The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to: navigation, search
"A&P" redirects here. For other uses, see AP (disambiguation).
The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company
Formerly called
Gilman & Company (1859–1869);
Fate Chapter 11 bankruptcy
Founded New York City, United States (1859; 156 years ago (1859))
Defunct November 25, 2015
(supermarkets sold)
Headquarters New York City (1859-1907} Jersey City, N.J. (1907-1927) New York City (1927-1974) Montvale, N.J. (1974-2015)
Number of locations

15,709 at peak (1930}

296 at liquidation (2015)
Area served
United States and Canada
Revenue US$ 5.5 billion (2014)
Number of employees
28,500 (2015)
in 1974, A&P moved its headquarters to Montvale N.J.

The Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company, better known as A&P, was an American and Canadian chain of grocery stores that ceased operations in 2015 after 156 years in business.[1] From 1915 through 1975, A&P was the largest food/grocery retailer in the United States (until 1965, the largest U.S. retailer of any kind).[2] A&P was considered an American icon[3] that according to The Wall Street Journal "was as well known as McDonald's or Google is today" and that A&P was "Walmart before Walmart."[4] Known for innovation, A&P and the supermarkets that followed its lead significantly improved nutritional habits by making available a vast assortment of food products at much lower costs.[2] Until 1982, A&P also was a large food manufacturer.[5] In his 1952 book, American Capitalism, John Kenneth Galbraith cited A&P's manufacturing strategy as a classic example of countervailing power that was a welcome alternative to state price controls.[6]

Founded in 1859 by George Gilman as "Gilman & Company", within a few years it opened a small chain of retail, tea, and coffee stores in New York City and operated a national mail order business. The firm grew to 70 stores by 1878 when Gilman passed management to George Huntington Hartford, who turned A&P into the country's first grocery chain. In 1900, it operated almost 200 stores. After Hartford acquired ownership, A&P grew dramatically by introducing the economy store concept in 1912, growing to 1,600 stores in 1915. After World War I, A&P added stores that offered meat and produce, while expanding manufacturing. In 1930, A&P, now the world's largest retailer, reached $2.9 billion in sales with 16,000 stores. In 1936, A&P adopted the self-serve supermarket concept and opened 4,000 larger stores (while phasing out many of its smaller units) by 1950.[2]

A&P's decline began in the early 1950s when it failed to keep pace with competitors that opened larger supermarkets with more modern features demanded by customers. By the 1970s, A&P stores were outdated; its efforts to combat high operating costs resulted in poor customer service. In 1975, A&P hired outside management, closing older stores, and building modern ones. When these efforts failed to turn A&P around, the heirs of the Hartford family, and the Hartford foundation that owned a majority of the stock, sold to the Tengelmann Group of Germany. In 1981, A&P launched its second store-closing program financed by the surplus assets of its employee pension plan, reducing the corporation to less than 1,000 stores. The plan also closed manufacturing operations except coffee production.[7]

Starting in 1982, A&P acquired several chains that were operated under their original names, rather than "A&P". While A&P regained profitability in the 1980s, in 2002 it operated at a record loss because of new competition, especially Walmart. A&P closed more stores, which included the sale of its large Canadian division; A&P also spun off Eight O'Clock Coffee, the last of its manufacturing units.[8] In 2007, A&P purchased Pathmark, one of its biggest rivals; A&P again became the largest supermarket operator in the New York City area.[9]

Highly leveraged after the Pathmark acquisition, A&P experienced financial difficulties because of the Great Recession and filed for Chapter 11 protection in 2010.[10][11] By the time of its filing, A&P had declined from the nation's largest grocery retailer to the 28th with operations limited to seven northeastern states.[12] In 2012, A&P emerged from bankruptcy by becoming a private company[13] and briefly returned to modest profitability in 2013 and 2014. A&P had been for sale in 2013 but could not find a suitable buyer. After declaring a loss in April 2015, it filed for its second Chapter 11 bankruptcy on July 20. All of its supermarkets were sold or closed by Thanksgiving; however, the future of its 17 liquor stores has not been decided.[14]


1859–1878: Gilman era[edit]

The forerunner of A&P was founded in the 1850s as Gilman & Company by George Gilman (1826–1901) to continue his father's leather tanning business; in 1858 the firm's address was 98 Gold Street in Manhattan. Gilman's father died in 1859, leaving the son wealthy. That year, Gilman & Company entered the tea and coffee business from that storefront. One source speculates that Gilman decided to enter a more respectable business in light of his wealth. In May 1861, Gilman turned over the tanning business to his brother Winthrop; George moved his tea business to 129 Front Street. Initially, Gilman & Company was a wholesaler. In early 1863 the firm became a retailer, Great American Tea Company. Quickly, it opened five stores, moving its office and warehouse to 51 Vesey Street.[2]

Gilman proved to be a master at promotion; the business quickly expanded by advertising low prices. The firm was able to offer low prices by acting as both the wholesaler and retailer. Gilman also built a nationwide mail order business. By 1866, the firm was valued at more than $1 million. In 1869, the transcontinental railroad was completed; Gilman changed the firm's name to Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Company to promote the then-new concept of prepackaged tea under the Thea-Nector name. The tea company continued to use the Great American name for mail-order purposes. In 1871, A&P introduced another concept when it offered premiums, such as lithographs, china, and glassware with the purchase of coffee and/or tea at its stores. These premiums are now collectables.[2]

1878–1951: Hartford era[edit]

George Huntington Hartford, mid-1870s.

