The Field Bazaar
|"The Field Bazaar"|
|Author||Arthur Conan Doyle|
|Published in||The Student|
|Publisher||The Students' Representative Council, Edinburgh University|
|Publication date||November 20, 1896|
|Preceded by||"The Final Problem"|
|Followed by||"The Hound of the Baskervilles"|
"The Field Bazaar" is a short story by Arthur Conan Doyle, first published on November 20, 1896 in a special "Bazaar Number" of The Student — a publication of the Students' Representative Council at Edinburgh University. It is a Sherlock Holmes story, published under Conan Doyle's byline and featuring both Holmes and his partner, Dr. John Watson. It is, however, treated by most experts as a parody or pastiche not suitable for inclusion in the traditional 60-story Canon of Sherlock Holmes, though there are dissenters.
In 1896, the Students' Representative Council at Edinburgh University, Conan Doyle's alma mater, was raising money to build a pavilion at the University's new cricket field in the Craiglockhart neighborhood, southwest of downtown Edinburgh. The main fundraising event was a bazaar, held November 19-21, 1896, in the Edinburgh Music Hall. One of the items for sale at the event was a special Bazaar Number of the Council's weekly magazine, The Student, containing works by several popular authors, including Conan Doyle, J.M. Barrie, Walter Besant, William Muir, and Louis Tracy. Conan Doyle's contribution, The Field Bazaar, was a very short story — it was two pages long — about Watson's connections to Edinburgh University, and his cricket-playing college days. The story was touted in the regular issue of The Student preceding the bazaar:
Dr. A. Conan Doyle, another of our graduates, has contributed an original story of the "Sherlock Holmes" type. We all remember the indignation aroused by the death of the redoubtable detective, a few years ago. This is the only "Sherlock Holmes" story published since then, and we have to offer our best thanks to the writer for his kindness in thus helping us and the Bazaar.
And in its first post-bazaar issue, The Student reported enthusiastic reader appreciation, including:
We received a good deal of gratuitous advice from people who were kind enough to buy the Bazaar number; but one man in particular really took the biscuit. After endeavouring to obtain his copy for sixpence, he told us that we ought to have a story by Conan Doyle every week! The Strand and The Idler only publish stories by "Sherlock Holmes" at varying intervals, and when even magazines like these can obtain a limited amount of MSS. from the talented author—well, where do we come in?
Nevertheless, The Field Bazaar disappeared from public view after the bazaar, and was not republished in Conan Doyle's lifetime.
Conan Doyle knew the central subject of The Field Bazaar — cricket — quite well, being an able (but not excellent) player himself. When he was a student at Edinburgh University, he was in the school's second XI in 1879. And he continued to play competitively well into middle age. According to his player profile at ESPNcricinfo, "Although never a famous cricketer, he could hit hard and bowl slows with a puzzling flight. For MCC v Cambridgeshire at Lord's, in 1899, he took seven wickets for 61 runs, and on the same ground two years later carried out his bat for 32 against Leicestershire, who had Woodcock, Geeson and King to bowl for them."
Watson narrates The Field Bazaar — which mirrors the reality of Conan Doyle's gift of the story to The Student — from a first-person perspective.
The story opens with Holmes and Watson at breakfast in the sitting-room of their residence at 221B Baker Street. Holmes infers—from a handful of odd clues—that an envelope Watson is holding contains an invitation to "help in the Edinburgh University Bazaar." He then concludes, to Watson's astonishment, "that the particular help which you have been asked to give was that you should write in their album, and that you have already made up your mind that the present incident will be the subject of your article." Holmes then returns to reading his morning newspaper.
Despite Conan Doyle's enthusiasm for cricket, The Field Bazaar remained his only story about the game for more than 20 years. Then, in 1918, he wrote Three of Them — a series of five short stories that he described as "an attempt to catch some of the fleeting phases of childhood, those phases which are so infinitely subtle and have so rare a charm." The second story in the series — titled About Cricket — featured a father telling his children bedtime stories about cricket. Conan Doyle also composed a poem about cricket — A Reminiscence of Cricket — that was published in 1922. And in 1928, he produced his largest cricketing work, The Story of Spedegue's Dropper, in which the protagonists are Walter Scougall and Tom Spedegue, not Holmes and Watson.
The Field Bazaar resurfaced in 1934 when the owner of a copy of the Bazaar Number of The Student, prompted by publicity surrounding the founding in London of the Sherlock Holmes Society (forerunner of the modern Sherlock Holmes Society of London), sent it to the head of the Society, A.G. Macdonell. Macdonell printed 100 copies of the story. He distributed them to other members of the Society and, when he visited the United States, to their American counterparts, The Baker Street Irregulars. The Irregulars published their own edition in 1947. Since then, The Field Bazaar has been republished several times, including appearances in collections edited by leading scholars of Conan Doyle and of Holmes. All modern editions silently correct a typographical oddity in the original 1896 version — missing quotation marks at the end of the story.
