The Iron Petticoat

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search

The Iron Petticoat
Iron petticoat59.jpg
Theatrical release poster
Directed byRalph Thomas
Written byBen Hecht
Produced byBetty E. Box
Harry Saltzman (uncredited)
StarringBob Hope
Katharine Hepburn
Noelle Middleton
James Robertson Justice
Robert Helpmann
CinematographyErnest Steward
Edited byFrederick Wilson
Music byBenjamin Frankel
Distributed byIndependent Film Distributors (UK)
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (US)
Release dates
Running time
94 minutes
CountryUnited Kingdom
Box office$1,385,000[1][2]

The Iron Petticoat (aka Not for Money) is a 1956 British Cold War comedy film starring Bob Hope and Katharine Hepburn, and directed by Ralph Thomas. The screenplay by Ben Hecht became the focus of a contentious history behind the production, and led to the film's eventual suppression by Hope. Hecht had been part of the screenwriting team on the similarly themed Comrade X (1940).

Hepburn plays a Soviet military pilot who lands in West Germany and, after sampling life in the West in the company of Hope's Major Chuck Lockwood, is converted to capitalism. Subplots involve Lockwood trying to marry a member of the British upper class and communist agents trying to coerce Hepburn's character to return to the Soviet Union.

The main story borrows heavily from Ernst Lubitsch's Ninotchka (1939), starring Greta Garbo, and very closely resembles Josef von Sternberg's Jet Pilot with Janet Leigh as the Russian pilot and John Wayne as the US Air Force officer. Jet Pilot, inspired by real-life Cold War pilot defections, completed principal photography in 1950 but was not released until 1957, after The Iron Petticoat.[3]


Captain Vinka Kovalenko (Katharine Hepburn) lands a Soviet Air Force jet in West German territory, to the surprise of the United States Armed Forces, who take her prisoner. However, she is neither on a mission nor defecting, just upset about a personal matter back home.

Capt. Chuck Lockwood (Bob Hope) is eager to leave for London and visit his wealthy fiancée Connie (Noelle Middleton). A superior officer named Tarbell (Alan Gifford) cancels his furlough, ordering Chuck to sell the Soviet aviatrix on everything good about America and convince her to permanently come over to their side. The colonel even dangles a $100,000 bonus check made out to Vinka to be given if Lockwood succeeds.

Vinka is pursued by her former lover, engineer Ivan (Robert Helpmann). She shows no interest in Chuck, and is just as determined to sell him on Russian virtues as he is on influencing her. He describes her as cold and unappealing, but when Connie makes a surprise visit, Vinka strolls into Chuck's room wearing little else but a pajama top and her military medals. Connie becomes increasingly angry, more so when she finds out that Chuck is not as well-off financially as he has pretended to be.

Vinka begins to dress in an increasingly enticing manner. One night, at a Russian restaurant, comrades come to kidnap her. A sleeping potion meant for Chuck ends up in Tarbell's drink instead. Connie is also mistaken for Vinka in a cloakroom and taken captive.

The Russians misunderstand Vinka's intentions and charge her with treason. Chuck leads a daring aerial escape, and they end up falling in love. Money does not matter as much to Vinka as it does to Connie. As she and Lockwood are leaving for America, a Russian agent runs up, offering her the $100,000 check. She declines, but Lockwood grabs it.




The original screenplay, Not for Money, was written by Ben Hecht[4] from a story by producer Harry Saltzman.[5] The two men formed a company called Benhar to produce the film.[6] Hecht wrote the film specifically as a vehicle for Katharine Hepburn.[7]

Hepburn was pleased with the original script and personally selected Ralph Thomas as the director because she liked his film Doctor in the House (1954).[8][4] She contacted Thomas and Doctor in the House producer Betty E. Box while they were making Doctor at Sea, and they agreed to take part.[9] "I had no idea what dramas were to descend on us as a result of that call," Box later wrote.[10]

"We accepted the job because Miss Hepburn agreed to do it, and because we liked the Ben Hecht script," said Thomas.[11] Box and Thomas were under contract to the Rank film organization, but were allowed to make outside films. "They [Rank] turned very sour," wrote Box. "But we stuck to our guns – we wanted to work with Hepburn, on top of which we were to be paid much larger fees than those guaranteed under our Rank deal."[12]

The film was an American-British co-production, with finance provided by MGM and Romulus Films.