Evolution of the grocery store[edit]

1888 advertisement for A&P from a Norfolk, Virginia guidebook, listing the range of items carried

George Huntington Hartford (1833–1917) joined Gilman & Company as a clerk in 1861; Hartford later was promoted to bookkeeper, then cashier, in 1866. By 1871 Hartford was in a position of authority and was responsible for expanding A&P to Chicago after its great fire. A&P's first store outside New York City was opened within days after the disaster. The firm rapidly expanded; in 1875 A&P had stores in 16 cities.[2] In 1878, Gilman left the active management of the firm to Hartford.[15] By then, the firm operated 70 lavishly-equipped stores and a mail order business with combined annual sales of $1 million.[2]

To raise revenue, Congress significantly raised tariffs on tea and coffee. Profits on these products declined, and about 1880 A&P started to sell sugar in its stores. The company continued aggressive growth and by 1884 operated stores as far west as Kansas City and as far south as Atlanta. The company also operated wagon routes to serve rural customers. About this time, two of Hartford's sons, George (1864–1957) and John (1872–1951), joined the firm. A&P lore is that George convinced his father to expand the product line to include A&P-branded baking powder. Over the next decade, the company added other A&P-branded products such as condensed milk, spices, and butter. As it expanded its offerings, the tea company was gradually creating the first grocery chain. By 1900, the firm had sales of $5 million from 198 stores as well as its mail order and wagon route operations. However, other grocery chains were expanding more rapidly and blanketing their respective areas while the tea company's stores were spread over a much larger area. A&P quickly found itself at a disadvantage.[2]

Newspaper ad from New York City, 1922.

In 1901, George Gilman died without a will, starting a legal battle among his numerous heirs. The senior Hartford stepped into the battle by asserting that, in 1878, Gilman gave him half of the company in an unwritten partnership agreement. Evidence provided to the court established that Hartford received half of A&P's profits since 1878 and that the company's leases were in his name. The heirs realized that without Hartford, the firm would quickly become unprofitable. Therefore, in 1902 they agreed to a settlement where A&P was to be incorporated, with $2.1 million in assets. Under this agreement, the Gilman heirs received $1,250,000 in preferred shares at 6% interest, while Hartford received $700,000 in common stock and the remainder of the preferred shares. This gave Hartford control of the voting stock. Over several years, Hartford was able to repurchase the preferred shares from the Gilman heirs.[7] At the end of the litigation, A&P dropped to fifth nationally[2] and the Hartfords moved to rebuild the enterprise. A&P opened an average of one store every three weeks. A nine-story headquarters and warehouse was built in Jersey City; it later expanded to include a manufacturing plant and bakery.[7]

By 1908, George Hartford Sr. divided management responsibilities among his sons, with George Jr. controlling finance with John directing sales and operations. The sons ran A&P for over 40 years. The younger Hartford moved aggressively to adopt the A&P brand, dramatically increasing the product line. To make space for the new items, A&P replaced in-store premiums with S&H Green Stamps. By 1912, A&P operated 400 stores and averaged a 22% gross margin, resulting in a 2% profit.[2] A&P's peddlers were also operating 5000 rural routes in distinctive red-and-black wagons.[15]

Development of economy stores[edit]

Food prices were a political issue in the 1912 presidential election after a 35% increase in 10 years.[15] To counter this trend, some chains experimented with a no-frills format.[2] After long debate, the Hartfords agreed to John's proposal of experimenting with an economy store designed to operate at a 12% gross margin. Capitalized at only $3,000 including its initial inventory, the prototype economy store operated with only a manager, and without fancy fixtures. Within two months, weekly sales increased to $800 and the store achieved a 30% annual return on investment. A&P quickly expanded the concept; by 1915 the chain operated 1,600 stores. A&P's tremendous growth created problems with suppliers. Cream of Wheat was the largest breakfast food manufacturer; it demanded that all retailers adhere to the cereal's pricing per box. A&P purchased the product at wholesale, 11 cents per box (3 cents less), and decided that a 1-cent mark-up was appropriate for its economy store format. Cream of Wheat cut off supplies and A&P sued. U.S. District Court Judge Charles Hough ruled against A&P, saying that a manufacturer can establish retail prices. As a result, A&P and other large chains significantly expanded manufacturing private brands.[2]

Hartford Sr. died in 1917; his will established a one-generation trust divided equally among his five children. The trust was administered by George Jr. and John; both exercised control over the stock. A&P's leadership remained constant until the brothers died in the 1950s.[2]

Adding stores that included grocery, meat, produce, and dairy[edit]

After World War I, A&P rapidly expanded; in 1925 it operated 13,961 stores.[16] The new, combination stores included space for meats, produce, and dairy, as well as traditional grocery items. Sales reached $400 million and profit was $10 million. However, the Hartford brothers were concerned that gross margins had reached 22% to cover higher costs and that the chain veered from its low-cost discipline. In early 1926, the brothers discussed the situation with division management and launched a program to lower prices and improve cost controls. That year, sales increased 32%; A&P moved its headquarters to the new Graybar Building adjacent to Grand Central Terminal.[7] In 1927, A&P established a Canadian division; by 1929 it operated 200 stores in Ontario and Quebec.[17] In 1930, the corporation's 16,000 stores reached $2.9 billion in sales,[18] resulting in a 25% grocery-store share in its operating areas, and about 10% nationwide. No retail company had ever achieved these results. A&P was twice as large as the next largest retailer, Sears, and four times that of Kroger. Unlike most of its competitors, A&P was in excellent position to weather the Great Depression. The Hartfords built their chain without borrowing; their low-price format resulted in even higher sales. From 1929 through 1932, A&P reported a record $110 million in after-tax profits with each Hartford child earning over $5 million yearly in dividends and equity.[7]

A&P's success caused a backlash that threatened to destroy it. Thousands of mom-and-pop grocery stores could not match A&P's prices. While small operators had little political clout, they were supplied by thousands of wholesale distributors which had considerable political influence. Anti-chain store movements gained traction in the 1920s, but became significantly stronger during the Depression. In 1935, Texas Congressman Wright Patman introduced legislation that would have levied a federal tax on chain stores. If adopted, this legislation likely would have ended A&P. While this legislation did not move in Congress, in 1936 Patman sponsored the Robinson–Patman Act that outlawed charging different prices to similar customers; this law passed. Patman then reintroduced his first bill. A&P retained a lobbyist and dropped its opposition to unionizing activities of the politically powerful American Federation of Labor. George and John Hartford also took the unusual step of publishing an open letter pointing out that the legislation would significantly increase food prices. The tide of public opinion then turned against the bill, which was defeated.[2]

Converting to supermarkets[edit]

