial Library, Cecil Sharp House, London.
- . Musikproduktion Jürgen Höflich, Munich. Preface by Michael Barlow. 2006. Missing or empty
|title=(help); External link in
- Text as noted by Butterworth from Mr & Mrs Cranstone, Vaughan Williams Memorial Library, Cecil Sharp House, London. Manuscript no.GB/6b/26.
- HMV C3491
- Belart CD 461354-2
- BBC Classics BBCRD 9119
- Lyrita SRCD 245
- Decca 468 802-2
- EMI 382 1572
- CHAN 8373
- EMI CDC7 47945-2
- Nimrod NI 5068
- IMP PCD 926
- Decca 436 401-2
- Meridian CDE 84330
- Chandos CHAN 9902
- Hallé CD HLL 7503
- Apex 2564614372