The Malay Dilemma

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
The Malay Dilemma
Dilema Melayu (in Malay)
The Malay Dilemma front cover.jpg
The front cover of The Malay Dilemma: With a New Preface
AuthorMahathir bin Mohamad
CountryMalaysia
LanguageEnglish
SubjectNon-fiction
PublisherAsia Pacific Press
Publication date
1970
Pages188
ISBN978-981-204-355-9
OCLC246739691

The Malay Dilemma is a 1970 book by Malaysian politician and writer Mahathir bin Mohamad, who went on to be the country's longest serving Prime Minister.

In it, Mahathir describes his interpretation of Malaysia's history in relation to its multi-ethnic society and racial tensions, and advocates for affirmative action policies for Malays. The book was originally banned in Malaysia; the ban was lifted 11 years after its first publication after Mahathir became Prime Minister. Commentators have since noted its influence on Malaysian society and governance, particularly the New Economic Policy.

Background[edit]

At the time of publication, Mahathir had just lost his parliamentary seat, been expelled from the ruling party UMNO and Malaysia had recently been rocked by the racial riots later known as the 13 May Incident.[1]

Summary[edit]

The book is a manifesto outlining Mahathir's political and racial beliefs. It analyses Malaysian history and politics in terms of race, and posits the following basic positions:

The dilemma thus, was whether Malays should accept this governmental aid—and Mahathir's position was that they should.

The book has attracted controversy for making racial generalisations, such as describing "Jewish stinginess and financial wizardry"[1] and calling Jews "hook-nosed".[2] Mahathir proposes in the book that affirmative action policies be a solution leading away from violence towards a harmonious, integrated Malaysia, albeit one where political and economic power is firmly concentrated in the hands of the Malays.

Initial ban in Malaysia[edit]

The book was banned in Malaysia upon its release, but was published in Singapore. Despite this, it was circulated widely, particularly among Malaysian Indians and Malaysian Chinese, who were concerned about Mahathir's return to politics in 1973 and subsequent rise to power. After Mahathir became Prime Minister in 1981, the 11-year ban was lifted after a proposal from Mahathir's deputy Musa Hitam.[1]

Impact[edit]

The book has been posited, including by Mahathir himself, as a major influence for affirmative action policies in Malaysia, most notably in the Malaysian New Economic Policy, which outlines racial quotas across Malaysian society in favour of designated bumiputera ethnic groups.[1][3][4]

Reception[edit]

In the preface of the book's first edition, its British publisher[who?] casts doubt on the accuracy of Mahathir's assumptions and assertions. Mohammad Bakri Musa, in The Malay Dilemma Revisited (1999) states that his assertions and assumptions were based on his personal observations and experiences, with no empirical data to support them.[5]

References[edit]

  1. ^ a b c d Kamm, Henry; Times, Special To the New York (1981-08-26). "MALAYSIA ENDS BAN ON PREMIER'S BOOK". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2021-12-05.
  2. ^ "Back to old habits, Malaysia's Mahathir calls Jews 'hook-nosed'". Reuters. 2018-10-02. Retrieved 2021-12-05.
  3. ^ "Mahathir's new Malay dilemma: address both poverty and prejudice". South China Morning Post. 2018-08-01. Retrieved 2021-12-05.
  4. ^ Souchou, YAO (2003). "After "The Malay Dilemma": The Modern Malay Subject and Cultural Logics of "National Cosmopolitanism" in Malaysia". Sojourn: Journal of Social Issues in Southeast Asia. 18 (2): 201–229. ISSN 0217-9520. JSTOR 41308012.
  5. ^ M. Bakri Musa (1999). The Malay Dilemma Revisited – Race Dynamics in Modern Malaysia. Gilroy, CA: Merantau Publishers.