A&P supermarket, in Snowdon, Quebec, 1941

In 1930, the first supermarket opened in California. On the East Coast, Michael J. Cullen, a then-former A&P employee, opened his first King Kullen supermarket in Jamaica, Queens. Two years later, Big Bear opened in Elizabeth, New Jersey, and quickly equaled the sales of 100 A&Ps. In 1933, A&P's sales dropped 19%, to $820 million, because of the competition. After considerable debate, the Hartford brothers decided to open 100 supermarkets, the first of which was in Braddock, Pennsylvania. The new stores proved to be very successful; in 1938, A&P operated 1,100 supermarkets. The chain continued to build supermarkets and slowly phase out its smaller stores except in highly urbanized areas; in 1950, A&P operated 4,000 supermarkets and 500 smaller stores. Sales reached $3.2 billion with an after-tax profit of $32 million.[7]

A&P's success attracted the attention of President Franklin D. Roosevelt's anti-trust chief, Thurman W. Arnold, who was urged to investigate A&P by Congressman Patman. In late 1941, following Pearl Harbor, the military placed many large businesses off-limits to the anti-trust division because of defense priorities, leaving grocery stores as an option. The next year, A&P and its senior executives, including the Hartford brothers, were criminally charged for restraint of trade in Dallas federal court. However, in 1944, prosecutors withdrew the complaint realizing that the Dallas federal judge thought the case was weak. The same day, charges were filed in Danville, Illinois, and were assigned to Federal Judge Walter Lindley. The prosecution complained that A&P had an unfair competitive advantage because its vertical integration including manufacturing, warehousing, and retailing allowed it to charge lower prices. Prosecutors also complained that A&P refused to buy from food retailers that insisted on selling through brokers or refused to give A&P advertising allowances. The judges contended that if unchecked, A&P would become a monopoly. A&P countered that its market share was only about 15%, significantly less than the leaders in other industries. Judge Lindley agreed with the government, fining each defendant $10,000.[2]

In 1949, the U.S. Court of Appeals upheld Lindley's decision; A&P decided not to appeal further. In September, the anti-trust division asked the court to order the spin-off of A&P's manufacturing operations and the break-up of A&P's retail operations into seven independent companies.[2] Thousands of letters poured into the Justice Department supporting A&P; the Hartford brothers gave extensive interviews with Time which put them on the magazine's November 13, 1950 cover.[18] Time wrote that, next to General Motors, A&P sold more goods than any other retailer in the world. John was quoted as saying, "I don't know any grocer who wants to stay small. I don't see how any businessman can limit his growth and stay healthy."[16] The case dragged on into the business-friendly Eisenhower administration. In late 1953, the government agreed to drop its demands to break up A&P if it shut down its produce brokerage that also supplied competitors.[2]

In fighting the anti-trust suits, A&P also emphasized the considerable impact of its activities on the public welfare, which had been recognized as the legacy of George Hartford Sr. and his sons. The concepts pioneered and perfected by the Hartfords and their competitors enabled the public to enjoy significantly healthier eating at lower cost. In 1950, the average American consumed 10 percent more food than in 1930, with poorer households enjoying an especially important improvement in the quality of the food they consumed.[2] John Kenneth Galbraith supported this contention in his 1952 book, American Capitalism, by citing A&P as an example of countervailing power. To support his thesis, he discussed a 1937 A&P study of the feasibility of opening a plant to manufacture corn flakes. The mere possibility of A&P producing corn flakes forced existing corn flake manufacturers to lower their prices by 10%.[6]

1951–1974: Post-Hartford era[edit]

A&P's new stores from 1955-1970 tended to be smaller than competitors. This unit, in Pluckemin, New Jersey, remained unchanged (except for A&P's "sunrise" logo) until it closed in 2013.

In 1951, John Hartford died in the Chrysler Building after returning from a meeting of the automaker's board of directors. George remained as A&P's chairman and treasurer, appointing the corporation's longtime secretary Ralph Burger as its new president.[7] While Burger started with A&P in 1910 as a clerk in Glens Falls, New York,[19] he was a staffer who lacked John Hartford's strategic marketing skills. Under Burger, A&P continued to report record sales and operated with expenses of 12.6% of sales when the industry average was 15%. Burger was also President of the John A. Hartford Foundation started by sons John and George in 1929, assuring Burger's control of A&P when George died in 1957. George's trust was dissolved; the stock began selling on the New York Stock Exchange (under the symbol GAP) at $59 per share. For the first time, A&P elected six outside directors onto its board. In late 1961, A&P stock peaked at $70.[7]

The seeds for A&P's 35-year fall from the country's largest grocery to bankruptcy (and later liquidation) were planted in the 1950s.

  • A&P was starved of capital. While A&P was publicly traded, control rested with Burger, who headed both the corporation and the Hartford trust. Most of A&P's profit was declared as dividends to satisfy the income needs of the trust and its heirs. A&P also remained opposed to debt financing; the only source of capital was the depreciation account. While competitors invested in larger, modern supermarkets, A&P was slow to update its retail capital plant. By 1970, A&P stores were considerably smaller and mostly older than those of its competitors.[7]
  • A&P placed too much emphasis on private label products. In 1951, the Supreme Court ruled that manufacturers could not establish minimum prices unless the retailer agreed to the arrangement. This decision launched a revolution in discount retailing[2] fueled by the rapid increase in television advertising that raised demand for national brands. Contrary to this, A&P invested substantial amounts of its scarce capital to expand manufacturing,[7] including $25 million to construct the world's largest food plant in Horseheads, New York.[19] Because A&P stores were smaller, its shelves were dominated by private-label products, and customers found that national brands were often out of stock.[7]
  • A&P's labor costs were higher than those of most competitors. Because A&P stopped growing, a rising percentage of its workers were making higher wages due to their seniority. This was not a problem for most of A&P's competitors because they were rapidly expanding and had relatively fewer workers with high seniority. To offset higher labor costs, A&P tried to operate stores with fewer employees, resulting in long lines at checkouts and empty shelves.[7]