The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes: The Field Bazaar, The Student (Students' Representative Council, Edinburgh University, November 20, 1896), pages 35-36.
The Field Bazaar (Athenæum Press, 1934), single sheet.
The Field Bazaar, in 221B: Studies in Sherlock Holmes by Various Hands (The MacMillan Company, 1940) (Vincent Starrett, editor), pages 1-4.
The Field Bazaar (Pamphlet House, 1947), pamphlet.
Two 'New' Holmes Stories, in The Daily Californian (January 14, 1969), pages 1 and 11.
The Field Bazaar, in The Victorian Cricket Match (Sherlock Holmes Society of London, 2001), pages 1-3.
The Field Bazaar, in The Green Bag Almanac & Reader (Green Bag Press, 2016), pages 370-371, 519-520.
"The Field Bazaar" Illustrated, in The Green Bag Almanac & Reader (Green Bag Press, 2016) (David Hutchinson, illustrator), pages 464-470.
- Christopher Redmond, Sherlock Holmes Handbook (2nd edition) (Dundurn Press 2009), pages 113 & 211; Ian McQueen, Sherlock Holmes Journal (Summer 1997), volume 23, page 66; Sherlock Holmes: The Published Apocrypha (selected and edited by Jack Tracy) (Houghton Mifflin Company 1980), page 3; Edgar W. Smith, By Way of Introduction, in A. Conan Doyle, The Field Bazaar (Pamphlet House 1947), pages 7-10.
- Ian Schoenherr, Baker Street Journal (September 1980), volume 30, pages 178-179; "The 62 Sherlock Holmes stories written by Arthur Conan Doyle". The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia. Retrieved 2019-08-05.
- Daniel Stashower, Introduction, in The Apocrypha of Sherlock Holmes (edited, with annotations by Leslie S. Klinger) (Gasogene Books 2009), page xii.
- C.M. Usher, The story of Edinburgh University Athletic Club (Athletic Club of the University of Edinburgh 1966).
- Craiglockhart, University of Edinburgh Journal (December 1979), volume 29, page 131; J.I. Macpherson, Twenty-one Years of Corporate Life at Edinburgh University (Students’ Representative Council 1905), pages 28-30, 44.
- The Apocrypha of Sherlock Holmes (edited, with annotations by Leslie S. Klinger) (Gasogene Books 2009), pages 1-4; The Uncollected Sherlock Holmes (compiled by Richard Lancelyn Green) (Penguin Books 1983), pages 147-148.
- The Student, Bazaar Number (November 20, 1896), pages 35-36 (reprinted in the 2016 Green Bag Almanac & Reader, pages 370-371).
- The Student (November 12, 1896), page 55 (reprinted in the 2016 Green Bag Almanac & Reader, page 318).
- The Student (November 27, 1896), page 70 (reprinted in the 2016 Green Bag Almanac & Reader, page 427).
- Richard Lancelyn Green, Introduction, in A. Conan Doyle, The Field Bazaar (Centenary Edition), Sherlock Holmes Journal (Winter 1996), volume 23 (addendum).
- Andrew Lycett, The Man Who Created Sherlock Holmes: The Life and Times of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (Free Press 2007), page 57.
- Richard Lancelyn Green, Conan Doyle and His Cricket, in The Victorian Cricket Match (Sherlock Holmes Society of London 2001), pages 34-36
- "Sir Arthur Conan Doyle". ESPNcricinfo. Retrieved 2018-06-26.
- "Three of Them". The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia. Retrieved 2018-07-20.
- "About Cricket". The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia. Retrieved 2018-07-20.
- "A Reminiscence of Cricket". The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia. Retrieved 2018-07-20.
- "The Story of Spedegue's Dropper". The Arthur Conan Doyle Encyclopedia. Retrieved 2018-07-10.
- "About the Society". Sherlock Holmes Society of London. Retrieved 2018-06-16.
- The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes: The Field Bazaar (Athenæum Press 1934).
- Richard Lancelyn Green, The Sherlock Holmes Society (1934–1938), Sherlock Holmes Journal (Winter 1993), volume 22, pages 12-13.
- "About The Baker Street Irregulars". The Baker Street Irregulars. Retrieved 2018-07-21.
- A. Conan Doyle, The Field Bazaar (Pamphlet House 1947), pages 7-10.
- Cattleya M. Concepcion, Arthur Conan Doyle's "The Field Bazaar": A Bibliography, in 2016 Green Bag Almanac & Reader (Green Bag Press 2016), pages 443-445.
- The Apocrypha of Sherlock Holmes (edited, with annotations by Leslie S. Klinger) (Gasogene Books 2009), pages 1-4; The Uncollected Sherlock Holmes (compiled by Richard Lancelyn Green) (Penguin Books 1983), pages 148-151.
- Ross E. Davies, The Quotation Mark Puzzle: An Imperfection of "The Field Bazaar," in 2016 Green Bag Almanac & Reader (Green Bag Press 2016), pages 511-518. "The Quotation Mark Puzzle". Retrieved 2018-07-04.