Bob Hope[edit]

According to Box, Hepburn originally envisioned the male lead being played by Cary Grant, William Holden or James Stewart.[10] However, casting the role proved difficult. "There was difficulty in finding a top star to play opposite Hepburn," wrote Box, "an example of the male chauvinistic attitude which baulks at the leading lady's part being better than the man's."[12]

Bob Hope read the script and wanted to play the role. It was unlike anything that Hope had done in the past, but he said that he wanted to work with Hepburn, and would play the character as written.[13]

"We all thought the idea quite mad at first," said Box of Hope's casting. "Then we all had second thoughts and said, 'Why not?' And I must say the first of us to see that it made sense was Katie."[9]

According to his biographer, Hope also saw the opportunity to get away from the United States at a time when a scandal was tarnishing his reputation as a family man. Hope had been embarrassed by the publication of a tell-all book by former lover Barbara Payton, and advised by close confidants to leave the United States until the bad press had subsided.[8]

The film project marked the first time that Hope had worked outside the United States, and in the country of his birth. It had also been more than 50 films since he last worked outside Paramount.[14] At one stage, Kay Kendall was meant to support Hope and Hepburn.[15]

Rewriting the script[edit]

Filming was to begin in November, but Hope was not available. He did not arrive in London until 7 December 1955. He then told Box and Thomas that he wanted to pull out of the film, saying that he was unhappy with the script. Hepburn and Hecht agreed to make changes to keep Hope on the film.[16] Hope also turned the script over to his own gag writers to tailor it to his style, as was his usual practice.[17] Many of Hepburn's best scenes were cut, and the title was changed from Not for Money. Hope had intended to change his role from that of a debonair leading man to that of his usual wise-cracking comic.[18] Hepburn considered her pairing with a co-star steeped in comedy routines as a "challenge."


Captain Vinka Kovelenko's arrival in West Germany is via a MiG-15 fighter, portrayed by a Republic F-84F Thunderstreak with Red Star insignia.

Hope and Hepburn had a wary relationship during the production; with the film being remade into a typical Hope comedy, Hepburn was forced to abandon her aspirations to deliver a Garbo-like role. Privately, Hepburn characterized Hope as "the biggest egomaniac with whom I have ever worked in my entire life." She also considered the film as "a cheap vaudeville act" in which she appeared as the "stooge."[19]

"It ended up as a Hope comedy," recalled Thomas. "He had seven writers, she had none. I can't really say I directed the picture. I refereed it. Each star would come on the set each day with a different piece of script. Each was happy with the scene he had – until they compared notes!"[11]

Donald Sinden, then a contract star for the Rank Organisation at Pinewood Studios, had a permanent dressing room in the same block as Hepburn's. He said, "Katharine Hepburn was delightful and most professional, but what was deemed by some to be 'professional' can also be called 'temperamental' by others. I happened to be on the set of The Iron Petticoat while Miss Hepburn was blowing off steam about something in a professional/temperamental manner. Bob Hope came to the rescue and with his superb sense of humour said to her, 'If you don't behave yourself. I'll tell everyone that you are Audrey Hepburn's father!'"[20]

A difficult time in the UK was compounded by Hepburn's worrisome eye infection, and she completed her obligations, although for years she would not talk about the film.[21] She would later recall The Iron Petticoat as an unlikely pairing of lead actors trapped in the wrong roles.[22] She recalled that Hope thought her sense of humour was basically "zilch."[23]