Ralph Burger attempted to reverse downward tonnage figures by reintroducing trading stamps, creating A&P's Plaid Stamps. However, by late 1962, the initial sales gains evaporated and the six outside directors threatened to resign unless Burger retired. When Burger left in May 1963, the stock was trading in the $30s.[7] Burger was replaced with a succession of presidents who were unable to stem the downward spiral. In 1971, the board turned to William J. Kane, who joined A&P in 1934 as a full-time store clerk. Kane believed that A&P could be turned around by focusing on basic store operations, including cleanliness, product availability, customer service, and courtesy. When his program stalled, he implemented a strategy to substantially cut prices by converting A&P to a warehouse store concept that became known as W.E.O. Warehouse Economy Outlet (or Where Economy Originates). The problem was that most A&Ps were not large enough to properly implement the program; losses quickly mounted. In early 1973, the stock dropped to $17, and Charles Bluhdorn of Gulf+Western made a tender offer at $20 per share. Kane rejected the offer, although some stockholders thought that the offer was attractive considering A&P's continuing difficulties.[7] A&P exited California and Washington State in 1971 and 1974, respectively, making Missouri its westernmost reach.[20] In 1974, the corporation also left its long-time headquarters in the Graybar Building, moving to Montvale, New Jersey.[7]

1975–2001: Scott/Wood era[edit]

During the Scott/Wood era, A&P started to build modern stores. This unit was in Belleville, Ontario. Note the "sunrise" logo introduced in 1975.

In February 1975, A&P considered a plan by Booz Allen Hamilton to close 36% of its 3,468 stores. Kane agreed to resign and was replaced by Jonathan Scott, the 44-year-old president of Albertsons. Under Scott, A&P closed 1,500 stores in three years, reducing to 1,978 units. Scott hired numerous executives from outside and pushed authority down to the regional level. During his first three years, A&P built 300 supermarkets ranging from 23,000 square feet (2,100 m2) to 32,000 square feet (3,000 m2), along with its first combination grocery-drug stores with 40,000 square feet (3,700 m2) under the Family Mart name. Scott continued Kane's efforts to improve basic store operations (including cleanliness and customer service) instituting a large training program. Weekly per-store sales increased from $37,000 in 1974 to over $70,000 in 1976, with total sales increasing from $6.4 billion to $7.2 billion despite the closures. Manufacturing was also reorganized.[5] While initial results were promising, by 1978, A&P profits started to slide due to economic conditions caused by high inflation.[7]

With the share price down to $7, the John A. Hartford Foundation finally came to the conclusion that it could no longer wait for a turnaround. Erivan Haub, owner of the German Tengelmann Group, expressed interest. Born in 1930, Haub studied retailing in the U.S. after World War II and built his family's grocery business into a 2,000-store chain with annual sales of the equivalent of $2 billion. Although still having a home in Germany, his children were born in the United States. Haub agreed to pay $7.375 per share for 42% of A&P's stock. Haub also quietly bought other shares until he owned 50.3% in February 1981. Scott did not renew his five-year contract; Haub hired James Wood to become chairman. Wood, an Englishman who was the same age as Haub, previously ran the American Grand Union supermarket chain. Many executives recruited by Scott left A&P; they were replaced by Wood's associates from Grand Union.[7] In Germany, Tengelmann had considerable success with Plus stores; they were smaller units featuring low price private-label products along with a limited assortment of meats and produce. A&P opened several divisions of Plus stores in the U.S. to take advantage of A&P's manufacturing plants and numerous small stores. However, the concept failed to win American customers who were attracted to other chains offering low prices on national brands.[7]

James Wood realized that another massive store-closing program was necessary to turn around A&P. In October 1981, A&P announced that it would downsize to under 1,000 stores and close the Chicago division. Under the plan, A&P also closed its large manufacturing group except the four coffee warehouses. To finance this program, A&P planned to terminate its non-union pension plan, using its $200 million surplus. The plan's obligations were covered by annuities that cost only about $130 million because of the then high interest rates. A&P's non-union employees were covered by a defined contribution 401(k) plan. William Walsh, then a recently retired executive, filed a class action that was ultimately settled by increasing the value of the annuities. A&P still realized over $200 million and was not required to pay taxes because of tax losses carried forward from previous closing programs.[7] The Philadelphia division also was to close, unless the unions agreed to contract concessions. When the unions refused, A&P started implementing the plan. The unions offered to purchase the stores, but realized that they did not have the capital required. As an alternative, the unions agreed to a profit-sharing arrangement if A&P formed a new subsidiary, and operated under a different name. The new banner, "Super Fresh", proved profitable.[21] A&P realized that its name was not the asset it had been.[7]

A&P Midland Park, New Jersey: Built in the late 1990s, it became an ACME in 2015 due to A&P's liquidation.

A&P started to acquire stores from other chains. In 1982, Stop & Shop exited New Jersey, not returning for almost 20 years. A&P purchased most of these stores to replace obsolete ones. In 1983, A&P bought Wisconsin-based Kohl's Food Stores (originally part of the Kohl's department store chain) from BATUS, enabling A&P to reenter Wisconsin and Illinois. In 1984, A&P purchased Pantry Pride's Richmond, Virginia division.[15] The next year, A&P reinforced its profitable Canadian division by closing stores in Quebec, and acquiring Ontario's Dominion Stores.[17] In the U.S., A&P started construction of larger 40,000-square-foot (4,000 m2) supermarkets known as A&P Future Stores. In 1986, A&P purchased Waldbaum's (with stores in southern New York and southern New England) and The Food Emporium, the latter an upscale New York City-based chain.[22] In 1989, A&P acquired Michigan-based Farmer Jack; also, A&P attempted to expand into Europe by bidding unsuccessfully for the Gateway Corporation (then the United Kingdom's third-largest grocery chain).[15] At the end of the decade, A&P reported a profit of 1.3% (compared to an industry average of 1.04%) on sales of $11 billion.[23]

In the early 1990s, A&P started to struggle again because of the economy and new competition, especially Walmart. In 1992, A&P's sales dropped to $1.1 billion; it posted a loss of $189 million. A&P responded by strengthening its private label program and overhauling its remaining U.S. units. Most stores smaller than 40,000 square feet (4,000 m2) were expanded, closed, or replaced with units from 50,000 square feet (5,000 m2) to 80,000 square feet (7,000 m2). The new stores included pharmacies, larger bakeries, and more general merchandise. A&P continued to suffer in the South and abandoned most of the region by pulling out of Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, the Carolinas, Tennessee, and Virginia; most of these stores were sold to Kroger. As a result, A&P was reduced to four regions: the Northeast, the Midwest (Michigan and Wisconsin), Ontario, Canada; and New Orleans. To reinforce the latter, A&P purchased six Schwegmann supermarkets; however, A&P was now reduced to 600 stores.[15] Christian W.E. Haub, the youngest son of Erivan, became co-CEO in 1994 and CEO in 1997 when Wood retired from that post. In 2001, Wood also retired as Chairman, with Haub assuming that title as well.[23]

2001–2015: Final years as a supermarket chain[edit]

A&P modified its sunrise logo in 2005, removing the colored bands and shrinking the oval's size.
Upon becoming a private company in 2012, A&P debuted a circular logo. The previous two logos were also used until the company closed operations.

