The Bishop's Man
|Publisher||Random House Canada|
|Media type||Print (hardcover, paperback)|
|ISBN||ISBN 0-307-35706-6 (10) & ISBN 978-0-307-35706-9 (13)|
The Bishop's Man is a novel by Canadian writer Linden MacIntyre, published in August 2009. The story follows a Catholic priest named Duncan MacAskill who became so successful at resolving potential church scandals quickly and quietly that he had to accept a position at a remote parish on Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia to give himself a low profile. MacIntyre, a native of Cape Breton, released the novel amidst the on-going sexual abuse scandal in Antigonish diocese in Nova Scotia. The book was awarded the 2009 Scotiabank Giller Prize and the Canadian Booksellers Association's Fiction Book of the Year. Critics gave positive reviews, especially noting MacIntyre's successful development of characters.
At the time of the book's publication, author Linden MacIntyre was 66 years old and living in Toronto with his wife Carol Off. MacIntyre was working at CBC Television where he had been the co-host of the fifth estate since 1990. He had written one previous novel, The Long Stretch, which was published in 1999. Both The Long Stretch and The Bishop's Man were set on Cape Breton Island in Nova Scotia where MacIntyre was raised. As a child, MacIntyre was raised by an Irish-Catholic mother and attended church regularly where the local priest inspired him to consider becoming a priest.
The book was published at the same time as a $15 million settlement was reached in the sexual abuse scandal in Antigonish diocese in Nova Scotia. Evidence emerged that the principal offender, Bishop Raymond Lahey may have assumed the role of the bishop's man in sexual abuse scandal in St. John's archdiocese in Newfoundland in 1989 when he served under then-archbishop Alphonsus Liguori Penney. In an ecclesiastical context, the term bishop's man generally refers to the title of vicar general, who serves as the diocesan bishop's principal deputy for the exercise of administrative authority or refers to the title of auxiliary bishop, a priest who is consecrated as an episcopal assistant to the local ordinary. The Bishop's Man is noted as one of the first cultural depictions of the Catholic sexual abuse scandals. In translating real-life situations to fiction MacIntyre stated, "I do believe that the very best of fiction is based on fact...and an awful lot of the factual situations I've been involved with just scream out for creative elaboration."
In 1994 Duncan MacAskill, a priest and the dean of a Catholic university in Nova Scotia is moved by his bishop to the parish of Creignish. The bishop warns that there are ongoing investigations and he wants MacAskill out of the way before people find him.
MacAskill grew up near Creignish and begins to slowly adjust to life there where many people seem familiar to him. He befriends Danny MacKay, the son of an acquaintance of his, Danny Ban as well as Danny's maternal aunt Stella. Young Danny is a troubled young man who seems to have a complicated relationship with the church. The feelings between MacAskill and Stella and Danny's erratic behaviour towards the church cause MacAskill to reflect back on his career. In the 70s he witnessed Father Roddie MacVicar, a close friend of the bishop's, molesting a young boy and when he mentioned it to the bishop he was sent to Honduras where he fell in love with a local nurse, Jacinta. Upon his return MacAskill began to be used to coverup priests who had behaved improperly ranging from priests who had impregnated their housekeepers or fallen in love with women to priests who had molested young boys. Part of MacAskill's job in these situations was to assuage angry parents and to tell them it was no use contacting the police and that the church would punish the rapist while knowing that they would simply be moved to a different parish instead.
In the present MacAskill continues to try to reach out to Danny, suspecting it is possible that his predecessor, Brendan Bell, now married to a woman, had molested him. Danny continues to behave erratically and after a fight in which he attempts to attack a local boy and ends up hitting MacAskill, Danny commits suicide. As a result MacAskill begins to drink more heavily.
In 1995 MacAskill is contacted by a reporter, MacLeod about Danny's suicide. MacLeod believes there is a link between Danny and Bell but after MacAskill informs him that Bell is now married to a woman he drops the story. Shortly after though he re-contacts MacAskill to inform him that there was another suicide in B.C. with affidavits saying that the man who killed himself had been molested by Father Roddie. MacAskill denies knowledge of this though he knows that Roddie was also implicated in the rape of a young girl with an intellectual disability as well. Though MacAskill gives MacLeod no information he begins to drink more heavily causing him to behave in improper ways which include kissing a former acquaintance and stealing liquor. His behaviour is eventually noted by the bishop who sends him to rehab near Toronto, a place where MacAskill knew he often sent other deviants.
After rehab MacAskill tries to contact Bell again. He is eventually able to contact him through a name given to him by his niece who is a journalist. Back in Creignish Bell finally comes to talk to MacAskill. He tells MacAskill that he did know Danny quite well and the boy confided him and even implies that Danny was molested but is unable to provide him with more information that that, telling him to "look closer to home".