Production took place primarily at Pinewood Studios, but also utilized unique background locations, such as Buckingham Palace and Piccadilly Circus, as well as air bases in the UK. Although the plot involved a defecting military pilot, only a minimal number of aircraft appeared in the production, with the use of a Republic F-84F Thunderstreak as a stand-in for the ubiquitous MiG-15 jet fighter, the staple of 1950s Soviet air forces. Red-star markings appear on both the F-84F and C-47 to convert them to their Soviet lookalikes. When Kovelenko's MiG is escorted into West German airspace, two USAF North American F-86D Sabres intercept it. A Douglas C-47 Skytrain (as its counterpart, the Soviet Lisunov Li-2) is used for the return to Russia, while a Boeing Washington B.1 bomber and Avro Anson transport aircraft also appear, albeit mainly as backdrops.


Clash between Hecht and Hope[edit]

The Iron Petticoat was released through Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer in the American market.

Hope, whose company controlled US rights as one of the film's producers, cut 12 minutes from the version that was released in the UK. Hope's cutting prompted Hecht to take a full-page ad in The Hollywood Reporter that stated:

My dear partner Bob Hope: This is to notify you that I have removed my name as author from our mutilated venture, The Iron Petticoat. Unfortunately, your other partner, Katharine Hepburn, can't shy out of the fractured picture with me. Although her magnificent comic performance has been blowtorched out of the film, there is enough left of the Hepburn footage to identify her for her sharpshooters. I am assured by my hopeful predators that The Iron Petticoat will go over big with people 'who can't get enough of Bob Hope'. Let us hope this swooning contingent is not confined to yourself and your euphoric agent, Louis Shurr.[24]

As Hecht told journalist Mike Wallace in a 1958 interview, "The movie was written for a lady, Miss Katharine Hepburn, and ended up instead as a role for the hero, Mr. Bob Hope. Miss Hepburn was removed from it by fifty percent. I got irritated and took my name off it – it had nothing to do with the movie I wrote."[25]

Hope replied with an open letter that stated:

My dear Ex-Partner Ben: You once wrote The Front Page, and now you've followed it up with the back page … I am most understanding. The way things are going, you simply can’t afford to be associated with a hit. As for Kate Hepburn, I don’t think she was depressed with the preview audience rave about her performance.... Bob 'Blowtorch' Hope.[26]

For the US release, the film's credits read "Based on an Original Story by Harry Saltzman." Saltzman often joked that his first motion-picture production was the only Bob Hope film that failed at the box office.[5] However, the latest version released by TCM features a large screen credit: "Screenplay by Ben Hecht."

Critical reception[edit]

The Iron Petticoat was a critical failure when it was released in December 1956 in the United States.[26] Bosley Crowther of the New York Times, noting that Hecht had disavowed his work on the film, summed up many of the critical appraisals: "'The Iron Petticoat', which encloses Katharine Hepburn and Bob Hope, is about as inflexible and ponderous as the garment its title describes. And everybody connected with it might be forgiven for trying to claim an out."[27] He also wrote: "Miss Hepburn's Russian affectations and accent are simply horrible, and Mr. Hope's wistful efforts with feeble gags to hold his franchise as a funny man are downright sad. The notion of these two characters falling rapturously, romantically in love is virtually revolting. If this was meant to be a travesty, it is."[5]

In a 1972 interview, Italian actress Rossella Falk said that Garbo was "unhappy with Hepburn because she made a movie called 'The Iron Petticoat'. The film was a parody on 'Ninotchka', and Garbo thought the Hepburn film was the worst film that she had ever seen."[28]

Box office[edit]

According to MGM records, the film was a modest box-office success, earning $1,260,000 in the US and Canada and $125,000 elsewhere. Low production costs resulted in a profit of $109,000.[1]

Subsequent history[edit]

The film's distribution rights were divided between Hope's company, which controlled the Western Hemisphere, and the UK company Romulus Films, which held the Eastern Hemisphere, including the UK. MGM received a 10-year licence for the Western Hemisphere in 1955.[5]