Walmart gained a dominant position in the grocery industry, forcing competition to downsize. In 2003, after declaring its largest loss, A&P closed Kohl's Food Stores[24] and A&P's remaining stores in Vermont and New Hampshire, reducing it to just over 500 stores.[15] Also in 2003, A&P spun off the Eight O'Clock Coffee division (its last manufacturing operation) to Gryphon Investors for $107 million.[8] (In 2006, Gryphon sold Eight O'Clock Coffee to Tata Global Beverages for $220 million).[25] In 2005, A&P sold its 237-store Canadian division (consisting of A&P, Dominion, and Food Basics units) to Montreal-based Metro Inc. for C$1.7 billion in cash plus shares of Metro. By 2009, the A&P name disappeared from these stores.[26] In 2007, A&P closed its New Orleans division, limiting A&P's footprint to the Northeast.[2] Also in 2007, A&P acquired Pathmark, a long-time Northeastern rival, for $1.4 billion.[27] As part of its settlement with the FTC, the corporation was forced to divest of some Waldbaum's and Pathmarks.[28][29]

When A&P marked its 150th anniversary in 2009, it was ranked only No. 21 by Supermarket News of the top 75 North American grocery retailers based on 2008 fiscal year estimated sales of US$9.6 billion.[30] Tengelmann held approximately 38.5 percent of A&P, with Yucaipa holding a 27.5 percent share; the rest was held by individual shareholders and investor groups. Christian Haub was Chairman. Eric Claus, then President and CEO, left A&P, with Sam Martin assuming these responsibilities.[31]

First Chapter 11 bankruptcy (2010)[edit]

The recession hit many supermarkets as customers migrated to Walmart in even greater numbers. A&P was especially hard hit because of its increased debt load to complete the Pathmark purchase. In June 2010, A&P stopped paying $150 million in rent on the closed Farmer Jack stores.[32] In August, A&P announced that it would close another 25 stores, in Connecticut, Maryland, New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania: 13 Pathmarks, 6 A&Ps, 2 Waldbaum's, and 4 Super Fresh stores. In September, A&P announced it was selling seven Connecticut stores to Big Y.[33] On December 10, 2010, bankruptcy rumors surfaced; A&P stock tumbled from over $3 per share to below $1 before trading was halted. Two days later, A&P announced it was filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. According to documents submitted to U.S. Bankruptcy Court in White Plains, New York, A&P listed over $2.5 billion in assets, and $3.2 billion in debt.[10][11]

After the filing, A&P remained in operation while it developed a reorganization plan. In November 2011, the corporation announced that it had entered into an agreement to receive $490 million of debt and equity financing from Yucaipa, Mount Kellett Capital Management, and investment funds managed by Goldman Sachs Asset Management. The agreement enabled A&P to complete its restructuring and emerge from Chapter 11 as a private entity in early 2012.[34] At this time, Christian Haub left A&P; and Tenglemann wrote off its books the remaining equity.[35]

Second Chapter 11 bankruptcy and supermarket shutdown[edit]

A&P briefly returned to modest profitability by cutting costs in its remaining stores, although customer spending further decreased. In 2013, again a company, A&P was put up for sale but could not find a suitable buyer. In January 2014, Sam Martin resigned. In March, Paul Hertz was named CEO and President as the company broke even. On January 15, 2015, the trade publication Supermarket News reported that A&P was still for sale.[36] There were rumors of several parties being interested, including Cerberus, still owning Albertsons assets; however, no suitable offers were received. In May, rumors emerged that A&P was in more financial trouble as it declared a huge loss (in April) for the previous year, losing more business to better-managed competition. As customers were staying away, A&P considered its second bankruptcy filing in less than five years. There were rumors that A&P would sell all stores more than 40 miles from its corporate offices, shrinking the company to about 100 stores; other rumors were that the company would sell all its stores. Rumors also surfaced about a Chapter 7 bankruptcy and total liquidation, selling the company in pieces, as well as a Chapter 11 bankruptcy with selling in pieces. The company remained for sale as a whole, receiving no bids for any of its stores. Other alternatives were explored, including selling other assets.[37]

On July 19, 2015, A&P filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection, immediately closing 25 underperforming stores. The next day, A&P announced that 76 of its stores (including Super Fresh and Pathmark units) had been sold to Albertsons (owner of Philadelphia-based Acme Markets), marking Albertson's re-expansion into the New York metro area (it left Connecticut in 2010 when Shaw's pulled out of the state). Stop & Shop purchased 25 units, mainly Pathmarks in New York City, Nassau, and Suffolk counties. The Key Food co-operative acquired 19 units, mainly in New York City, including all remaining Food Basics and Food Emporium stores.[38] Morton Williams acquired two Food Emporium stores in Manhattan, while Wakefern Foods (the largest member of the ShopRite cooperative), acquired 13 units, including 9 Pathmark stores. Local grocers also acquired units either through sales or auctions.[39] All supermarkets were closed by Thanksgiving; however the disposition of the profitable 17-store Best Cellars at A&P division has not yet been announced.[14]

Store design[edit]

The A&P in New Orleans′ French Quarter (1930-2007).