Shortly after, while MacAskill is out by the harbour he comes across Willie Beaton, a local man, who drunkenly admits that he was the one who molested Danny. In anger MacAskill attacks Willie, pushing him so that he falls and injures himself on the rocks. He leaves the scene of the crime and then comes back to find that Willie has died. Though there is an investigation and a witness who saw MacAskill, MacAskill is let off as Willie's alcohol level was high and the witness was unsure whether MacAskill was moving to help Willie or not. As an act of contrition however MacAskill gives his journals, detailing the numerous cover ups he participated in, to the police. He sends a letter of resignation to the bishop who refuses to accepts it. Nevertheless he decides to leave for a vacation, deciding to stay in Stella's place in the Dominican Republic. Before he goes Stella admits to him that she and her sister knew about Danny being molested but decided not to tell his father as his father would murder Willie.
As he is leaving MacAskill runs into Danny Ban at the mall. The two men embrace each other as they say their goodbyes.
- Duncan MacAskill: a Catholic priest who for 20 years specialized in moving around deviant priests for the church.
- Danny MacKay: One of Duncan's young parishoners
- Danny Ban: Danny MacKay's father who suffers from multiple sclerosis
- Stella: a single woman in Creignish who Duncan grows close too, Danny's aunt
- Effie: Duncan's sister
- John: Effie's first husband
- Sextus: Effie's second husband
- Brendan Bell: an errant former priest currently married to a woman who was involved in numerous illegal activities
- The Bishop: Duncan MacAskill's bishop who has distain for the victims of the priests and who works to cover the crimes of priests
- Father Roddie: a contemporary of the bishop's who raped vulnerable children
- Jacinta: a young married nurse who MacAskill had an affair with in Honduras in the mid-70s
- Alfonso: a priest from Honduras who was MacAskill's best friend and who was mistakenly murdered by Jacinta's husband
Publication and reception
The Bishop's Man was published by Random House Canada and released in August 2009. It debuted on Maclean's bestsellers list in the August 28 issue at #8. In early-October The Bishop's Man was included on the shortlist for the Scotiabank Giller Prize and it reached #5 on the bestseller list on October 15. While it fell back to the #9 spot on November 5, it remained at #1 for several months after being awarded the 2009 Scotiabank Giller Prize. At its Libris Awards, the Canadian Booksellers Association awarded The Bishop's Man its Fiction Book of the Year and Linden MacIntyre its Author of the Year award. The book was also awarded the Atlantic Independent Booksellers' Choice Award and the Dartmouth Book Award (Fiction) by the Atlantic Book Awards Society.
In the Quill & Quire Quebec writer Paul Gessell said that he found the characters to be "very credible" and "complex" but concluded that "at times, the plot is convoluted and the back-and-forth chronology gets rather tiresome. Generally, however, it is a well-crafted, brave, and painful examination of one of the most monstrous issues of our time." The review in Publishers Weekly found the book to be an "engrossing, lyrical page-turner".
Author Nicholas Pashley reviewed the book for the National Post, writing that "Some readers might find MacIntyre's frequent timeshifting a distraction, but by and large the author handles the various decades of his tale deftly. And as a native Cape Bretoner himself, he brings the region and its residents vividly to life." In the Telegraph-Journal, Sylvie Fitzgerald writes that regarding the characterization "MacIntyre succeeds in demystifying the man beneath the medieval vestments, reminding us that a priest is a man first" and that "MacIntyre's work is resuscitated with colourful local colloquialism".
- Wagner, Vit (August 3, 2009). "New novel set amid church's abuse scandal". Toronto Star. pp. E1.
- "Suspicion about Lahey raised 20 years ago". The Catholic Register. Retrieved January 11, 2011.
- Friscolanti, Michael (December 7, 2009). "The Truth About Priests". Maclean's 122 (47): 42–45. Retrieved January 11, 2011.
- Barber, John (August 20, 2009). "Mining fact for fiction". The Globe and Mail. pp. R1. Retrieved January 11, 2011.
- "Maclean's Bestsellers - Fiction". Maclean's 122 (46): 73. November 30, 2009. Note: The book remained at #1 until late-March 2010, except for the week of February 8 during which it was #2 on the besteller list.
- Medley, Mark (November 11, 2009). "CBC journalist wins Giller Prize". The Vancouver Sun. pp. E6.
- Barber, John (November 10, 2009). "MacIntyre takes Giller Prize". The Globe and Mail. Retrieved January 11, 2011.
- "CBA Libris Awards 2010". Canadian Booksellers Association. May 29, 2010. Retrieved January 11, 2011.
- "Linden MacIntyre wins two Atlantic Book Awards for 'The Bishop's Man'". The Canadian Press (Canadian Press Enterprises Inc.). April 15, 2010.
- Gessell, Paul (September 2009). "The Bishop's Man". Quill & Quire 75 (7): 48–49.
- "The Bishop's Man". Publishers Weekly 257 (32): 33–34. August 16, 2010.
- Pashley, Nicholas (August 8, 2009). "When a fixer breaks". National Post. p. WP8.
- Fitzgerald, Sylvie (October 24, 2009). "Questioning redemption". Telegraph-Journal (Saint John, New Brunswick). p. G6.