After its initial theatrical release, The Iron Petticoat had only two public screenings in the US, at the Museum of Modern Art and the American Film Institute, both sanctioned by Hope Enterprises after MGM's rights expired in 1970. Apparently withheld because of Hope's unhappiness over the public controversy with Hecht, the film was not shown on US television nor had been released on home video there for many years, though it is readily available in the UK, where rights are currently controlled by ITV.[5]

Turner Classic Movies indicated in April 2012 that it had entered into an agreement with Hope Enterprises for a 10-year licence for US and Canadian TV rights and negotiated to release The Iron Petticoat on Blu-ray and DVD in North America as part of its TCM Vault Collection video line. TCM aired the film on 29 November 2012, almost a decade after the deaths of both leads.[5]

Proposed followup[edit]

After filming ended, it was announced that Saltzman, Hecht and Thomas would make an adaptation of The Imaginary Invalid starring Robert Helpmann,[29] but this film was never made.

See also[edit]



  1. ^ a b c "The Eddie Mannix Ledger". Margaret Herrick Library, Center for Motion Picture Study (Los Angeles).
  2. ^ Domestic take: See "Top Grosses of 1957". Variety, 8 January 1958, p. 30.
  3. ^ "Notes: 'Jet Pilot'." Turner Classic Movies. Retrieved: 29 March 2015.
  4. ^ a b A. H. WEILER (1 May 1955). "OF PEOPLE AND PICTURES: Hepburn-Hope Team -- New 'Carmen', 'Wuthering Heights' -- Other Items". New York Times. p. X5.
  5. ^ a b c d e f Fristoe, Roger. "Articles: 'The Iron Petticoat'." Turner Classic Movies. Retrieved: 16 December 2012.
  6. ^ The (21 April 1955). "Louella Parsons: Warners Scores Beat With Dr. Salk Story". Washington Post and Times Herald. p. 32.
  7. ^ Quirk 1998, p. 238.
  8. ^ a b Higham 2004, p. 167.
  9. ^ a b STEPHEN WATTS (15 January 1956). "HEPBURN-HOPE-HECHT TRIPLE PLAY ON THAMES: Production Team Stars' Orbits". New York Times. p. X5.
  10. ^ a b Box p. 109
  11. ^ a b SHEUER, PHILIP K. (8 July 1958). "Types Casting Pros and Cons Argued: Producer Calls It 'Insult;' Hope-Hepburn Fiasco Told". Los Angeles Times. p. B7.
  12. ^ a b Box p. 118
  13. ^ Box p. 119
  14. ^ Quirk 1998, p. 239.
  15. ^ Schallert, Edwin (22 September 1955). "Large British Combine Announced; Bette Davis Formulates Film Slate". Los Angeles Times. p. b15.
  16. ^ Box p. 128
  17. ^ Faith 2003, p. 255.
  18. ^ Faith 2003, p. 256.
  19. ^ Berg 2004, p. 232.
  20. ^ Sinden 1982, p. 238.
  21. ^ Leaming 2004, p. 470.
  22. ^ Quirk 1998, pp. 237–238.
  23. ^ Chandler 2011, p. 216.
  24. ^
  25. ^ Wallace, Mike. "Ben Hecht: The Mike Wallace Interview, February 15, 1958." Archived at Harry Ransom Center, University of Tennessee, Austin. Retrieved: 29 March 2015.
  26. ^ a b Quirk 1998, p. 240.
  27. ^ Crowther, Bosley. "Screen: 'Iron Petticoat'; Bob Hope, Katharine Hepburn are stars." The New York Times, 2 February 1957. Retrieved: 29 March 2015.
  28. ^ "Small Garbo Stories & Anecdotes – Part 3: When the Italian Garbo met the real Garbo." Garbo Forever. Retrieved: 23 November 2015.
  29. ^ Schallert, Edwin (23 August 1956). "Jerry Lewis Picks New Find; Molière Comedy Named for Helpmann". Los Angeles Times. p. B9.


External links[edit]