The A&P Historical Society describes early stores as "resplendent emporiums" painted in vermilion and equipped with a large gas light T sign. Interiors included crystal chandeliers, tin ceilings, and walls with gilt-edged Chinese panels. A clerk stood behind a long counter to serve customers (self-service did not become common until the 1930s), and the cashier's station was shaped like a pagoda. When A&P started offering premiums, the wall opposite the counter was equipped with large shelves to display the giveaways. After John Hartford became responsible for marketing in the 1900s, A&P began offering S&H Green Stamps[2] to free space for the expanded line of groceries available in the stores. The economy stores John Hartford developed in 1912 eliminated frills. Typically 600 square feet (56 m2), these stores were equipped with basic shelving and a small ice box. A&P agreed only to short leases so that it could quickly close unprofitable stores.[19]

In the early 1920s, A&P opened combination grocery/meat/produce stores. One of these stores, at 701 Royal Street, in New Orleans′ French Quarter, remained open from 1930 until it was sold in 2007. Despite being A&P's smallest store for most of its 77 years, it had among the highest average weekly sales. Having survived Hurricane Katrina in 2005, it was not sold until A&P closed its New Orleans division.[2]

A&P started converting into supermarkets in the 1930s. On average, each supermarket replaced six older combination stores. A&P's policy of agreeing only to short-term leases resulted in differences in store design into the 1950s.[19] Except for the West Coast stores (which had a marina design), A&P stores constructed from 1955 to 1970 usually featured a distinctive cupola and weather vane (bow and truss) design on the buildings' roofs, red brick finish on walls (including the rear), and a raised triangular point in the front facade where the store's lollipop logo was placed. Some older stores were remodeled to include these features, which became A&P's signature.[40] However, during this period, A&P stores were considerably smaller in size than those of other chains. As late as 1971, half of the A&P stores were under 8,000 square feet (740 m2).[7]

During the Scott era, store design was modernized and controlled from headquarters. A&P developed four different-sized prototypes: 23,000 square feet (2,100 m2), 28,000 square feet (2,600 m2), 30,000 square feet (2,800 m2), and 32,000 square feet (3,000 m2). Family Mart stores were combination grocery/drug units with 40,000 square feet (3,700 m2) of floor space. A&P also built a store in Saudi Arabia. During the Wood era, A&P developed the "Futurestore" concept; these supermarkets used black-and-white decor.[7] In the mid-1990s, A&P began adding pharmacies, concentrating on building units of 50,000 square feet (4,600 m2) to 80,000 square feet (7,400 m2).[15]

Rise and decline in number of stores[edit]

Architectural rendering of an A&P Sav-A-Center supermarket, commonly built in the 1980s-1990s.
Year No. of Stores
1863 5
1878 70
1900 400
1915 1,600
1930 16,000
1950 4,500
1970 4,000
1980 2,000
1990 1,000
2000 600
2010 395
2015 296[14]

Store names[edit]

A&P acquired the 79-store Farmer Jack chain in 1989 and used that name until the division was closed in 2007.
In 2007, A&P acquired the 141-store Pathmark chain, and continued to operate most of them as such.

For most of its history, A&P operated its stores under that name. That changed during the Scott and Wood eras when A&P created chains, or used the original names of acquired chains. The following were A&P's significant retail operations under a different name:

  • Family Mart: Started in 1977, this chain of large grocery stores/pharmacies was based on similar units built by Skaggs-Albertson's when A&P Chairman Scott worked for the latter.[5] Initially successful, within 10 years Family Mart opened 28 units in Alabama, Florida, Georgia, and the Carolinas. The 18 Family Marts in Florida were sold in 1987[41] and the remaining Family Marts were closed by 1999.[42]
  • Plus: In Germany, Tengelmann operated many small stores under the Plus name, focusing on private-label groceries. After acquiring a majority stake of A&P, Tengelmann believed that it could convert many of A&P's smaller stores to the Plus concept and take advantage of A&P's large manufacturing operations. The experiment failed; Plus was closed in the United States in the 1981-82 restructuring[7] but continued as one of Germany's largest chains.[19]
  • Super Fresh: When A&P announced the closure of its Philadelphia division (which included Delaware and southern New Jersey) during the 1981-82 restructuring, the unions offered to buy many of these stores. A&P agreed; the corporation and the unions settled on a new labor agreement that included a profit-sharing provision. The agreement also called for the stores to be operated under a new name, Super Fresh. These stores proved to be profitable, and in 1986 the name was extended to supermarkets in Maryland, the District of Columbia, and Virginia; the latter included Richmond-area Pantry Pride stores A&P purchased in 1981.[21] Super Fresh stores were still in operation when A&P began liquidation.[43]
  • Kohl's Food Stores: A&P acquired the Wisconsin-based Kohl's Food Stores in 1983 after closing A&P's large Chicago division in 1982. The first Kohl's opened in 1946; during the 1960s it expanded into department stores. In 1972, Kohl's was purchased by British-American Tobacco, which decided to spin off the grocery stores to A&P a decade later.[19] (The department stores were purchased by an investor group that built Kohl's into the second-largest U.S. department store chain). A&P closed Kohl's Food Stores in 2003.[24]
  • Dominion (Canada): In 1985, A&P acquired the Dominion chain in Canada, consisting of 92 supermarkets, 2 warehouses, and an office complex.[19] Dominion was sold in 2005.[44]
  • The Food Emporium: Also in 1985, this 26-store New York City based chain was acquired by A&P. Founded in 1919 as Daitch Crystal Dairies (later becoming Shopwell Supermarkets), the chain peaked at 103 stores in 1962. In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Shopwell closed many of its stores and changed its name to The Food Emporium to focus on affluent areas.[22] Many Food Emporium stores were still in operation when A&P began liquidation.[43]
  • Waldbaum's was acquired in 1986. The New York City-based chain was founded in 1904 and opened its first supermarket in 1951. The company quickly expanded from the city into Nassau and Suffolk counties, and later into Connecticut and Massachusetts. In the early 2000s, A&P operated 80 Waldbaums's in southernmost New York state (outside Manhattan).[19] The Food Emporium and Waldbaum's banners did not overlap. Many Walbaum's were still in operation when the company started liquidation.[43]
  • Farmer Jack was a 79-store supermarket chain based in Detroit; it was purchased by A&P in 1989. Farmer Jack started in 1924; in the mid-1950s its name was changed to Borman′s. These stores were renamed Farmer Jack in the late 1960s. In 1987, Farmer Jack was depleted of cash in a lengthy strike; it was sold in 1989 to A&P for $76 million. Within five years, all A&Ps in the Detroit area were converted to Farmer Jack, as were some A&Ps in Virginia and South Carolina.[19] By 2007, all Farmer Jack stores were sold or closed.[45]
  • Pathmark was a large New York-area chain that was one of A&P's major competitors when it was acquired in 2007.[9] Pathmark, originally known as Supermarkets General, was formed in 1956 as a subgroup of the Wakefern co-operative known as ShopRite. When Supermarkets General broke from ShopRite in 1968, it converted its 81 stores to Pathmark. By 1977, Pathmark started to build largre stores with pharmacies. To overcome a hostile takeover in 1987, Pathmark's management instituted a leveraged buyout of $2.7 billion that committed it to make large debt payments. In 2000, Pathmark entered bankruptcy; after it was reorganized, Yucaipa Holding purchased 40% of Pathmark for $150 million. At the time of its 2007 purchase by A&P, Pathmark operated 141 stores and had a capitalization of $634 million.[9] Many Pathmark stores were still in operation when A&P began liquidation[43]

Private brands[edit]

A&P, 246 Third Avenue, Manhattan, 1936. Note the prominent ads for A&P's private brands.

When A&P was founded, there were no branded food products, and retailers sold food commodities in bulk. In 1870, the company became among the first to sell a branded pre-packaged food product, introducing "Thea-Necter" brand tea. In 1885, the name "A&P" was introduced on baking powder containers. Also in the 1880s, the company adopted the name "Eight-O'Clock" for its coffee. When A&P moved its headquarters to Jersey City in 1907, it included a bakery and coffee-roasting operation.[2]

A&P’s evolution into one of the country’s largest food manufacturers was the result of the 1915 court decision in the Cream of Wheat litigation that upheld the right of a manufacturer to set retail prices. To keep prices down, A&P put emphasis on private label goods.[2] By 1962, A&P operated 67 plants before consolidating many of them into the 1.5 million-square foot Horseheads facility, which was the largest food manufacturing plant in the world under one roof. As late as 1977, private label represented 25% of A&P’s sales, with A&P manufactured products accounting for over 40% of this total. That year, A&P manufacturing reported sales of $750 million from its 23 plants[5](which by itself would have ranked A&P's manufacturing group at about number 350 in the Fortune 500.)[46]

Until the creation of a combined Manufacturing Group in 1975, the corporation’s production operations were conducted by four separate divisions.[2]

  • Bakery (Grandmother’s, Marvel, and Jane Parker): Until 1923, Jersey City was A&P’s only bakery. A&P rapidly expanded the division until it was America's largest baker, with 37 plants.[2] By 1977, the number of bakeries was reduced to seven;[5] the division was closed during the 1981-82 restructuring.[19]
  • Coffee (Eight O’Clock, Bokar, Red Circle): In 1919, A&P consolidated its coffee business into the "American Coffee Company", building roasting and grinding facilities.[2] By 1977, A&P owned three coffee roasting plants, and one for canned coffee.[5] The coffee operation survived the 1981-82 restructuring, not sold until 2003.[8]
  • Dairy: This division dates to 1922 when A&P purchased the White House Milk Company of West Bend, Wisconsin to produce evaporated milk. At that time, grocers rarely sold fresh milk because of the lack of refrigeration.[2] By 1977, the division operated three dairies, a cheese plant, and a dry milk plant.[5] All were sold during the 1981-82 restructuring.[19]
  • Grocery (Quaker Maid, Ann Page, Our Own Tea): In 1907, A&P opened a vegetable cannery. After World War I, A&P took advantage of the collapse of canned salmon prices to acquire canneries in Alaska.[2] A&P then acquired facitities to produce a wide range of canned goods, frozen foods, nuts, tea bags, pasta, peanut butter, detergents, insecticides, gelatin, paper goods, and candy. A&P also operated a printing plant to produce labels and packaging for the other facilities, and promotional material for the stores. By 1977, A&P operated the Horseheads plant, plus six smaller facilities.[5] All were closed in the 1981-82 restructuring.[19]

With the closure of these facilities, A&P private brand products were produced by other manufacturers. In 1994, A&P introduced four store brands (America's Choice, Master Choice, Health Pride, and Savings Plus) so that the private label program would be consistent through A&P's banners. The America's Choice name was a rebranding of the entire A&P line (which replaced many older brands, including Jane Parker and Ann Page). Master Choice was A&P's line of premium items, including meat and baked goods. The Health Pride brand was used for health and beauty aids, while Savings Plus targeted price-conscious consumers. Ironically, while Tengelmann eliminated the use of the A&P name for U.S. private label products, it started marketing A&P-branded items in Germany, complete with A&P's then-sunrise logo. A&P stood for "attraktiv" and "preiswert" (German for "attractive" and "low-priced").[19]

In 2008 and 2009, the corporation added the environmentally-sensitive Green Way brand, Hartford Reserve (replacing Master Choice), and America's Choice Gold; the latter a brand positioned between America's Choice and Hartford Reserve in terms of quality. Later, America's Choice Reserve replaced the America's Choice Gold line in produce, poultry, bakery, and deli. In 2009, the corporation introduced Via Roma Italian foods, Preferred Pet dog and cat foods, Market Spa shampoos, conditioners, and lotions; Live Better (over-the-counter health products, and America's Choice Kids child-healthy foods. The number of store-brand products had grown to over 20,000. In 2010, A&P added Food Basics and Home Basics entry level store brands. A&P's newest store brand was The Food Emporium Trading Company.

Woman's Day[edit]

Harry Horlick, conductor of The A&P Gypsies, an early radio program

What became Woman's Day was started by A&P in 1931 as a free leaflet with menus. In 1937, it was expanded into a magazine that was sold exclusively in A&P stores for 5 cents. In 1944, circulation reached 3 million, reaching 4 million by 1958, when the magazine was sold to Fawcett Publications.[47]

A&P slogans[edit]

The singer Kate Smith was a popular spokesperson for A&P
  • "Who cares? We care" (used in magazine advertisements and in commercials in the 1960s)
  • "WEO! How A&P prices have changed! (early 1970s. "WEO" was an acronym for "Where Economy Originates", or Warehouse Economy Outlet)
  • "The time has come to put price and pride back together." (mid-1970s)
  • "We pick the best so you can, too." (used in conjunction with the Price and Pride campaign)
  • "We Watch Our P's and Q's" (early 1980s)
  • "We Built A Proud New Feeling" (1986)
  • "The Great Store Just Next Door" (1993)
  • "We're fresh obsessed." (Early 2000s, borrowed from the Canadian division)
  • "Fresh Thinking Since 1859"

In media[edit]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ Verdon, Joan (November 14, 2015). "A&P granted extension file bankruptcy plan". North Jersey Record. 
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w x y z aa ab ac Levinson, Marc (2011). The Great A&P and the struggle for small business in America. Hill and Wang. ISBN 978-0-8090-9543-8. 
  3. ^ "Everything You Need to Know About the A&P Bankruptcy". December 13, 2010. Retrieved 2010-12-14. 
  4. ^ "A&P Heading to the Checkout Counter?". December 10, 2010. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h "A CSA full-issue study of A&P". Chain Store Age. December 1977. 
  6. ^ a b Galbraith, J.K. (1952). American Capitalism, the concept of countervailing power. Mifflin. ISBN 978-1560006749. 
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u v w Walsh, William (1986). The Rise & Decline of The Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Company. Lyle Stuart Inc. ISBN 0-8184-0382-9. 
  8. ^ a b c "Company News: A&P to sell eight o'clock coffee unit for $107 million". New York Times. October 21, 2003. 
  9. ^ a b c Sullivan, Tom (July 31, 2015). "Pathmark's downfall began with A&P". North Jersey Record. 
  10. ^ a b N.J. grocer A&P files for bankruptcy
  11. ^ a b "A&P, Century-Old U.S. Grocery Store Owner, Files for Bankruptcy"
  12. ^ "SN's Top 75 Retailers for 2010". 2009-12-15. Retrieved 2010-07-15. 
  13. ^ "Supermarket chain A&P emerges from bankruptcy"
  14. ^ a b c Ramey, Corinne (November 19, 2015). "A&P's imprint on New York Region Fades as Stores Close". Wall Street Journal. 
  15. ^ a b c d e f g h Patterson, Jay. International Directory of Company Histories, 2003. St James Press. 
  16. ^ a b "Red Circle & Gold Leaf," Time Magazine, November 13, 1950.
  17. ^ a b History of A&P Canada from Metro Inc. website
  18. ^ a b Red Circle & Gold Leaf (subscription required)
  19. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o Anderson, Avis (2002). The Story of the Great Atlantic and Pacific Tea Company. Arcadia. ISBN 978-0-7385-1038-5. 
  20. ^ "Sweeping Changes Outlined By A.&P.'s Vice Chairman: Campaign for Better Image Is Planned, Dropping of W.E.O. Tag Considered". New York Times. 1975-01-20. 
  21. ^ a b Mayer, Caroline (December 8, 1986). "Super Fresh breaths life into A&P". The Washington Post. 
  22. ^ a b The Food Emporium company history
  23. ^ a b "Obituary, James Wood, Former A&P CEO". Progressive Grocer. March 31, 2015. 
  24. ^ a b "A&P to close area Kohl's Food Stores". Milwaukee Business Journal. June 13, 2003. 
  25. ^ "Tatas buy Eight O'Clock Coffee". The Economic Times. 26 June 2006. 
  26. ^ "Metro to dump A&P, Dominion names". 7 August 2008. Retrieved 24 May 2011. 
  27. ^ Docket No. C-4209
  28. ^ Supermarket chain moving on greater Island presence
  29. ^ With ceremony, Pathmark returns to Staten Island's New Dorp community
  30. ^ 2009 Top 75 North American Food Retailers:A&P Profile, Supermarket News. Retrieved October 26, 2009.
  31. ^ "Company Facts" sidebar, A&P website. Accessed 10/26/2009.
  32. ^ A&P stops rent on Farmer Jack spaces: 24 lawsuits filed; owners in default
  33. ^ Big Y buying seven CT A&P stores
  34. ^ [1]
  35. ^ Springer, Jon (August 8, 2011). "Haub to retire from A&P organization". Supermarket News. 
  36. ^ Unions: A&P for sale Jon Springer, Supermarket News, January 15, 2015
  37. ^ A&P of Montvale said to weigh second bankruptcy filing in five years
  38. ^ A&P store closures, Stop & Shop purchases announced
  39. ^ UPDATE: What Will Become of the Remaining A&P Stores? The Latest List, accessed 5 November 2015
  40. ^ article on A&P
  41. ^ Smith, Denise (January 19, 1987). "A&P Goes Against Tide of Expansion". Orlando Sentinel. 
  42. ^ Hubbard, Caroline (May 31, 1999). "A&P still shopping soon to close Atlanta stores". Atlanta Business Chronicle. 
  43. ^ a b c d Bomey, Nathan (July 20, 2015). "A&P grocery chain files for bankruptcy again". USA Today. 
  44. ^ "Metro Inc in deal to buy A&P Canada fot $1.7 B". July 19, 2005. 
  45. ^ Duggan, Daniel (October 3, 2010). "A&P stops rent on Farmer Jack stores". Crains Detroit Business. 
  46. ^ "1979 Fortune 500". Retrieved 2015-10-28. 
  47. ^ Walsh, David (2010). The Magazine Century, American Magazines Since 1900. Peter Lang. 
  48. ^
  49. ^ Michael Chiarello to Mentor on Supermarket Superstar

Further reading[edit]

  • That Wonderful A&P!, Hoyt, Edwin P., Copyright 1969, Hawthorn Books
  • The Rise & Decline of the Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea company, Walsh, William I., Copyright 1986 Publisher Lyle Stuart
  • The Great A&P and the Struggle for Small Business in America, Levinson, Marc, Copyright 2011, Hill and Wang

External links[edit]